HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

remosi

132 karma · joined January 5, 2011

submissionscomments
remosi··on Telehash: JSON+UDP+DHT = Freedom
Speaking as someone who spent a long time working on Undernet trying to make IRC work. The RFC is poorly specified (eg ~ and ^ are missed from the case equivalent list). IRC scales poorly (the protocol relies heavily on global state). IRC doesn't do UTF-8, or in fact, any sane character set (see the case mapping mentioned above). Client's ignore the parsing rules (eg the : marking multiword last arguments) and kludge around them. Each network went off and did their own thing, fragmenting the protocol space, and then declared themselves as being the One True IRC Protocol. IRC puts a lot of trust in all the server admins on the network, making it difficult to federate, and so on.

IRC was a great protocol in the 1980's, it's been dead for a while, just there are no good replacements.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2