HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rbarooah

1,972 karma · joined May 31, 2008

submissionscomments
rbarooah··on What can you do with an Android application with no permissions?
I thought the whole selling point of Android is that it is not tightly controlled.
rbarooah··on Google (as a company) is more popular than Facebook, Twitter, and even Apple
Those are not criticisms of Google the company. They are minor feature gripes about products.

This supports my point.

rbarooah··on What can you do with an Android application with no permissions?
It seems like a rhetorical question.
rbarooah··on What can you do with an Android application with no permissions?
Press the 'reader' button in safari.
rbarooah··on Google (as a company) is more popular than Facebook, Twitter, and even Apple
What proof are you speaking of?
rbarooah··on Google (as a company) is more popular than Facebook, Twitter, and even Apple
In other words Android users don't criticize Google.

edit:

It is hardly a big reveal that this correlation exists. Presumably people's opinions have an influence on how they choose to spend their money and vice-versa.

Singling out 'Apple Users' in this regard is just an ad hominem.

rbarooah··on Apple Snubs Firm That Discovered Mac Botnet
It's easy to point to Alan Kay's research and then wistfully say that it will hopefully bear fruit one day, but that actually does a disservice to anybody working on today's systems that treat the user as a mature, self-actualizing owner - whether they be creating new software or making existing software more user-friendly.

Setting the straw-men aside, which systems did you have in mind?

rbarooah··on Apple Snubs Firm That Discovered Mac Botnet
Instead of being introduced to a world full of self determination and limitless possibilities (as early computer adopters were), modern day users are shown a standard no-free-lunch world where "they either get you coming or going". Developers are still able to seek out freedom, but the goal of empowering an end user to solve their own problems couldn't be farther from sight.

I couldn't agree more with this. However that dream seemed to die with the breakup of Alan Kay's original group. Nobody is even approaching this problem except perhaps Kay's own FONC group, and even that seems to be more academic than practical now.

That said, I think that as digital culture matures as more generations grow up with digital creation, programmability will become the primary constraint, and then we might see progress in this area. If Apple doesn't keep up (although I expect they will), this is the domain I expect the killer app to emerge from.

I'm not sure why you bring up the device-id thing. Apple corrected that issue without external pressure. Also, in the real world, I think that expecting end-users to manage a second cookie-like entity with subtly different semantics to cookies is unrealistic.

rbarooah··on Apple Snubs Firm That Discovered Mac Botnet
By #3 I was referring to the parent's 3rd comment about the focus on improving the toolchain and runtime. I doubt that you're serious about the jailbreak comment.

By far ahead, I was referring to the deployment of code signing technology.

I think it's pretty clear that although Microsoft has solid code signing technology, they are much further behind in promoting effective use of it in the field.

rbarooah··on Apple Snubs Firm That Discovered Mac Botnet
I agree with your first point, but I disagree that it makes Mac OS into a 'display terminal'. Particularly since although hoops are being introduced for good reason, there is no evidence that Mac OS X will be closed in the way iOS is.

Your second point as I've indicated, is just conjecture. I don't see good evidence for it actually happening. Certainly nothing that Apple has publicly disclosed suggests that it will. It seems pretty unlikely to me.

But yes, if they did go that far, they would indeed control what average users were capable of.

If it ever gets to that point, I'd hope that by that time, there would be some obvious killer apps for another OS to demonstrate why it was a problem.

[edit: Coarse grained whitelists might not be the answer, but I highly doubt that Apple is going to stop there. Every OS release is a step along the way. It's worth noting that iOS has generally developed in the direction of providing more capabilities to programmers, rather than less over time.]

rbarooah··on Apple Snubs Firm That Discovered Mac Botnet
It's not an arbitrary dichotomy, it's a factual one. Mac OS doesn't resemble a centrally controlled 'display terminal' at all, whereas Chrome OS does.

You also didn't answer the part about trusted code.

rbarooah··on Apple Snubs Firm That Discovered Mac Botnet
1. Where are those bug searching tools used?

2. I'd agree that the outreach program is something that Apple clearly hasn't done.

3. Apple clearly is doing this too.

HP's work on secret agents in the 90's shows that you can't prove code to be trustworthy. You can only assign trust to the intentions of the originator.

Therefore, the most significant thing you can do to improve security is to verify the provenance of trusted code and the isolation of untrusted code.

Windows clearly has decent technical code-signing infrastructure, but Apple seems far ahead in terms of effectively deploying this model into the field.

rbarooah··on Apple Snubs Firm That Discovered Mac Botnet
Are you sure you're not talking about Chrome OS?

Also, what's your proposal for establishing the trustworthiness of code?

rbarooah··on Apple Snubs Firm That Discovered Mac Botnet
You didn't answer my question. You've offered a vague opinion about appearances.

If you had answered my question you would be able to pick out at least one thing that Microsoft had done that Apple had not.

You said: Microsoft did their job years ago, now Apple has to follow.

This is simply not supported by the facts.

rbarooah··on Apple Snubs Firm That Discovered Mac Botnet
You dodged the question.

You haven't listed a single thing that Microsoft has done that Apple has not.

You are right that Microsoft started to take security seriously before Apple did, but Apple is not still behind.

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2011/07/21/mac_os_x_lion_securi...

rbarooah··on Apple Snubs Firm That Discovered Mac Botnet
What do you think Microsoft has done that Apple has not?
rbarooah··on AOL Sells 800 Patents For $1 Billion To Microsoft
It may be consistent but suing over standards essential patents is dishonest. Arguably it's worse than what Apple and MS are doing.
rbarooah··on AOL Sells 800 Patents For $1 Billion To Microsoft
Their refusal to clarify what they intend to do with Motorola's standards essential patents groups them in with Apple and MS.
rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
Just to be clear - you do get that I agreed with you in my previous comment? I even went as far as to mildly echo Sayre's comment about economic nationalism.

Having said that, these quotes are good to see.

rbarooah··on While Apple Is Criticized for Foxconn, Other Companies Are Silent
I agree that it's achieving the goal of pushing Apple to improve working conditions although given that they started their improvement program in 2006, it's highly debatable whether the recent outrage has achieved anything that wasn't already happening.

It remains to be seen whether this will have any effect on other manufacturers.

rbarooah··on A Man. A Woman. Just Friends?
Lord of the rings draws its dramatic tension from evil and the threat or violence and death instead of sex.
rbarooah··on While Apple Is Criticized for Foxconn, Other Companies Are Silent
Nokia isn't doing the most to improve working conditions. Apple is.
rbarooah··on While Apple Is Criticized for Foxconn, Other Companies Are Silent
I didn't say it wasn't working. I just think don't think it's helpful to claim it's the best way.

[edit: one reason I think it's unhelpful is that it legitimizes misleading reporting, which is itself a great harm]

rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
I'd definitely agree that trade at gunpoint is on the same spectrum as war. I can see how you get from there to all protectionism being on that spectrum too.

Short of eliminating national borders, I don't see how this would go away.

rbarooah··on While Apple Is Criticized for Foxconn, Other Companies Are Silent
Since they are doing the most to improve working conditions, perhaps they deserve more profit.
rbarooah··on While Apple Is Criticized for Foxconn, Other Companies Are Silent
Targeting Apple has proven to be the best vehicle for that.

Do you have any evidence at all for this? How do you know that targeting other companies too wouldn't be more effective?

rbarooah··on While Apple Is Criticized for Foxconn, Other Companies Are Silent
So do you think that Samsung for example, has less responsibility for its worker's conditions than Apple?
rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
I'd suggest that war is different because with protectionism one side can choose not to trade if they don't like the terms, whereas one cannot simply choose not to participate in war.
rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
Summary: If it there was a straw man, you'd be able to identify the argument that it was being used to win.

You can't, so there is no straw man.

rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
The least I can say is that you come across as someone who disagrees with your interlocutor's opinion. If you are not willing to admit that, I will call this conversation over.

I don't think that the relatively emotive statement that the interlocutor made paints a particularly complete picture. That's why I asked the question. I don't know enough of his opinion to disagree with it or not because he didn't answer.

If you reread what my interlocutor wrote you'll see that he introduces a number of different ideas which don't add up to a single coherent argument to agree or disagree with.

Typically when someone presents me with this sort of communication and I find it interesting, I don't consider it an argument. Instead I try to find out more.

You say 'all you can do is to question my intellectual honesty', but if you really thought I tried to win an argument using a strawman, you would be able to point out where I did that and yet you can't.

If you won't acknowledge the possibility that you have perceived an argument in what was actually a discussion, then I have to, in return, question your intellectual honesty.

It's counterproductive to the cause of rooting out fallacies to make drive-by comments out of context.

← PreviousPage 4 of 30Next →