A friend and I debate this topic all the time
Is this time really different?
Pro:
1) Automation and Ai is replacing white collar work this time. There could truly be insufficient job creation as we see already with the gig economy
2) As Charles Murray wrote preciently in the 90s a great spoil of the wealth goes to people of higher intelligence. People in these walled gardens (literally sometimes) cannot relate to life on the outside. E.g. article today on front page about more Americans than working 2 jobs and the top comments there [A]. Also seen with the increasing wealth gap and increasing in wealth for the uber rich after covid and 08. There is no catching up especially with fed policies that reward existing asset owners
3) There may come a time where there is no marginal use for labour at a living wage
4) The ubi has already started and will now just accelerate. E.g. earth as portrayed in the expanse
Con:
5) Libertarian argument: this has all happened before. Human wants and needs are unlimited. Labour is a scarce and valuable resource. There will always be jobs maybe at lower nominal wages but higher real wages if govts stop controlling interest rates and let prices fall
I'm on the con side of the argument but I can't think of anything more compelling
Hope this article becomes popular as I look forward to expanding my horizons via the educated hacker News crowd
[A] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26184012