HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rekoil

1,220 karma · joined October 15, 2013

submissionscomments
rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
That's a fair argument, you've honestly swayed me.
rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
There's scale. Spotify being dicks doesn't impact as many users as Apple being dicks.

But I agree with you in general!

rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
Because there are laws about what a driver is allowed to do while driving and for very good reasons. Infotainment systems are a natural source of distractions, and without safeguards there isn't anything stopping things like Netflix from running while the car is being driven.

I wish we lived in a world where we could say, "sure but the driver knows not to put that on while driving, so we're all good!", but we very much unfortunately don't...

rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
"Just" make the implementation imitate some old Spotify Connect hardware that isn't being updated anymore and it would be near impossible for Spotify to realistically tell the difference.

Sure, people would still worry about using such software, but from an engineering standpoint, unless there's a signed Spotify Connect chip that for some reason can't be emulated, there isn't much Spotify can do to detect well-implemented reverse engineered API clients.

Not something you throw together in a day obviously, but definitely not impossible.

rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
That's a little different, but an interesting topic to discuss!

In my opinion there are 3 ways forward in such situations.

1. The manufacturer designs the car so that the infotainment unit is replaceable when they stop updating the original. Replacements not certified as "road safe" would be illegal to install.

2. The manufacturer literally never stops updating the software... (yeah, obviously this isn't a real alternative, but it's technically acceptable if a manufacturer wants to attempt to make that promise)

3. The manufacturer, after ceasing updates, provides the necessary documentation for an alternative software to be built, but it wouldn't be obviously legal to install just anything, the software would need to be certified "road safe" and how you would assert that you're not running unsafe software is not obvious to me.

rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
It is shitty they killed libspotify, but it isn't hard to reverse engineer the way the app communicates with the backend, this has already happened in the form of https://github.com/librespot-org/librespot as an example.

And if Apples ecosystem wasn't so locked down I could write a HomePod client using librespot and Daniel Ek could get however mad he wants about it.

rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
It is an infuriating state of affairs.

Ironically, if the Apple ecosystem wasn't so locked down the open source community would have solved this issue by now.

rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
> Why isn't the iPhone a smartphone, a purpose-specific device?

Because it can be extended via software to support whole new categories of apps.

Sure, a games console technically is a computer and the above statement is true for it as well, but it wasn't marketed as such.

rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
> Had they, there would be a false marketing angle to play. But they didn't so there isn't.

That argument is relevant for the original iPhone, not for any iPhones sold after the advent of the App Store.

> Apple never marketed its devices as general-purpose computers.

Yet they are. It isn't up to the manufacturer to choose which class of regulations they want to play under, that definition is for an external part to decide, otherwise Apple could just classify all of their devices as fidget spinners and do whatever the hell they want.

rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
> I would consider a phone as damgerous as a scooter, if not more - considering the amount of private information in it and the access to bank accounts it grants.

App sandboxing protects you from apps trying to access your information without your say-so, I'm not advocating for Apple to allow these third party apps to bypass the sandbox.

rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
But it's optional enshittification. I should have the option of messing up my device. Apple are free to scare me away from doing so, but the choice needs to be mine as the owner.
rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
They already have annoying modals that pop up when apps are using my location in the background, they could easily make these hypothetical "NotificationServiceKit apps" spawn similar modals when they take up a lot of CPU time, memory, or other energy intensive metrics.
rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
> My thermostat updates itself OTA.

I can't tell if you're being intentionally obtuse. It's pretty obvious from the discussion I am not talking about anything that has updatable software, I'm talking about things sold with the promise to be able to add broad new functionality in multiple fields. A thermostat may be able to add new methods of scheduling, energy saving, other means of control, integrations with other smart devices, but all with the singular purpose of controlling a radiator, under-floor heating or other heating device.

But if we're gonna entertain the notion somewhat, yes, if the thermostat allowed installation of non-thermostat related things like video streaming services, games, Twitter, or other apps that were allowed to run on the device to give it more use than at point of sale, and it was also marketed as such when sold, then yes, it was being sold as a (rather silly) general-purpose computing device and should be required to give users access to what they need to build their own software and run it on it, sans manufacturer control.

rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
PlayStation is a games console, it's a purpose-specific device. I think there needs to be regulation there as well, but not the same regulation as for general-purpose computing devices like the iPhone or Android, or whatever Apple are slowly trying to turn MacBooks into.

I don't pretend to know all the answers, my stance is that the reason our society is where it is today is at least in part because computers have been computers, and not this "my way or the highway" approach Apple has for the iPhone.

rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
> Since when have iPhones been marketed as such?

Prove to me that Apple has never marketed the App Store or the fact that you can run non-Apple software on an iPhone. If you can do that I'll drop this argument immediately.

> Just the framing of being "able to install whatever software we want on hardware we own."

But I'm specifically not saying that, I'm saying hardware sold to me with the promise that I'll be able to expand its functionality via software. Regardless how you want to try to spin it that's what general-purpose computing means.

I'm saying that if you want to sell a product which relies on software written by other people (that are not the vendor) to be successful, then you have to go the whole way, you can't then say "ah but see actually I'm the only one that can decide WHAT can run on your device, and you have to pay ME forever for the pleasure of running anything on it!". You can put up road blocks if you want, but you've sold me a device intended to be expandable via software, a general-purpose computing device, not a purpose-specific device.

rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
This is certainly one of the takes of all time.

I want some of what you're smoking mate.

rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
Not if those devices aren't marketed as "being able to install new software".
rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
General-purpose computing on devices marketed as general-purpose computing devices should be a no-brainer for regulators.

Cars, electric scooters, boats, anything where there's other conflicting safety regulations I fully agree that a manufacturer doesn't need to provide the general public with full software access. I still think even in those cases there needs to be some regulation that ensures manufacturers allow independent, qualified, repair shops to effectively repair broken tech.

rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
Conflicting regulations when it comes to cars, and for WiFi refrigerators (meaning any gadget that runs some sort of OS) I don't necessarily disagree with you, but I think it makes sense to make different regulation for general-purpose computing devices and purpose-specific devices.

Though if you ask me, software should be covered by right-to-repair. I should have everything I need to technically be able to support my own device when the manufacturer throws in the towel. Unlockable bootloader, source code for device bring-up, drivers, but not necessarily an OS, just the device specific stuff.

rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
I think they are referring to like a really simple scorched-earth solution that Apple could make which would scare off literally 99% of users but would technically be fully compliant.

Unlockable bootloader should 100% be a thing, but I doubt it'll happen, and in its absence Apple will probably need to open up their walled garden more to actually be DMA compliant.

rekoil··on Spotify CEO Daniel Ek tells investors Apple's DMA rules are a 'farce'
> This is genuinely tricky due to battery life and data usage considerations.

Which isn't really any of Apples business if I want to make that sacrifice, but rather something they can promote as a win by using their solution if it turns out that alternative push notification services implement it poorly.

rekoil··on Netflix: Piracy is difficult to compete against and growing rapidly
Totally agree with you CEOs are overcompensated. There should be a law regulating how much more a CEO can make over the lowest rung in the company, the problem is there are just so many workarounds to that (stock options, spinning off the actual workforce into a sub-entity, etc) that it would never work.

I do understand that a million monthly listeners is a large amount, sorry I was over-exaggerating a bit in my last comment. My point was that Spotify helps with discoverability through their playlist-generation, but I guess that doesn't automatically mean anything more than the odd play here and there, and not necessarily more "monthly active listeners".

I'd love if artists made more on Spotify than they do today, but isn't the big problem all the middle-men in the music industry? It's my understanding that companies like Spotify shorten this ladder at least a little bit, but thinking about it again I guess I agree that the pay is a little too low.

rekoil··on Netflix: Piracy is difficult to compete against and growing rapidly
It's great that it exists, but I'm priced out.
rekoil··on Netflix: Piracy is difficult to compete against and growing rapidly
Yeah I really wish there was a global history of my plays that I could look at.
rekoil··on Netflix: Piracy is difficult to compete against and growing rapidly
Yeah I know discs still exist for now, I'm talking about when they suddenly don't anymore. Hopefully that's far far into the future.

And as for Spotify exploiting artists, I don't know how accurate this[1] is, but if it is then it seems pretty fair to me? Maybe slightly on the lower end of what I had expected, but not that far off.

If you have a million monthly listeners (and today you have access to over 574M monthly active users[2] via Spotify) then you're making $5,000/month in static income, meaning you have zero hours of work and still have enough to live on (depending on the size of the band I guess).

The notion that artists (or movie stars for that matter) should be making 10x that or more is a little ridiculous if you ask me.

1: https://purecalculators.com/spotify-money-calculator

2: https://www.statista.com/statistics/367739/spotify-global-ma...

rekoil··on Netflix: Piracy is difficult to compete against and growing rapidly
Case in point, that time when Spotify removed all references to the word "queue", and replaced it with "up next" while also changing the behaviour of it. Ridiculous change which they eventually reverted thankfully.

Or that one time when they removed the "set as current playlist" feature, which they still haven't restored. That feature was the only way to change playlist without breaking in the middle of a song, besides literally waiting until a song is over and doing it then, wasting time.

I like Spotify, but they do some infuriating things sometimes.

Don't get me started on their beef with Apple which has resulted in my HomePods still not being able to take music requests via Siri almost 3 years after I got the first one.

rekoil··on Netflix: Piracy is difficult to compete against and growing rapidly
Yep, I know that, and you're right it's a very confusing UX that's easily invoked by accident.

There really should be at least a modal to confirm if the result will mean deleting more than say an album.

If you're offline or on roaming mobile data (not sure if they can reliably determine this though, at least not on iOS) when invoking it then they should make you answer a somewhat complex question to confirm that you indeed wanted to delete the songs.

rekoil··on DEF CON 32 Was Canceled. We Un-Canceled it
Stockholm please!
rekoil··on Netflix: Piracy is difficult to compete against and growing rapidly
It happens, but pretty rarely in my experience, though I'm probably not the most avid consumer of music so other people might have a better grasp of the extent of this issue on Spotify.
rekoil··on Netflix: Piracy is difficult to compete against and growing rapidly
I personally find that Spotifys offline content has worked reliably over the years. You just gotta remember that when you get a new device you have to go to library and click download and then leave Spotify open for a few hours.

Spotify is also a great example of how to beat piracy. I haven't downloaded an mp3 file since I got a Spotify Premium account in 2007. OK that's probably a slight overstatement, but it's near enough to the truth for this argument. They made it so simple and convenient to pay for access to music that I've had zero reasons to even consider piracy. They have everything (well, enough that I've never felt something was missing anyway), they have clients for everything, the pricing is reasonable, and they have great value-add in the form of playlist generation.

As for the rest, full agreement, the low bitrate of streaming services is the big one for me as I'm a film enthusiast with great gear that definitely doesn't reach its potential using any streaming services. Now that it looks like physical media is going the way of the Dodo I'm wondering where I'm gonna get actually high bitrate content from in the future.

← PreviousPage 7 of 21Next →