HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

richk449

815 karma · joined December 11, 2016

submissionscomments
richk449··on Oregon decriminalized hard drugs – early results aren’t encouraging
And if I want to know if I or my neighbor should be shamed for something, I just consult you, the oracle of shame?
richk449··on Huazhong University demonstrates LK-99 diamagnetism
Do you have a link to this? I’m interested to learn more.
richk449··on Why don't we get our drinking water by taking salt out seawater? (2008)
So salt combining with water takes energy, and separating it gives off energy. Yet combining happens spontaneously, and separation doesn’t. Because I don’t understand this, it seems like a paradox. What am I missing?
richk449··on 6 days to change 1 line of code (2015)
I’m sympathetic to the pain for the programmer, but I still have so many questions:

The months of backlog to build against was hard coded? Changing it requires rebuilding and redeploying the entire software stack that runs the factory? This must be some custom in-house MES? The testing requirements to redeploy that must be extensive right? If that is hard coded, who knows what else is. And if the software doesn’t work right, you end up buying or making the wrong parts?

richk449··on The shady world of Brave selling copyrighted data for AI training
Butlerian jihad is a good reference point. Something so bad happened that a large enough portion of the population was convinced to destroy thinking machines, and this no-computer norm was held in human society for a crazy long time (been too long for me to remember how long elapsed before Chapterhouse, which I think is the book where thinking machines start returning). It was a core belief of humanity that computers were bad, not a law imposed by a judge or legislature.

So say a US judge did impose severe restrictions on LLMs through US copyright law. The giant companies that are using LLMs will just move to another country. And just like tax law, others will be happy to have them. Would the US start blocking inbound internet traffic from countries that don’t have the same interpretation of copyright? That seems very unlikely.

The point is that the only way LLMs get the butlerian jihad treatment is if the people rise up against them. Right now, that is nowhere close to happening.

richk449··on The shady world of Brave selling copyrighted data for AI training
> A judge willing to commit the Butlerian Jihad[0] might even say that regurgitation does not matter and that all AI outputs are derivative works of the entire training set[1].

A judge can’t “commit” the butlierian jihad. A jihad is a mass event caused by some fraction of the population believing in some cause.

Which kinda gets to a point that seems to be missed. Copyright law is not “intrinsic” - nobody thinks that copyright is a natural law - it is just a pragmatic implementation which balances various public and private goods. If the world changes such that the law no longer does a good job of balancing the various goods, then either the law will get changed or people will ignore the law.

richk449··on Ask HN: How does the prospect of AGI affects your retirement planning?
Fun question.

What does it mean to be "less financially conservative"? Invest more in stocks than bonds? Or buy a fast car?

Maybe the right move is to invest in raw materials that are used for the components that go into computers? Finally a justification for being a goldbug?

Or maybe invest in companies trying to get humans off earth, in case AGI wipes out life here? Seems like a lousy financial investment, but that's the point in hedges, right?

Just buy Nvidia stock?

Invest in tin foil?

richk449··on Fractal Vise
Farnsworth fusor
richk449··on Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-air missiles
Sure, now imagine the backup system was discontinued twenty years ago and not tested since then.
richk449··on While US celebrates its independence, Hawaiians still wait for theirs
> “The problem is that it’s not a treaty; that’s an American law,” Sai said. “The United States could no more annex a foreign country by passing a law than it could pass the law today for the Congress to annex Canada. It has no effect beyond the borders of the United States.” I'm actually not sure? Prima facie, I think it would in fact be legal for Congress to conquer and annex Canada. A bad idea. But the constitution does not seem to prohibit it.

It would be legal within the US where the governing law is the constitution. It would not be legal outside if the US. Which is the point the original article was making.

richk449··on Neglected Wittgensteinian critique of the computer model of the mind
I think it is a reference to Hinton's comments about Wittgenstein in the New Statesman:

https://www.newstatesman.com/long-reads/2023/06/men-made-fut...

There are, he conceded, aspects of the world ChatGPT is describing that it does not understand. But he rejected LeCun’s belief that you have to “act on” the world physically in order to understand it, which current AI models cannot do. (“That’s awfully tough on astrophysicists. They can’t act on black holes.”) Hinton thinks such reasoning quickly leads you towards what he has described as a “pre-scientific concept”: consciousness, an idea he can do without. “Understanding isn’t some kind of magic internal essence. It’s an updating of what it knows.”

In that sense, he thinks ChatGPT understands just as humans do. It absorbs data and adjusts its impression of the world. But there is nothing else going on, in man or machine.

“I believe in [the philosopher Ludwig] Wittgenstein’s position, which is that there is no ‘inner theatre’.” If you are asked to imagine a picnic on a sunny day, Hinton suggested, you do not see the picnic in an inner theatre inside your head; it is something conjured by your perceptual system in response to a demand for data. “There is no mental stuff as opposed to physical stuff.” There are “only nerve fibres coming in”. All we do is react to sensory input.

The difference between us and current AIs, Hinton thinks, is the range of input.

Further discussion here: https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2023/06/wh...

richk449··on Russian paramilitary chief says his forces will turn around
At least part of the point is recognizing that this was a credible threat to Putin.

What would it take for the US president to leave Washington DC though? Obviously a real possibility of nuclear war. What else though?

richk449··on Debris found came from missing Titan sub, says friend of passengers
Why is it not a mass shooting if a gang is involved?
richk449··on Nearly 30% of people under 30 support gov't surveillance cameras in every home
> that's how tyranny works. if a large enough (like 15%) people are stupid enough to give up a basic right for a perceived safety, tyranny flourishes

Is that how tyranny works? Asking because I honestly don’t know. When the Americans rebelled against King James, was tyranny taking place because the majority of people were stupid and accepted safety by giving up some rights?

What about nazi germany? Did the German people support hitler because he provided them safety?

Or the original use of the word - did the Greeks accept tyrants as long as they provided safety?

richk449··on Workers rely on medieval era tech to reconstruct the Notre Dame
> If I hired a babysitter and on their watch, one of my kids caught on fire, yes, I'd insist on attributing that to the person whose one job it was to ensure their safety, and at least not hiring them again.

Interesting that the responsibility stops there. What about the person that hired the obviously incompetent babysitter? They don’t appear to have sufficient judgement to be responsible for kids.

richk449··on Ask HN: Do you think there will be social mobility after AGI?
You seem to have captured some truth. But isn’t it also true that the cushy life is possible because of the previous generations strivers? It was Glug that caught only the minimum amount of animal needed to survive that built the modern world, it was Sven that spent his spare time figuring out how to make tools.

Maybe life is cushy enough now that we can stop trying? But don’t you think that if we put I. Another hundred years of hard work, we will look back and think of the 2020 life as pretty brutal by comparison to 2120?

richk449··on Chief executives cannot shut up about AI
> No they don't seem vastly more powerful. They're stochastic parrots--there is no 'intelligence' or problem solving, logic, comprehension, etc.

This doesn’t feel like a coherent argument to me. The statement “There is no “intelligence” in LLMs” does not demonstrate that LLMs are not more powerful than previous chat bots. Same for every other loosely defined subjective word you claimed LLMs are not.

Leave aside the question of whether LLMs do comprehension or whether they are a path to AGI. Just ask if they are a more powerful tool than what came before.

richk449··on Chief executives cannot shut up about AI
> I don't buy it, it's a better chat bot

It feels like this is a category error that is causing you to miss the reason there is so much excitement.

It like saying “I don’t get it, the model T is just another car. We have had them before, and most of them are better than what Ford is selling”. The revolution wasn’t that model T cars were way better than what came before - it was that the way they were built enabled huge new markets.

LLMs seem vastly more powerful than the technology previous chat bots were built on. Plus, there is a whole ecosystem of generative techniques being applied to images, videos, sound, and others.

richk449··on America Has Too Much Pork
> Sampling evidence shows that Salmonella prevalence varies substantially across the pork industries. On average, 30.3 percent of comminuted pork samples were Salmonella-positive. For pork cuts samples, an average of 9.3 percent were Salmonella-positive.

Wow. I followed the link assuming you were grossly exaggerating, but it really is rampant.

richk449··on HBO Max new Captcha system
To a plasma physicist, 10 is within an order of magnitude, so as good as one could hope for.
richk449··on Why Frenemies May Be Hazardous to Your Health
> I don't think "I would have gone about the topic differently, but you’re doing fine" is a growth opportunity. It just has something of an ambiguously negative vibe without actually saying what it's about, while also kind of saying something superficially positive without making it easy to tell if it's genuine.

Totally fair point. If that was the entirety of the feedback then it isn’t helpful at all. I was assuming that it was the topic sentence and followed by specifics.

I wish I could see the actual study, rather than a two sentence interpretation of it.

richk449··on What deserves our attention?
The world is changing much faster than humans evolve.

The last ice age wiped out many large mammals in North America. The right mix of traits in warm weather wasn’t right when the cold weather hit.

So maybe social media winter is coming?

richk449··on Why Frenemies May Be Hazardous to Your Health
> In one experiment, people gave impromptu speeches on controversial topics in front of a friend who offered feedback. Unbeknown to the participants, the researchers had randomly assigned the friend to give ambivalent or negative comments. Receiving mixed feedback caused higher blood pressure than pure criticism. “I would have gone about the topic differently, but you’re doing fine” proved to be more distressing than “I totally disagree with everything you’ve said.”

I can’t read the actual study, but this description makes it seem like the ambivalent feedback case is the growth opportunity. “That was great” and “that was completely terrible” aren’t really actionable feedback, but “that was decent but I would change this” is helpful. Maybe helpful advice is more stressful because it is a chance to change and grow and those are stressful activities? So maybe if we want to push ourselves, we need more frenemies?

Put another way, should going through life with the minimal possible stress be the goal?

richk449··on ‘The Last of Us,’ fruit fly edition
In the same way that Russian roulette isn’t a black and white issue?
richk449··on Ask HN: Why do so many assume we’re on the cusp of super-intelligent AI?
> Even if an AI has the launch codes for ICBMs somewhere in its training data, it doesn't have an interface to the nearest missile silo to use them. It cannot commandeer the resources (hardware, space, cooling, electricity) it needs to operate, it is dependent on humans to supply those.

How do you know the AI doesn’t have an interface to the middle silo?

Are there no military systems that are connected to the internet?

Is the power grid connected to the internet? How about our water filtration system?

I’m not worried that gpt4 is going to start launching missiles, but I also don’t understand where the certainty comes from that it isn’t possible for an internet connected AI to launch missiles.

richk449··on Ask HN: Why do so many assume we’re on the cusp of super-intelligent AI?
It’s amazing how easily people are fooled into thinking something is intelligent. I met Stephen Hawking once and asked him how to slice video with ffmpeg. He didn’t have a clue! Obviously he isn’t an intelligent person. Yet so many people think he is smart.
richk449··on Intelligence and Consciousness: What's the Difference?
> We can start here: what is the difference between intelligence and consciousness? Let’s find out!

> Let’s explore the idea that there are three forms of consciousness: natural, artificial, and synthetic. We (humans) have natural consciousness. Artificial consciousness -- artificial general intelligence as it is commonly referred to -- seeks to imitate natural consciousness.

Seems like an exercise in question begging.

richk449··on Why do recipe writers lie about how long it takes to caramelize onions? (2012)
Recipes are terrible when it comes to time. I have this one open in a tab so I can try it soon:

https://www.seriouseats.com/lamb-biryani

The first step is the prep step, which it says takes 5 minutes. In that step, I have to:

- trim the fat from, and cube (1in) 2 pounds of lamb

- peel and chop 6 cloves of garlic

- peel and grate 2 inches of ginger

- mix with yogurt and salt in a zip lock bag

That looks like at least 20 minutes of work to me. Include cleanup (raw meat and garlic are both a pain), and it is easily a half hour of work.

Maybe 5 minutes is for an expert chef in a professional kitchen?

richk449··on Ask HN: What are your favorite sci-fi books?
Not just much closer - it seems inevitable that something close will be built in the next year. Khan academy, beast academy, and Wikipedia show that we are already close.

I don’t think people at red grappling with how much this will change society.

richk449··on San Francisco office values fall
Yes, in Sim City.
← PreviousPage 4 of 14Next →