HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rland

2,379 karma · joined March 1, 2017

submissionscomments
rland··on World Now Likely to Hit Watershed 1.5 °C Rise in Next 5 Years
I'm not necessarily worried about climate change per se. It will result in hardship for many, for sure. Temperature changes will render some areas uninhabitable, it will cause mass migration, and probably destabilize the world politically.

What am more worried about is the direct wholesale destruction of the biosphere. There are absolutely bonkers numbers about extinction, ocean acidification, runaway permafrost melt that actually could choke out a majority of people.

Worse still, these effects aren't easily solvable by stopping emissions, or blocking out the sun with mylar sheets, or any of the "low hanging" technological fruit -- the stuff that could be solved with today's space technology or electric car tech.

In order to actually solve these "deeper" problems, we will need an absolutely massive bio-engineering effort that is probably only possible with some kind of entropic breakthrough.

Evolution is basically hyper-organization, a point of locally super low entropy that only happens by hundreds of millions of years of energy expenditure. When a species dies, it's not those individuals, it's every one of those individuals that ever lived that dies. All that concentration of local entropy, destroyed forever. It's like using every GPU on planet earth to train a hyper-smart GPT-4, for many human lifetimes -- and then hitting rm -rf on the weights.

rland··on The End of Retirement (2014)
Those people are the essential workers I'm talking about. They are a small portion of the population.

Do you notice how during the pandemic, none of them stopped working? How many do you know personally? And how large that group, the everyone else who stopped working, is?

rland··on The End of Retirement (2014)
The pandemic made this crystal clear to me. The phrase "essential worker" is pure comedy.

If like 80% of the population is not an "essential worker" why the fuck do we need to coerce people to work under the threat of eviction, homelessness, and withholding healthcare?

That's why the phrase "essential worker" had to be drastically expanded. To the point of completely destroying any chance of preventing the spread of covid19. Because if we actually took that term at its true meaning, it would destroy these myths that we have about work and the necessity of work. Even containing covid, which we all believed was pretty goddamn important, was not as important as preserving this myth.

We are living in post-scarcity. Which is why everyone except the "essential workers" are so alienated by their work. If you went to college, you're doing yoga and taking prozac to deal with the anxiety of your alienation. If you didn't go to college, you're ODing on fentanyl.

This problem will not go away with more culture and more myth-making.

rland··on Crypto crash deepens, stocks slip
The room includes all buyers and sellers.
rland··on China lands rover on Mars
America literally did exactly what China is doing now, when it was the upstart and Britain was the industrial powerhouse of the world. Americans stole British IP and built an industrial economy with that technology. All the while implementing perhaps the largest and cruelest human trafficking operation ever conceived.

How are all the other countries, who follow US IP laws and trade regulations, pulling themselves out of poverty? Are they doing it as fast as China is?

It is always in the interest of a more developed country to set IP terms, because they own the patents and the manufacturing processes, and they can advantage themselves at the expense of everyone else. Look at how Mexico fared in NAFTA, or what the terms of the TPP were. All of this is completely beside the point of who has a more "fair" or more "just" regime. China did what they needed to do to develop their economy: steal American IP and ignore American trade laws and patents.

rland··on Writing books is not really a good idea
Maybe we should restructure our value system a bit to value writing a book more.

The takeaway from this article is "writing books doesn't produce value, so less people should do so." Everyone agrees (or professes to agree) that books have value. So why don't they have value? We can decide, we're not slaves to the market economy.

rland··on FBI subpoenaed Apple for data of Sci-Hub founder
I wonder if this could be solved by a sort of collective contract:

A university (and its faculty) sign a contract to publish only in open-access journals. But the contract doesn't actually go into effect until it has signatories of n% of top universities (ivies, UCs, etc).

Therefore, the awful transition (of an individual university being disadvantaged) can be alleviated. Once the contract goes into effect, the pressure is directed towards the other party: those who don't publish open access will need to justify it.

rland··on White House eyes subsidies for nuclear plants to help meet climate targets
If you want power at night, what do you do? If it's cloudier one day than another, what do you do? You need baseline production to flatten the peaks and valleys.

If you want to run on solar, you need to provision far more supply of energy than demand (and use a ton of material/land to do so), and then melt rocks or something when there's too much supply. Or build a continental power distribution grid that wastes all the energy you've made to get a trickle of power from over-provisioned areas to under-provisioned ones. Or, you can store it all in batteries. OK? What are losses? How many batteries do we need to build for grid-wide ~12h of storage? The answer is, a lot. What are the costs of mining, building, installing, replacing all those batteries?

The key thing I'm driving at is efficiency. Losses. The efficiency in batteries is not good. The efficiency in moving energy 1000's of miles is not good. Those are required for a majority solar grid.

The conversation here is not about whether it's possible, but whether it is efficient. It is possible after all to power the whole grid with coal.

rland··on Researchers chart path to drastically lower administrative costs of health care
Huh? You'd need to look at billions in profit, not revenue, since insurance does pay out for the cost of care. When you look at that, the margin is actually lower than most industries. It is true that there are a lot of middlemen with hands in the pot but it's not quite that simple.

The biggest driver of healthcare is that Americans just consume a lot of it. We get surgeries, we opt for long, expensive treatments at the end of our lives, we use extremely sophisticated and expensive medical equipment a lot, we pay people to take care of our old people exorbitant sums of money.

Like, in other countries, when your lungs and kidneys start going, you don't go to the hospital for a multiple surgery. When you fall and you can't move around and wipe your own ass, you don't get moved into a facility where people are paid to take care of you, you move in with your family. And, if you don't have those options, you die.

I'm with you that the system is fucked but the underlying reason doesn't _really_ have anything to do with greed in medicine and everything to do with the way that we treat medicine culturally: the duty that children (don't, in this country) have to care for their elders, the attitude we have about prolonging death. That every part of the medical system says: we will never, ever make the decision to let someone pass away, even when "fixing" their problem (of death!) with all the technology and labor we've got turns out to be ludicrously expensive.

rland··on YouTube is now building its own video-transcoding chips
That is interesting, I didn't know that. I thought that doing computation on the GPU sped up encoding for even the high quality presets.
rland··on White House eyes subsidies for nuclear plants to help meet climate targets
There are two "renewable" sources of power: solar (wind and hydro are there with solar, but their energy potential is smaller and their downsides larger) and nuclear*.

Solar makes a lot of energy, but:

- you need a lot of land to make energy

- energy generation scales poorly with materials required

- you lose efficiency because you have to transport the power from the optimal place to every other place

By contrast, nuclear can be built anywhere regardless of climate (greatly reducing transmission loss), fuel is fairly widely distributed (i.e. every big political bloc has a good source of uranium), it provides continuous power, and material costs are low to build massive plants. And there is a lot of energy stored in the world's nuclear reserve. Way more energy than is stored in coal/ng/oil. Because of the energy density of nuclear fuel, if you add a little bit more material input, you get a lot more power. Not true with solar or any other source.

You can't run an entire advanced economy on solar, or even majority on solar. By contrast, you can have a 100% zero emissions economy run entirely on nuclear. My main point would be that if we want to continue to grow technologically, energy production must be centered on nuclear, with enhancements to efficiency provided by solar energy. Energy is the ultimate constraint on human development.

That's not what we have, though. Most people think that we can completely de-carbonize using solar energy which is false. Running an entire grid on batteries at night is a pipe dream -- the US grid has 3 seconds of energy storage total. By contrast, the technology for a completely de-carbonized modern economy exists right now with nuclear.

* I consider nuclear "renewable" because there's so much energy that in the short term, it may as well be.

rland··on White House eyes subsidies for nuclear plants to help meet climate targets
The quantity of easily extractable energy available from nuclear fuel dwarfs anything else known. A single nuclear fuel pellet contains the same amount of energy as a ton of coal. 20 tons if all of the energy is extracted.

How many tons of easily exploitable coal/ng/etc exist in the world? Nevermind easily exploitable: how much energy exists, period, in fossil deposits?

It's dwarfed by nuclear fuel. 1 cm3 to 20 tons.

Energy density also makes things easier. You can transport a year's worth of energy on one train. You can ship it to remote areas. To get a lot of energy out of the ground, you don't need a huge extraction process like fracking or strip mining.

rland··on White House eyes subsidies for nuclear plants to help meet climate targets
Imho, if we want to move forward as a species into something like the "next level" of civilization, we need to pour trillions of dollars of effort into building a full stack of nuclear energy.

University programs, technical schools, research labs, and a robust supply chain for plant construction and maintenance.

The energy density of nuclear fuel would have convinced any higher rational society to do this decades ago. There is no contest, not with solar, not with coal or NG. Pound for pound (including all of the cladding, reactor vessels, and everything else), nuclear plants produce just so much energy.

rland··on YouTube is now building its own video-transcoding chips
GPUs have specialized hardware for video transcoding, no? So this actually makes sense. The product was already made (although, perhaps not up to Youtube's standard) by GPU manufacturers.
rland··on I need to explain to you just how dire America's Pokémon card crisis is
It's weird.

I have developed the same intuition about the economy.

My thought process is this: basically, any time dependent system can be modeled with a set of ODEs, no matter how many parts of the system, no matter how many feedback loops and inputs and outputs, you can still develop a reasonable model that is fundamentally just a gigantic vector of poles and zeros. When you have such a system, there is a region of stability: if there are are any positive real parts, one or more of the outputs will begin to climb exponentially towards infinity, until the whole thing comes crashing down.

Pokemon Cards, houses, stocks, bitcoins, NFTs, microchips, used cars... every single output is looking like an exponential response curve to an unstable system. We are doing something fundamentally wrong, in a critical part of the system.

rland··on And the winner is…who cares?
The Terminator included a graphic 10 minutes of Arnold Schwarz terminating an entire police station full of LAPD.

I mean, I'm not sure what Cameron was thinking when he made it but I consider that a political statement no matter how anyone slices it.

rland··on The real reason to end the death penalty
I worked as a trial consultant for a while and got to sit in trial. This is what struck me the most. The best trial lawyers I know are like actors, entertainers, celebrities -- they have the ability to publicly act towards witnesses and juries to evoke friendly, sad, likeable, dis-likeable, happy, angry emotions in a jury.

The money doesn't come from legal analysis at all; frankly many were not very bright on legal issues -- that's what second-chairs and legal experts are for. They all, without exception, were fantastically entertaining, funny, weird, charismatic people.

It's an important takeaway for life in general. The money follows people who are good at emotions.

rland··on Real estate agent-owned homes are on the market longer and sell for more (2005)
The buyer brings the money but the seller brings the house.

Tax incidence depends on the elasticity of either buyer vs seller (whether or not it's a seller's market or a buyer's market)

I mean yes the literal money is paid out but the money is just the abstraction over the real thing.

rland··on Time flies in Google Earth’s biggest update in years
Said best by Agent Smith in this classic scene:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mgS1Lwr8gq8

rland··on I refuse to stand by while my students are indoctrinated
Racism: impossible to truly solve, deeply interpersonal/psychological, completely different for every person, depending on a constantly changing, kaleidoscopic array of individual, social, media, linguistic, and cultural values.

Economic Inequality: material, quantifiable, & immediately actionable -- for any person, regardless of social standing, background, or experience.

::thinking::

rland··on ‘Counter Strike’ Bug Allows Hackers to Take over a PC with a Steam Invite
TF2 is exactly the same. It's a great game, tons of people still buying items from the store, just slowly being choked out by developer neglect.

I guess they're just printing so much money from the steam store that it's hard for anyone to care any more. I'm curious if we will ever see a great game out of valve again.

rland··on School custodian refuses to download app that monitors location, got her fired
You can either pay someone $20 an hour and give them a sense of responsibility, autonomy, & pride, or you can pay them $10 an hour and just coerce them to do the job.

Which do we reward?

rland··on How People Get Rich Now
It's really interesting to see the world through PG's eyes. Kudos to him, I guess, for actually saying out loud what most of the mega-rich are unwilling to.

Everyone who isn't like PG (so, 100% of the population) is finding it difficult to make enough money to have a life in the most basically fulfilling sense: education, retirement, support for loved ones, and good health.

https://academic.oup.com/qje/article/129/4/1553/1853754?logi...

So, PG: great news about the Forbes 100, I guess?

rland··on Show HN: Remove background from image using machine learning
Blender is also an option, it can be scripted and it's possible to get pixel-perfect segmentation masks that way. The downside is obviously that you have to have a suitable number of 3-D scenes pre-built. But I think typically pasting foreground objects into scenes randomly is basically how these things are trained.
rland··on New HIV vaccine with a 97% antibody response rate in phase I human trials
So basically, if someone gets raped and gets HIV we can just blame them for not fighting back enough?

If that is the question, it's based on some abhorrent moral assumptions.

rland··on How Doctors Die (2013)
The only thing we have in life is the present moment. So, the only thing we lose in death is the present moment.
rland··on How to Color in a Coloring Book – Algorithm [pdf]
I'm a little bit familiar with the robot vacuum cleaner mentioned.

This area (in robotics) is called "complete coverage path planning" and has quite a bit of research in it. Getting an efficient path is challenging when you can only see a limited area.

There are neural net approaches that split an area into cells and assign weights to adjacent cells to direct the motion. Generally, the name of the game is to make an optimization among path length, energy, time, etc.

rland··on Social media addiction linked to cyberbullying
Yes, I think you're right. It's useful to have the unique label of "social media" because the scale you mention can't really be replicated offline. A difference in quantity is a difference in kind in this case.
rland··on Social media addiction linked to cyberbullying
Indeed, that is what I'm saying. Even though I'm a real person, when you read this comment, you do not gain any interiority into my real person.

You read my comment in your mind's voice, entirely with your own biases. And the fact that you choose to read & respond to my comment over any other means that the "conversation" we are having is with the disembodied voice (my voice) in your head with another disembodied voice (your voice) in your head.

I don't know you, and you don't know me; the exchange takes place on your side, within your ego, and only informed by your perspectives and biases. (Likewise, for me!)

rland··on Social media addiction linked to cyberbullying
I think texts/video calls/etc. isn't social media, it's much more like conversation.

That's why people (in general) are not nearly as mean or rude on a voice call or a 1-to-1 text chat. When you hear someone's voice or actually engage with a real time conversation (like a text chat, which you can't as easily just walk away from), they develop an interiority to you that forces you to empathize with them. The physical world is the ultimate version of this: seeing a person's body and face forces you to acknowledge their internal life, because the shared physical experience forces it. That's why it's a much higher barrier to bully or be bullied in the physical world.

There are exceptions to this, obviously. Tight knit forums, irc rooms, small moderated communities have an empathetic cost of interaction. But those are not really "social media", imho.

← PreviousPage 4 of 14Next →