It doesn’t need to be said so much, obviously. I’ve counted what, 3 times so far in just this thread?
It doesn’t make you sound smarter.
72 karma · joined April 30, 2020
It doesn’t need to be said so much, obviously. I’ve counted what, 3 times so far in just this thread?
It doesn’t make you sound smarter.
In a project that’s been around since 2012.
I was really excited to experience the new wave in computing. I found smoke and mirrors. Cool idea though.
There are innumerable things I take for granted. Sure, I assume Ifixit isn’t a CIA front and their tear downs fairly accurately represent what ships to the customer. Barring hopeless threat models, the light is a decent trade off.
Beyond that, have you considered the actual average user? You either never worked tech support or forgot. It’s bad out there, it’s like people are moving backwards with computer skills because of phones.
How did you come to this statement? Because my initial reaction is not a flattering one for you, but hey, I’m learning too and I find this topic super interesting. Could you provide an example of a secure platform securing against threats in such an absolute way? Maybe QubesOS? I’d like to hear your reasoning a bit more.
Also, I want to touch on your statement of browsers not having walled gardens, and being secure in a general sense. Are you under the impression that modern browsers are equivalent to all other kinds of apps in regards to their threat profile? Also, are you aware that most modern browsers phone home URLs to check against a malicious site list? I look at this as “walled-garden lite”
Personally, I keep flip flopping between MacOS, Windows 10 with WSL2 + Fedora, and a 8GB RPI 4B, which for the last few days has been doing ok for a desktop.
My point? The security vs freedom debate is complicated, and for many, rages back and fourth even in the same person. There are very few absolutes in this world. Save your hills to die on for points you KNOW you’re right about, because in this, you’re waaaaaaay off base.
So let’s define our terms a little bit. What is our walled garden and what does it bring to the table in terms of security?
Off the top of my head I’m thinking we get more eyes during the review process, maybe some static/malware analysis, etc.. Another thing is the “soft controls”, not allowing certain classes of apps that Apple doesn’t feel “belong” in their garden. Well that’s a net security benefit too. Less apps, less possibility of exposure, more careful and selective choosing of apps allowed, you’re going to see less shady stuff and abuse.
Compare the two app stores, it’s not even close.
So the security benefits of a tight review/control process are pretty clear, and play out in the results of malware outbreaks between Google and Apples app stores.
The question of trading freedom for security is another topic, one that cuts deep into the fabric of western society. Too deep for this convo!