HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rgifford

739 karma · joined July 19, 2016

submissionscomments
rgifford··on Understanding Jane Street
As mentioned earlier: phones and financial services are not similar. The market for consumer electronics hasn't fundamentally threatened the stability of the US government every decade for the past 5 decades. I can pick up an iPhone and use its features. It's clearly a complicated device with years of widely publicized, widely understood iterations. Renaissance Technologies Medallion fund may as well be an insider trading scheme for all the public can tell. We have no ability to introspect it. It's a complete black box. And the other financial services provided by Renaissance are garbage.

> They provide liquidity and sometimes take liquidity but only tend to hold those positions for seconds or minutes.

Do HFTs issue or purchase billions of dollars of debt with the express goal of market liquidity? No? So why do you use the term "providing liquidity?" You know "providing liquidity" isn't the same thing as "frenetically purchasing and selling derivatives," right? If these funds didn't exist, I've seen no compelling evidence markets would so much as hiccup. I've seen plenty of compelling evidence that much of financial services in this country are a net drain on its productive capacity.

> We do not need time. We already know.

We'll have to agree to disagree. I think far too much activity happens in financial services, that they aren't nearly boring enough. I harken back to the 70s/80s back before massive deregulation in financial markets, when financiers had to get two jobs just to tread water. I suggest we might revisit such a time. Time will tell!

rgifford··on Understanding Jane Street
Market coercion, regulatory capture, negligence, or any other plain old market manipulation like pump and dump or insider trading or bear raiding, etc.

Enron straight up lied to regulators, many of their employees were also plain negligent. HFTs will probably find their own flavor of fraud given a few more years, if they haven't already.

rgifford··on Understanding Jane Street
Context matters. We were speaking in the the context of financial services. In that context, the past decade has been shooting fish in a barrel. You had to be an idiot to lose money with how index funds performed.

Point me to three funds that have maintained greater than 20% YoY profits for more than 20 years. I would be floored if you could do it. Apple, arguably the best and most profitable business in the world, manages between 20-30% YoY profit. They're the largest contributor to world financial markets rather than operating only on derivatives. I can not imagine a world in which the largest trading firms can outperform that without fraud of some kind. In my mind, it's like gravity. Little rocks rotate around bigger rocks.

rgifford··on Understanding Jane Street
A recounting of the recent history of US financial markets suggests, at least to me, that these firms have the burden of proof. If they haven't proven legitimacy and societal benefit, assuming fraud is a pretty safe bet. I honestly can't name any investment firm with double digit returns YoY for more than a decade or two that doesn't have bodies in the closet. Even Berkshire Hathaway pretty much tracks the S&P500 these days. And as for hand wavy platitudes about price discovery, I don't understand them in the least.

Occam's razor is all I'm saying: What's the simplest answer to the question, why aren't large HFTs with high overheads being eaten alive as technology decentralizes access to trading? Wouldn't we expect types like Burry -- self-driven, confident financial geniuses -- to be equally decentralized? Wouldn't we expect returns to become equally decentralized?

Fraud is the simplest answer. Maybe that comes in the form of market coercion, regulatory capture, negligence, or any other plain old market manipulation. Look back at Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room. It's all much too similar for my tastes. Time will tell.

rgifford··on Understanding Jane Street
CPUs operate due to quantified phenomenon. They're well understood. They've been refined over nearly 100 years.

HFTs came into their own over the past decade or so -- during a time of falling interest rates, unprecedented growth, and notable lack of regulation in financial markets.

One of these things is not like the other. I'd be entirely unsurprised to see most HFTs turn out like Lehman Brothers, Enron, or AIG. They all lasted more than a decade or so. But their gains were fraudulent and they failed spectacularly.

rgifford··on Waymo car swarmed by skaters in San Francisco 'hill bomb'
I worry about egg stains on sweatshirts too. Some folks join us with age. Others live life right up to the brim, good for em I say. The world needs all kinds.

Reminds me of Cooper's Hill Cheese-Rolling and Wake. It's this race in Gloucester, England. It's been going on since the early 1800s. Folks run down a 45 degree hill for 200 yards to catch a 10 pound rolling cheese wheel. It's as dangerous as it sounds, but fun to watch [1]. Medical staff is onsite and ready for the inevitable hospital visits that follow. They swapped out the cheese for foam a decade back for safety reasons, which makes me chuckle for some reason.

If anything the SF hill bomb tradition should get adopted by the city. Give it a date and time, close down the street, get medical staff and police on site, get some minimal safety measures in place, and give residents some notice. Then is there anything to be upset about?

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KEh3wz-92i4

rgifford··on What do lawyers do?
A majority of Americans think we should interpret the constitution in a modern light [1]. The young, secular, internet-age population are going to challenge the constitution further as the generation of Reagan and American exceptionalism go to the nursing home. I'm sure of it. It's a shame we have to suffer the death rattle of traditionalists in the meantime.

1. https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/05/11/growing-sha...

rgifford··on FiveThirtyEight 2022 Election Forecast
Many states in middle America receive net federal subsidies while exercising outsized per capita political influence in presidential elections and Congress. You tell me how that's fair or right.
rgifford··on What do lawyers do?
> Have you actually read SCOTUS trial transcripts? Because they come across as incredibly sharp people to me even when I don't agree with their views.

Yes. Get nine professionals together to write a subject matter document over a year. I don't care who they are, that document will appear at least superficially put together. I have lots of thoughts/criticism. This isn't the conversation for that, so here's just one of those criticisms:

> Attempts to justify abortion through appeals to a broader right to autonomy and to define one’s “concept of existence” prove too much. Casey, 505 U. S., at 851. Those criteria, at a high level of generality, could license fundamental rights to illicit drug use, prostitution, and the like.

Oh no, drug use and prostitution could be licensed too? Obviously those are terrible and morally repugnant. Backtracking is clearly necessary. What? Why? This isn't the 1970s and the nation isn't 100% on board with Reagan and the war on drugs anymore. A majority of Americans support decriminalizing sex work for example. This point IS contentious, but it's treated as though it's self justifying. It so obviously comes from minds trapped in a bygone era where traditionalist values went unquestioned, where appeals to them were enough.

> Actually there are psychology studies examining professionals who have to deal with bias (scientists, judges, etc) that indicate that the competent ones tend to slightly over rather than under compensate.

I'd love to see these studies. I don't know what over/under compensate means in this context or how that says anything about cognitive decline.

> How is that different than legislating from the bench? Isn't updating laws a job best reserved for the legislature?

The pace of technological progress is increasing. It has surpassed our legislative ability even under the best of circumstances. We aren't in the best of circumstances. Our legislature hasn't effectively represented popular interests for years now [1].

1. https://act.represent.us/sign/problempoll-fba/

rgifford··on What do lawyers do?
> If there were broad consensus to change the law as written then presumably the legislature would vote to do so.

The legislature does not represent popular interests any more and hasn't for years [1]. This is widely studied and accepted. You can see it plainly even in its demographic and socioeconomic composition.

We don't have enough of a shared reality here to come to agreement and should agree to disagree.

1. https://act.represent.us/sign/problempoll-fba/

rgifford··on What do lawyers do?
> Law is about persuasion...

Yep, we have an adversarial, common law system. So we measure our lawyers on their ability to manipulate regardless of the moral or social outcome. I don't think this is a facet of law in general, so much as a legal system that hasn't grown past ~1790.

rgifford··on What do lawyers do?
> However the lifetime appointment of US Supreme Court justices is a purposeful designed feature...

It was a feature in a time when white men lived, on average, to the ripe old age of 38.

I'm tired of treating anything the founding fathers came up with as sacred. Different time, completely different context. Economics, psychology, and almost all of STEM didn't even exist then. They did not know what they were doing. They got lucky in almost every regard.

Keep in mind in all of human history only about 1/4 of violent revolutions are successful, many that "succeeded" left all parties involved much worse off. America, especially in its inception, was an incredible anomaly that far too many paint as something more in the name of American exceptionalism.

EDIT: Look, our legislature is a complete and abject failure. It's completely gridlocked, arguably by the design of private interests. If it were working to reflect popular interest, I imagine American law and government would look very different. I don't think any of what I'm suggesting here would be even slightly controversial to be quite honest.

rgifford··on What do lawyers do?
> Law is amazing and much older than programming...

And boy does it show. Recent events have me examining The Supreme Court and American law from a programmers perspective. And let me tell you, there are warts:

The Supreme Court is comprised of lifelong appointees, mostly in the dwindling twilight of their cognitive ability. This made sense when we didn't understand cognitive decline. Now with the rapid pace of technological progress, it's a joke. To be plain, I don't know of any ICs their age able to keep up. They move up or age out.

The whole legal rationalist ideal that you can start from the base principles of the constitution and reason up indefinitely is ridiculous. We programmers have all sorts of tooling to navigate code bases larger than we can readily keep in our heads. That tooling regularly fails us. The best programmers I've worked with regularly hit compiler errors. This all happens in the sterile environment of code. Why should I believe that judges, who can't even agree on whether to interpret the constitution in a modern lens or hold to its writers original intentions, are less susceptible to irrationality or bias or plain incompetence with far less tooling? A lot of modern psychology suggests they can't.

For all you programmers out there, read a handful of legal documents. As far as complex logical reasoning goes, it comes off like a kid building a treehouse compared to code for even simple web apps. The legal profession needs to recognize its limitations and catch up with the times. Here are some ideas:

- Rigorous, regular cognitive testing after for all licensed legal professionals older than 45. You have to pass a test to drive in old age, but you can sentence someone to life in prison no problem.

- Term limits for everyone, everywhere.

- In certain cases, law should embrace statistics. Certain cases aren't suited for proposition-like rule based reasoning. Law needs a larger tool chest that can make argument based not on precedent, but on what exists right now in American society.

rgifford··on FiveThirtyEight 2022 Election Forecast
The needs of these states are less important. They have fewer people, less productive capacity, less economic output, etc. They are lesser by every metric imaginable. In our nation's bread basket folks love to hold up agricultural achievement. Ironically California dominates that too [1].

Getting rid of the electoral college system in favor of popular vote isn't enough. A couple states drive the productive, agricultural, intellectual and economic engines of our country. In a meritocracy, these states would dictate federal policy. Instead they're subject to the capricious whims of deadbeats. Another way to put it: who really needs who?

Some players are MJ or Kobe or Lebron, some sit on the bench. That's life.

1. https://www.ers.usda.gov/faqs

rgifford··on FiveThirtyEight 2022 Election Forecast
Passion votes count the same, sure. But impassioned voters advocate for their candidates and get their friends to vote. Lesser of two evils voters don't really care like that.

It's the whole reason startups go for natural marketing. Users that naturally come upon and love your product will proselyte it more and better than anyone else.

rgifford··on FiveThirtyEight 2022 Election Forecast
9 of those 30 states have more cows than people [1].

When your state is a single dude standing in a field filled with cows, getting the popular vote doesn't say much.

1. https://beef2live.com/story-cattle-inventory-vs-human-popula...

rgifford··on Life is not short
Don't like most "progress people," don't like most philosophy, don't like most self help.

If you have "it" figured out, why is that not enough? All I can see are ulterior motives: a desperate need to feel seen or remembered or virtuous or important, something to sell, an attempt to elevate one's status, etc.

rgifford··on As weed gets more potent, teens are getting sick
Can't help but think of Mac Miller's Tiny Desk performance of his song 2009 [1]. Mac started using weed heavily in his teens to cope with the stress of touring. 2009 was a big year for him: two major mixtapes, the cusp of fame and his intro to harder drugs. The song is celebration and acceptance and resignation, and totally unapologetic. He died of an OD two months after this performance at the age of 26.

1. https://youtu.be/QrR_gm6RqCo?t=699

rgifford··on Coinbase lays off around 1,100 employees
Go back and read the HN thread from the Coinbase DPO [1]. Their valuation was insane then, before the war in Ukraine, inflation, or Omicron. The top comments on that thread shock me. Even at that time I expected every other comment to be about how overvalued they were, but it just wasn't the case.

Wonder if people could've been made to see this then. I went full on Chicken Little [2] and mostly just got treated like I was yelling at children to get off my lawn.

1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26808275

2. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26808275&p=2#26812175

rgifford··on Full consensus for disconnecting Russia from SWIFT achieved, process has begun
(1) In context, "wrecking Ukraine" referred to continued actions from a distance (in Crimea and elsewhere). Again, he was wrong.

I'm glad previous adminstrations didn't put stock in his ideology.

rgifford··on Full consensus for disconnecting Russia from SWIFT achieved, process has begun
(1) I'm assuming nothing. In the context of the quote, Mearsheimer was directly stating the impossibility of an invasion of Ukraine by Russia. He has said as much on multiple occasions since. He was wrong. Period. Much of his political theorizing around Russia goes out the window with that assumption. For example, The West arming Ukraine was inarguably correct at this point. Ukraine is using those weapons to defend their sovereignty as we speak. Did that heighten tensions? I guess. Does blocking your face when someone punches you heighten tensions? I guess. Stating as much isn't exactly novel.

(2) Agreed. Keep an eye on Russian currency markets come Monday. Between removal from SWIFT and freezing central Russian bank assets, significantly painful sanctions are ramping up. The conflict has only been ongoing for 4 days.

(3) Agreed. It's ridiculous.

rgifford··on Full consensus for disconnecting Russia from SWIFT achieved, process has begun
"If you want to wreck Russia what you should do is tell them to try and create a greater Russia. It will lead to no end of trouble. I think Putin is much too smart for that." - John Mearsheimer 2015

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JrMiSQAGOS4

Wowza. That aged like milk. Really glad this guy didn't have a hand in our foreign policy. His apologist attitude towards autocrats is pretty gross too.

"I believe he is sowing divisions in The West that will manifest over time. If he is smart he will sit back and continue to pull levers as he has over the past year or so, and in the end ... he will get what he wants." - John Mearsheimer 2022

https://news.wttw.com/2022/02/21/us-impose-new-sanctions-ami...

Yep. I didn't know who John Mearsheimer was an hour ago, now I actively dislike him. Pretty impressive how consistently he's been wrong about Putin and his intentions over the years.

rgifford··on Eric Schmidt plans to give A.I. researchers $125M
Most Americans don't have money to save or invest. Capital gains functionally rewrites tax brackets.

There's lots of ways to make sure that people so rich they don't have to wage earn pay their fair share. We choose not to.

rgifford··on Eric Schmidt plans to give A.I. researchers $125M
People talk about it quite a bit. It hasn't amounted to anything material in my lifetime. If anything just the opposite.

I don't think effective tax rates for the uber wealthy have ever been lower.

rgifford··on Eric Schmidt plans to give A.I. researchers $125M
From what I've read the uber wealthy pay an effective tax rate of ~10%. US voters and legislators have set our top tax brackets at ~40%.

What is a fair tax rate? I don't know. Less is more IMO.

But by the terms we've all agreed on, the uber wealthy skimp by ~3/4.

rgifford··on Eric Schmidt plans to give A.I. researchers $125M
I doubt we taxed him anywhere near his fair share. That effective tax rates decline with wealth floors me. It also bothers me how cut throat capitalists grow into philanthropists as they become old and vulnerable. Years tax dodging, suppressing wages, lobbying, and engaging in veiled class warfare to gain every bit of wealth possible. And then they deign to give a fraction of what was owed the people (for roads, the internet, public safety, etc.) back in bits and spurts to be celebrated as generous. It makes me laugh.

At least your run-of-the-mill Scrooge has the decency to be consistent, to be hated.

While I say all that, I am also glad he's donating.

rgifford··on How to Work Hard
This is really good advice.
rgifford··on How to Work Hard
... what? Do you have a source here?

> The major correlates with high economic mobility Chetty identifies are racial segregation, income inequality, school quality, family structure and social capital.

https://www.huduser.gov/portal/pdredge/pdr_edge_featd_articl...

rgifford··on How to Work Hard
> ...we should think about how we can help more people become successful.

It's like you're purposefully missing the point.

What if most of serious wealth and success is decided at birth? What are the logical consequences of that?

Let's go extreme: A rich guy wins the lottery. He then tells everyone in town how they could've won if they bought tickets. What's your reaction?

> Even poor people today live better than kings in the past.

I generally agree with this on quantitative measures of productive or technological progress. Other quantitative measures don't look so great: education, housing and healthcare costs; health (esp. mental health) issues in developed vs developing nations; prison populations in the present vs past.

Michael Foucalt has better arguments to make here than I do [1].

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BBJTeNTZtGU

rgifford··on How to Work Hard
And by the US in the 1930s with the New Deal [1]. Many at least partially credit it for the economic prosperity that followed WWII.

It's a tricky balance it seems.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Deal

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →