815 karma · joined December 11, 2016
It was Percy Spencer - fourth employee at Raytheon (third employee was Vannevar Bush, for reference)
He came back a few days later and said that chatGPT knew what was in the book - was it okay if he just read the summary?
I wasn’t sure what to say. It’s probably true that chatGPT can summarize all the main points from the book. But it has always been easy to find the key points from books on line. The hard part of being a manager is figuring out how to take the obvious instructions and act on them consistently.
Maybe some people can do that just be reading the summary. For me though, reading the whole book is important. I find myself thinking back to the examples used to illustrate the points. And I find that repeating ideas in different ways as I read the book helps make them part of my mental framework. I read lots of interesting ideas in quick articles, but they rarely stick with me unless there is a specific translation to action.
I ended up telling my colleague that it was up to him to decide how to learn best. If it was me, I need the book. But he needs to know his own learning system.
Definitions of dissolve:
to cause to disperse or disappear
to separate into component parts
to become dissipated (see DISSIPATE sense 1) or decompose
BREAK UP, DISPERSE
Those seem like pretty accurate descriptions of what happened. Yes, dissolve can also mean something stronger, so perhaps it is fair to call the statement ambiguous. But it isn’t incorrect.
In the book, Postman analyzes how media affects humans and society. He basically gives a framework for predicting and understanding the effects of different types of media. The book was written before social media, so the examples are books, newspapers, tv, radio, etc. But so much of social media seems obvious once you read his analysis.
Every time I see the typical discussion (person A: social media makes people dumb; person B: Plato said books make people dumb) I think that the discussion could use some Postman - not all media affects us in the same way - some media encourages behaviors that are good for society, and some media encourages behaviors that are bad for society.
(2) it says that IT employers will be attending the carer fair.
(3) it also says that they plan to have more government employees for software engineers at the next career fair.
The article argues it makes it less expensive to reach any specific quality level (above some threshold).
The threshold isn’t really addressed in the article, but it is implied that for any realistic quality need, the write twice approach will be cheaper.
To conclude it makes everything twice as expensive, you have to ignore any cost except the initial write. That’s not realistic.
I think your point supports the general thesis that many technologies are developed before they are economically viable.
Some technologies are developed by the free market before they are economically viable too. LEO constellations for instance (both the original - iridium, and starlink).
My son is playing with other kids. I wander off. When I check back, all the kids are watching a screen. I say “what’s going on?” And some parent says “the kids were getting roudy, so I put on a show to calm them down”.
I guess the reason that isn’t true is differing time horizons. If the consequences of the deal only become apparent years later, then the PE firm can sell the business before the chickens come home to roost.
But how do they sell Red Lobster without the buyer realizing what is going to happen? Who would be dumb enough to buy from a company that has a history of crippling companies it owns then selling them to suckers?
Where is my Flying Car?
Zero to One
Paradise Lost
East of Eden
It is easy to tell if a tennis instructor is giving “good” instruction, where good means instructions that help you be a better tennis player. You just look at their students. If you want to know if they give good fundamentals for long term growth, you look at their much older students.
How do you know if a meditation teacher is giving good instructions? Seems much harder to me.
It is interesting that many of the traditional religions have hard to quantify benefits. Buddhism offers a personal inward help, and the abrahamic religions often benefit communities.
https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2024/02/my...
For AI, you wouldn’t be doing EC to make sure the AI was saying truth, you would be doing EC to ensure that the AI hasn’t drifted due to the 1% error rate.
Of course I have no idea how to actually do it - if it isn’t being done now, it is probably hard or impossible.