837 karma · joined March 8, 2022
1) Whether the weights are static or dynamic over time is not of importance. As a simple counter argument, if for instance the theory that LLMs could produce AGI if they could just be pushed to an absolutely colossal scale, then a planet scale computer might produce a machine intelligence by the definition of this conversation. That’s a big what if, and it’s about as useful as string theory, but it illustrates something I touch on in point #2.
2) A second counter argument to the “well the weights are hardcoded and ChatGPT doesn’t learn” argument, ChatGPT does learn. I’ve taught it conversational protocols, where it stored information mutates it, and lets me retrieve it in a standard I invented on the spot. This is the entire basis of ChatGPT, understanding call-response of human conversation in the probabilistic abstract. The apparatus ChatGPT uses to “stretch the similar distribution into the temporal dimension” is that it can store new information passively in the continuing conversation thread. You could theoretically teach ChatGPT about 2023 by having a conversation about recent events. It probably wouldn’t be as effective as having trained it on new information, but nonetheless.
3) Finally, a deeper argument against what you’re saying, what you’re arguing has nothing to do with the definition of intelligence I’m using here. That is: “An agent which is exceedingly effective at its game.” it’s important to characterize intelligence by the game that the agent in question aims to play. When we say a child is intelligent, we don’t mean it in the same way that we say a doctor is intelligent. The two are playing entirely different games, yet both are considered intelligent. This is because the game parameterizes intelligence, and the intelligence explosion is all about the proliferation of specialized intelligences for the variety of “games” out there. ChatGPT is exceptional at its game of “general human conversational prediction up to the year 2021”.
But back to what I’m really saying here: “Generative AI eruption” is a mouthful whereas “intelligence explosion” is concise.
I really think we should stick to Nick Bostrom’s (or pls fix attribution) term “intelligence explosion”
Because there’s lots of evidence that correlates socioeconomic status with access to nutrition. It’s almost like you are what you eat, or something. Nobody is 300lbs eating daily the foods that trigger ketosis. It’s not the outrageous availability of corn that is driving demand for corn syrup, right?
I respect that to a degree people are responsible for their own nutrition. But there are plenty of people that lack life experience diff’ing how they feel on a week of McDonalds vs how they feel on a week of literally anything else.
> food prices are incredibly low
I.. they’re not, but please share where you’re living globally where this is true, because omw!
Also I get that basically the Soviet Union failed this exact idea.
If I could do the work of even two developers, I’m definitely getting paid. I think software engineering is headed for a John Henry moment.
(1) tests (2) features and or fixes (3) perhaps supporting documentation (4) perhaps even applicable build changes
Sorry to disappoint, I too am frustrated about ChatGPT/GPT-3/LLM mainstream gossip deluge, but that doesn’t mean I disagree with augmenting my productivity with the latest tools.
The official Arch Linux wiki url is https://wiki.archlinux.org/
The cool thing is, a file will always be configuration data, so decide what format works for you and your team and keep your wheels on the ground. Yaml, despite its opponents, is my first choice. I’ve never run into the problems people say the have with it, and I use it frequently to configure Docker-compose and kubernetes resources anyway.
1. Install App (such as Reddit) before use, delete after.
2. Scorched Earth Campaign on my Notifications settings on my smartphone
3. Stick to Hacker News, as most of it is boring irrevelant drivel these days.
4. Trained myself to recognize when I was instinctively cracking open a news website, or Social Media.
I've realized that my daily tendencies are really just repeats of some tendency from days ago, in my mind's helpless attempt to stay preoccupied. If those daily tendencies include a habit loop like "hey, this sucks, maybe crack open your phone to get out of the way of the misery", then as long as my phone is telling me to fuck right off, it operates as a reminder that I'm not interested in it.
A similar dismissive argument can be made of discipline.
“Discipline, broadly speaking, operates on the erroneous assumption that you can dominate yourself to execute endlessly without fear of utterly snapping.”
At some point you look up and realize you’ve wasted the best decade of your life trying to build something nobody wants, at which point you start considering the shape of objects you might put in your mouth besides food.
There’s a lot to be said for going with the flow.
“Everybody knows that x”, or the crowd who appeals to authority
“Everybody who thinks that x has been duped”, or the contrarians.
In summary, it’s all basically Counterstrike.
You asked me what my reasons were for disliking C# (circa 2017, remember I said it’s been awhile, so these are the impressions I left with), and then when I gave my reasons, as you requested, you changed your tune and said “well, those are all personal preferences.” Yeah, dunno if you noticed but, a lot of the time things boil down to developer preference.
For example, I’ve proposed to teams before that we write new necessary services in different languages than the vogue one for the team, for performance purposes. The (arguably reasonable, despite being displeasing) answer given was “no, we’re a JavaScript shop, it’s our preference.” Software dev is social as much as it is technical.
So, all things considered, if a language has the typical feature set of garbage collection, FCF/FP patterns, some flavor of OO, a framework for interacting with the OS for things like threading and file IO and networking, a package manager and an ecosystem, is maybe even holding hands with LLVM, the average enterprise CRUD SaaS software developer (me in 2017) isn’t going to need to make the investment to implement the same code multiple times and benchmark to make sure they’ve picked the most technically optimal system. It’s going to boil down to personal preference, or indirectly the personal preference of available engineers, or there legacy of code left behind by other engineers, and I don’t really care that you don’t think my personal preferences are valid.