HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rajekas

268 karma · joined October 17, 2014

submissionscomments
rajekas··on Mir Books
Many many years ago, I used to take the 560 from Kamal Cinema to Connaught Place (in Delhi for those who don't know these references) with a couple of geeky friends.

We would walk from the CP bus terminus to Connaught Circle, grab a bite to eat at Nirulas and then make the pilgrimage to the MIR store, which used to occupy a huge space right in the middle of the circle. I don't even know what's in that space now. Probably a McDonalds or a jewelry store.

That's where I bought books by Piskunov, Nikolskii, Perelman and many many other books. I still remember being puzzled that every discovery that had one name attached to it in the the western texts that I got out of the British Council Library - the next stop in the pilgrimage - had another name, usually ending in -ov or -sky attached to it in the MIR books.

That was before the end of the Soviet Union, liberalization and Shining India. That world has faded away faster than my imagined memories of Gondor.

rajekas··on Eat less meat: UN climate change report calls for change to human diet
I am Indian, I am vegan and was brought up vegetarian and I am not short. I am a foot taller than my parents. It has nothing to do with approximating western diets and everything to do with proper nutrition, vegetarian or not.
rajekas··on Patrick Winston of MIT CSAIL has died
He was a wonderful man. I took 6.xxx with him and liked it so much that I started attending his group meetings and eventually asked him to be part of my thesis committee.

Some of the best mentoring I have received on the inner workings of academia came from Patrick. A great example: his theory of presentations, where he had a wonderful template: Vision, Step and News, i.e., the grand theory of your research, the concrete steps you're taking in the next year or so and the latest findings. He gave me that advice two days before my defense and it worked like a charm.

A great teacher, a great mentor and a great human being. I will miss him.

rajekas··on Apple begins exporting India-made iPhones to European markets
It's possible without being patronising or racist to say that India needs to follow a different model of development than the western one. In fact, that idea was central to the Gandhian independence struggle - just read the great man's Hind Swaraj!

There are many reasons for doing so. For one, we don't have colonies we can screw over - i.e., India's India - while enriching ourselves. Assuming we would want to do that at all.

We also don't have the window of opportunity that China had for becoming a manufacturing hub. That's been done and while we can compete for a percentage of the spoils, it will never be the gold rush that took manufacturing to China. The politics of globalization alone will ensure that.

Second, we don't have the luxury of several decades of uninterrupted "development" before thinking about the environment. Climate change is going to hit us hard well before that, and one look at the water crisis should tell you that the basic necessities of life will need to be carefully managed.

I have nothing against assembling iPhones in Bangalore. Or becoming the world capital of CRISPR technologies. However, those can't become the driving forces of a future India. We need to think boldly beyond those constraints. I am not saying returning to a romantic conception of an ideal past, but a detour around the mess that industrial capitalism is already creating and will continue to create if we don't think of alternatives.

rajekas··on India's super-rich peak tax rate, at 42.7%, now higher than USA
As a middle class Indian who lives in the West much of the time, I think you're dead wrong. First of all, almost all the state investments go to the middle class. I was brought up in a state owned company township - in what's called the public sector - and I got a free education when I was there.

We moved cities and in this new city I went to a private school that took the rich but also kids of government employees since they wanted to play nice with the powers that be.

Then I went to a public university that gave me excellent education for which I paid next to nothing. That in turn got me a scholarship at a major US research university where I got paid to study.

In other words, I had all the support from a poor society to succeed. Sure, I worked hard, but so does every manual laborer, car driver, restaurant worker, house maid and farmer. And guess what: they get very little for their efforts. Meanwhile the people they work for have drivers and maidservants and care givers and what not. That's an unequal society.

I don't want a drone. I would much rather the world had way fewer cars. What I would like is lush forests, cities with sidewalks, good public transport, healthcare for everyone. And the ability to dream a future that's different from Lamborghinis. Perhaps seven dimensional universes in which you can turn a Lamborghini inside out and velcro the seats to a lamp post.

If I may say so, you know very little about India, about what middle class means, what poverty means and what privileges come from making $10000 a year.

My taxes should be higher.

rajekas··on Sanders to propose canceling entire $1.6T in US student loan debt
I am not American though I live in the US and I don't have student debt. I probably won't retire in the US either, which means that all the money I pay into social security is a donation from me to you. And I grew up in circumstances substantially more constrained than most people here who are complaining about the unfairness of Bernie's proposal.

I don't agree with that one bit.

The US is the richest country in the history of humanity. It owes its citizens a good life - education, health etc - no questions asked. In fact, it owes that to the rest of the world, since so much of the wealth has been created through the hard work of immigrants :)

If I could vote, I would pull the lever for Bernie without hesitation for being the only candidate for the Presidency who truly understands the depth of transformation this economy needs. An America without pain and uncertainty will make the world's problems easier to solve.

rajekas··on Less Processed Meat, More Plant-Based Foods May Boost Longevity
To be honest, I don't get the mania for processed meat substitutes when there's excellent vegetarian/vegan fare from cuisines that have been doing it for millennia. As an Indian brought up in a vegetarian family, I had no inkling or desire to eat meat until I came to the US for grad school.

One day I had this niggling doubt that I continued to be a vegetarian for cultural rather than ethical reasons. I tested that hypothesis by eating a hamburger. It was literally the worst thing I had ever tasted. I had to try hard not to throw up and offend my hosts.

Then I tasted bacon, hot dogs pastrami sandwiches and fried chicken and I understood why people like meat. That continued for a few more months.

About six months after the hamburger episode, I had another epiphany that I don't like eating animals since I don't like animals being eaten. I turned vegan. All's well that ends well.

rajekas··on To stop a virus, California has euthanized more than 1.2M birds
Why is it that when it comes to nonhuman beings we turn to violence first? Then there's the hiding of the violence behind scientized euphemisms for bonus points.
rajekas··on Witcraft by Jonathan Rée and the History of Philosophy by AC Grayling
As someone said, probably me, analytic philosophy is precise but boring while continental philosophy is vivid but incoherent. I always enjoy Terry Eagleton's barbed wit - he's convinced me to crack open a pint of Witcraft.
rajekas··on She Thought She’d Married a Rich Chinese Farmer. She Hadn’t
I am not well off. I am not Muslim and I am not a Pakistani woman, but I can see why the NYT is carrying this story. It's been snapping at China's heels all year long, reporting on the various ways in which China is exerting power in the world, and Pakistan - traditionally an American client state - is exhibit A in this change of guard. The Chinese are loaning them money, building their ports and power plants and are now the leading market for mail order brides. Soft power meets hard power, which is why its news.
rajekas··on Show HN: Mochi – Make notes with markdown, study them with spaced repetition
Very well done. Strikes me as literate programming married to Anki, so great for explanation as well as memorization.
rajekas··on The Achievement of Vasily Grossman
I have a friend, G, whose father, like Vasily Grossman, was a Jew in the Soviet army. An embedded journalist, just like VG.

Stalin only employed Jews in these forward positions because however bad it was on the Soviet side, it was worse in the Nazi camp, so no chance of defection. Then there was the added bonus of knowing Yiddish, i.e., a language closer to German than Russian.

G's father started the first German language newspaper in the Soviet zone. G's mother was his first employee. They fell in love, got married, had G and then a couple of years later, as Stalin became ever more anti-Semitic, G's father was purged. This was in 1950, before the Doctor's Plot. G was two years old.

Purged but not killed. I believe exiled to Gorky (Nizhny Novgorod) or some other place in Siberia. Which is where he lived out the rest of his life. G didn't see his father until 1977.

Such was life in the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics.

rajekas··on Show HN: Koonchi – Convert Photo to Hand-Painted Painting by Artists from India
My earlier comment met with some resistance, so let me try to get some more downvotes by stating my objections once again and more comprehensively.

I should say I have nothing against the premise of the business - if it provides livelihood to traditional craftspeople (or just talented artists of any kind) more power to you.

However, you are not making it easy for me to believe that you have the artist's best interests in mind. Let me count the reasons why:

1. Not a single individual artist or craftsperson is mentioned anywhere on the site. I don't know about you, but when I hear the term "artist," I think of an individual with a specific way of looking at the world. Absolutely every Indian artist and craftsperson I know has a desire to see their individuality recognized. You claim to be sourcing artists but you don't recognize their personhood anywhere. That's rather strange don't you think? It's possible that during the portraiture itself a bond is established between the representer and the representee but that's not the case on your site. It's an easily added feature if you're serious.

[EDIT] - as another commenter pointed out, there's a byline for each artist so what I said above is flawed. I still think you would be better off highlighting the artist's vision in more detail. For example, did artist X make the portrait in style Y - Suprio for Ballpoint Magic for example? If so, why aren't the portraits signed? Why choose to anonymize them at every stage? Otherwise it looks as if you are choosing to stroke the vanity of a western/affluent Indian audience.

2. Every Indian state and linguistic community has artistic traditions. Madhubani is different from Company painting is different from Mughal paintings. None of these traditions are even mentioned. In fact, there's no evidence that any Indian aesthetic tradition matters at all. Instead, what you have are generic categories - "the vision lure" - without connection to artistic traditions of any culture.

3. Then there's the origin story - "the idea was hatched when so and so were sipping coffee and discussing the works of Raja Ravi Verma in the historical city of Udaipur." At the very least that suggests an intimate connection between Raja Ravi Varma and Udaipur, especially if you aren't Indian. Except that RRV lived out his life in Kerala, far away from Udaipur and from a very different artistic and cultural milieu. If you had started the story with Tantric paintings [1] that are still produced anonymously in Rajasthan (just like your artists) I would have taken notice.

Suppose I went to a cafe in Stockholm, discussed the "da Vinci code" with a friend and decided to start a business in Italian greeting cards made for cut rates by unknown artists in Neapolitan neighborhoods (in between assignments for the 'ndrangheta, if you want to add some mystery to the whole process)- in what way would that be beneficial to European art?

[1] http://sigliopress.com/book/tantra-song/

rajekas··on PepsiCo sues Indian farmers for growing trademarked potatoes
Not only do I support the continued "stealing," I hope there's a farmer's campaign against Pepsi in India that leads to the company being banned as a whole. They have no idea of the depths of anger emerging out of the ongoing agrarian crisis.
rajekas··on Much of the “science” used in design is bullshit (2014)
Except that you don't need to publish journal articles anymore. Instead, combine 1 cup pseudo-psychology, 1 cup vague design principles and 1 cup quotes from Donald Norman and Massimo Vignelli. Sprinkle with Kahnemann on thinking fast and Pinker on evolutionary strategies. Publish it on Medium and watch it go viral - pop design science and Medium's business model being perfectly aligned right now.
rajekas··on Excerpts from Richard Stallman's talk in Mandya, India
In a strange coincidence, I was flying back from Bangalore in late Jan and the long curly haired person in the Emirates check-in line looked awfully like Richard Stallman. That's because it was Richard Stallman and in good Indian fashion, he was bring dropped off by someone who clearly adored him. I can't say I reach that level of admiration, but it's good there are people like him in the world.
rajekas··on “Silent Night” turns 200
No I haven't. Seems apropos. For some strange reason, the description reminds of of Erich Maria Remarque's "All Quiet on the Western Front," which doesn't have much joy in it.
rajekas··on “Silent Night” turns 200
I am not a Christian, never was, but I can't listen to Silent Night without tears coming to my eyes. May there be peace on earth for all beings.
rajekas··on Inside the court of Ashurbanipal, king of the world
Even the name percolates down the sands of time. The fifth Mughal emperor and builder of the Taj Mahal took the name "Shahjahan," i.e., King of the World. Like Ceasar becoming Kaiser, etymology recapitulates history.
rajekas··on Show HN: WriteFreely – minimalist, federated blogging platform
You're right - I interpreted the OP as wanting a single blog. The $10 a month or more is for hosting 250 blogs or more. I would say that's a pretty good deal.
rajekas··on Show HN: WriteFreely – minimalist, federated blogging platform
It's not $10 bucks a month but $1 or $6. I am a paying customer myself and very happy with the service.

They are generous enough to say that if you don't want to pay them money or have a different idea of what a blog should be, then take their software and make it into whatever you want it to be after inspecting their code.

Don't like that either? You can always come to HN and impugn their motives. Never let a good deed go unpunished.

rajekas··on Ask HN: Book which comprehensively covers probability theory?
Feller's two volume classic [1] has plenty of motivation - his exposition of combinatorics at the beginning of the first volume is a great introduction to that subject! However, it wasn't written with algorithms in mind.

Venkatesh's more recent volume [2] is very well motivated and is better suited to modern engineering applications. Both have lots of exercises.

[1] https://www.amazon.com/Introduction-Probability-Theory-Appli...

[2] https://www.amazon.com/Theory-Probability-Explorations-Appli...

rajekas··on Existing laser tech could be used for “porch light” to attract alien astronomers
I bet aliens love it when you shine a pointer in their eyes
rajekas··on How Congress Stopped Working
The United States minus Congress is essentially the Chinese system with two parties instead of one - overwhelming authority for the executive, overt and covert threats to get with the program. Not surprising, since our networked, interconnected world concentrates everything - wealth, fame, power etc.

I wonder how much of the balance of power is due to asymmetries of knowledge and expertise. We live in a very complex world and the President (perhaps not this one!) has access to top-drawer talent and large, specialized institutions whose job is to crunch the data to suit his mood. How can generalists who spend most of their time fund-raising hope to compete with the executive branch?

rajekas··on Blood money
Sorry for the confusion. What I meant was an analogy - just as Colombia or parts of Mexico were taken over by the narcotics industry and everything about them was transformed by the influx of drug money, Vancouver has been taken over by Chinese money transfers and everything about it has been transformed by that influx.
rajekas··on Blood money
In this case, the one nation whose sanctions are likely to impact the culprit is hesitant to do so because that will prevent the sales of weapons that invite the sanctions in the first place.
rajekas··on Blood money
Absolutely. It would be a sign of progress if politicians and NGOs along with companies stopped taking blood money.
rajekas··on Blood money
True. In a just world, the UN would be sanctioning KSA for its war in Yemen, but what are the chances of that happening? A privatized version is a modest alternative - a pledge that companies sign and enforce about their sources of financing. Nowhere near as good as state backed sanctions but a start.
rajekas··on Blood money
Of course, foreign capital inflows are hardly unique to Silicon Valley tech. Dodgy capital finds its way wherever speculation and money laundering are to be had. Real estate is a huge example. We have known for a while that some of the priciest real estate in the world in cities such as New York and London is due to capital inflows from the Middle East, Russia, China, India and other places where people have made enormous fortunes through illegal or semi-legal means. But that's only the tip of the iceberg. There's a difference between selling drugs on the street and creating a narco-state. If you want to see the first narco-state of real estate, move to Vancouver, where Chinese capital has turned the city upside down.

The fact is that dodgy capital inflows are central to every speculative bubble: real estate, bitcoin, Uber for X, you name it. Who else has the money to throw around?

I feel like we are at the beginning of a sweatshop moment for finance. Way back when it became known that kids were slaving away to produce your shoes, there was a global outcry and enormous pressure put on companies such as Nike to improve their operations. Did that save the world? No it didn't, but it changed the way outsourcing was implemented.

Similarly, we need to change the moral landscape of finance. I don't mean the radical solution of socializing investment or samizdats that people write in secret communist pamphlets. I mean raising the bar for the mainstream - making it impossible for otherwise profit minded people to take certain kinds of money.

rajekas··on Who Are My Investors?
I am several standard deviations to the left of Fred Wilson, but I can't fathom why his decision is being greeted with so much negativity.

He might have taken dodgy money at some point (but he's willing to acknowledge it) and now he's big enough to screen his LPs but he still didn't have to write this piece. That he has chosen to do so is a sign of progress. Let's give credit where it's due.

As a vegan, I want the world to stop eating slaughtered flesh, but I will be the first person to applaud if McDonalds stopped purchasing factory farmed meat (if only!). There's always the next frontier in our quest for justice and all the more reason to applaud an act of courage.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →