HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rajup

699 karma · joined September 18, 2017

submissionscomments
rajup··on Tell HN: My wife was banned from WhatsApp without reason or recourse
> Our only guess as to what could have caused this is that a week or so before the ban she received a spam message sent to a giant group and marked it as spam.

Hmm that's mildly concerning if that's the reason. My acquaintance got a similar spam message yesterday and they marked it as spam as well. No account closures yet though...

rajup··on Chinese students at Cornell “taunt” Uyghur classmate
> it takes surprisingly little people to overthrow a dictator, so counterintuitively dictators have much higher support than democracies.

That’s a very unique perspective I never thought of it that way. I wonder though if some or most of a dictator’s power come from having a tight control over means of suppression, from controlled media to the military. The latter 2 would seem to require a much smaller percentage of support than 90%

rajup··on The Washington Post Fires Reporter Felicia Sonmez
Oh the delicious irony...
rajup··on Dropbox deletes Rick and Morty creators account for secret TOS violation
Sadly this story could have happened with any big cloud provider.

Ideally there would be more regulation around the ability of big tech companies to shutdown your digital life through a mindless algorithm, with close to zero recourse. Unfortunately I don’t see anything happening unless someone really powerful (say a member of Congress) gets bitten by this.

rajup··on The case for expanding rather than eliminating gifted education programs (2021)
I mean hypothetically all the money given to a school could be used to build a giant statue but does that actually happen? In your example, are we sure giving teachers a pay rise does not make them more motivated and hence leading to better outcomes?
rajup··on The case for expanding rather than eliminating gifted education programs (2021)
Well how should it be measured then?
rajup··on Chesa Boudin Recalled by San Francisco Voters
> what is the story from their side of things?

That crime is going down (but see grand-grand-grand parent's point about less prosecutions).

That these policies actually help the homeless or reduces crime(initial evidence does not look good).

That voters voting for recall are brain-washed by misinformation from Republicans (?!. Ah yes the classic misinformation bogeyman misleading the poor gullible voters).

rajup··on Chesa Boudin Recalled by San Francisco Voters
> lol, that's pretty easy to do when you just stop prosecuting people. Same way graduation rates increase if you just stop failing people.

Or the way COVID cases drop when you stop testing!

rajup··on Chesa Boudin Recalled by San Francisco Voters
I agree with you, but this is more a matter of linguistic convenience than lack of education or perspective imo. The people who call chesa far left in the USA know perfectly well what they mean, other people have no trouble understanding it either.
rajup··on ACCC: Airbnb allegedly misled Australians about accommodation prices
Even in the USA it seems to depend on the length of stay. For 28 days or less, the search pages has a per-night rate AND the total next to it, that includes cleaning fees, taxes etc, i.e the exact price you would pay. For monthly or more stays it does not seem to show the total which seems like a very inconsistent user experience.
rajup··on The children of atomic bomb survivors: A genetic study
As a corollary, I imagine this also probably means the dangers of nuclear power are overblown.
rajup··on Google cancelled a talk on caste bias
> Or it can be is as simple as saying a caste system is dumb

Agreed.

And this ironically is the crux of the problem: most Indians find it dumb, don’t care for it and hope it dies out soon. But some groups would like to keep using it as yet another way to divide for myriad reasons: vote bank politics being the biggest if you follow any Indian politics at all. Preventing base bigoted discrimination is a reason too, but a very small reason.

This group equality labs is less of the latter and more of the former.

rajup··on Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallowed from Giving Lecture
What you said makes sense, thank you!
rajup··on Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallowed from Giving Lecture
Systemic? I just pointed out the rights and privileges guaranteed lower castes in the Indian constitution. How much more un-systemic does it get? The past and inherited poverty: for how long? It’s been 70+ years since India’s independence…
rajup··on Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallowed from Giving Lecture
> I’ve had 4-5 instances when these Bigots found me because I was eating chicken and they had to lecture about my sin.

Oh haha that has happened to me as well, I’m an “upper” caste fellow and eat meat on occasion and have been lectured by one of these guys on how I am doomed to be reborn as a worm or something! Shitty people exist everywhere I guess..

rajup··on Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallowed from Giving Lecture
> Ofcourse they would. They are mostly those whose parents (or themselves) were privileged enough to make it to the US.

I keep seeing this thrown around, but I am yet to see anyone respond exactly what form this "privilege" takes as it pertains to caste. The Indian constitution was co-written by a very forward thinking Dalit and affirmative action for lower castes is literally written into the Indian constitution. The only "privilege" I know of is that only upper castes can conduct priestly duties etc (at least used to), but I mean cmon that's just clutching at straws...

rajup··on Sr Manager at Google Resigns After Dalit Activist Disallowed from Giving Lecture
> Something like 90% of the Indian immigrants in the US are high-caste (big surprise, lower-caste Indians are less likely to be able to get work visas and travel), so of course this is a minority problem.

Why do you think this is the case despite one of the most active affirmation programs in the world (just search "Reservation in India" on Wikipedia)? Something like 50-60% of seats in colleges and jobs in the government are reserved for lower castes (not a typo, the Wikipedia page should link you to official Indian constitution websites). I am from India and I genuinely don't know the answer myself.

rajup··on Google cancelled a talk on caste bias
> You'll do whatever you can to maintain the fragile worldview that you haven't been the beneficiary of a class-based system that discriminates and gives you an unfair advantage.

I find this POV extremely fascinating outside India. Here's the thing in case you are unaware: in India, roughly 50-60% of jobs in the government sector, seats in government funded colleges and private colleges (and soon probably even in private companies) are set aside for the "lower" castes and tribes[1]. I use scare quotes here, because there is a whole other discussion of how many "lower" castes actually need this kind of affirmative action since they are extremely well off that I won't get into here. I come from an "upper" caste family (scare quotes here because I find the terminology stupid and divisive, I definitely don't consider myself "upper" in any way) where my grandfather was a dirt-poor farmer who moved from the village to the city, died dirt poor as well (think Slumdog Millionaire level poverty). My father worked hard, educated himself and got himself a job in the government sector despite having nothing "reserved" for him. I did the same too with nobody handing me anything. This is the same story across millions of families across India. So tell me, what unfair advantage or privilege did this system really afford me? And then I see this enlightened person on the Internet who has probably heard/read about caste in the last couple of days have a fully formed opinion on all things caste, with no real intention of really understanding the issue. A superficial understanding is only going to get you so far without descending into all out stereotypes and bigotry, like another commenter on here who equated wearing the sacred thread with a Klan hood. But then I guess you are right in a way: we're all just different groups of chimpanzees with tools.

[1]. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reservation_in_India

rajup··on Google cancelled a talk on caste bias
Godwin’s law strikes again. All Brahmins are nazis. Excellent.
rajup··on Google cancelled a talk on caste bias
Well, most religions are inherited and (as of today at least) identifying as religious does not automatically make one <insert-favorite-identity>-ist.
rajup··on Google cancelled a talk on caste bias
> I know but all Brahmins wear the sacred thread.

False. I may have only anecdotal evidence, but even one counter-example renders your statement incorrect.

rajup··on Google cancelled a talk on caste bias
> You show that you care about tradition.

“Caring” about tradition (whatever that means) is equivalent to being complicit in social ills. Ok got it.

rajup··on Google cancelled a talk on caste bias
Many Brahmins I know don’t wear it. So how is it a caste marker? Heck I wear it only during certain ceremonies. So the point the gp was making about people wearing the sacred thread condoning the caste system and discrimination is patently false and bigoted.
rajup··on Google cancelled a talk on caste bias
> It doesn't matter what reasons you have. What matters is the consequence of your behavior, namely, it is visible difference between castes, which makes discrimination easier and avoiding discrimination harder.

Not unless I go running around naked

> And your comment show that you are not concerned in a slightest about discrimination. Tradition is more important to you than people.

How exactly do you infer that? You don’t know me. I care about discrimination just as much as the next person. What I don’t care much for is rank identity politics disguised as benevolent activism spewed from a non-existent moral high ground.

rajup··on Google cancelled a talk on caste bias
We seem to be on the path to it for sure :)
rajup··on Google cancelled a talk on caste bias
Wrong, I wear the thread the same reason a Sikh wears a turban or a Muslim woman wears a niqab/burka. Wearing a sacred thread has about as much relation to condoning/accepting caste discrimination as wearing a niqab has to terrorism, but these kinds of bigoted ignorant comments are exactly why Google was right in not allowing the talk to happen.
rajup··on CNN cutting back on over-hyping everything as “breaking news”
How exactly is this flamebait?
rajup··on SPACs are warning they may go bust
If it's a pretty big index it's unlikely a company going bust here or there is a big deal.
rajup··on Behind the Pretty Frames: Elden Ring
Having played some of the soulsborne games before I much prefer being able to go away and explore something else if I hit a hard boss or area. It keeps the game much more enjoyable and not feel as "grindy". You do have a point about hitting some things earlier or later than you should, but usually under-leveled players are not going to make much progress in the tougher areas anyway...
rajup··on Ask HN: What to do about ‘Good at programming Bad at Leetcode’
> My advice? Start memorizing the riddles.

I don't have a strong opinion either way, I got with the Leetcode grind program for my current position, but I really wonder about this: is it really possible to memorize these questions? Last I checked Leetcode has over 2000 questions, anyone who can memorize the solutions to all those is some kind of genius savant and should be hired anyway. Or is memorizing meant in a different context here?

← PreviousPage 6 of 12Next →