HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rahimnathwani

16,483 karma · joined March 9, 2012

I've lived in San Francisco since 2019.

2010-2019 I lived in China.

Before that I lived in London, where I was born.

My personal web site: https://encona.com/

Random tools: https://tools.encona.com/

Other random stuff about me:

- English is my native language, but I also speak (to varying degrees of fluency) Mandarin, Gujarati and Spanish.

- My career so far has been a mix of startups/cofounding, big tech (I was a PM at Amazon and at Google), and exec roles.

- I'm a qualified accountant (CIMA), have two undergrad degrees (one in CS) and an MBA (sorry!).

- I got married in 2012 and our son was born in 2016 (I spend a lot of time thinking about how best to raise him to be a capable and kind adult)

Email: rahim AT encona DOT com

LinkedIn: http://www.linkedin.com/in/rahimnathwani

X: https://x.com/rahimNathwani/

submissionscomments
rahimnathwani··on Has early Scratch experience led to fulfilling careers?
What would you choose instead?

I am trying to get my son to learn Python using Carol Vorderman's book.

rahimnathwani··on Has early Scratch experience led to fulfilling careers?
"It has led to academic improvements across entire school districts"

This sounds amazing! Is there anything more you can share about this? Or any articles/papers about the results or how you supported kids to progress with Scratch?

rahimnathwani··on The teenage girls behind a $25 minimum wage fight in rural Alaska
When you said "It's a fairly well established geopolitical principle." I assumed you were talking about the legal aspect. That's why I responded the way I did.

Now I understand you're talking about not about the legality, but the practicality. That's even easier to refute I think: if a world power wanted to annex that part of Alaska, the ~4000 current residents of Nome wouldn't be much of a deterrent, even with their hunting rifles.

rahimnathwani··on The teenage girls behind a $25 minimum wage fight in rural Alaska
"it needs to maintain an actual population there and provide basic services to it. It's a fairly well established geopolitical principle."

I don't think that's true.

See the middle paragraph of page 46 here: https://icj-cij.org/sites/default/files/permanent-court-of-i...

The ICJ said that sovereignty over "thinly populated or unsettled countries" can be sustained with very little actual exercise of sovereign authority. It upheld sovereignty over unsettled portions of Greenland. They later used the same principle talking about islands that were "uninhabited or not permanently inhabited".

You seem to be saying there's a general requirement that every part of sovereign territory must maintain a resident population AND that the government must provide certain 'basic services' there. But that doesn't seem to be true, at least according to the ICJ.

If what you said were true, then no state could claim sovereignty over an unhabited place. But that's not true. The ICJ ruled that Malaysia had sovereignty over Ligitan, even though the island has a population of zero. https://www.icj-cij.org/node/103163

rahimnathwani··on The teenage girls behind a $25 minimum wage fight in rural Alaska
These teenagers aren't thousands of years old. Neither are their parents.

The folks suggesting that other people should pay to improve things for people choosing to live in that area seem to simultaneously believe that these people:

- have a right to the benefits of what you call '"modern" settled life', AND

- cannot be inconvenienced by the things that make that life possible (like density)

rahimnathwani··on The teenage girls behind a $25 minimum wage fight in rural Alaska
Or the people who don't like living in a remote area with high prices could choose to move somewhere else? The US is huge.
rahimnathwani··on Hunch: Drive your Mac with any LLM: focus-free, in the background, over MCP
I was trying to find a comparison between Peekaboo (what openclaw uses for computer use) and cua (what Hermes uses). I didn't find anything useful on a quick google search, so I went to HN search and searched for 'peekaboo cua'.

The only thing I found was this 'Show HN' from 4 weeks ago, with zero comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49102017

The guy who wrote it claimed:

  I benchmarked Hunch against Peekaboo (OpenClaw's computer use) and Cua Drivers, and out of the 54 MacOS local tasks, Hunch completed 53 while costing $6.03. Peekaboo completed 41 tasks and used $31.03, and Cua Driver completed 31 tasks and used $37.42.
That makes me curious. But the repo only has 17 stars so I'm curious whether other folks on HN have tried it.

It sounds/looks good but I'd rather learn from someone else who has tried it, than run my own benchmarks.

rahimnathwani··on GLM-5.3-Flash
Related: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49446422

(281 points, 118 comments)

rahimnathwani··on Apple introduces M6 and M5 Ultra
If I had 128GB unified RAM I'd try hf.co/unsloth/Qwen3.8-27B-GGUF:BF16 which needs 55GB for just the weights.

Something like this would give you three concurrent sessions, each with 240k token context:

  sudo sysctl iogpu.wired_limit_mb=110000
  
  llama-server -hf unsloth/Qwen3.8-27B-GGUF:BF16 -c 786432 --parallel 3 -ngl 99 -fa on
rahimnathwani··on Adafruit USB Type C CC Resistor Fixer
You can get five of them for less than $4 total here:

https://a.aliexpress.com/_mtW11kT

rahimnathwani··on Why your local LLM feels dumber than it is
orcarouter or obliteratus?
rahimnathwani··on I Became the Scapegoat in the Jason Arday Affair
When you wrote this sentence, were you referring to Cofnas?

"But people jumping from nucleotide polymorphisms to grand social policy (that just happens to echo a century's worth of rightly-discredited eugenics advocacy) deserve the scepticism they get in my view."

If so, what is the 'grand social policy' that Cofnas advocates or has advocated?

As far as I can tell from the paper, the only thign that seems like a policy proposal is that educational programs should be tailored to different ability profiles (and what he said about Head Start). But him saying that maybe we should fund different educational interventions isn't eugenics, or abouyt treating individuals differently depending on their race/ancestry. The paper argues against using group differences to blame or rank anyone. (See section 5.2 as it's the main point there.)

The overlapping-distributions point makes sense: even if group differences turned out to be partly genetic, group mean/median IQ or whatever isn't a good proxy for individuals from that group. So if you have a policy that is based on group membership (not individual assessment), it's going to be poorly targeted and end up wasting resources.

Section 4 endorses 'tailored' programs and doesn't explain how they'll be targeted. He doesn't say they'd be targeted by group membership, though. He references Jensen 1969 (https://gwern.net/doc/iq/1969-jensen.pdf) and in that paper Jensen advocated individual testing, not assignment based on race/ancestry. From page 78:

  The important distinction between the individual and the population must always be kept clearly in mind in any discussion of racial differences in mental abilities or any other behavioral characteristics. Whenever we select a person for some special educational purpose, whether for special instruction in a grade-school class for children with learning problems, or for a "gifted" class with an advanced curriculum, or for college attendance, or for admission to graduate training or a professional school, we are selecting an individual, and we are selecting him and dealing with him as an individual for reasons of his individuality.
rahimnathwani··on I Became the Scapegoat in the Jason Arday Affair
If your opinion of Cofnas is based mainly on what other people have said about him, or based on quotations from things he's written, I'd highly recommend you:

- read this paper: https://doi.org/10.1080/09515089.2019.1697803

- read the Harvard data behind the famous "0.7%" quote

- watch his interview with David Starkey

I do not believe Cofnas is racist or that his exposure of Arday was motivated by racial animus.

But, even if it were, he still did a service to the public by exposing the governance failures at Cambridge.

rahimnathwani··on Asus Bike Booster
"How do I take it off to charge inside?"

It has a removable battery so it seems the mechanism is designed to be left on the bike.

rahimnathwani··on CFTC declares market emergency, orders Kalshi to continue to operate in New York
I addressed this in my earlier comment with a question:

"Would they have to immediately move their HQ and fire all New York based employees?"

rahimnathwani··on CFTC declares market emergency, orders Kalshi to continue to operate in New York
As I said earlier, the complaint says "within or from New York OR to persons in New York" (emphasis mine).

This is inconsistent with your statement "It seems New York is not attempting to have any say over what Kalshi does outside of New York, when it does not involve New York residents."

rahimnathwani··on CFTC declares market emergency, orders Kalshi to continue to operate in New York
I was specifically responding to this part of what DannyBee wrote:

"The claim they are trying to prevent them from offering all event contracts nationwide is simply false."

rahimnathwani··on Ntfy – open-source Push to Mobile
I didn't know what you meant by Capacitor, but I now understand it's a modern replacement for Apache Cordova: https://capacitorjs.com/
rahimnathwani··on Ntfy – open-source Push to Mobile
Right, but if you use ntfy.sh you can get proper mobile push notifications (instead of keeping the app running and using long polling or websockets).

If you use the public version of ntfy.sh then you don't need to do anything to set this up. If you self-host, you need your own Firebase Cloud Messaging (FCM) account and (for iOS) your own Apple Developer account so you can use APN.

rahimnathwani··on The Neurosurgery Resident Who Proved Crouzeix's Conjecture [pdf]
Repo with prompt: https://github.com/jinshanmu/CrouzeixConjecture
rahimnathwani··on CFTC declares market emergency, orders Kalshi to continue to operate in New York
The complaint says "within or from New York or to persons in New York". But Kalshi is headquartered in Manhattan, right? So how can they continue to offer all event contracts nationwide without operating 'within or from New York'? Would they have to immediately move their HQ and fire all New York based employees?
rahimnathwani··on U of Michigan drops first-semester grades to ‘curb mental health crisis’
I grew up in the UK. When I started working full time, I had three academic things on my CV:

- 11 GCSE grades

- 4 A level grades

- 1 University degree

For virtually all of these, the grades/results were determined by exams taken at the end of a period of study:

- GCSE exams taken at ~16yo

- A level exams taken at ~18yo

- University finals taken at ~21yo

At the time, I thought it was very very strange that my GCSE grades for English Language and English Literature were not based on exams, but on a bunch of essays I had written over a two year period.

It seemed strange because those past essays did not measure my current capability, but something else.

But this (measuring students on performance over multiple years) is the norm here in the US. Sure, many students take the SAT or ACT or various AP exams. But many students enter university with their academic performance measured on their high school GPA, which seemingly doesn't even attempt to measure mastery.

rahimnathwani··on U of Michigan drops first-semester grades to ‘curb mental health crisis’
I did my undergraduate degree at Oxford. My degree class was entirely determined by my performance on eight 3-hour exams in the final weeks of the final term. These covered topics studied in the final two years.
rahimnathwani··on Launch HN: Keet (YC S24) – An app to create video courses on anything
I'm excited to try this.

I installed it on an iPad Air (M2). On launch, I am given two options:

- Get started (primary CTA). Tapping this takes me to a blank screen.

- Sign in (secondary CTA). Tapping this and choosing 'Continue with email' gives me a login screen. I tried entering my email and choosing a password but it says "Couldn't find your account"

rahimnathwani··on Tax cuts for the wealthy only benefit the rich (2023)
In most rich countries, the % of income people pay already goes up with income.

When you say 'pursue greater equality' do you mean we should keep making the tax system more progressive until everyone's after tax income is equal? If not, what should the shape of the curve be?

rahimnathwani··on Show HN: Science for Kids
Yes, good idea.
rahimnathwani··on Tax cuts for the wealthy only benefit the rich (2023)
The paper talks about economic growth, income distribution and unemployment.

I'm mostly interested in economic growth, so looked at what the paper claimed about that.

It found that major, sudden reductions in taxes on the rich did not have any statistically significant effect on the trajectory of economic growth over the following five years.

But:

- Their sample is small. They only looked at relatively large, discrete declines in their home-grown measure of taxes on the rich. They did not look at all tax-rate changes.

- They did not look at effects beyond the five-year horizon, which means it would probably exclude the impact on people starting startups, as the successful ones usually take more than 5 years to start making serious money. (or did during the period the paper considered, even if timelines have subsequently accelerated.)

- Big sudden tax cuts don't happen in a vacuum, and I don't see a way to control for confounding.

rahimnathwani··on Show HN: Science for Kids
If you like this you might like this other thing I made with AI: https://philosophy.ocaho.com/

(Of course, if you hate this, you will hate that even more.)

rahimnathwani··on Show HN: Science for Kids
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38092081
rahimnathwani··on Show HN: Science for Kids
I'm close to satisfied with the article text.

I'm still experimenting with the best ways to generate the images. I'm very happy with some of them, but unhappy with others. I need to figure out how to create an effective review loop. As you say, I'm not familiar enough with all of the subjects. Like I can't tell whether a diagram of a hearts has all the tubes in the right place.

I think AI is ideally suited to something like this, and I should soon be able to get to a point where I can generate an article, without human review, an article that's as good as that in a median kids' print magazine.

If I reach that point, the next goal would be to match or exceed the quality of the median article in Oyla (https://oyla.us/) or Aquila (https://aquila.co.uk/).

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →