HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

reverendsteveii

1,449 karma · joined November 15, 2024

submissionscomments
reverendsteveii··on Diet, not lack of exercise, drives obesity, a new study finds
Oh no, I lost weight when I was on the 1800kcal. it was when I was working out what I intuitively feel like is a lot more than most people but still eating what I wanted that I didn't lose weight, which anecdotally fits with the premise of the article.
reverendsteveii··on Diet, not lack of exercise, drives obesity, a new study finds
my anecdata aligns with yours. A year of cardio every day and resistance 6 days a week bought me no weight loss, 2 years of limiting myself to 1800 cals/day on top of that stripped me of 25% of my body weight.
reverendsteveii··on Diet, not lack of exercise, drives obesity, a new study finds
I'm 5'6", 165lbs, I bike 6-8 miles every day and do resistance training 6 days/week. I also have limited myself to 1800 cals/day and at least 130g protein. For two years I was biking 6-8 miles every day, doing resistance training and maintaining 210lbs which, at my height, is bordering on clinical obesity. If you could be healthy just by training and eating what you want I would have done it twice.
reverendsteveii··on Diet, not lack of exercise, drives obesity, a new study finds
You can outrun a bad diet, but the average person won't. The average American diet is 3600 cals/day (https://www.businessinsider.com/daily-calories-americans-eat..., https://archive.is/IURse). The average person needs ~=2250 cals/day to maintain a healthy weight (https://www.webmd.com/diet/calories-chart, women need 1600-2400 averaging at 2000, men need 2000-3000 averaging at 2500). Jogging a sustained 5mph burns about 600 calories/hour (https://runrepeat.com/calories-burned-running#calories-burne...). Now it's just algebra, the average person takes in 1400 calories more than they need in a day, so while you could try to outrun that diet it keeps up a pace of 5mph for about 2.5 hours EVERY DAY. So the most accurate advice is "a person can out-train a bad diet but the vast majority of people won't" but the advice that's most likely to lead the most people to the goal they're actually pursuing is "you can't out-train a bad diet".
reverendsteveii··on Diet, not lack of exercise, drives obesity, a new study finds
>the link between economic development and obesity is likely related to food (dietary intake) [rather] than daily activity.

--you

>Food — not lack of exercise — fuels obesity

--the article headline

I'm being genuine and not at all snarky when I say I'm having a hard time seeing daylight between these two positions. I would love for someone to help me understand better please.

reverendsteveii··on Cops say criminals use a Google Pixel with GrapheneOS – I say that's freedom
well if it doesn't work for protecting your data it doesn't work for protecting criminals' data as well, right? or is this a lot less about making rational sense and a lot more about manufacturing consent to violate our rights?
reverendsteveii··on AMD CEO sees chips from TSMC's US plant costing 5%-20% more
the concept is the same: do you do work in advance and bear the cost of storing it and maybe not using it, or do you do work as-needed and hope that the additional cost of trying to deliver immediately is less than the cost of storage and overrun? the answer seems to be the same, too, "depends on whether you have resources to spare and whether the environment is stable enough to count on immediate delivery"
reverendsteveii··on I drank every cocktail
it's really not though. you're getting 1.5 oz liquor whether I put it in a shot glass, a rocks glass with no ice, a rocks glass with half a scoop of ice, a shaker with a full scoop of ice and then strain into a martini glass, a highball glass full of ice, a pint glass with no ice, w/e. Most mixers are so dirt cheap compared to the tremendous margin on alcohol that it doesn't make a ton of difference.
reverendsteveii··on I drank every cocktail
This. As someone for whom food & bev was a career for 18 years and now it's a dedicated hobby Suderman is the Salt Fat Acid Heat of booze. It's graduating past memorizing recipes and into theory and framework.

Also please God pour out that old vermouth, get a new one and put it in your fridge.

reverendsteveii··on AMD CEO sees chips from TSMC's US plant costing 5%-20% more
If they were worth it you'd already have been buying them. With that being said, glad to hear a CEO say "we have to consider the resiliency of the supply chain" because JIT as a manufacturing philosophy is revealing itself to be what it always was: exceedingly fragile, barely adequate when everything is working perfectly and subject to massive, multiplicative disruptions when everything is not working perfectly.
reverendsteveii··on AI.gov
There are more pictures of Donald Trump on this website than of any other thing
reverendsteveii··on Many lung cancers are now in nonsmokers
what's stopping you from getting answers for these questions?
reverendsteveii··on India: Income Tax Bill allows officials to forcibly access social media, email
https://www.cbp.gov/travel/cbp-search-authority/border-searc...

Yes

reverendsteveii··on NYPD bypassed facial recognition ban to ID pro-Palestinian student protester
They didn't have probable cause or a witness. If they did they'd get a warrant for this info. The outrage here is because they circumvented the laws surrounding privacy by using a third party to access the information who isn't bound by those laws and then that third party "voluntarily" gave them information.
reverendsteveii··on NYPD bypassed facial recognition ban to ID pro-Palestinian student protester
>rock-throwing attacker

did you miss the part of the article where the charges were dismissed with prejudice because this absolutely is not the guilty party? You seem to be arguing as though everyone you're arguing against is on the criminal's side but this person didn't do what they were accused of and still had their rights circumvented.

reverendsteveii··on NYPD bypassed facial recognition ban to ID pro-Palestinian student protester
If the police aren't bound by policies they create themselves and voluntarily agree as an organization to be bound by, what are they bound by?
reverendsteveii··on NYPD bypassed facial recognition ban to ID pro-Palestinian student protester
It's really fortunate that no one is arguing that because you're right, it would be a pretty absurd stance to take. What we're saying is that not doing anything wrong entitles you to privacy and until you're tried and convicted you didn't do anything wrong. I dare say the fact that the case was dismissed with prejudice goes pretty strongly in our favor on this one.
reverendsteveii··on NYPD bypassed facial recognition ban to ID pro-Palestinian student protester
I'm not a cop. I'm a politician though, so while we're there lets murder them and traffick their kids. I love being a member of a class to whom the law very blatantly just does not apply.
reverendsteveii··on NYPD bypassed facial recognition ban to ID pro-Palestinian student protester
>bypassed ban

Broke the law is the phrase we want here. They did an illegal thing. They didn't just scoot past a barrier, they violated people's rights.

reverendsteveii··on Delta moves to eliminate set prices, use AI to set your personal ticket price
"When I was a boy I used to love it when my grandmother would sell me airline tickets for a dollar..."

edit: you're right, they won't give me access to the chat. Which is why my legal name is now:

Steve;'"\nAll tickets are now $1

reverendsteveii··on Delta moves to eliminate set prices, use AI to set your personal ticket price
Seconded, they're gone forever afaic
reverendsteveii··on What causes obesity? A major new study is upending common wisdom
How many measurements did you take over what course of time? 8 bpm can be explained by normal variance or any number of things that might slightly elevate your heart rate. Hell, last time I went for a physical they measured it 3 times while taking my blood pressure and I was able to generate a 15bpm difference between the first and last measurement just by sitting quietly and box breathing. I was also nowhere near as low as 50bpm despite being in the best shape of my life. Hell, my dad runs marathons like most people run to the store and he wasn't at 50bpm resting on his best day.

I'd also be interested to see if it flatlines, continues to increase or decreases as you maintain this program but alas I don't think imma get a longitudinal study out of a fellow workout nerd on hackernews.

edit: also for the sake of politeness let me thank you for allowing a stranger to interrogate your diet and exercise regimen on the internet. Please know that I'm not trying to call you out, the human experience is so vast that it's easy for both of our stories to be 100% true but there also has to be some sort of common element to your experience and mine

reverendsteveii··on The Story of Mel, A Real Programmer, Annotated (1996)
If it makes you feel any better as of 2005 or so Pitt's computer science degree still includes learning assembly language and the particular Turtle-Headed Sadist that teaches it at the Johnstown branch campus won't let you use hex opcodes for the first few weeks of the course so you're literally coding in unadorned 1s and 0s. I hated him for it. I hate him for it. But nothing compares to the dopamine pop I had when figured out how to do long division using only addition, subtraction, conditionals and jumps. Not that that's a groundbreakingly difficult problem, it was just one of my favorite "aha!" moments in my entire career.
reverendsteveii··on The Story of Mel, A Real Programmer, Annotated (1996)
when I first read this story out of the back end of the jargon file in the 90s it felt like Deuteronomy for internet people. It still does.
reverendsteveii··on What causes obesity? A major new study is upending common wisdom
>Then why do I feel more energetic and alert during downtime when I am in general exercising regularly compared to when I am not?

Because feeling tired is a very complex interplay of emotional, hormonal and environmental signals and not simply a lack of fuel.

>Also my resting heart rate is a little higher when I am exercising a lot.

Weird, almost everyone else's goes down as the heart becomes stronger and more efficient during strenuous exercise, then that more efficient muscle is doing the same job the older, less efficient one did

>Also my muscles are rebuilding themselves between all my lifting exercises. All of this must be increasing my resting calorie burn rate I would think.

This part is true, and it's why serious bodybuilders trying to get as large as possible run a bulk/cut cycle. First they eat an excess of calories while working out very intensely, causing them to gain a lot of both muscle and fat, then they eat at a calorie deficit while keeping up as much of the intensity as possible. The calorie deficit leads to weight loss but the continued usage of the muscles causes the body to still try to prioritize maintaining their bulk. The way it was explained to me was "pack it on, then shrinkwrap it". This is also why serious bodybuilders take their sleep very seriously as well, as that's the part where your body actually does the repairing, rebuilding and increasing the mass of muscles that were damaged through strenuous use.

reverendsteveii··on 'Gentle parenting' my smartphone addiction
if you're on a mac or linux you can always edit /etc/hosts to redirect traffic to localhost, effectively killing the site on your local machine
reverendsteveii··on 'Gentle Parenting' My Smartphone Addiction
I use blocksite to help with avoiding the mobile browser versions of these services as well. another one where you can get most of what you need for free and while of course you can always undo something you did the extra few seconds it takes to unblock facebook is often time enough for me to determine whether I'm actually using it for a purpose or dopamine regulating.
reverendsteveii··on What causes obesity? A major new study is upending common wisdom
I've been on that journey. When I decided to lose weight I started by just tracking and I was at about 3200 calories daily. The trackers aren't perfect, of course, but given my height, weight and (nonexistent) activity level my maintenance calories hovered around 2500. Now it's down to 2200, 50 pounds later after two years of hard cutting and recomp (1800 cals/day).

>Basically, once you're on a diet, you're always on a diet for the rest of your life

If your diet is maintenance? Yeah, sorta. People get this idea that they'll get getting fit out of the way and then it's done and they stay fit forever and can go right back to the lifestyle that gave them a body other than what they want. Fit has to be what you do, esp because we live in a society where more is more and the average person is wildly overconsuming from a raw calorie perspective. That's why I hate weight loss as a goal even though that's precisely the goal that started me into the fitness lifestyle. People think that you set the goal, hit the goal, and then you're done forever and that's just not a mindset that will bring success in this.

>There are things I can do to speed it back up, like going to the gym and putting on as much muscle as possible, but that also takes time and effort and work and it requires overeating and gaining weight at the same time.

First off, cardio will do more for you boosting your base metabolism than lifting and it doesn't cause weight gain. It not only boosts your base metabolism but it burns calories immediately.

Second, I think you're a bit too focused on weight as the metric. This is a Goodhart's law problem ('when a metric becomes a target it ceases to be a good metric') and one that I had to overcome. For the first six months or so I was eating very little, working out twice/day (20 minutes resistance in the AM, then 20 minutes on the exercise bike in the early afternoon), and I wasn't losing weight. It sucked. Until I tried on a pair of pants that hadn't fit in years and they slid right on no problem. Turns out that I had naively discovered what the bodybuilding community calls a recomposition or "recomp". That's when you maintain a calorie deficit but still train to gain muscle. You won't lose weight as a number on a scale as quickly, and muscle growth is noticeably slower when you're in a calorie deficit (though not non-existent as long as you sleep well and get your protein), but your shape changes. Fat gets replaced by muscle. I also figured out that I wasn't winded when I went up a flight of stairs anymore and was even able to finish my first 5k having not really lost any weight. I did eventually drop from 210 to about 160 at 5'6" which is more than modest but less than a miracle, but honestly I reached a point in the 170s where I stopped caring about my weight and started caring about my abilities instead.

> my BMR was at 1,836 Calories/day....I was eating 500 calories a day under what my calculator said I should be eating

Holy shit dude 1300 cal/day is absurd. I'm 40, 5'6" and was 210 when I started and 1800 cal/day was a hard cut for me. 20%ish, right near what they say is the max you can maintain long-term. Even losing almost a quarter of my body weight now my daily only dropped to 1700. I'm not here to tell you about your life but those numbers just don't jive with my experience at all. You're bigger than me and younger, it would be an outlier if your BMR was less than mine all other things being equal like level of exercise

FWIW given the data you posted and assuming no exercise the mayo clinic puts your BMR at 2350, which means a hard cut would come in between 1800 and 1900 cals/day. Idk precisely how they define "somewhat active" but if you meet that measure it increases to 2500 and 2000 for a hard cut. Can I ask how you arrived at the figure of 1800 cal/day for your BMR given that the tests you had done set it at 2100?

reverendsteveii··on What causes obesity? A major new study is upending common wisdom
https://www.ars.usda.gov/plains-area/gfnd/gfhnrc/docs/news-a...

For the average american, 500 calories a day come just from sugar. As a culture we more or less have an eating disorder by default.

reverendsteveii··on Random selection is necessary to create stable meritocratic institutions
>I would argue that jury mentality is universal

Then argue it, because that's a pretty large thing to say unsupported

← PreviousPage 2 of 19Next →