HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

repelsteeltje

1,560 karma · joined September 15, 2023

submissionscomments
repelsteeltje··on Access to frontier AI will soon be limited by economic and security constraints
...But there's a new world dawning for photonic chips.

No reason to expect Moore's observation to apply there (though, maybe?), but it will have big implications for power usage.

repelsteeltje··on Access to frontier AI will soon be limited by economic and security constraints
Today's tech echoes 1960-1970 mainframe era: very centralized around a handful of companies controlling "massive cloud compute" in bespoke mainframe-like topology.

All of that will all be legacy in a couple of years. Today's B200 clusters are tomorrow's e-waste. Decentralization might happen gradually or abruptly. But to me it's obvious that we'll be thinking of high-tech tensor processors and GPUs the way we thought of individual transistors and tube amplifiers in the 1980s.

If AI turns out to be the revolution it purports to be, than the underlying hardware will change much more rapidly than it did with ICs and microprocessors in the late 1970s. Today's hot is tomorrow's junk.

repelsteeltje··on Details of the Daring Airdrop at Tristan Da Cunha
Free (but admittedly useless) advice when you plan to fall seriously ill:

- do not get on a cruise ship

- do not get off at a remote island

repelsteeltje··on Technical Dimensions of Live Feedback in Programming Systems
Hah. Coincidentally, I was listening to this exact episode of future of coding podcast while stumbling upon this HN mention.

Access to these visuals really helps understanding what they are talking about

repelsteeltje··on Twin brothers wipe 96 government databases minutes after being fired
> European laws require us to give people something like two months' notice. Even then we don't trust them; we pay them their salary and tell them to stay home.

Escorting them to the door, and revoking access for the remainder of contract yet paying wages for that period seems very descent. Off course, you don't do that when the termination was triggered by employee's misbehaviour.

But, yeah - the point I was trying to make is that there is only so much you can do as an employer to protect the company while there's an infinite number of reasons for anyone to be traumatized or otherwise act erratic. Admins are always entrusted with huge power and while wariness is probably warranted, distrustfulness is IMO counterproductive and often harmful.

repelsteeltje··on Rars: a Rust RAR implementation, mostly written by LLMs
Haha, off course! The three major sources of software failures: off by one errors and race conditions.
repelsteeltje··on Twin brothers wipe 96 government databases minutes after being fired
I suppose that's a very powerful way of preventing "accidents" on termination. But isn't that just theatre? I mean - as though termination is the one and only case where an employee with the power to destroy the company gets angry and might do something really stupid?!
repelsteeltje··on Rars: a Rust RAR implementation, mostly written by LLMs
I hope the developers of, say, the brakes in my car don't interpret 'software correctness' the way you do.

Added, later: hey you changed your comment, added a whole paragraph.

repelsteeltje··on Rars: a Rust RAR implementation, mostly written by LLMs
It works == it's correct?
repelsteeltje··on Googlebook
Also, any name with Google in it sounds cheap, gross, subsidized by ads, you pay less because you're the product.

Chrome..., Pixel..., Gemini..., Android..., anything but Google, please.

repelsteeltje··on Dutch suicide prevention website shares data with tech companies without consent
Totally agree that Google should not be on a service like this in any shape or form.

But "sharing data" does somewhat suggest they are sharing the payload, the actual conversations.

repelsteeltje··on Leaving GitHub for Forgejo
It's kind of breaking the social contract. Licences were drafted, conferences were held, and endless flamewars tried to codify what it means to collaboratively build, distribute, own and use open software.

Then came the model trainers, ignoring the entire discourse, reasoning: "if I can download it, it's mine too use". And then basically selling the resulting tech back to the community.

Not unlike big tech extracting money from open source, but at least the latter usually (somewhat maliciously) complied with the license.

repelsteeltje··on I moved my digital stack to Europe
Yeah echelon seemed overwhelming at the time, and encryption was to be the answer.

But it turn out surveillance works just fine if you only focus on the meta data. Knowing who takes to whom, and which sites people visit is much more valuable (and much cheaper) than scanning the actual payload.

And why collect all that data yourself if ad companies are happy to sell it to you, ie to the government? (Huh, maybe that's why Facebook changed its name to Meta, come to think of it)

repelsteeltje··on SecurityBaseline.eu
Maybe post this as Show HN? And adjust headline to fit max chars.
repelsteeltje··on Screenshots of Old Desktop OSes
> [..] lovely [..] cute [..] ugly [..] naive...

First and foremost to me those screenshots are somewhat disappointing as they can't match my memories. NeXT, BeOS, Irix, OpenLook, SunOS, Arthur (imagine the diversity)... they were SO awesomely impressive at insanely high multi-sync CRT resolution.

Reality simply can't match the mind's eye, at least not for me.

repelsteeltje··on Palantir to be granted "unlimited access" to UK NHS patient data
> While broad access was originally intended only for NHSE employees with security clearance, the FT reported that the briefing noted that external workers had requested the same permissions “as it is too inconvenient to apply for all of the necessary individual CDAs”.

Let's get rid of those pesky ACLs. Trust us, we know what we're doing.

repelsteeltje··on A.I. note takers are making lawyers nervous
> Give it a few more months to years and things will likely settle how he pitched - at least in the context of note taking: only let it become "lore" if it didn't have to guess a word.

I'm hesitant to admit even that. Like any computational linguistics problem, accuracy relies on coverages of all levels: form morphology, through syntax and semantics to speech act and world knowledge.

I worked with state of art speech recognition in healthcare setting. The model was specifically trained on small set of languages with emphasis on covering medical terminology.

It worked great for conversations most of the time, but sometimes messed up very badly. For instance when patient would mention the name of a relative, a street address or phone number. Spelling out an email address would mess it up completely.

It's just like when you're a horrible typist and rely on spell checking: The red squibles are gone, but the story no longer makes sense. Or when you "autofix" a syntax error, but the meaning diverges from your intention.

As the technology improved the number of words decreases, but the mistakes get more severe.

repelsteeltje··on European Money Pours into Palantir
This. Giving markets free reign, usually doesn't result in alignment with long term best interests or political objectives.

It took years of activism and voting with our money to get banks, pension funds and similar institutions to stop funding cluster munitions, land mines, nukes, oil, tabacco. Now big tech and some AI companies are on the radar.

repelsteeltje··on Local AI needs to be the norm
We tend to overestimate the short-term change, while underestimating the long term impact. A lot of hot air will likely vent when businesses realize LLMs didn't magically replace their workforce. Also, prices will go through the roof when energy production inevitably fails to keep up with demand for compute. Also, Moore's law more or less predicts we'll have today's technology in our phones in less than a decade.

I predict the B200 data centers we're build today will be obsolete in 3 years and we'll be using whatever models and hardware that isn't even on a road map today. Likely not NVIDIA, likely not OpenAI or Anthropic. Maybe Chinese?

In the mean time, we must continue building software with the clumsy coding agents tied to cloud services as this (for now) seems to be about the only area where AI economically makes sense.

repelsteeltje··on Hardware Attestation as Monopoly Enabler
It probably won't matter to the average user: buy Apple, buy Google and be (little bit less) happy while your access to the free web gets little more enshittified...

...But there is always at least one hacker.

The issue with hardening DRM is that at the core it's hard to protect against an adversary that with physical access to the device that keeps the very secret. From the vendor perspective, the very customer paying you is your potential enemy.

That means that the root of trust isn't itself protected with cryptography. Instead, it relies on security-through-obscurity, Faraday cages, fuses, anti-tampering and lots of glue. And it's a numbers game if there are thousands of different devices, potentially with different flaws while your adversaries are hidden among billions of customers.

There is still a gap between the hacker and main-stream availability, though: laws and legalism, like DMCA that penalize disclosing how the obfuscation and all work.

repelsteeltje··on Hardware Attestation as Monopoly Enabler
Hardware attestation is like hardware DRM. It is intended to limit and restrict abundance. Abundance of clients (as a proxy for user attention) and abundance of copying, access and replay (as a proxy for "piracy"), resp.

It won't matter to the masses, it won't hamper "bad actors" because hackers will find flaws instantly.

It's just enshitfication.

repelsteeltje··on PipeDream on the Acorn Archimedes
In some ways Archimedes' RiscOS was ahead of its time, in some ways it was a disappointment. It never matured due to lack of momentum, market share.

I suppose that most of all, it reminds me of time when actual, genuine real innovation in UI design was still on the menu.

repelsteeltje··on Google broke reCAPTCHA for de-googled Android users
How about consumers paying a little extra for their device? The way it's going, add sponsored big tech is dieing because click fraud detection is becoming too expensive. Either we give up privacy and track every user, or we let bots have at it, stop targeting ads to users and bill advertisers on bandwidth.
repelsteeltje··on An Introduction to Meshtastic
Yeah. Actuality I was thinking about less sophisticated adversaries. So called "failed states", nonstate groups, organized crime, amateur surveillance, corporate espionage, sabotage.
repelsteeltje··on An Introduction to Meshtastic
Some scary applications come to mind.

For instance, sprinkling a bunch of nodes + sensors in hostile territory should allow for gathering intelligence, guiding drones, setting of fuses...

repelsteeltje··on Eight More '8-Bit Era' Microprocessors
It's easy to forget how much innovation divergence was happening in the early 70s. Up till the late nineties we speculated that ISAs other than x86 (spec. RISC designs) would win in the end.

Imagine these 8 bitters were mostly hardwired, with less than a million transistors.

repelsteeltje··on Maybe you shouldn't install new software for a bit
This is exactly the feeling I have. First: excessive growth of dependencies fueled by free components.

* with internet access to FOSS via sourceforge and github we got an abundance of building blocks

* with central repositories like CPAN, npm, pip, cargo and docker those building blocks became trivially easy to use

Then LLMs and agents added velocity to building apps and producing yet more components, feeding back into the dependency chain. Worse: new code with unattributed reuse of questionable patterns found in unknowable versions of existing libraries. That is, implicit dependencies on fragments multitude of packages.

This may all end well ultimately, but we're definitely in for a bumpy ride.

repelsteeltje··on Richard Dawkins: Claude (for one) has 'passed' the Turing Test
So, your theory says it's about prediction, estimation, extrapolation? Like a Kalman filter?

I'm thinking of the first episode of Alex Garland minisery Devs, where a somewhat brilliant Russian guy demos predicting the exact movements of a bacteria. That would be proof that the model works. And even it it were to mispredict, most of the time, it sounds plausible.

repelsteeltje··on Agents need control flow, not more prompts
I was thinking of declarative, but PROLOG rather than SQL. So with actual control flow and reasoning capabilities.

And then you run into similar issues as the llm does, like silent failures, loops, contradictions unless you're very careful.

The essence might be the same closed world assumption problem. In llm case this manifests as hallucination rather that admitting it does not know.

repelsteeltje··on Richard Dawkins: Claude (for one) has 'passed' the Turing Test
> We lack a theory of consciousness [...]

Nitpick: off course we don't really lack a theory of consciousness. It's just that Alan Turing choose to ignore all the existing prior discourse in humanities and philosophy.

← PreviousPage 3 of 18Next →