HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rhodozelia

290 karma · joined November 27, 2020

submissionscomments
rhodozelia··on Solar Is Cheapest Electricity in History, U.S. DOE Aims to Cut Costs 60% by 2030
how long before I can buy a Tesla for 50% of what one costs now? If the batteries are going to get so cheap we should be seeing some great price drops in electric cars. If not ... why not? And that reason will probably apply to battery energy storage too.
rhodozelia··on Solar Is Cheapest Electricity in History, U.S. DOE Aims to Cut Costs 60% by 2030
Who pays for the shadow generation system that we keep perfectly maintained and ready to generate 100% of system demand on the 5 days stretch of cloudy windless days? This cost has to be added to the cost of building a 100% solar/wind system.

Nobody is arguing the solar and wind power isn’t cheap, but the cost of power on those cloudy windless weeks is going to be real high to make having all that standby generation around. It’s the cost to achieve the same reliability and 99% carbon free that is expensive.

Money is imaginary and global warming isn’t so let’s just print some bonds or move some numbers around in some database and build it all! - an electrical power engineer

rhodozelia··on Equivalent of 97% of Scotland’s 2020 electricity consumption was from renewables
Compare gasoline prices to the electricity prices in Texas recently, Texas has experienced negative prices in windy periods and prices at the artificial market limit of 11,000 $/MWH, which is the equivalent of $396 / gallon of gasoline. Electricity prices change much faster and the swings are much larger than gasoline.

Electricity is different from gasoline since it can’t be easily stored production and consumption are always perfectly in balance.

Gasoline is a world wide commodity, whereas electricity is consumed relatively close to where it is generated.

Oil and gasoline are global markets, but there are many regional electricity markets with their own sets of regulations which are constantly evolving.

From what I’ve seen The only way people sink money in to building electrical infrastructure is with some long term certainty for prices from some buyer. Maybe it is different once the asset is paid off you can operate in the spot market but I believe financiers prefer the certainty of a fixed contract.

Maybe refineries that are built find a buyer for their product before they build them too?

rhodozelia··on Equivalent of 97% of Scotland’s 2020 electricity consumption was from renewables
A 60 gallon tank is considered large around here, so no wonder you had a 200 gal tank if it only heated at night!
rhodozelia··on U.S. rent has increased 175% faster than household income over past 20 years
What if you rent the house out? Can it be an investment then? It would produce a return, positive or negative depending on your costs and the rent you can charge.
rhodozelia··on Equivalent of 97% of Scotland’s 2020 electricity consumption was from renewables
How much would you have to save? For me it is thousands I can’t be bothered to delay kids bath times to save five bucks!
rhodozelia··on Equivalent of 97% of Scotland’s 2020 electricity consumption was from renewables
the grid is quite reliable in most of the world and provides as much power as you want whenever you want.

I much prefer simple dumb appliances than smart crap that is garbage after 5 years. If the price is high like in Texas recently I can decide to not use the dryer.

rhodozelia··on Equivalent of 97% of Scotland’s 2020 electricity consumption was from renewables
How much money do you need to save for the incentive to exceed the effort and discomfort? If you make $50 an hour how much effort will you spend every day to save $50 a month?

I am sure the variable rates helped to incentivize people to conserve electricity in Texas recently but that is an extreme case.

Electricity infrastructure is capital intensive and long term stable rates are required to finance it.

rhodozelia··on Amazon Delivery Drivers Forced to Sign 'Biometric Consent' Form or Lose Job
Can you be forced to sign something that changes the terms of your employment agreement?
rhodozelia··on Why the Wuhan lab leak theory shouldn't be dismissed
I can’t find the link but the virus they took from sick miners to study and what is now called covid-19 were 95-99% the same. A fellow did their masters thesis on it in 2016 or so
rhodozelia··on NYC Spent Half a Million Dollars per Inmate in 2020, Report Says
Commit a non violent crime and get 500k? Where do I sign up
rhodozelia··on FreeCAD 0.19
I had a drafting course as part of my ee degree. It was mostly paper and pencil drawing shapes from different perspectives but it did have an autocad component once we were supposed to know what to draw. One of the first things they taught us was this selection feature.
rhodozelia··on Tesla's “full self driving” beta is potentially dangerous
Everything gets to be crap by adding the label beta. Texas electricity system, beta!!
rhodozelia··on Focalboard – a self-hosted alternative to Trello, Notion, and Asana
I’ve been using redmine for project management for a decade. It is reliably excellent.
rhodozelia··on Satellite imagery shows Northern California kelp forests have collapsed
Link?

There are a lot of caveats to that! Does it get the solar to 95% of the time available at name plate rating? 98%?

rhodozelia··on An argument that nuclear power makes the climate crisis worse
>If you ran your entire grid on just solar and wind, no nuclear, or coal or natural gas peaker plants, you'll find that wind and solar is no longer cheap, and is much less resilient to exceptional circumstances. >That kind of is my point: countries are doing this and without blackouts and it's actually fine.

A system that can meet the demand with an increasingly higher percentage of non dispatchable wind and solar needs some plan B for when it is night time and there is no wind. Or it is cloudy and not windy for days. It can be batteries but there is a cost to that too. Any place with a high share of non dispatchable generation tends to either have good interconnections to their neighbors who have firm power supplies, or they have their own natural gas or diesel generation, but there is a cost to having that sitting around too.

I’m fine with cost for nuclear, for batteries, for over building wind and solar, and for nat gas used as a backup for that weather system that moves in once a year that would otherwise result In a blackout. cost is just a number in a ledger somewhere.

The energy supply should come from diverse sources and nuclear is a good part of that solution.

rhodozelia··on SpaceX plans Starlink broadband for cars, boats, and planes
Devices like “spot” which allow a distress signal to be sent exist. Some can tether to your phone so you can use the phone to enter a message.

I just miss the days before screens

rhodozelia··on SpaceX plans Starlink broadband for cars, boats, and planes
I’m happy with the status quo of going to wilderness as one of the only ways to get people to leave their phones alone.
rhodozelia··on Israel, Cyprus and Greece agree to link power grids via subsea cable
Not sure why you are downvoted. Utilities are natural monopolies. It makes sense for one entity to provide the network. The risk is that the monopoly gets fat and lazy, but there are many examples of failures from both approaches.

And I also believe Germans would not produce or tolerate the California or Texas debacles.

rhodozelia··on Nuclear power must be well regulated, not ditched
I am sure nuclear is just about the most expensive power if we are counting construction, operation, and decommissioning. But also consider that it is a firm source of power not subject to the weather. The value of a kWh is quite high when otherwise there would be none.

I suppose if you add to the the cost of a solar or wind plant the cost of a battery system to make the output 100% constant like a nuclear plant that would be a better $/kWh comparison.

rhodozelia··on Nuclear power must be well regulated, not ditched
Hanhikivi is 1000 MW and will supply 10% of Finland’s energy needs according to Wikipedia.

Olkiluoto is 1600 MW and should therefore supply 16% of Finland’s energy needs. Wikipedia says it will Be online in February 2022.

So for 16 billion euro Finland gets 26% of their energy from a firm source with no carbon Emissions.

British Columbia is spending 16 billion CAD on a 1000 MW hydro dam callers site C, in a system with a peak load of 16,000 MW that is 90% hydro.

16 billion euros for two nuclear plants that will make Up a quarter of the Finnish system doesn’t seem that bad to me? You need something for the cloudy week with no wind.

I’m not saying don’t also pursue renewables, but nuclear is part of the solution. It isn’t an either/or, it’s both.

rhodozelia··on Canada's parliament votes to label China's persecution of Uighurs as genocide
Personally i don’t think what happened in Canada is anywhere near on the same level of “genocide” as what is going on in China, but it is impossible to truly know. I Was hoping to get some discussion on the comparison between the two situations, but I got two apologetic Canadians who agree with the prime minister and the upvote/downvote roller coaster.

It is a difficult topic to discuss without aquiring a label, and obviously very few are willing to wade in to those treacherous waters.

rhodozelia··on Canada's parliament votes to label China's persecution of Uighurs as genocide
The prime minister of canada declared that canada had conducted a genocide against the pre-european inhabitants of the continent. It looks like Louis Riel's Metis revolt in 1885 was the last [0] real battle or war. The genocide Canada has declared they conducted was also not a violent slaughtering of people. So I guess they are in good company with the Chinese as soft-genocidaires?

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_conflicts_in_North_Ame...

rhodozelia··on Whole school board resigns in shame after forgetting their WebEx call was public
Dice up their pay any way you want, I get 15 days off a year above and beyond statutory holidays. Teachers get ... over 50? That’s a lot of time to live that most people dont get
rhodozelia··on The road to electric is filled with tiny cars
These vehicles are more like golf carts than cars. Top speed of 56km/hr. No safety features. What is interesting is that the batteries, converters, and motors are so cheap that they offer a golf cart with a vehicle body for $2500.
rhodozelia··on Activists who embrace nuclear power
Uh ... it does compete with farmed solar? Anyone deciding whether to buy power from the utility or generate their own is doing the analysis to see which “wins” the competition.
rhodozelia··on Activists who embrace nuclear power
Granted, I’ve never worked on a natural gas fired turbine, but I imagine every generator given the option would prefer to run consistentently at maximum output as that is how they would get the maximum ROI.

Hydro plants can adjust output but it changes river levels and flows with environmental consequences.

I imagine nuclear plants could use control rods to generate less power if they had to?

Or if you have the nuclear power because you need it anyway in case it isn’t sunny/windy but it is a sunny and windy day how do you decide if solar/wind or nuclear should be curtailed? Both have near zero marginal cost.

rhodozelia··on Activists who embrace nuclear power
keeping old fossil plants sitting idle but in working order is possible but will cost nearly as much as generating at full capacity, minus the cost of fuel.

Imagine a car that sits in a garage and once a decade you take it out and thrash it. Machines degrade just from time not necessarily wear as rubber and gaskets become brittle, metal rusts, capacitors leak, fuel degrades, algae grows, rats chew on whatever they can, shafts and bearings and motors seize or get flat spots from sitting.

Look at Texas and their fleet of plants that didn’t start when they were needed. Any machine that is not running is likely to stay not running.

rhodozelia··on Activists who embrace nuclear power
I don’t foresee anybody paying for all this over built over provisioned solar/wind generation and transmission. I suppose if it has to be overbuilt 4x to be as reliable as the power system we have now then my power bill will be 4x more.

When people quote $1/W for solar generation it really should be $4/W because you have to build 4x as much and then add another ... infinite amount for increasing the size of the transmission system by 4x too so that areas that have sun can transmit to areas that have none. All possible just expensive.

rhodozelia··on Activists who embrace nuclear power
Given that residential customers pay quite a bit more than the wholesale rate for power rooftop solar must be an investment that pays for itself or nobody would do it!
← PreviousPage 4 of 7Next →