HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

revelio

1,142 karma · joined March 18, 2023

submissionscomments
revelio··on Ask HN: Why is there no major push towards Android for Servers and Desktops?
I'm gonna assume "Android" here is a word meaning a centrally developed and somewhat more planned OS platform, not literally Android itself.

The main reason there's no such OS is because developers by and large will not pay for software if they could use something free instead. That's it, that's the only reason. Once there were quite a few such server operating systems, e.g. Solaris and Windows Server, but they've all been crushed by Linux because Linux costs nothing and that is overwhelmingly the most important criteria for developers. See also the massive Red Hat drama lately. Note that they'll happily fork over a lot if the alternatives also cost money, which is why everything commercial for devs takes the form of services not software because they'd have to pay for servers anyway so once you've crossed that bridge why not pay for expensive fancy servers in the form of cloud services too. But a generic OS platform you could use anywhere? Devs won't go for it unfortunately. They'd rather chew devops glass than do that. It's not entirely irrational. There's safety in numbers and Linux's complexity = job security and career advancement, after all.

OK so what would an "Android for servers" actually look like? The big problem with defining this is that Android gets a lot of its simplicity from not caring about scalability. It's scoped to a very specific set of use cases which don't involve processing much data. The moment you talk about a server OS, are you even talking about one machine anymore? Or something more like Kubernetes where the "OS" is lots of computers fused together. Is your server platform meant to power a 10,000 machine cluster or is it focused on single machines? You talk about uploading .apks to the server which suggests you're after something more single-user focused, which is a lot simpler to do but again there's no demand because people would rather just create accounts on the 10k machine cluster and share all their data (despite what the EU thinks nobody cares about data privacy, convenience wins every time).

So yeah - summing up, there could be something way more sane, more structured, simpler, more consumer-like in its usability. But whoever tried to create such a thing would go bankrupt because nobody would buy it. You may not like it and find it a nightmare but for better or worse devops is a job and companies would rather grow their empire by hiring people to do it than pay a third party for easy to use software that means they don't have to.

revelio··on Ask HN: Why is there no major push towards Android for Servers and Desktops?
Sandstorm was an attempt to do this, but there isn't much demand. Why install WordPress when wordpress.com will run it for you as a service?
revelio··on That Time I Posted Myself Out Of a Job
People can complain about old jobs, sure. But not if they explicitly make a promise not to do so, especially not if they get paid in return for that promise. Whether governments will let her get away with it or not, it's a backstab to extract cash from someone in return for a promise to be nice, and then to break it.
revelio··on Monday Was the Hottest Day Ever as Global Temperatures Rise
Within climatology people like Roy Spencer or Judith Curry. Outside, there's stuff like these papers I posted a couple of days ago.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36559554

Note the response - yes they may be nuclear physicists or hydrologists but they can't possibly comment on climate, they're the wrong sort of scientists. Also they even say they have a good understanding of science and then define science as "what 99% of experts believe" which is just hilariously medieval.

These are just examples. I can't be bothered trying to draw up huge lists. Other people have done that, it doesn't matter, the crisis true believers just use a circular definition of expert in which if you disagree the world is doomed you can't be an expert, therefore, are not worth listening to.

revelio··on Monday Was the Hottest Day Ever as Global Temperatures Rise
How is trust in the scientific community not belief? If you aren't checking their claims directly, then it's just that you believe them and others don't.

BTW it's not really trust in the scientific community. There are lots of scientists calling foul on this kind of story. What happens is, we get told they're the wrong kind of scientists, or "fringe" or whatever. It's social signalling all the way down and the message is Follow The Science.

revelio··on That Time I Posted Myself Out Of a Job
She's not technically right. Her article is filled with "all my bosses cheerfully agreed that the social media policy was impossible to comply with", which is nonsense. She could have just stopped using Twitter. She's not a shark who will die if she doesn't tweet every few minutes, it's just social media. Yet she seems to be convinced that she found some clever gotcha here and everyone in every meeting bowed to her superior intellect, meaning she has an impressive inability to read her colleagues.
revelio··on That Time I Posted Myself Out Of a Job
> some speech chills other speech

Is this not just a way to say "my speech is free speech and protected, your speech is hate speech and should be banned"?

revelio··on That Time I Posted Myself Out Of a Job
Even worse than that. She took the $40k in return for agreeing to not disparage VMware. She then immediately started disparaging them, but it was "in private" whatever that means, so she presumed she wouldn't get caught. And then once her preferred candidate is in the White House she figures it's now safe to violate her agreement in public too, thus keeping the $40k AND going back on her word. She stiffed VMware once at the conference, and then again afterwards! Clearly this person cannot be trusted in any kind of business relationship at all, as the threat of enforcement is the only thing that keeps them from immediately turning around and stabbing you in the back.
revelio··on Oregon County Sues BP, Chevron, Shell, Exxon for $51B Climate Damages
Projection, your honor! We started with "probable billions" on climate-related PR and you replied with evidence of millions, much of which isn't on climate related stuff. Now you're saying what you meant wasn't billions at all. That's goal post moving!

Yes you hedged your claim, but so what? It's still wrong. You don't get to make wild and totally false claims by sticking "probable" onto everything.

> That you find a climate-disinformation spend

You haven't shown that or even laid the groundwork for that. Even if these firms were spending the amounts you claim, which they apparently aren't, did it occur to you that they might be right? Nope. You just assume anything they say must be wrong, because you've been brainwashed by propaganda. You can't even find any specific campaign!? If you could we could then debate the real issues, but didn't even get that far.

revelio··on Oregon County Sues BP, Chevron, Shell, Exxon for $51B Climate Damages
I looked up the correct URL for the Watts report:

https://heartland.org/wp-content/uploads/documents/2022_Surf...

Well, I haven't yet seen you change any of your opinions, but obviously that isn't proof you're unwilling, so I don't think trying to figure out other people's willingness is very productive. How would anyone ever know? If someone is putting in the effort to cite sources and defend their position, it makes sense IMO to assume a default of good faith argumentation. The alternative is a kind of nihilism. Indeed, I'm willing to continue. It's you who aren't! So, who is most willing to change their views?

Let's agree that our disagreement here stems originally from a disagreement over the nature of citing sources. I'd prefer to discuss the original claims (the leaves, as you put it), or at least finish discussing them, with the source excerpts being there to back up those claims only. You'd prefer to debate the entirety of the sources themselves as part of determining the validity of the original claims. Am I right in understanding this is because you don't (yet) believe the specific claims about the airport, the logbooks, etc? Or do you accept that this problem did occur and now wish to have a broader debate? Also how wide does this go? Will you bring up non-cited articles by the same author? Non-climate articles on the same site?

Getting more towards the roots. There seem to be three "branches" of this tree. (1) the RAF airport, I believe this has been proven conclusively unless you think Morrison is inventing FOIA requests and things out of whole cloth so let's put that to one side now, (2) data adjustment vs improved instrument quality and (3) the sea ice chart.

I've already laid out my views (and those of zacharees I guess and lots of other people) when it comes to (2). We don't accept the idea that scientists should just suck up data of arbitrarily low quality, do some processing and then demand the public blindly trusts that the data is fixed. Jet exhaust spikes being declared climate change are clear evidence that this fixing process doesn't work properly, but there's also a logical circularity issue. Anyway. No need to repeat all that as I wrote it out above.

That leaves (pun intended har har) (3) the sea ice chart. It helps to have context here about what Morrison believes. His line is that global warming was real, but "started to run out of steam 20 years ago" as he put it. He thinks that CO2 saturates i.e. climate response isn't linear but logarithmic and that whilst there was indeed some industrial warming in the 20th century, in the last 20 years most impact on temperatures has been a mix of natural factors like El Ninos and poor data handling by climatologists. The 1980-2010 trend line remains because, firstly, climate skeptics don't like tampering with charts! These charts are generated by government provided websites and the standard in that community is to use the generated images as-is. And secondly, because it doesn't contradict his views on what's happening. Indeed he calls it out specifically, "As can be seen in the graph above, the decline rate of the sea ice extent is not far off the 1981-2010 average and well above 2012" so I don't understand why you say he didn't even remove it. Why would he? He goes on to talk about natural cycles and the AMO/PDO, so it's a part of his argument. The chart supports that view because if sea ice were driven purely by human activity (the standard line we're fed) then sea ice should continue to decline year-on-year but there's been no effect from the last 10 years of emissions, apparently. So clearly natural variation is dominating here.

revelio··on The Energy Transition Isn’t
Are you sure? That first graph is very oddly worded. It says investment in "energy transition" matched fossil fuel investment, not renewables, but that only half of "energy transition" investment was investment in supply. What exactly is investment in demand meant to mean? This doesn't seem to be comparing investment in energy sources at all.
revelio··on The Energy Transition Isn’t
It presumably ends in 2022 because that's the last full year and the data for 2023 would be incomplete and therefore not be comparable. That's expected, not some sort of sneaky trick.

As for including the fracking boom, so what? Isn't that a rephrasing of his point? Hydrocarbon usage has gone up a lot. How is it cherry picking to use nearly 20 years of data?

revelio··on The Energy Transition Isn’t
> to imply that hydrocarbons as a whole aren't successfully being replaced is deeply misleading.

But natural gas is a hydrocarbon? Replacing coal with gas isn't a replacement of hydrocarbons.

revelio··on Oregon County Sues BP, Chevron, Shell, Exxon for $51B Climate Damages
But I'm not asking you to find me credible. Why would I, this is an anonymous account, as is yours. If you can't reason about things except via who's saying them, then this really isn't the site for you. That's why we have to debate issues and facts.
revelio··on Oregon County Sues BP, Chevron, Shell, Exxon for $51B Climate Damages
I'm trying my best to "argue in good faith", but if you want to change the topic or respond to different parts of an article than what's relevant to the topic it's really helpful to clarify that. I did figure it out, but it'd have been faster if things were clearer.

Feel free to not respond to any of the points made, but the arguments so far are in good faith. If you think they aren't then the problem is on your side.

revelio··on AI and the Automation of Work
Don't feel too bad about that one. I've seen Docker's default of non-persistent storage cause disaster even for professionals with years of experience. It's just a really bad bit of design.
revelio··on Oregon County Sues BP, Chevron, Shell, Exxon for $51B Climate Damages
We're looking for a smoking gun because the original poster said there were "billions of dollars spent in an effort to increase public ignorance". For that claim to be true you'd need an entire battlefield of smoking guns. The idea that there's billions of dollars spent on influencing the public and the whole thing is entirely covert is a conspiracy theory. It can be true, but requires good evidence, not a light-year sized goalpost move.

> You're saying that Gates Foundation is playing subterfuge

No I haven't said that. I've said, quite clearly, that the Gates Foundation is an example of spending vast sums very openly and non-subtly. You can even search their website to learn about their spending. Which is my point! I can evidence my claims because a billion dollars spent on influencing the public is about as non-subtle as you can get and easily proven when true.

This is the second time you've quite seriously misinterpreted clear statements by me in this thread. Firstly you read 60 seconds as 1 second, now you think I've said the Gates Foundation is an example of "playing subterfuge", but that's not a claim even its critics make of it. You've projected your own biases onto my posts and read things that aren't there.

revelio··on Oregon County Sues BP, Chevron, Shell, Exxon for $51B Climate Damages
Your posts are quite confusing, do you realize that? I started a reply asking if you had mixed up different locations in the thread, because it seemed like none of the stuff you were writing was connected with the topic or people being discussed. Now I look carefully you seem to have gone off on a tangent and started replying, without any setup or intro, to random other parts of the linked articles, instead of treating them as a citation for the claims being made and sticking to that. I was like, Anthony Watts? Huh? Why is he suddenly appearing? What report? What are you talking about? Going back it seems you've picked a fight with paragraph 9 in the second link when the relevant information for answering your query is in paragraph 1?!

We can discuss other unrelated stuff, that's fine. But please accede first to these three requests:

1. Let's resolve the RAF Coningsby discussion before moving on. You appear to have mis-read the initial claim and then decided it didn't make sense and asked for sources. You now have the evidence. As you don't mention RAF Coningsby or the record breaking temperature in your reply, is it OK to assume you accept that evidence and thus that this reporting problem is real and did in fact occur as stated?

2. Please make it clear what the heck you're actually replying to! Quotes would avoid a lot of confusion here. Remember that some of these articles came out a year ago and I dug them up to satisfy your request for sources, I don't remember every single sentence in them by heart.

3. Finally, please cut out the attempts at philosophical lessons. You seem to be a climatologist, from your posts saying "we" when talking about that group? If so then that's a small community and one with a poor track record of accepting when its theories and evidence have been successfully knocked down by others. Before lecturing others about epistemic humility and truth seeking you may wish to take on Mann and other famous grifters that clutter up the scientific landscape, before random internet commenters of no note or impact.

Moving on.

> If you know the direction it is biased, you can unbias it. Processing data is pretty common. I mean we aren't fucking idiots. If you can figure out an issue in 2 seconds, you bet it has been addressed.

If you know the direction and magnitude of the bias, which the Met Office clearly do not, and if the bias is constant and well characterized, etc. That's important! As you seem to have accepted by choosing to debate something different, climatological agencies are happy to report momentary blasts of jet exhaust as evidence of climate change. That's an issue that literally anyone can figure out in two seconds the moment they discover the thermometer isn't in the village as claimed, but rather right next to a place jet fighters take off, and yet, unambiguously, the Met Office had not figured this out. They even claimed they'd used a rigorous verification process!

So please forgive us if we assume that you guys are in fact not addressing issues that any "fucking idiot" can spot in two seconds, because this would seem to be one of them.

More generally, your field's attitude to data quality is guaranteed to create train wrecks like this. If your data is poor quality you often won't know how to characterize the corruption, which is exactly why good scientists obsess over how to collect data with high quality instruments and setups in the first place. They don't just scrape whatever data they find on the internet and then assume with 100% confidence that 100% of the measurement error both can be well characterized and actually will be. That's an absurd methodology that is guaranteed to lead to continuous disasters like this, as well as the entirely reasonable lack of trust when people discover that you constantly rewrite the historical record. You guys can't even change the data once, you keep doing it, meaning that the vast majority of the climate literature is based on measurements you later decided were wrong! Most of the climate literature should have been retracted by now! This is inevitable when you can't reliably characterize measurement error. Thermometers aren't advanced tech and it's easy to build networks to a standard that satisfies even critics so why do you persist in "fixing" and then constantly "refixing" corrupted data sets?

revelio··on Oregon County Sues BP, Chevron, Shell, Exxon for $51B Climate Damages
Sorry, it's easy to forget that many people have never encountered these facts before. Climatologists continuously rewrite history which is why it's so confusing. In 1999, NASA climatologist James Hansen was wondering why the USA hadn't got any warmer in the 20th century:

https://web.archive.org/web/20090404150607/http://www.giss.n...

This is a very interesting historical article which NASA has long since deleted from their website. Look at the two graphs, in particular the graph of US temperatures on the left. The text says this:

How can the absence of clear climate change in the United States be reconciled with continued reports of record global temperature? Part of the "answer" is that U.S. climate has been following a different course than global climate, at least so far. Figure 1 compares the temperature history in the U.S. and the world for the past 120 years. The U.S. has warmed during the past century, but the warming hardly exceeds year-to-year variability. Indeed, in the U.S. the warmest decade was the 1930s and the warmest year was 1934.

OK, so in 1999 the historical record said there was no clear climate change in the USA and the hottest year was 1934. Temperature declined from +1.5F (anomaly) to about -0.2F in 1970. Now look at the modern NASA temperature graph:

https://data.giss.nasa.gov/tmp/gistemp/CUSTOM_GRAPHS/87aa1e2...

If you look at the 1900-2000 period in both graphs, the story is very different. Now 1999 is hotter than 1934. In the old graph, the period between 1980 and 2000 doesn't do much. In the modern graph you see rapid warming.

So what's going on? As you can see, by the year 2000 climatologists were getting seriously bothered by the US data. It can't really be called global warming if it isn't global. Also, the US temperature network had a lot of problems but it is by far the most comprehensive for 20th century data. Much of the world doesn't have any data at all for much of the 20th century! Theory and observed data didn't match, so they went looking for reasons to change the data. If you look hard and long enough you can find such reasons, and they had plenty of time. The weather stations were never intended for climate monitoring so their siting and procedures weren't good enough for that. More and more adjustments started being made until the picture you see today: they cooled the dustbowl years and warmed the most recent history. Fast forward 20 years and they're so comfortable with changing historical data that some temperature records rewrite the entire history of every thermometer reading, every month.

This isn't really kosher, obviously, hence the construction of the new Climate Reference Network. Unlike the historical network this one is built for climatologists, with very careful siting away from heat sources. It shows no warming. So to recap: in 1999, the weather stations show no warming in the 20th century. A few years later a new network opens, and it shows no warming either. The appearance of warming comes from big piles of FORTRAN that reprocess the old data. Although this is about the US data, the global thermometer network has even bigger problems with siting, rewritten histories etc.

Hopefully that's enough to go on, if you feel like researching the topic further!

revelio··on Oregon County Sues BP, Chevron, Shell, Exxon for $51B Climate Damages
OK here are the sources. Note that I said the spike was 60 seconds, not 1 second, not sure where you got a 1 second spike from. Re-reading the stories it seems it was more like a few minutes rather than one minute. Anyway, the RAF Coningsby investigation was done by Chris Morrison over the course of about a year. I suspect you or others will reject the source for ideological reasons, but here's how he developed the story. This brief spike mattered because it was widely covered in the UK as irrefutable evidence of climate change, it being the hottest temperature ever recorded there. It's not about inclusion in monthly averages.

It begins here, with the BBC lying about where the record temperature was observed. Not a great start:

https://dailysceptic.org/2022/07/20/climate-alarmists-turn-u...

"The BBC noted on Radio 4 last night that the record temperature arose in the “village” but co-ordinates on the Met Office site place the device halfway down the runway at RAF Coningsby, home of two squadrons of frontline, combat ready squadrons and a training base for Typhoon pilots."

Here's where they discover the record was set during a brief spike:

https://dailysceptic.org/2022/11/27/fresh-doubts-emerge-abou...

"Over six minutes, the temperature jumped suddenly by 1.3°C to 40.3°C at 15.12 (3.12pm), and was 0.6°C lower just a minute later. In just two minutes from 15.10 the rise was 0.6°C."

Here the Met Office claims that they have a rigorous verification process, and maybe a break in clouds was the reason for the spike, but Morrison got a satellite photo that showed it was a cloudless day:

https://dailysceptic.org/2022/12/04/doubts-remain-about-40-3...

Here's where they FOIA the logs and find the 3 planes landing at the time the record was set:

https://dailysceptic.org/2023/06/28/exclusive-three-typhoon-...

Re: no warming. Someone else was confused by this, maybe my language wasn't clear enough. The US CRN only has data back to 2005 because that's when it was opened. The point is that the older network is garbage, with lots of heat-causing corruption in the record and very low data quality. Climatologists in the 1990s were drawing totally different temperature graphs to today's, yet they are both supposed to be based on the same observations. This is clearly a terrible situation to be in for any field, and a big driven of distrust in climatology. Good scientists care about instrument accuracy, they don't collect low quality data and then constantly rewrite the collected data in a never ending attempt to retroactively fix it! So if we restrict our view to the data collected by the trustworthy weather station network, what do we see? No warming at all, even though CO2 rose constantly over the time period in question. That's a serious problem and the attempts at debunking it aren't convincing.

revelio··on Oregon County Sues BP, Chevron, Shell, Exxon for $51B Climate Damages
1. That list contains items like "Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory", "Congress of Racial Equality", "Chemical Education Foundation", the "Independent Women’s Forum" and so on, in fact not one of these organizations is specifically about climate, yet your source claims all $33M was spent exclusively on climate change. So already this website is lying to you in its very first sentence. Not a great start.

2. This $33M appears to be all charitable giving by Exxon spread over more than 20 years. That's not much, nowhere close to billions of dollars.

3. The tiny amounts are a problem for them, so they say they "know" it's really a lot more. As befits a site that just makes things up, the reason they "know" is: "We assume this is not the first (or the last) contribution Exxon has made to the US Chamber of Commerce". Brilliant. Assumptions, facts, what's the difference?

Again, this isn't evidence for "billions of dollars" being spent on "increasing public ignorance". It's not even evidence for any money being spent on climate, because the reasons they donated to these various foundations isn't really known to the desmog guys. It's just more assumptions.

revelio··on Oregon County Sues BP, Chevron, Shell, Exxon for $51B Climate Damages
The New Yorker article doesn't provide support for the claim of "probable billions of dollars" being spent on "increasing public ignorance", which is what I'm asking for. I didn't ask for examples of donations of more than $10k, that's obviously an irrelevant amount anyway, I just pointed out that it was the only example anyone could find last time I challenged this claim.

And it still stands, because the climate part of the New Yorker piece isn't about spending on propaganda. It says the brothers

"succeeded in persuading many members of Congress to sign a little-known pledge in which they have promised to vote against legislation relating to climate change unless it is accompanied by an equivalent amount of tax cuts"

So apparently climate change legislation is fine as long as it's tax neutral, which is also what the old version of the "noclimatetax" website says too. The New Yorker is biased as hell and tries to frame this pledge as making climate legislation impossible, which is clearly not the case. These are guys who hate tax rises a lot more than anything climate related, it seems. The New Yorker can't even tie any spending directly to this pledge, with all mentions of amounts and donations being about many different topics.

Yes, my views are movable. I'll happily accept a source that backs up the original claim about billions of dollars spent on public ignorance, but it has to do that. The other guy was reduced to something like, "ok but if this guy got 5x the money he asked for, for 20 years, then that's 1/5th of a billion so that's kinda like billions being spent right now", which is just hilarious.

I really don't get why anyone is trying to defend this claim that billions of dollars are being spent by oil companies on climate related advertising. It's just transparently untrue. All the most effective stuff arguing against climatology is by individual authors, bloggers, journalists and scientists. And they're doing it for peanuts, or nothing at all.

revelio··on Oregon County Sues BP, Chevron, Shell, Exxon for $51B Climate Damages
> I have a decent understanding of how science works in general. <consensus>

That's not how science works, that's the opposite of how science works. This is the first reason we cannot get anywhere in this thread.

Science is not some academic claiming everyone agrees with him, some random journalist reporting that as gospel, therefore it's true. That's the pre-scientific approach. Science is a method for arriving at the truth regardless of what people's titles are, and regardless of how popular they are or claim to be. It's about data and theories, not social support, that's why it works. The alternative you're trying to use here is a mishmash of tribal signals combined with strange attempts to do title-based reasoning, like trying to decide whether physicists, hydrologists or climatologists are more "expert" for any given topic. The world doesn't neatly break down that way.

> If you say that a fundamental aspect of this consensus is false, that claim is extraordinary and demands extraordinary proof.

This is the second reason we can't get anywhere. I've already given you proof of all these claims in the form of data. Even data in the form of peer reviewed studies, by scientists, although that isn't actually necessary for it to be proof.

You're rejecting it because you seem to be reasoning purely on the basis of social signals. That's a problem, because for a claim of the form "those people over there are making false claims", no level of proof can ever be accepted if you think that way, no matter how extraordinary. It's a form of circular reasoning: These guys says they're experts and every other expert agrees with them. Those guys says they're also experts and the first group are wrong, but the first guys told me every expert agrees with them, so therefore the others must not be experts, and therefore I must not listen. If you think that way it's just a race to see who can get to you first.

The way out is to recognize that it's not really that complicated. You can engage with the science on its own terms quite easily. If the news says extreme weather is getting more common, and charts of extreme weather events show otherwise, the data should win unless you have some reason to believe it's wrong.

revelio··on Oregon County Sues BP, Chevron, Shell, Exxon for $51B Climate Damages
From my original post:

> A couple of decades ago this problem flared up in the US and Congress spent the money to build out a new state of the art weather station network

> For nearly 20 years it's shown no warming in the USA whatsoever.

i.e. since the construction of a high quality network, warming doesn't happen anymore.

If you zoom out to the 1950s you're incorporating data from the old network. The US government built a new one because data from the old network was being extensively modified by climatologists post-collection, and they were even modifying data long in the past, using the low quality of the network as a justification for doing so. More than half of all observed warming comes from these administrative adjustments and aren't actually visible in the original data, so you can see why you'd want to fix that.

revelio··on Oregon County Sues BP, Chevron, Shell, Exxon for $51B Climate Damages
Did you actually look at the data or just immediately Google for a rebuttal? The page you link to asserts there to be a trend, but then links back to the page I linked to, which:

a. Doesn't plot trend lines. What are they trying to link to, exactly?

b. Has no observable trend in it. You can see that with your own eyes.

Look at the graph!

BTW, in the text there's a claim there's a trend but, "the warming rate (trend) in USCRN annual temperatures is 0.86°F per decade, with uncertainties ranging from -0.58°F to 2.31°F per decade."

In other words the trend is so tiny the uncertainty bound includes zero, which means they can't actually say if there's a trend at all. It might even be going down. This is all another way to say there's no observable problem in this data. It's called global warming, but in the country with the best temperature network it doesn't happen.

revelio··on Oregon County Sues BP, Chevron, Shell, Exxon for $51B Climate Damages
Well documented? This claim about extreme weather gets repeated and echoed by people who assume that it must be true because they keep hearing it, so they don't check. But it's not actually true.

There's a summary paper here that explores the data and shows this to be true:

https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1140/epjp/s13360-02...

The analysis is then extended to some global response indicators of extreme meteorological events, namely natural disasters, floods, droughts, ecosystem productivity and yields of the four main crops (maize, rice, soybean and wheat). None of these response indicators show a clear positive trend of extreme events

There are other indicators you could use but they also don't show any crisis of extreme weather, often the opposite. Examples:

- Wildfire burn acreage is drastically down over the past 100 years.

- Hurricanes are in decline, both in frequency and energy.

- Rainfall is also down slightly.

You can google those claims to find them if you like because the datasets are all public, except maybe the third which is a bit obscure so I'll give it here:

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00221...

the small- and medium-size precipitation systems both exhibit significant decreases during 2001–2020 with trends at −1.13 and −2 mm/h per century, respectively. The large-size precipitation systems exhibit nonsignificant increasing trends during 2001–2020.

revelio··on Oregon County Sues BP, Chevron, Shell, Exxon for $51B Climate Damages
No it's just Twitter requiring a login now.

None of the claims zackees is making are new or obscure. They're well known problems proven many years ago. For example so many thermometers are located next to runways because climatologists collect data from weather stations that were never intended for them. Airports need this data but then it gets mixed into datasets that are claiming to measure general change in climate.

This can lead to absurd outcomes. The UK had a very hot day last year, with the Met Office reported a "record breaking" temperature. The problem is that this temperature was recorded by a thermometer right next to a military airbase runway at the exact moment three fighter aircraft were landing. The temperature spiked up to the record level for 60 seconds and then dropped again, with the spike+drop being quite massive. Finding this out took a year of FOIA requests, done by independent bloggers of course, not journalists.

Jet exhaust shouldn't be reported as climate change, but it is, because climatologists don't seem to care much about data quality. The underlying networks they use have a lot of corruption in them from various sources and the error bars are wide, but the uncertainty is never reported or shown to the public.

A couple of decades ago this problem flared up in the US and Congress spent the money to build out a new state of the art weather station network just for climatologists, with very carefully sited stations. It's called the Climate Reference Network and climatologists refuse to actually use its data. If you review the thermometer readings it generates you can see why:

https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/monitoring/national-tempera...

For nearly 20 years it's shown no warming in the USA whatsoever.

revelio··on Oregon County Sues BP, Chevron, Shell, Exxon for $51B Climate Damages
Last time someone made this claim about "probable billions of dollars" here, I asked for examples and the best anyone could show was a $10k donation to a tiny charity run by one guy that campaigned against offshore wind farms, with a stated justification that there were better ways to help the environment.

Can anyone show an accounting of these billions? Because you can't spend that kind of money without leaving a lot of paper trails.

revelio··on The downfall of National Geographic
Not exactly, no. Most newspapers are profitable. The mostly non-newspaper titles you list were all chasing the over-saturated market for liberal commentary and opinion.

http://marcedge.com/jombs.pdf

"This research follows on a 2014 study of North American newspapers which examined annual financial reports for publicly traded chains and found that none posted an annual loss on an operating basis between 2006 and 2013. An analysis of UK newspaper company financial reports was thus performed to determine whether predictions of extinction similar to those made in North America are likewise unfounded and to compare their performance. Results showed more variation than in the U.S. and Canada. Most UK newspapers are still profitable, but not as profitable as before. The Times, historically a loss maker, has moved to profitability in recent years with the introduction of a paywall for its online content. The same paywall reduced the advertising revenues of News Corp’s Sun and was thus dropped."

revelio··on Bill C-18: Google to remove news links in Canada over online news law
There are plenty of news websites with paywalls, it's common amongst conservative media. It's primarily the left wing media that thinks the government should tax tech firms instead of newspapers being required to charge customers.
← PreviousPage 2 of 26Next →