815 karma · joined December 11, 2016
https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/uploads/prod/2023/0...
It’s a well documented and easy to implement project.
> But… that gets everything backwards. The reason for this excessive caution around nuclear power was the lack of thoughtful and careful early deployments, leading to disasters like Three Mile Island and Chernobyl. It’s perfectly reasonable to suggest that the precautionary principle has gone too far, and overreacted to such a degree that we’re holding back useful nuclear deployments, but if we had been more careful and thoughtful in the early deployments of nuclear power, such that meltdowns were not something we had to deal with and the risk was effectively zero, then we’d see much more nuclear power around the globe.
Three mile island was about as good of an example as you will get of well designed carefully considered deployment of nuclear power. Yes, mistakes were made, and the core melted, but because the plant was generally well designed, no significant contamination of the environment occurred, and no danger was posed to the public.
We spend so much of our life determining what is useful in one sense of the word, and rarely stop to think about the usefulness of what we do in the philosophical sense.
Now we are getting somewhere.
I’m sure you would also accept that at some point it could become too late to start worrying about the risks if the danger has already gone exponential.
So how do you determine when is the right time to worry? If you have to error on worrying too early or two late, which way do you bias your decision?
The Tragedy of the Commons as a historical event in Medieval England has been criticized (hard to say debunked from this one article, but perhaps there are more).
The Tragedy of the Commons as an economical/social phenomena has not been debunked.
Since 99.9% of the uses of the phrase Tragedy of the Commons are referring to the second case, I'm not sure it is helpful to say that it has been debunked.
Just like the word car doesn’t mean anything. Last time someone threw out the buzzword car to me, it turned out they were actually talking about a 2008 four door Honda civic with four speed automatic in blue paint. I don’t know why they couldn’t have said that instead of trying to bs me by saying they were buckling their kid in the booster seat in their car.
I have questions though.
Is the davinci amazing? I have heard that it is.
Why doesn’t someone else make a similar product? Is there technology that is hard to replicate?
If DaVinci hadn’t developed the robot, would more people be able to afford health care?
The die binders that I used to use had physical motion reduction systems - are there more general versions of these available?
It seems like the classic music industry is in many ways like the VC model. Fund/invest in many startup bands, with the goal that one in a hundred get huge and return massive profits.
The end of the article talks about Bandcamp as an alternative, which is in some ways analogous to YC.
Is this an acknowledged similarity across industries? Are there other industries that have a similar model?
In areas such as the Great Plains of North America, where not a single wheat stalk grew 10,000 years ago, you can today walk for hundreds upon hundreds of kilometers without encountering any other plant. Worldwide, wheat covers about 2.25 million square kilometers of the globe’s surface, almost ten times the size of Britain. How did this grass turn from insignificant to ubiquitous?
Wheat did it by manipulating Homo sapiens to its advantage. This ape had been living a fairly comfortable life hunting and gathering until about 10,000 years ago, but then began to invest more and more effort in cultivating wheat. Within a couple of millennia, humans in many parts of the world were doing little from dawn to dusk other than taking care of wheat plants. It wasn’t easy.*
Can you tell the shape of a vase by looking at it?
Would you say “yes” or would you infer that the speaker was asking if you could distinguish all unique vases from one another by looking at them?
Was Urek, the first caveman able to generalize a physical theory of orbital motion when he looked up at the sky? It took humans millions of tries and hundreds of thousands of generations to come up with Kepler. Why does he give up on NNs so quickly?
The quick answer I am often given is, "Yes, of course hearing a drum's shape is possible. All that is needed is a sufficiently large dataset of sounds associated with drumhead shapes (for supervised learning) or indeed even without association to the shapes (for unsupervised learning) and use of an effective training algorithm and validation methodology. Once a model has been trained on the data, it will infer the shape of a drum from any recorded spectrum it is given."
This answer is wrong, and it is the reason Kac's famous question merits being revisited in the context of today's AI to solve complex problems. In the 1990s, mathematicians finally proved that it is, in fact, not possible to hear the shape of a drum, or at least not uniquely.9 This is because drumheads exist of different shapes that produce exactly the same sound, or in mathematical terms, are isospectral.”
That seems entirely unfair. The question is if you hear the shape of a drum. The actual answer is yes. But he says this answer is wrong, because you can’t uniquely hear the shape of the drum.
I’m trying to decide if this goalpost moving is a better metaphor for this full piece, or for much of the analysis of AI in general.