HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rhodozelia

290 karma · joined November 27, 2020

submissionscomments
rhodozelia··on Activists who embrace nuclear power
They could have moved even more power consumption off of fossil fuels had they not freaked out after fukashima and turned all their reactors off!
rhodozelia··on Activists who embrace nuclear power
>As of March 2019, China has 46 nuclear reactors in operation with a capacity of 42.8 GW and 11 under construction with a capacity of 10.8 GW.Additional reactors are planned for an additional 36 GW. [1]

China is planning to double their nuclear generation capacity. It is staggering to think they have 11 1000 MW plants under construction and plans to build another 36. The USA has lost the ability to build even 1 plant economically. I think China is “just doing it” when it comes to nuclear, as much as they can, which is a lot.

In comparison usa has 95 plants for 98,000 MW and has shut down 34 plants.

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_China

rhodozelia··on Boeing 747 loses parts after take-off from Maastricht – 2 injuries
maybe related to a large number of planes sitting idle due to covid - come back in to service after sitting for 9 months and unexpected degradation has taken place
rhodozelia··on Clearing price for supplying power to Texas grid –$31.65
Vertically integrated government owned and operated utilities have imploded too- notably Ontario hydro failed due to costs related to their nuclear plants, and the rate payers had an extra line item on their bill - $10/mo? - for I don’t know how many decades to pay down the stranded debt.

I don’t think markets are the right tool for electricity generation transmission and distribution - too much coordination is required between the different functions, central planning optimizes the outcomes, and the lead times are so long on significant projects that a high $/MWh for a week in 2021 isn’t going to result in a new nuclear plant.

There are natural monopolies in distribution and maybe transmission as well.

100% regulated even if there are private players is the way.

rhodozelia··on Coinbase valued above $100B, ahead of direct listing
I think it is so that you take care with what you post - it will be readable forever and someone who goes looking for you online may be able to link your profile to your posts by the details you divulge
rhodozelia··on Coinbase valued above $100B, ahead of direct listing
What prices are down? Big Macs? Flat screen TVs? Crap from Walmart?

How about the actual things you need: housing, groceries, college, gas, electricity, a vacation?

Due to the pressure on government to keep inflation low to avoid devaluing their dollar inflation is a gamed number and the goal posts have been moved to keep it low so things look good. Meanwhile the price on everything that I buy or want to buy is through the roof and I can’t find a job that will pay me more than my current one - guess I should have gone with software instead of hardware

rhodozelia··on Perseverance Rover lands on Mars [video]
Nortel and it’s predeccessors bell northern telecom used to put weights in the handsets so they had a nice feel to them.
rhodozelia··on Texas was minutes away from months-long power outages, officials say
"black start" of a power plant, the ability for it to start the generator rotation, provide current to the field, and energize a power line is something that costs more to provide when building a plant. Utilities that have old school focus on reliability will generally have that capability. Private companies who just generate power to make money don't have any incentive to pay for that function. If the grid is dead there is nobody to use that power.

Another cool thing that utility power plants can do is feed themselves - keep the pumps running, lights on, heaters running, coffee hot, etc in the power plant using the power from the generator in the plant even if it is not connected to the transmission system. Most privately owned power plants forego this ability along with black start and will have a diesel generator instead.

rhodozelia··on Texas was minutes away from months-long power outages, officials say
particularly skilled people go in to grid operation control rooms, power plant control rooms, airplane cockpits, etc, all over the world every day. This is their career. They are trained to deal with failures of the system they operate and to take over control from the automatic systems when the computers can't make the right decision.
rhodozelia··on Texas was minutes away from months-long power outages, officials say
Resonance slightly above rated speed I have heard of.

Pole slipping, a loss of synchronism, i would associate more with transient events such as large losses of load or generation that cause big changes in power flows as opposed to a sustained operation at 58 Hz. Loss of synchronism or pole Slipping should be protected against by out of step protection elements?

rhodozelia··on Texas was minutes away from months-long power outages, officials say
true. generally if frequency is greater than 62 Hz or less than 57 Hz generators will be allowed to disconnect immediately to avoid damaging themselves.

Offhand I am not quite sure what the damage from off-nominal frequency operation is though - inductance is jwl - any impedances with a lagging reactive component will vary proportionally with frequency. a decrease in frequency will cause an increase in current. I imagine off-nominal frequency operation causes something to get hot.

rhodozelia··on Texas was minutes away from months-long power outages, officials say
are you referring to modern wind turbines and solar farms which have their output converted through power electronics?

I have literally never seen a large induction machine used as a generator, every machine larger than 300 kW I have seen has been a synchronous machine. If I've read about 600 different power plants, 598 of them have had synchronous machines.

Where in the world, what application, and in what age of installation are engineers choosing induction machines + power electronics over synchronous machines?

rhodozelia··on Texas was minutes away from months-long power outages, officials say
Generators are spinning machines with mechanical power applied to the shaft via some type of prime mover such as a gas turbine. The gas turbine has a throttle which controls how much mechanical power it makes, and how much electrical power the generator makes.

When the power applied to the generator shaft by the turbine is greater than the load placed on the generator by people’s lights and heaters, the turbine and generator speed up until the gas turbine backs off the throttle a bit to balance power out of the turbine in to the generator and power out of the generator.

If people turn on more lights and heaters and power out of the generator is greater than power in, the imbalance is made up from the rotating machinery’s inertia and it slows down. If the imbalance isn’t corrected by opening the throttle on the gas turbine it slows down until it stops rotating.

If the throttle is already wide open and demand exceeds supply the machines slow down until they stop and nobody gets any electricity, so they have to have some blackouts to reduce the load so that demand is not greater than supply.

Nothing should blow up though.

rhodozelia··on Analysis: Texas power outage leaves officials working political angles
So you’d prefer radioactivity and c02 in the air from coal to spent nuclear fuel in holding pools at nuclear power plants? Which potentially could be used as fuel again for a different type of reactor? This is literally the choice - something needs to be Baseload generation on a cloudy week with no wind.
rhodozelia··on What’s interesting about the Florida water system hack is that we heard about it
Sure plants have safety mechanisms to protect human Life. So does your car, but it will still let you do stupid things with it. Sometimes they are ok: person in the car is injured and I need to drive in a way that might normally be unsafe. The machine can’t make the judgement calls about when it is ok to operate outside of the normal desired operating envelope. Machines have physical limits and usually they are built to protect themselves from damage, but you can still crash a plane or a car or put a brick on your gas pedal and leave the car in neutral and destroy your engine.

In this specific case I imagine the plant wasn’t physically capable of dosing at that rate - and there should be alarms if the outgoing water is outside the desired operating parameters.

rhodozelia··on Autopilot on Cars for $999
If someone else using the product causes you injury? Putting unsafe cars on the road is terrible.
rhodozelia··on What’s interesting about the Florida water system hack is that we heard about it
Do you have a different approach to providing equipment to utilities?
rhodozelia··on What’s interesting about the Florida water system hack is that we heard about it
Thanks for the VPN link.

>They might be relatively harmless in isolation, but it could be really harmful if an attacker could compromise a dozen of these small plants and disable or destroy them at the same time so there's less reserve capacity in the grid to pick up the slack when you launch your main attack.

I suppose it depends on what is considered a small power plant. I would say anything less than 20MW is small, greater than 30 MW is medium, and greater than 100 MW is large. Simultaneously tripping a dozen 20 MW power plants would result in a loss of 240 MW of generation, about the same as 2 large units. There is 258,000 MW of nameplate generation on the western north american grid and a peak load of about 150,000 MW. The link below [0] shows that transmission level operators are looking at 1000's of MW of lost generation to have a measurable impact on the grid but losing that amount of generation causes operational headaches and not automatically an outage.

[0]: https://www.wecc.org/Reliability/2013-10%20WECC%20JSIS%20-%2...

rhodozelia··on What’s interesting about the Florida water system hack is that we heard about it
the western grid has 258,000 MW of generation. renewables go up and down like yo-yos, power plants go on-line and offline all the time and a large and always increasing fraction of it is unscheduled and uncontrolled.

Of course it depends on the size and location of the power plant, but there are many more small plants that can go offline without causing any significant effect to the grid than there are large ones, and the large ones probably have the resources to be manned 24/7 either on site or from a remote site over a dedicated and thereby secure fibre link.

One take-away from this thread is that not all infrastructure is 'critical'.

rhodozelia··on What’s interesting about the Florida water system hack is that we heard about it
I could imagine a malicious defect in Tesla firmware that would cause all Tesla vehicles on the road to make an aggressive manoeuvre that would most likely result in a crash at the same time. So I think the potential scale for death and injury With remotely updatable vehicle firmware is large.

Can you recommend any VPNs that are up to the required standard for critical infrastructure?

Although since the power plants I work on would struggle to kill even one person and damaging them would only cause financial hardship for the owner or an insignificant exceedanve of environmental regulations, so they must not be critical.

rhodozelia··on What’s interesting about the Florida water system hack is that we heard about it
Other than syncing a generator totally out of phase I can’t think of anything that could potentially hurt someone at the power plants I work on.

If the machines are killing people sometimes that is probably a whole other level of risk and I agree not something I would want to touch remotely.

rhodozelia··on What’s interesting about the Florida water system hack is that we heard about it
I wish more attention (money) was given to cyber security on infrastructure projects, and all projects. Cyber security is a mess everywhere. How Many organizations in the USA have not been hacked or are Unhackable? The only one I would guess is google and maybe amazon? Banks and financial markets seem competent as well.
rhodozelia··on What’s interesting about the Florida water system hack is that we heard about it
You’d make more money as a plumber
rhodozelia··on What’s interesting about the Florida water system hack is that we heard about it
Plants still have skilled human operators that know better what they need at that exact moment than whoever programmed the system ages ago, like a pilot should be able to fly a plane according to his inputs, so unless you are a system programmer that wants phone calls from all of the projects you have ever worked on saying “the system won’t let us do x” you give the owner all of the tools they might need to do whatever they might want with their equipment.

Confirmations to ensure setting is entered accurately and logging of changing of settings and by whom are good ideas though.

rhodozelia··on What’s interesting about the Florida water system hack is that we heard about it
The plant owners have made that call.

Is a vpn secure?

If Tesla can update the software in a fleet of vehicles remotely why can’t I update the software in a power plant?

rhodozelia··on What’s interesting about the Florida water system hack is that we heard about it
It’s an interesting question i was contemplating while writing the post, is it possible to cause damage by hacking the plants I work on? Exceeding conditions set forth in Environmental certificates, yes, destroying the machinery ... would be possible only because some modern equipment is used and connected to the network, if the Ethernet ports on the devices containing the sync-checks were disconnected, or an older dumb device where any setting adjustments are made with a screwdriver, then it wouldn’t be possible to damage about half of the plants. The other half with oil pumps you could cause some significant damage by telling it the oil pump is running when it is not and suppressing all the bearing temperature protection.

I wonder what if any cyber security requirements are imposed by their insurance companies.

rhodozelia··on What’s interesting about the Florida water system hack is that we heard about it
Private and public companies own power plants too.
rhodozelia··on What’s interesting about the Florida water system hack is that we heard about it
I work on about 30 different power plants for which I have written software in the control systems. I can access all of them remotely, no way i’m flying/Driving to middle of nowhere to make a change, and no way those customers are going to pay me for three days what otherwise takes a few hours.
rhodozelia··on Even before Covid-19, nightclubs were struggling
the cobalt in Vancouver BC had dirt floors until not that long ago
rhodozelia··on Show HN: Haven – Run a private website to share with only the people you choose
Facebook and Instagram are using your contact list for their purposes and running their algorithms on all your photos for their purposes.
← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →