HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rickycook

692 karma · joined June 16, 2014

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/rickycook; my proof: https://keybase.io/rickycook/sigs/V0nSHpU2l5arnKSd953WEYUlLTx5mZIo4uHIAlhJEA4 ]
submissionscomments
rickycook··on AirPods with Wireless Charging Case
i would wager that your argument is a rounding error compared to laptops, phones, and tvs... are airpods less environmentally friendly than regular headphones? sure, but let’s tackle things that actually matter before nitpicking. my airpods are devices that i’ve had longer than many of my other electronics purchases, and they’re certainly a quality of life improvement
rickycook··on Kidfluencers' Rampant YouTube Marketing Creates Minefield for Google
well, yes and no; what are parents going to do? sit with the kid and watch the whole thing after they (parent) picked out the content?

i agree the parent should pick out the content, but the whole auto play at the end of a video situation makes it difficult: is make a good wager that (like when i was a kid) “TV time” is when the parents get things like laundry done, so they have to come back right at the end of a video to pick a new one. if it couldn’t play without the parents consent, the kid would at least yell out.

it’s not about parents being lazy (or hell even if it is, parents need a break too) it’s about creating a user experience that caters to the highly stressful life of being a parent. that’s what youtube kids should be!

rickycook··on Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage
not entirely true... you can pair a new device which shares the decryption key. hell, you could even do a p2p sync so the server stores nothing... there are plenty of options that get technically harder with each increment (perfect forward secrecy gives you some limitations), but you can absolutely backup and restore, or even live sync conversations between multiple devices even if it’s e2e
rickycook··on Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage
but also you can remove your phone number after you sign up. unsure how that’s handled though, so could provide nothing extra if they still allow searching of it, or continue to store it?
rickycook··on Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage
it’s not quite that brazen, but from what i remember the whatsapp server can push a new public key for your contact/chat to the device, which means that they can MITM you. the chat shows that the key changed, but most users wouldn’t know what that means and ignore it
rickycook··on Spotify to Apple: Time to Play Fair
a laptop is not a tablet, a tablet is not a phone, a phone is not a watch; that’s part of apple’s philosophy behind how their devices work together. knock it all you want (and there are legitimate criticisms), but it works remarkably well and makes all these devices feel like they have a natural place and purpose

*EDIT: i’m not saying “place and purpose” is a reason why macos and ios have different security models, but just pointing out that “why is a laptop different to a phone” is not reeeeeeally a particularly valid place to start

rickycook··on Cookie Warning Shenanigans Have Got to Stop
“you’ve visited this site a few times recently. are you still okay with these settings? (if you ever change your mind, click privacy at the bottom of the page)”

just because we don’t currently have solutions doesn’t mean they aren’t out there. i guarantee my 5 second developer definitely not UX idea is the LEAST that a real UX professional will come up with, when pushed

*EDIT: and yes this kind of cookie is okay with GDPR because it’s not tracking a “data subject”... it’s maybe a broad timestamp (the day you first accessed the site), and a counter for the number of articles/site loads... you don’t have to ask for this permission, because you can’t track someone with it

rickycook··on Cookie Warning Shenanigans Have Got to Stop
duck duck go has ads and doesn’t track you... you don’t need cookies to show ads; only to show intrusive “track you across the internet” ads
rickycook··on Cookie Warning Shenanigans Have Got to Stop
well the GDPR does say many things about how the tracking consent can’t be the default right? so yeah it’s working if you just click through... of course if businesses are breaking the law, that’s different and enforcement will come

for reference there are at least 2 parts that make this outcome true:

“Consent must be freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous ... Any element of inappropriate pressure or influence which could affect the outcome of that choice renders the consent invalid”: a default choice if “i agree” is influence

“The withdrawal must be as easy as giving consent”: if you hit “i agree” in a box that automatically pops up to give consent, there must be a withdrawal mechanism that’s as easy as that to withdraw (and then they must delete your tracking data)

https://gdpr-info.eu/issues/consent/

rickycook··on Cookie Warning Shenanigans Have Got to Stop
we have definitely seen movement (plenty of data protection authorities have issued warnings), but it really hasn’t been that long (it’s been less than a year)

the only way that a law like the GDPR that’s purposefully vague and broad can work is to allow plenty of lead time for warnings and fixes before fines

it’s a process; you shouldn’t expect it to change everything overnight

rickycook··on Black Hole Propulsion as Technosignature
assuming that we got that right and didn’t just misunderstand what we are seeing (or assuming that there’s no “side channel” to know how to correct for it)

we also can’t get to a black hole, so for this civilisation it’s safe to assume they have a significantly better understanding of physics than us. we don’t know what we don’t know

rickycook··on HIV Is Reported Cured in a Second Patient
in australia at least these days, i’ve gone to arbitrary doctors for my 3mo tests and things and almost always they’ve offered to prescribe me PrEP... i’m already on it, but it seems here it’s being promoted by almost everyone!
rickycook··on K3s – Lightweight Kubernetes
pretty sure critical airline systems have redundancy
rickycook··on Microsoft CEO defends US military contract that employees say crosses a line
yup exactly: if it was for medics, there would be no problem
rickycook··on Microsoft CEO defends US military contract that employees say crosses a line
specifics: you can use an iron bar to kill someone, but that doesn’t make an iron bar a weapon.

putting a hololens on a soldier serves only a single purpose: to increase their “lethality” as the US military puts it

i’m certain that if the contract was for medics, there would be no issue

rickycook··on FastMail loses customers, faces calls to move over anti-encryption laws
well, australian voting systems aren’t exactly progressive (it’s just a few steps above the worst case), and neither is the voting populace

id say our government matches closer to our electorate than what the US government does, but we still have only 2 major parties which severely limits choice. there are ways to combat this (NZ, Germany for example)

this example is also a fairly poor one, because it’s possible this law came as a “test the waters” as part of 5 eyes, so it could be followed in other counties. where spying and secrets are concerned, we shouldn’t draw too many conclusions because we don’t know all the facts

rickycook··on Could 'Oumuamua be an icy fractal aggregate ejected from a protoplanetary disk?
everything is randomly bashing things together; every human is randomly bashing things together. we are similar, but have billions and billions of tiny differences that make up the specific things about us.

everything has selection pressures too: just like life forms exist and thrive in different environments, dust behaves differently at different temperatures and gravities.

life as an event, and specific things that happen thereafter are no less “random” than specific chunks of rock/dust in specific configurations

rickycook··on Opening the Filecoin Project Repos
see my reply to the parent; there’s a retrieval market too, which could help that issue
rickycook··on Opening the Filecoin Project Repos
from what i understand, you get a reward for serving the data, so you miss out on a good portion of bounty. you probably COULD attack the data like that, but it would cost you which might stop large scale attacks

*EDIT: and not just for serving it, but for serving it quickly.

from their site:

> Are you in the middle of a dense city? Do you have access to very fast Internet pipes? Have a rack in a carrier hotel? Perfect! In Filecoin's Retrieval Market, miners get rewarded for delivering content quickly. This makes the retrieval market good for miners who have low-latency, high-bandwidth connections to lots of users (but not necessarily the most disk space).

rickycook··on Office 365 global authentication outage
piracy is only an issue if it effects people paying for your product; if they were never going to pay anyway, why not give it away for free? keeping a digital product locked away out of spite is just... spiteful

especially when it comes to poor economies! the cost of a windows/office license is a good portion of (if not an entire) yearly salary in some countries! removing the tools that help them to compete with more affluent economies is pretty poor form

rickycook··on Office 365 global authentication outage
... there's a pretty damn good explanation given in the comment actually

and it's pretty obvious regardless: status pages are highly transient. it's probably good to have a record of what's being discussed?

rickycook··on DOOMBA
sure but it’s unlikely his site is going to be the target of anyone willing to spend the time to even tell the bot where the text to recognise is. it stops bulk; not target... but he’s unlikely to be a target so it serves its purpose
rickycook··on The Sharing Economy Was Dead on Arrival
tipping culture and minimum wage in the US is detrimental to restaurants; not the tourists buying the food!
rickycook··on Optician Sans – A free font based on the historical eye charts
and at least when it comes to contracts, ambiguity goes in favour of the party that didn’t write it afaik? so it’s a VERY permissible license if that holds
rickycook··on Compiz: Ubuntu Desktop's little known best friend
i wouldn’t necessarily call it a knock-off. i could be wrong, but looks like spaces first came to OSX in 2006, which is the same year that compiz launched

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spaces_(software)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compiz

rickycook··on Show HN: Dark Reader extension – Dark mode for every website
yes. to submit to firefox you’re required to provide them with the source code, but you may transpile it so long as they can verify that it’s the same AFAIK?
rickycook··on U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute
plenty of reasons. the difference between android and apple is pretty stark, and they both have merit but dont dismiss the arguments against the more closed ecosystem

the apple method allows a really easy UX for every single purchase and install on ios; if you allow a developer to decide that they’re only releasing on NewOpenAppStore, a user has to go ahead and somehow install that, which is a mess. apple don’t want that, because it just looks bad for the whole ecosystem

the security implications are obvious; if a user wants a pirated app, they will follow the “technical instructions” to click through menus and allow 3rd party installs so they can download their package from legitnotmalware.com

there are plenty more in the same kinda thinking, but overall they are different approaches but the walled garden should not be dismissed. you can argue that the down sides outweigh the upsides, but don’t just dismiss anyone that decides the upsides are worth it as “apple apologists” in an effort to condescend and shut down conversation

rickycook··on U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute
mentioned and expanded on in a parent comment, but the important part of the article related to that is right at the bottom:

“The San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals last year revived the lawsuit, deciding that Apple was a distributor that sold iPhone apps directly to consumers.”

the question is whether apple sells the apps, or the developer sells the apps.

rickycook··on U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute
the important part against that line of reasoning though is at the very bottom of the article:

“The San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals last year revived the lawsuit, deciding that Apple was a distributor that sold iPhone apps directly to consumers.”

if they decide that apple sells apps directly (after all, you go through apples distribution, payment, and “editorial” channels and have only a tenuous link to the developer i question) rather than the developers selling apps, then that could be an issue for them

rickycook··on U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute
i wouldn’t pin that all on anti competitive behaviour though... the end to end control of the platform is kind of Apples MO, and is a fairly distinguishing feature between the Android ecosystem and the Apple ecosystem. it’d be nice to have another distribution option, but not at the expense of a simple UX, security, or any other very valid reason to only allow a tightly controlled experience
← PreviousPage 3 of 11Next →