268 karma · joined October 17, 2014
Which neglects the superstructure on which the current growth story is based and also neglects the huge human and environmental cost of privatization even when it enables growth as [1] will tell you.
And that's why it's a terrible example to illustrate the value of private prisons in the US since those prisons also prey upon the most vulnerable and marginalized communities in that country.
In other words, GP's main point was to use India as an example for praising the merits of privatization vis-a-vis central planning there and then mapping that to the US to praise the privatization of prisons in comparison to state run prisons.
What, in fact, it shows is the exact opposite, that when it comes to services that need to put human welfare first and where money presents conflicts of interest, it's best done under the state umbrella or with strict supervision.
[1]: https://ruralindiaonline.org/articles/a-long-march-of-the-di...
I seriously doubt it.
Let's just take one simple example: the software boom centered in Bangalore and other (primarily) South Indian cities. Do you know why those booms happened there? It's because there was a large, educated workforce stemming from government investment in public sector firms - i.e., state enterprises. It's the children of government and public sector employees who set up most of the now famous software firms.
In other words, the private sector boom is unimaginable without two generations of public investment in industry and education and the first Indian prime minister, Nehru was acutely aware of the state's responsibility to make that happen because at the time of independence, there was no private industry that could invest in the kind of infrastructure - whether human or material - that led to the sort of development you are now claiming was unshackling India from suffering under central planning policies.
If you want to bring your ideology to work go right ahead, but please don't quote examples or historical precedents of which you know nothing.
Yes, a David Attenborough or Jacques Cousteau can make the natural world come alive. But an interactive digital platform will enable very different forms of storytelling.
> seeing and hearing what a tiger hears through your digital display is not the same
Of course not, just as being a Masai tribesman for a day or even living with them for three years as a peace corps volunteer is not the same as herding cows in Kenya. While stories never transport you into the real world, we all love the idea of platform 9-3/4. They serve different cognitive functions.
>I would wager that digitally experiencing nature from our comfortable cities does not raise that same connection to nature that one gets from actually being out there and experiencing it with _all_ of their senses.
Too broad a brush in my view. For example, there are things that you can do digitally that you can't do in person. However deep you go into a forest, you will never see it with a tiger's eyes because your bodies are different and your brain is different. Forget tigers and forests, you experience your home differently from a dog or cat that you have as a pet. Seeing your home through their eyes - however crudely - will be an act of interspecies empathy that you will never get through other means. It's possible some creatures are so different that their world will be incomprehensible to us even if we stream their senses 24/7. We won't know until we try. It remains an empirical question as to how much of that gap is bridgeable.
> to the point that they want to change their behaviours to protect it
I don't think we are at a point in human history when changing individual behaviors will save the planet, either from climate change or from ecological collapse. We need large scale political action with laws that have teeth and means of enforcing them at a planetary scale. The problem I am trying to solve here (or rather, claim as one needing solving) is a different one: how to transport ourselves into the bodies of other creatures? It's the animal equivalent of reading Dostoevsky to understand Russia - a problem very different from pouring billions into strengthening your computer systems because Russians are hacking your elections.
Nevertheless, this article strikes me as being deliberately written for its own cult members. Its air of injured rationality is exhibit A in grievance studies, the white people version.
Is there some vast underground of fence-sitters waiting to be convinced by their argument? I doubt it. Instead, the article is catnip for those who share the same grievances as the writers. Sure, they have one more data point that the other side is gullible or stupid.
I am more than willing to admit that portions of academia are cultish with guru figures who can easily destroy your life.
However, all one needs to do is look outside the ivory tower and ask if there are real injustices in the world, and the answer isn't hard to find. The vast majority of activists I know, women and men fighting for the rights of women, people of color, animals and trees have no interest in the battles over grievance studies.
This is not an article written in good faith. Which is to say, it's propaganda.
Having spent the last two years building a climate action platform I have lots of climate change problems with startup worthy solutions, but the item that really struck me was the online zoo. As an animal lover, the very idea of zoos - even the most enlightened ones - is problematic. Instead, why not let the mountain go to Mohammed?
Who wouldn't want to be a blue whale for a day. Or an eagle? Or a tiger? What might it be like to be an Octopus?
These are questions I have researched as a scientist, but in order to truly revolutionize the science, we need data. Lots of data and the best way to collect that data would be to create interfaces that allow people to see/smell/hear the world from the animal's perspective. It's like anthropology but with other species.
That's where the digital is actually better than the physical - while I can go to a regular zoo to see a tiger pace up and down, I can't actually be the tiger.
I bet people would be willing to pay money to be a tiger for a day. And you don't want that tiger to be in a zoo when you're the tiger. Much better if it was out there in the jungle where it was meant to be.
We need an unzoo.
Seems outrageous, but it's the one project I can see in this list advancing the frontiers of knowledge, saving other species and creating a business.
1. By aggregating all the apps I use, it invites almost as much distraction as the open web :) I would love it if there was a distraction free mode that locks Station for X amount of time in a pre-chosen cluster of apps. That way, I get to work with all the apps in my current workflow while being protected from the big bad web out there.
2. Resource use: not only does it become slower with multiple apps open, my laptop fan spins like crazy. Not the silent meditation I want as I attempt to enter a flow state.
3. My mental UNIX wants to work on one thing at a time and do that well. When I am in UNIX mode (i.e., whenever I am not distracted by the spawn of Zuck and Jack) I use the native/web app for that specific use case. I know switching out of that one app into another takes time, but it's still under my control.
In all, I am wondering if by recreating a full-fledged OS for apps Station is replicating the very problem that it's trying to eradicate.
I am amazed the commentary across the web is about Amazon's reasoning and almost no coverage of the patient organizing done by the SEIU and countless others to make $15 the minimum wage.
Then again, that silence is arguably a good thing, for it hides the fact that socialist ideas are increasingly mainstream in the heart of capital :)
What intrigues me more is that each era's barons find certain causes more appealing than others. Carnegie gave a lot of money to public libraries at a time when the printed word was expanding its reach. It's not surprising that Wikipedia is a favorite amongst tech tycoons along with education.
However, your mock poetry about plants yearning for freedom is close to being an ad-hominem attack. Are you saying you don't eat plants because you feel their pain? My guess is probably not. Instead, you are trying to deflect attention away from the suffering of those whom we know do feel pain.
[0]: https://www.amazon.com/What-Plant-Knows-Field-Senses/dp/0374... [1]: https://www.amazon.com/Hidden-Life-Trees-Communicate_Discove... [2]: https://www.amazon.com/Plant-Sensing-Communication-Interspec... [3]: https://www.springer.com/us/book/9783319755953
Save the world for whom? The tacit answer seems to be: for humans. Most vegans, including me, are vegan because we find the exploitation of animals morally unjustifiable. Our world includes the nonhuman world. And by being vegan we are saving it.
I am not as worried about the ease with which Indian citizen's privacy will be violated if these laws pass - systems such as Aadhar are far greater threats to our privacy and those come with the full force of the law and have support from every government in power, whether NDA or UPA or some third alliance. Plus, I would want foreign companies collecting data about Indian citizens to be accountable to the Indian public. The Bhopal tragedy is a good example of what happens when a foreign company isn't accountable to Indians in any manner whatsoever.
Of course, one might doubt whether Indian efforts to secure our data will withstand NSA or Chinese efforts to crack them, but we won't know until we try!