HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

richardfeynman

467 karma · joined September 16, 2011

submissionscomments
richardfeynman··on Israel used Palantir technologies in pager attack in Lebanon
Everything you say here is false. 1. Israel's stated goal is to neuter Hamas and return the hostages, not kill civilians. 2. Arabs speak a semitic language; the "semites" in "anti-semite" has always referred to Jews. 3. Jews, including white Ashkenazi European Jews, are levantine in origin. Their lineage traces to Judea. 4. "Antisemitic" means anti-Jew. You are using it to mean anti-Arab, but arabs are not semites 5. You did make all that up!
richardfeynman··on Israel used Palantir technologies in pager attack in Lebanon
I am simply pointing out OP's double standard: when it comes to Israel, everything is to be distrusted; when it comes to Israel's enemies, everything is to be believed. I am well-aware of the differences between Hamas and Hezbollah and have studied this conflict for well over two decades.
richardfeynman··on Israel used Palantir technologies in pager attack in Lebanon
Hi @dang. Here is a factual comment of mine that does not break the rules which, along with many other comments on one side of the Israel/Palestine issue, was unnecessarily and unjustifiably flagged: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45832233
richardfeynman··on We collected 10k hours of neuro-language data in our basement
Makes a ton of sense, thanks.

I wonder if there will be medical applications for this tech, for example identifying people with brain or neurological disorders based on how different their "neural imaging" looks from normal.

richardfeynman··on We collected 10k hours of neuro-language data in our basement
I noticed you tracked sessions per person, implying a subset of people have many hours of data collected on them. Are predictions for this subset better than the median?

For a given amount of data, is it better to have more people with less data per person or fewer people with more data per person?

richardfeynman··on We collected 10k hours of neuro-language data in our basement
This is an interesting dataset to collect, and I wonder whether there will be applications for it beyond what you're currently thinking.

A couple of questions: What's the relationship between the number of hours of neurodata you collect and the quality of your predictions? Does it help to get less data from more people, or more data from fewer people?

richardfeynman··on What it's like to watch AI fix a bug
;-)
richardfeynman··on Show HN: Supabase-Test – Fast Isolated Postgres DBs for Testing Supabase RLS
Great tutorials.
richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
"Both statements are beyond doubts. Could you be so kind as to point the disinformation I’m allegedly spreading?"

Sure StopDisinfo910. You're spreading the following disinformation:(1) that the IDF establishes control lines arbitrarily; (2) that these lines are always unpublished and invisible; (3) that the IDF purposefully shoots innocent palestinian civilians; (4) that the IDF has a bloodlust that leads it to want to kill even their own hostages.

1. The IDF does not establish what you call "no go zones" arbitrarily. You wrote: "We are talking of an army arbitrarily establishing no go zone in the middle of streets" The lines the IDF establishes, for example the yellow-line, are not arbitrary but rather the result of extensive negotiation and both tactical and strategic considerations.

"and then having snipers shoot down civilians crossing these imaginary lines" First, the lines are not "imaginary" - they're very real, which is why people get shot when crossing them. Second, can you prove that snipers shot down innocent civilians specifically? You say they are civilians - are you able to distinguish them from palestinian militants, who fight without uniform? Do you have a video that shows the IDF sniper shooting an innocent civilian with a time, date, geolocation data? If so, what were the names of the people who were shot? Third, in all wars crossing frontlines is going to be fatal, civilian or militant. Try walking around Pokrovsk right now, or in the DMZ. You'd get the same result. There's nothing different about crossing an IDF line.

". An army so blood thirsty they shot their own defenceless hostage who came in front of them with hands raised." Do you really thing bloodthirst is what caused the IDF to kill their own hostages? How do you square that with the fact that they're willing to risk so much to save and recover hostages? A more likely explanation is that the IDF mistakenly thought the escaped hostages were palestinian militants. They were in a warzone, military age men, and the IDF thought the escaped hostages were trying to lure them into an ambush -- the same type of ambush that killed many other IDF soldiers in booby trapped buildings. Friendly fire is a fact of war, it doesn't prove bloodlust.

Gaza is the most filmed war in history. If the IDF were massacring civilians en masse, as Hamas did on October 7, there would be many clear videos of these massacres, with both the IDF soldiers and the innocent civilians in view. There's none.

"Both statements are beyond doubts. " I have reasonable doubts about them, and the onus is on you to prove your quixotic explanations about "arbitrary lines" and the like. as you can see, so they are not.

richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
No. And stop pretending your delusions are real.
richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
Earlier cholantesh failed to accept the bedrocks of western jurisprudence. I would be happy to debate cholantesh if he first accepts: (1) the western concept of presumed innocence; (2) that while the video from Sde Teiman does show suspicious circumstances, the allegations must be tested in court; (3) the accused are innocent until proven guilty; (4) there is also certain potentially exculpatory evidence undermining the accusations (a hospital report that doesn't show rape; a grainy and edited video, where the alleged sex act cannot clearly be seen, among other things)

In the meantime, what I will say for other readers is that just as cholantesh ignores the foundations of western jurisprudence, cholantesh also ignores one of the foundational principles of the enlightenment, and the motto of the royal society: nullius in verba - take nobody's word for it. One doesn't make a case by appealing to authorities like the Church of England or agencies with three-letter acronyms, but thinks from first principles to generate good explanations. Various evidence-free circular theories, like "kids look starving due to prenatal nutritional deficiencies" sound incredibly stupid (really, 10 year olds? kids with cerebral palsy?), and classifying arguments as belonging to forbidden categories ("hasbara talking points") is a dollar store technique for throwing reason out the window.

richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
The videos are current, and there are hundreds more like them. Sorry to burst your bubble!

The ingredients (chocolate, vegetables, fresh meat) are let in by Israel, which has let in 1.8 million metric tons of aid during the war, more than any belligerent in history. Educate yourself.

richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
... and does not exist in Israel, which is a liberal democracy, not a theocracy, and not fundamentalist.
richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
His vision is fine. He didn't say Palestinian lives aren't worth saving (you misread him), and the genocide hoax has been debunked.
richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
tguvot gets it.
richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
haha I love this thread.
richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
I agree with you that if all he did was attack the Israeli court system, we could have a reasonable discussion. However, he was not dunking on Israel, he was dunking on the enlightenment and western values of jurisprudence, for example the right to a fair trial and the concept of presumed innocence. In any event, his comment was flagged and is now deleted, so apparently the mods agreed with me.
richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
There are active restaurants in Hamas-controlled areas. There are hundreds of videos (and recent google reviews) proving this. Here's one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DFjhyAsHYFo
richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
All the claims are true.

> Obesity is common There are countless videos of obese people in Gaza today.

> Restaurats everywhere. Google it! Not restaurants under rubble, but restaurants serving faties today. Here's a short list of open restaurants: - Manaqish restaurant - Ghazetna restaurant - Hotdog restaurant - Zaitouna cam restaurant - Chef Hamada - O2 restaurant

> No pictures of starving families. Yes, of course adult bodies are more resilient, but in real famines (unlike the one in Gaza) adults die too. And the kids that look starving had preexisting conditions.

>there have been only about 200 malnutrition related deaths in two years of war in gaza A googleable claim.

>no belligerent in the history of war has ever allowed in more aid to the opposing side than Israel. It's a factual matter, nobody debates it. You can't find a country that sent more aid to a belligerent on a per capita basis.

richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
"How could there possibly be "restaurants everywhere" after that?"

There are plenty of restaurants in Gaza, as a quick Google search will reveal, so this is a question for you to ask yourself. Perhaps your premise is wrong.

richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
There is no rape shown in the video.
richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
Just because you called my argument a strawman doesn't make it one. Since I see you're not willing to advocate for normal common law justice, I don't think we'll ever agree, and I'll put this argument to rest.

By the way, there is no serious debate about whether the video was altered. Any casual watcher an see it's spliced clips. The question is only whether it was altered maliciously, to paint a specific picture. That is what needs to be tested in court.

richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
I see you're linking to some debunked articles about the gaza starvation hoax.

Do you seriously think Israel had a policy of starvation? Obesity is common in gaza; there are restaurants everywhere; there aren't any pictures of starving families; all the pictures of starving kids have turned out to be of kids with serious pre-existing conditions; there have been only about 200 malnutrition related deaths in two years of war in gaza, orders of magnitude less than here in the US. And no belligerent in the history of war has ever allowed in more aid to the opposing side than Israel.

richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
He's advocating for a return to medieval methods of justice, and trying to cloak that advocacy with sarcasm. If that's not worth derision (the kind of derision where you simply point out what one is saying), what then is worth derision?
richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
The opinion piece you link to is false in two respects: first, Israel has never had a starvation policy in Gaza, and second, the courts never defended the policy because it never existed.
richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
I see you ignored this opportunity to confirm the accused is innocent until proven guilty and deserves a fair trial before people call them rapists. Too bad.

Of course I didn't walk back my claim that the video is doctored, and of course it's not unsupported. Here is one of many articles alleging the video is doctored and pointing to the specific person (Guy Peleg) who doctored it by splicing together different clips from different days: https://blogs.timesofisrael.com/sde-teiman-the-leak-that-sho...

This is just reporting, and it will need to be tested in court. But my claim is not unsupported.

richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
I made an argument that there should be a trial and argued explicitly against those who think thee shouldn't be a trial. Here's how you responded to my defense of common law and due process:

"Right, because over the course of the past 400 years, those institutions have always worked everywhere and no one's ever been at the margins of the justice system, been arrested arbitrarily or ignored by the police, had to languish in jail without a charge, been denied access to competent attorneys, a fair and speedy trial, or been subject to institutional biases and unwarranted imprisonment. Certainly that would never happens in a territory where it has happened routinely for 70+ years."

To me that sounds like you're saying that the standards of jurisprudence developed since the enlightenment are unnecessary because they sometimes fail, and that therefore a trial would be superfluous; it's fine to prejudge rape in this instance. This is at least my reading of your comment; I admit your comment is dripping with sarcasm so it's hard to tell what you actually meant.

I've also been consistent that the accused should be presumed innocent and has a right to due process. If you disavow your prior comment and agree with these common law principles then congratulations you've found a point of agreement with a zionist, and you disagree with the others in the thread who argue that a rape definitely occurred and the accused can be presumed guilty.

richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
My comment clearly advocates for common law standards: the right to a trial, the presumption of innocence, and so on. Am I understanding correctly that you think this advocacy--a staple of western thought--is bad faith? You prefer mob rule, no courts, medieval justice, and so on, and consider that good faith? What a topsy-turvy world we live in.
richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
The whole point of the judicial system is to navigate through contested allegations. A trial is what I'm advocating for. You're the one suggesting we should prejudge this, no trial needed.
richardfeynman··on Israels top military lawyer arrested after she admitted leaking video of abuse
You phrase your argument in a sarcastic way, because if you clearly stated what you mean your argument would appear ridiculous.

Take the sarcasm out of your position and this is essentially what you're saying: "Yes, I reject the past 400 years of progress in jurisprudence because it's not always perfect, and I would prefer for us to return to medieval times."

← PreviousPage 4 of 9Next →