HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rbrogan

125 karma · joined December 14, 2014

ARTICLES http://rbrogan.github.io
submissionscomments
rbrogan··on Ask HN: Do you think software can be art?
IMO, art involves intention and conveys something. I do not know what to call what it conveys, but it comes from the artist. It is not accidental. So, a piece of software can be beautiful but not art. But software (e.g. games) can convey something and can be art.
rbrogan··on ‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next game
He is featured in this nice documentary about indie games along with a couple of different development teams:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lq5HRdTyKUs

rbrogan··on The Singular Universe and the Reality of Time
Personally, I can also recommend Philip Turetzky's Time for those interested in the question "What is Time?" from a philosophical (rather than a physical) POV. The book is a survey of thinking about Time from the ancient Greeks through the 20th century. It is not light reading, but no philosophy PhD is needed if you read it carefully.
rbrogan··on I have no idea what I'm doing
Everyone knew everything about everything they do then AI would be easy.
rbrogan··on Science’s Biggest Fail
If no one says anything, then is there any motivation for it to get any better? Is the article is totally wrong or can it be translated into a problem statement whose solution is an improvement? IMO, it is equivalent to a user complaint about a software product. Possibly science researchers would not be the ones to solve the problem, but rather science journalists (I don't know). But still, if the public devalues the results of scientific research due to lack of confidence then that could conceivably result in less funding for scientific endeavors and less scientific progress.
rbrogan··on How would the world change if we found extraterrestrial life?
That is not obvious (no offense). When I think of "the world", I also think about things beyond "social human behavior". For instance, you could ask how contact with alien life could affect how we use this planet Earth (e.g. usage of natural resources, pollution, etc.). Conceivably, it could also change how we think about (non-human) life on this planet. One can talk about "the world" and talk about humans without necessarily being anthropocentric.
rbrogan··on Why can’t the world’s greatest minds solve the mystery of consciousness?
Is there anything for which you cannot ask a similar question of the form: Why does xyz exist? Why are things not just [this simpler thing]? For those types of questions, I imagine one would answer: because if it were not so then things would be nonsense.

If this question is asked of consciousness without saying what consciousness is doing such that if you took it away then you would have nonsense, then I do not see how anyone can answer it.

The way the question is framed up, consciousness accomplishes nothing as far as survival goes. "evolution could have produced zombies instead of conscious creatures – and it didn’t" Zombie seems to be defined as: phenomena that you think has consciousness but does not.

If consciousness has been defined as some phenomena where you have an intuitive understanding of what is being communicated by that word "consciousness" but also it (consciousness) does not do anything, then how can anyone explain why consciousness should be? Anything you can think of as a function of consciousness, can then be hand-waved as able to be accomplished by zombies.

rbrogan··on The Best Way yet to Talk to Aliens, If They’re out There (2013)
If there were aliens that understood the "hailing message" and did not respond, and if we were to assume there was a message that would get a response, then how to figure that out? How to get better at sending messages when getting no response?
rbrogan··on To Be More Creative, Cheer Up
A lot of nice information in the article. I think people can be more creative than they realize if they (1) legitimize associative thinking (this is what I translate "being uninhibited" to mean) and (2) insist that they have a basic capacity for being creative. Creativity often does not come immediately when you want it, so (IMO) when it does not, you have to insist you still have the capacity rather than treat that as a failure and give up.
rbrogan··on Why the modern world is bad for your brain
I am optimistic as well. I have dealt with many of the problems in the article and developed my own mental tech to solve them (mostly around personal organization and self-discipline). I think it is better assume that problems do have a solution, rather than think there must be something bad which is the cause (e.g. technology itself).
rbrogan··on Study: The Effects of Line Length on Reading Online News (2008)
Any guesses as to why this would be so? My guess is that people thought they were reading faster at fewer words per line because there was less effort involved. If it were so, I wonder what it should mean for usability? Should you engineer things so that your users are more effective or so that they believe they are more effective?
rbrogan··on ‘Soft’ Artificial Intelligence Is Suddenly Everywhere
I also have a dumb question: Where is "AI" in our software development toolchains? Intellisense comes to mind. Compiler optimizations also come to mind. What more is coming or is already out there? Lately, I find myself thinking more and more about Prolog (or something similar) to help encode some thinking. We have seen functional programming make a comeback. Will we see more logic programming as well?
rbrogan··on People Can Be Convinced They Committed a Crime That Never Happened
"The fact that the students appeared to internalize the false events to the extent that they did highlights the fundamental malleability of memory"

Is it true that the memories themselves are false or is it the remembering process that is influenced to produce false beliefs about what happened?

rbrogan··on Google Glass sales halted
Wondering if Google had always expected this and Glass was a long-term strategic move or if this was unexpected and should be considered a blunder.
rbrogan··on Writers Say They Feel Censored by Surveillance
"Whoso would be a man must be a nonconformist. He who would gather immortal palms must not be hindered by the name of goodness, but must explore if it be goodness. Nothing is at last sacred but the integrity of your own mind. Absolve you to yourself, and you shall have the suffrage of the world." -- Ralph Waldo Emerson, Self-Reliance

People have to (be able to) say what they think or there will not be much thinking going on at all.

rbrogan··on What Made OO Be Successful
Nice response, and I agree with a lot of it. Particularly, I think this is key: "This is why good software developers hate working in these places. It would be like a fine watch craftsman going to work on the Timex digital watch assembly line at Foxconn." For an individual developer, OO can be restrictive and prevent them from writing their best code. This tends to make us argue against OO on various (legitimate) technical bases but for an organization the (perceived) weight of the pros will tend to be for OO and the cons are not seen to make for enough of an actual bottleneck on peoples abilities.
rbrogan··on What Made OO Be Successful
That is correct, in the abstract. There can be programs written in both C and Java that do the same thing. The question is then: if people are writing programs in Java, what is the cause, what is making that happen?
rbrogan··on The Problem of the Many
What weight does an interpretation hold? I would propose adopting a basic rule similar to Occam's Razor like: "The most mundane and reasonable interpretation is best."
rbrogan··on The Problem of the Many
Maybe there is a difference between an idea and a concept. I have an idea of a cloud. I have no strong concept of a cloud, and that would not matter unless faced with a problem that required a strong concept of a cloud in order to resolve the problem.

Is there a problem? Seems to me if there were an actual and important problem whose solution were dependent on "what a cloud is" then you would have no shortage of conceptualizations. What then matters is to what extent they are useful for resolving problems.

I believe this is quite normal and our conceptualizations of ideas change as the problems we face change. For instance, you can always ask what does Justice, the Idea, mean. People have developed concepts over time and applied them. The success leads to further problems, asking again what Justice means, and further concepts.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2