290 karma · joined November 27, 2020
Nobody is arguing the solar and wind power isn’t cheap, but the cost of power on those cloudy windless weeks is going to be real high to make having all that standby generation around. It’s the cost to achieve the same reliability and 99% carbon free that is expensive.
Money is imaginary and global warming isn’t so let’s just print some bonds or move some numbers around in some database and build it all! - an electrical power engineer
Electricity is different from gasoline since it can’t be easily stored production and consumption are always perfectly in balance.
Gasoline is a world wide commodity, whereas electricity is consumed relatively close to where it is generated.
Oil and gasoline are global markets, but there are many regional electricity markets with their own sets of regulations which are constantly evolving.
From what I’ve seen The only way people sink money in to building electrical infrastructure is with some long term certainty for prices from some buyer. Maybe it is different once the asset is paid off you can operate in the spot market but I believe financiers prefer the certainty of a fixed contract.
Maybe refineries that are built find a buyer for their product before they build them too?
I much prefer simple dumb appliances than smart crap that is garbage after 5 years. If the price is high like in Texas recently I can decide to not use the dryer.
I am sure the variable rates helped to incentivize people to conserve electricity in Texas recently but that is an extreme case.
Electricity infrastructure is capital intensive and long term stable rates are required to finance it.
There are a lot of caveats to that! Does it get the solar to 95% of the time available at name plate rating? 98%?
A system that can meet the demand with an increasingly higher percentage of non dispatchable wind and solar needs some plan B for when it is night time and there is no wind. Or it is cloudy and not windy for days. It can be batteries but there is a cost to that too. Any place with a high share of non dispatchable generation tends to either have good interconnections to their neighbors who have firm power supplies, or they have their own natural gas or diesel generation, but there is a cost to having that sitting around too.
I’m fine with cost for nuclear, for batteries, for over building wind and solar, and for nat gas used as a backup for that weather system that moves in once a year that would otherwise result In a blackout. cost is just a number in a ledger somewhere.
The energy supply should come from diverse sources and nuclear is a good part of that solution.
I just miss the days before screens
And I also believe Germans would not produce or tolerate the California or Texas debacles.
I suppose if you add to the the cost of a solar or wind plant the cost of a battery system to make the output 100% constant like a nuclear plant that would be a better $/kWh comparison.
Olkiluoto is 1600 MW and should therefore supply 16% of Finland’s energy needs. Wikipedia says it will Be online in February 2022.
So for 16 billion euro Finland gets 26% of their energy from a firm source with no carbon Emissions.
British Columbia is spending 16 billion CAD on a 1000 MW hydro dam callers site C, in a system with a peak load of 16,000 MW that is 90% hydro.
16 billion euros for two nuclear plants that will make Up a quarter of the Finnish system doesn’t seem that bad to me? You need something for the cloudy week with no wind.
I’m not saying don’t also pursue renewables, but nuclear is part of the solution. It isn’t an either/or, it’s both.
It is a difficult topic to discuss without aquiring a label, and obviously very few are willing to wade in to those treacherous waters.
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_conflicts_in_North_Ame...
Hydro plants can adjust output but it changes river levels and flows with environmental consequences.
I imagine nuclear plants could use control rods to generate less power if they had to?
Or if you have the nuclear power because you need it anyway in case it isn’t sunny/windy but it is a sunny and windy day how do you decide if solar/wind or nuclear should be curtailed? Both have near zero marginal cost.
Imagine a car that sits in a garage and once a decade you take it out and thrash it. Machines degrade just from time not necessarily wear as rubber and gaskets become brittle, metal rusts, capacitors leak, fuel degrades, algae grows, rats chew on whatever they can, shafts and bearings and motors seize or get flat spots from sitting.
Look at Texas and their fleet of plants that didn’t start when they were needed. Any machine that is not running is likely to stay not running.
When people quote $1/W for solar generation it really should be $4/W because you have to build 4x as much and then add another ... infinite amount for increasing the size of the transmission system by 4x too so that areas that have sun can transmit to areas that have none. All possible just expensive.