how so? deepseek and others do models on par with previous generation for a tiny fraction of a cost. Where is the moat?
1,091 karma · joined November 7, 2017
how so? deepseek and others do models on par with previous generation for a tiny fraction of a cost. Where is the moat?
Humans are biological machines. We know how to replace hearts with artificial ones that can last years. Soon they may start lasting decades.
We can replace many hormones with artificial ones.
I do not see any reason we can’t learn how to replace other organs and systems.
And in this case you may as well live 200+ years
If you want the agent to do things for you - there is literally zero reason to use a browser instead of an API.
Like 1 bulletproof API call vs clicking and scrolling and captcha and scam stores etc - how can this possibly be a good idea?
You may as well buy a shooter game starter pack or whatever that can save you >1year of coding, no llm needed.
Code is not a hard part.
Making mechanics fun and good assets is what is hard and takes forever.
Sure you can use llm to write a generic game, but its easier to find same game on github and just use that code, why would you write it again with llm.
Fixes one pain point good. Can’t really be applied to everything.
So just another tool, not a magic bullet like it is being marketed.
If you want me to put in the effort- you have to put it in first.
Especially considering in 99% of cases even the one who generated it didn’t fully read/understand it.
The only reason one may not want disclosure is if one can’t write anything by themselves, thus they will have to label all code as AI generated and everyone will see their real skill level.
It is absurd that anyone can mess up anything and have absolutely 0 consequences.
Maybe, but it has nothing to do with change itself.
Change can be either positive or negative. Often it is objectively negative and can stay that way for decades.
I usually go to option 2 - just write it by myself as it is same time-wise but keeps skills sharp.
>> I thought I would see a pretty drastic change in terms of Pull Requests, Commits and Line of Code merged in the last 6 weeks. I don’t think that holds water though
The chart basically shows same output with claude than before. Which kinda represents what I felt when using LLMs.
You "feel" more productive and you definitely feel "better" because you don't do the work now, you babysit the model and feel productive.
But at the end of the day the output is the same because all advantages of LLMs is nerfed by time you have to review all that, fix it, re-prompt it etc.
And because you offload the "hard" part - and don't flex that thinking muscle - your skills decline pretty fast.
Try using Claude or another LLM for a month and then try doing a tiny little app without it. Its not only the code part that will seem hard - but the general architecture/structuring too.
And in the end the whole code base slowly (but not that slowly) degrades and in longer term results net negative. At least with current LLMs.
Sure, but if I do 5 reviews for a task - in 99% of cases it is net negative as it is faster to DIY it at that point. Harder for sure, but faster.
It is very useful for simpler tasks like writing tests, converting code bases etc where the hard part is already done.
When it comes to actually doing something hard - it is not very useful at least in my experience.
And if you do something even a bit niche - it is mostly useless and its faster do dig into topic on your own that try to have Claude implement it.
It’s called a skill issue and to prevent these you have to actually spend time learning instead of vibing.
It’s literally the same as driving a car without license.
Everyone can do it - but shouldn’t.
Kinda crazy. In any other industry they would not even allow you in the door without showing some king of understanding what you do.
You can't even sell hotdogs without food license. But in software - wild west.
After that you may want to rethink suspending new entries.
Yep. This is literally what every AI company does nowadays.
This is not about syntax but about learning how to create solutions.
When you read solution you merely memorise existing ones. You don’t learn how to come up with your own.
So unless you have 15+ yoe better add more reps. You can always switch to llm code assist in a blink, there is no barrier to entry at all.
all these are just tools. there is nothing more to it. there is no etc.