2,379 karma · joined March 1, 2017
Perlin noise is cool, but why not try to fully simulate plate tectonics, weather patterns, drainage? It would go a long way if deserts were in the rainshadow of mountain ranges, islands corresponded to real volcanic activity, etc.
I guess there is a limit to what you can do with the chunk-by-chunk approach, but I think a certain type of minecraft player stays basically put within a couple dozen chunks. Having worlds "load" on exploration would be a worthwhile tradeoff.
I get that this is a hard, but it is interesting, and it's a problem that would captivate an intelligent developer. They have like a million dollars, why not?
An economy (any kind of economy!) is just a feedback control system.
Generally, when you're choosing a feedback controller, you have two options: PID, where you have a set of 3 "dumb" rules, and all you have to do is tune the gains on those dumb rules. Or MPC, where you need to actually build a model of the system you are controlling, and then you can optimally plan to control it the future.
In general, MPC is quite good, much better than PID, if you have a great model of your system. It fails when the model is bad, or when you can't determine your state with accuracy.
PID can be very good -- for systems with very fast dynamics and response times, it is better than MPC, because you don't spend a lot of time in the feedback loop evaluating the model, and you don't need to worry about modeling at all ("model-free")
I think of an economy (very broadly) the same way. The mythical "free market" that everyone talks about is like a PID controller over the whole economy. It's a simple rule, supply and demand, and you can keep prices under control quite well with just a PID controller. But PID can fail spectacularly, too, and cause instability.
In general, you know when instability is happening when you look at a graph of your state variables and it looks like an exponential with a positive coefficient [1]. I'm sure you can see where I'm going with this: every single chart we can draw about our economy right now looks like an exponential. Energy, probably the most base measurement, looks like an exponential. This is bad [2] and everyone knows it, which I think is the source of a lot of the modern ennui.
Our old MPC models failed spectacularly, because we didn't have a good way of modeling the whole economy, we only had very granular and incomplete information about the markets, and we didn't have a way of actually solving the optimization problem. The obvious missing link here is the computer.
I agree wholeheartedly with the author, and I think it's really valuable to bring up that we already have central planning going on in the form of the corporation. There are thousands of people whose work is completely decoupled from profit and who engage in long term planning at a scale larger than the market they operate in.
What he describes is like a cascade controller, where the inner loops occur in the linear supply/demand region and the outer loops are a smarter model-informed controller. Rather than pretend like the outer loops are just like the inner loops (a pie-in-the-sky libertarian view) or pretend like the inner loops are just like the outer loops (the anti-capitalist view) we should be thinking about the strengths and weaknesses of both. Right now we're very good at the inner loop but we're basically randomly flailing about with the outer loop.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exponential_function
[2] https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2011/07/galactic-scale-energy/
I also watched that video, it's just so depressing. The amount of externalized costs we incur is simply staggering.
When I see someone throw something away, or when I throw something away myself, I just think: "Everything you've ever thrown away is somewhere."
And you can look for yourself: our crime rates are comparable to, in many cases worse than, any other place that superficially resembles ours.
The way your comment is written makes it seem like you are sympathetic to this idea.
There is no "out of society." They're still here, we still have to deal with them. Not only with them, but also with the machine that we built to coerce them into living the way they live. In exactly the same way you have to deal with me, and I have to deal with you, and we both need to deal with seeing a vending machine vandalized. The question is, how do we deal with that?
Although if push comes to shove I guess all of this can be solved trivially by not growing ridiculous water intensive crops and not having golf courses and stuff in the middle of the desert.
But an institution must be larger than a single person. Because if you want something to last longer than about 40 years (which is about the maximum amount of time a superhero can be super) you have to have succession.
It's also notable that those "greats" had in common a vision larger than themselves. Selflessness and an annihilation of ego, in service of a larger project, seems to be a requirement for getting yourself to that superhero status in the first place.
If you’re operating a factory, you want housing, healthcare, etc to be cheap, so that you don’t have to pay your workers as much. If you’re a tiny group of people coming up with new ways to financialize housing, healthcare, etc. you want exactly the opposite.
I think of this division as something like “Industrial” vs “Financial” capital. Part of the reason the old labor movement isn’t relevant any more is that we don’t actually make stuff any more. “Industrial” capital is not at the seat of power any more.
The real problem with today’s unions is that the counterparty has changed. The people who are making houses expensive aren’t at the table negotiating with the unions; they have no employees! Unions are fighting the shrinking ghost of “Industrial” capital.
The reason for this shift is geographic. The stuff that actually gets made is made (under a yoke of hellish cruelty) at the periphery. There, housing is cheap! But the profits flow back here unevenly, to a tiny group of holders. And hence we are dominated by financial capital.
This is also the origin of the red/blue divide, roughly speaking: One is the local “Industrial” concentration and one is global “Financial” concentration. The third bloc, labor, were only really relevant when labor actually had a relationship (with the leverage inherent to that) with the dominant form capital. Now the two groups have predictably been crushed: the local concentration of capital and the union. They’re both sitting at the wrong table.
An infinite number of mathematicians walk into a bar. The first one orders a pint. The second one orders half a pint. When the third orders a quarter of a pint, the bartender rolls his eyes, places two beers on the bar, and says "you all need to learn your limits!"
I do feel that I can judge people for that, because other people work like dogs to cook their meals for them at below poverty wages. I'm judging, and I'm also raising the point that the current state of affairs is the absurd one. Not a possible future state of affairs where restaurants are again a luxury and people have to cook meals at home.
There are people who dine out 3, 4, 5 times a week, who don't really know how to cook anything beyond microwaved meals... that's completely insane!
And I think that's kind of what all of this hysteria is about. Because yeah, if the price of a burrito went up by $2-3, those people would have to learn how to cook some basic meals for themselves.
Not so long ago, dining out -- having another human being cook & bring you your food -- was a luxury, reserved for special events. This is something completely different.
If you don't intend to pay debt when you acquire it, that is fraud. But your equivalence ignores the counterparty: a worker is not loaning out their time to a company contingent on a loan agreement, they are making value as soon as the work is made, a fraction of which they own at that point. The terms are legally very different; one is a credit agreement and the other is a wage, because the counterparties are different.
In an ideal world, the wage agreement is far stricter than the credit agreement -- hence, it is called "theft" when it is violated. Unfortunately, as stated in the article, we do not live in an ideal world.
I think you may be failing at the task!
Let's assume for a second that there is a dollar amount to "underwriting global free trade" (spurious to begin with). What actually is that dollar amount? Is it 3x more than what we're spending? 10x less? How could we ever know?
As it turns out, whatever we are currently spending, that's the amount required. We could double the number of aircraft carriers, nuclear submarines, jet fighters, missiles, spy satellites, military bases; we could start another war, another engagement, another "peacekeeping mission," do another few "surgical strikes"... And yep, that would be exactly what's required for freedom.
"Tired of your awful insurance. Like ugh, us too! Insurance can be like, so heckin lame sometimes. Let me let you know about [INSURANCE BRAND] ... "
That stuff is absolutely psychotic and is an instant red flag. Just say "Buy this insurance, it's cheap and has features x y z w" and be done with it. I'm not your bff.
This is kind of an aside, but I feel like fast food companies have really taken over this area. Wendy's posting on twitter like "feelin heckin smol right now. normalize self care." NO! Give me McDonalds -- they show a huge picture of the burger with big text that says "Eat This Burger Now" or whatever. That's all I want from you people!
/rant
It cannot be both.
Unfortunately, the engine driving this thing (the whole country) is real estate as an investment.
So if you're traveling at the speed of causality, everything you "hit" or go past happens instantly, because you're traveling "with" causality/information itself.
Obviously, you only have time to basically summarize points made on the listing and in the reviews for the product for it to be worthwhile.
This was pre GPT-2, though.
Which... it already has. Coal plants have been spooled up just to mine btc. The idea that we should continue or expand crypto mining is ludicrous, because it already has harmed the environment, even at its small market cap.
You cannot improve your lifestyle to prevent Type 1. However, it is epidemic across the entire western/developed world -- incidence doubles every ~6-7 years.
Bear in mind: when you mis-dose insulin, your blood turns into acid.
No endocrinologist would ever recommend treatment with older insulins over the new stuff. The only way it happens is because of cost.
Totally non-scientific, but my dog seems to be "happy" when something that she thinks is one way is actually the other. Like when I am totally silent, not looking at her, and then all of the sudden make a noise at her or look at her. She loves it.
I think that's the essence of humor, it's when your brain experiences something it didn't expect in a low-stakes way.
I'd be happier if they announced that recycling was fake and everything you throw in the blue bin is trash.
We could do that, I think, in about 20 years, if we really wanted to just get rid of this 1.5degC rise. But we can't, we have the ocean acidification, the desertification, the pollution, the acid rain, the plastic pollution. My point is that it's not really the temperature I'm worried about, it's the everything else.