HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

riazrizvi

3,289 karma · joined February 20, 2012

submissionscomments
riazrizvi··on China sentences official to death for taking $325M in bribes
Fascinating development in Chinese politics.
riazrizvi··on “Beyond the limit”: Satellites and mirrors in space pose threat to the night sky
Yes okay, good luck with that. The strategic importance to nations is far too high, it just means astronomy will evolve to a thing where it's done from space. But if you want to be the region where you support these ideas and undermine your own political support for national self-interest then that's your choice. Europe is overrun by these professional class types with nice ideas that are misprioritized. It's like a land of people that behave like pets lacking practical self-sufficiency.
riazrizvi··on Half-Baked Product
Fundamentally they are not sufficiently attached to the people's reason for using an oven. They are only attached to the goal of staying alive and making money. And when the balance shifts slightly more to the users need, the whole operation and reason for existing in every one in the company shifts in a way that makes it look like a rare and weird company that people generally don't have a frame of reference for. Most people wouldn't recognize such an entity if they saw it at this founding stage. It all starts with the right founder/s.
riazrizvi··on Factories are just rooms
There is an interesting interplay between mystery and motivation. Churches/theologians generally are good with this interplay.
riazrizvi··on Ford rehires 350 engineers after AI fails to preserve expertise or train juniors
When you first lose everything, in the process you end up having to pawn expensive principles like that, so when other things like this happen, it's easy to seize the opportunity.
riazrizvi··on Sixty percent of US consumers say 'AI' in brand messaging is a turnoff
One of the best ads of seen is for the Ava AI Sales Agent. I have to stare at it because of its location near one of my favorite spots. They've found a model with dead eyes that perfectly capture the existential dread you feel as you see a future with fewer humans in your life, and instead it's just more machines.

Not sure if that's their conscious intention, but somewhere along the creative process, some living soul was able to express itself in the final product.

riazrizvi··on SpaceX to buy Cursor for $60B
You're essentially making the case here that your work is now automated into a set of one-shot actions that can be performed by an AI model and your job has become to selectively apply these actions. That says either a) we don't do the same work, and instead you're doing some kind of low level devops function that I've only ever seen in rare cases where a human isn't needed anymore, or b) you've vastly oversimplified the software engineering you're doing.

Sophisticated chain of reasoning LLMs like ChatGPT have baked in some natural language operations and they make it so i can create at a higher level of the language expression stack. But I'm still formulating my own expression. There's no conceivable path I can see where an improved model is going to be able to do what I do. I think that is clear from my ChatGPT threads at least.

riazrizvi··on SpaceX to buy Cursor for $60B
That's not going away.
riazrizvi··on US and Iran announce deal to end military operations
It's adorable that you think Iceland somehow maintains itself without power. In the 1976 Cod War with the UK, where we the UK asserted dominion over 200 miles of their water with our superior navy, Iceland countered with its superior position to surveil Soviet movements in the GUIK gap, and it leveraged that with a powerful alliance within NATO members to get the UK to back down.

In WW2 Iceland's sovereignty was merely overridden. Britain took it over, because the Nazis had done the same in Denmark. We gave it back because the nature of our political, economic and diplomatic profile, compared to Nazism, made it advantageous for us to do so, all things considered.

riazrizvi··on Ask HN: Has anyone replaced Claude/GPT with a local model for daily coding?
All you get here is some market signal from 1 or 2 posts if you already know how to do it. Most of these responses are garbage.
riazrizvi··on US and Iran announce deal to end military operations
The reality that a contested position is determined by whoever can assert the claim, isn't a moral choice, it's simply an observable political fact.
riazrizvi··on US and Iran announce deal to end military operations
For the same reason all land ownership across the world and across the ages and across all animal species has been determined.
riazrizvi··on US and Iran announce deal to end military operations
After 400 years of Ottoman rule, we the Brits took that region because we won WWI. We gave some to different Arab groups, and some to the Israelis. The muslim religious head of Jerusalem wrote fan mail to Hitler advocating for the Final Solution. The hostility toward Jews had been whipped up for years and the general unwillingness of the neighboring regions to agree to the lines that the UK delegated to the UN is why after we left the region descended into war. The Israelis held on to their land. The Iranian mullahs came along in the 70s and jumped onto the cause because they feed on hate. My father was an advocate of the Iranian regime, because he was a vulnerable conflict survivor with deep psychological issues. But I saw what they were peddling 45 years ago and I heard what they were inculcating in him, through the mullahs that they trained and sent to the UK. They love to stress the idea of Abraham sacrificing his children. These are people that use children in war. They fire their rockets and shoot their guns where their own civilians will get hurt in the counterattack because they are just pawns to them. They sent young boys to the frontlines against the Iraqis and they use human shield tactics against the Israelis. It's a tragedy when innocents die, but against a foe that uses innocents in the propaganda war, only steely resolve and self-preservation will rid this world of the scourge that is these Iranian mullahs.
riazrizvi··on Shall we play a game? – LLMs use tactical nukes in 95% of simulations
It's not their domain, it's the domain of the Commander-In-Chief and his entire apparatus. The War Department are meant to be more focused around the tools they bring to the table.

The first line in the article describes a crisis between two powers. Not a theater of war.

riazrizvi··on Shall we play a game? – LLMs use tactical nukes in 95% of simulations
The beauty IMO of LLMs as a computational surface, is the ease of generating the data to feed it. Everyone understands how to create natural language records already.
riazrizvi··on Shall we play a game? My AI nuclear simulation
Simulations are only as good as the reality representations they are based on. If they keep using tactical nukes, they've been fed by weak data. Do the war games include the broader economic and politic environments that military successes are won on? WWI was settled by a naval blockade.
riazrizvi··on OpenCV 5 Is Here: The Biggest Leap in Years for Computer Vision
I guess i'm the only one blown away by this announcement and super excited to get back into image processing.
riazrizvi··on Stop the Apple Music app from launching
Yes. I've got no interest in leaving Spotify, I have the same loyalty to them as I do to Apple. Though of course anyone could screw it up. Then they lose me forever, like AT&T.
riazrizvi··on Stop the Apple Music app from launching
Probably a generational and professional divide. I switched to Apple after a decade of coding on Windows, in 2006 when they were known for introducing UNIX as a commercial platform that effectively killed planned obsolescence in consumer software platforms. I'm still on their system today enjoying the fruits of that pivot that Steve Jobs effected with the NeXT team.
riazrizvi··on Stop the Apple Music app from launching
It's very sad to see Apple using these lowbrow Microsoft tactics. Press ganging your users into launching your other shit product is brand cannibalism.
riazrizvi··on LLMs are eroding my software engineering career and I don't know what to do
Execution has just moved up the conceptual stack. We once wrote assembly, and then changed to higher order languages. Same is happening with lexical work generally.
riazrizvi··on Ask HN: What was your "oh shit" moment with GenAI?
Some ppl do dump trash on the street intentionally, out of laziness but also for some even their actual goal is to deteriorate a neighborhood. But you're pulling in a rare edge case to what by and large these GenAI blogs and Youtube videos are intended for. By and large ppl are trying make income. They are hoping their content will be well received and they will get repeat customers. They are trying to figure out how to use GenAI in a non-sloppy engaging way.
riazrizvi··on Ask HN: What was your "oh shit" moment with GenAI?
Spam and slop is to GenAI as pollution is to Industrialization. GenAI is beneficial generally but it comes at this cost.
riazrizvi··on Three Ways to Get Paid (2018)
Thanks. I keep doing 3. I needed this.
riazrizvi··on The dead economy theory
Yeesh. Math itself is a constructed input-output modeling system that provides functional benefits to the computational organisms that support it. Language is the same type of system, but with more individual slack. "Stochastic parrots" is just your human minimization device, that will either serve you or not. Reality is not embodied by language, we are not in the business of reality representation, we are in the business of functional representation systems, that work to differing degrees based on our goals. That's why we have multiple languages, multiple religions, multiple doctrines. It's silly to measure someone's belief in astrology against 'reality', we measure ppl's beliefs against their observable effectiveness and success. Ppl talk about reality but it's inconceivable. Any representation of reality is a subjective exercise in prioritization, listen to anyone describe it and they have to make choices about what to cover. That's not reality.
riazrizvi··on The dead economy theory
The ultimate outcome in life for humans is human relationships. Sure tech will continue to confuse and fascinate ppl with side shows that make them irrelevant, bc human relationships are hard. Ppl get frustrated, they give up for periods of time. But to say we can be not worthwhile. Imagine you're a Renaissance artist, you're part of generations of ppl who engaged in society by doing realistic portraits, then someone comes along and makes photographic chemistry. After cameras, realistic portraiture doesn't occupy the same space in the economy. It isn't the vehicle anymore to show and share the heights to which humanity can achieve which is what we are primary doing here. Sure when you're young, you can be fascinated with a fancy shower, or a nice car, or holiday, but that shit gets old fast, because it isn't interesting because it lacks the challenge surface on which we become more human. Gratification doesn't have that much runway. If it did, we'd all be sitting it fields staring at amazing flowers, and sunsets, and just being happy.
riazrizvi··on The dead economy theory
There are two problems in the line of thinking being criticized here that weren't touched on. 1) When machines automate a previously human endeavor, we recalibrate our concept of what is granted by nature, and that stuff becomes commoditized and less interesting, focus moves to where automation is lacking. So all the stuff the AI takes over will just become a far smaller part of the economy which will reorient itself into wherever humans remain. Humanity is the constant unit of the economy, not amounts of work as we conceive of them today. That was always shifting. 2) There is no path to AGI (autonomous creative work) from LLMs today. LLMs are the result of the transformers paper solving the computational problem of applying RNNS to language. That allowed the assimilation of language operations, intellectual operations, into a machine. It was done on civilization's entire body of work. The next step, getting all the proprietary knowledge that ppl have that gives them an edge, a way to make a living, into some data form, and then creating a new computational architecture to assimilate that. How is that going to happen. You've got these efforts in China and Meta to get ppl to train machines replacements for ppl, but that's like starting at the dawn of the printing press or writing and saying, let's write down what we know. Not only is it going to take a looong time, it's a process that is at odds with itself. No-one is rewarding these ppl enough to put themselves out of a livelihood. So it's going to take a long time, and it's going to be filled with garbage, think a million Galen Ersos baking in flaws to the Death Star.
riazrizvi··on We've made the world too complicated
Silly premise. Perhaps we haven't done a superb job of making the world more artificially simple while maintaining its select powerful and intriguing qualities that any particular beholder wants to focus on. With that I can agree there's a loooooong way to go. But the real world, real nature, is so complex it can make you puke when you try hard to conceive of it.
riazrizvi··on Halt and Catch Fire
This article subverted my expectations past the first couple of sentences. Nice read. The show is great too btw.
riazrizvi··on AI is making me dumb
Thanks. This was useful. I've been considering the whole approach today and maybe there's a narrower way to use Codex that I haven't tried yet.
← PreviousPage 3 of 32Next →