HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

reubens

101 karma · joined November 28, 2018

https://www.aboutmedicine.com.au/

reuben.schmidt (at) icloud.com

submissionscomments
reubens··on Single Headed Attention RNN
Now that was some refreshing reading.
reubens··on Okuna.io
Looks great. Any idea who is backing it financially?
reubens··on Ask HN: Does being practical act as a hinderance to one’s imagination?
Peter Carey’s early novel Illywhacker [1] has a central character that is both practical and imaginative, and is a brilliant description of these two coexisting. Well worth a read.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illywhacker

reubens··on How Quantum Teleportation Works
I'm visualising a collaboration between Michael Nielsen and 3b1b... mmm
reubens··on It’s Not Enough to Be Right – You Also Have to Be Kind
> “as a statement of opinion, rather than a statement of fact”

I think your prior statement about ‘nuances’ discounts this as a fact. Perhaps your strong opinions are not entirely facts?

reubens··on Google Open-Sources Cardboard
Come on mate. Think about Final Fantasy VII. Was the brilliance of the creativity entirely due to the new medium, or was it script / music / visual design first, 3D graphics engine second?
reubens··on Twitter to ban political advertising
I think this kind of response muddies the issue. Refusing political ads by political parties or promoting political parties is a clean way to define things, and it sounds like this is what Twitter has done.

You can argue that any other advertising is still political (e.g. retail ads promoting a ‘capitalist agenda’).

reubens··on New Features in Vue 3
You can do this within Vue if you like - you just increment the complexity of your exisiting component, rather than creating a new child
reubens··on Ask HN: What's a promising area to work on?
I disagree. Some doctors will attempt new procedures with only a company promoting new tools.

I once saw a surgeon try out new combined cut & staple hardware designed for bowel surgery on a patient's liver, because he had been told it would work. It didn't, and there was a ridiculous amount of staples in the patient's abdomen afterward.

Doctors often become more risk prone the more power they have, and the hierarchy of human medical doctoring contributes to this.

reubens··on How can we develop transformative tools for thought?
That was wonderful, thank you.

> someone either with exceptional empathy or who has just mastered the material, recording notes for themselves and then sharing.

Great stuff. Mr Nielsen lands firmly in the first category.

reubens··on How can we develop transformative tools for thought?
Thanks for your response Michael, and my apologies for the temerity of my initial comment. At the end of four years of Med school, I am truly Anki fatigued (and a bit fed up with learning facts about rare diseases I may never see in practise). The points you highlight here I recall being present to a degree in Quantum Country, so I really don’t have a leg to stand on- apologies for directing my frustration toward your work.
reubens··on How can we develop transformative tools for thought?
That is a very elegant way to put what I said so grumpily, thank you.
reubens··on How can we develop transformative tools for thought?
As another commenter below notes, a recommendation is to spend one second reviewing each card. Thus, your cards are generally quite simple. This can very easily lead to a patchwork of simple details, but no glue holding them together. I’ve come to believe that the mental effort it takes to understand something should be prioritised over memorisation. If you’re relatively busy and spending a lot of time doing Anki cards, you may be limiting your opportunities for this kind of challenge.
reubens··on How can we develop transformative tools for thought?
As a long term user of Anki, I think the hype here is too much. Spaced repetition helps you learn facts, but that is such a limited representation of what learning something means. I get that the point of a mnemonic medium is to improve your memory, but the focus on memory in and of itself is reductive. Memorising things helps no one gain a better understanding. If anything, it’s just a way to avoid the mental effort of real comprehension (roughly analogous to a google search for a solution rather than solving a problem yourself).

Edit: I love Michael Nielsen’s work, but I don’t love his glorification of this tool.

reubens··on Iraq blocks Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp, and Instagram, shuts down internet
Thanks. It seemed to me counterintuitive to respond to protests about inadequate services by cutting off another service (fanning the flames)
reubens··on Iraq blocks Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp, and Instagram, shuts down internet
From what I’ve gathered, disenfranchised citizens in Baghdad are protesting, and the government has responded by shutting down the internet. I understand it’s reactionary but what is their logic here?
reubens··on Goodhart’s Law: Are Academic Metrics Being Gamed?
Spot on. I like to think that the system-gaming doesn't necessarily disadvantage the committed and passionate researcher (who researches to satisfy personal curiosity).
reubens··on Time to Abolish "Statistical Significance"?
I don't think the article suggests dispensing with the threshold, it suggests mainly that the language used to treat p < 0.05 is disingenuous and should be reconsidered:

"We conclude, based on our review of the articles in this special issue and the broader literature, that it is time to stop using the term “statistically significant” entirely."

reubens··on Time to Abolish "Statistical Significance"?
Could you expand on what you mean by the 'abuse of knowledge'?

I agree that the focus on this metric negatively influences research outcomes, which extends to university structuring, but I'd like to hear your thoughts on how this extends to abuse of knowledge in general.

reubens··on How Sydney destroyed its trams for love of the car
I love that
reubens··on Building a Web-Based Motion Graphics Editor
Can't wait to use this. The many times I've wanted to have simple motion graphics in FCPX but didn't want to shell out for Motion or AE, I wished something like this was available. More power to you
reubens··on The New York Times course to teach its reporters data skills is now open-source
Agreed, and as an entry level program I think jamovi leads the pack https://www.jamovi.org/
reubens··on Researchers use lasers to detect and destroy tumor cells in melanoma patients
The beauty of it is that no blood need be removed. That is a huge improvement in terms of patient experience.
reubens··on Knowledge Extraction from Unstructured Texts (2016)
Thank you for the link. That was enlightening.
reubens··on BioRender – Professional Science Figures
+1 would like to see this game too.

As a medical student, however, I can vouch for the utility of clip art in visualisation. You get delivered so much visual information that if there is coherence to it, you have more chance of processing it correctly.

reubens··on Biomarker for chronic fatigue syndrome identified
They were bumping the Na to 200mOsm/L, which is insanely high compared to our plasma.

Hypertonicity like this causes the cell to shrink, which spoils the delicate relationships and ionic bonds between molecules in the cell. This causes a litany of issues, but one thing is an increase in production of reactive oxygen species, a byproduct of normal metabolism. ROS, otherwise known as free radicals, is what they use to measure cell stress.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2