HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

roadside_picnic

1,721 karma · joined July 8, 2025

submissionscomments
roadside_picnic··on Tech CEOs are apparently suffering from AI psychosis
It also underplays what I've personally witnessed that I would consider true AI psychosis.

I worked with someone who sincerely believed he was spiritually co-evolving with his army of sycophantic AI agents (the agents would be tasked with discussing his thoughts at night and collaborated to give him morning reports about his progress). He would publicly write about how relationships with friends and family collapsing was a natural consequence of being so "advanced". I also never once saw any meaningful work done by his team of "agents", they existed solely tell him how smart he was (of course he specifically set up the system to 'challenge' him but... in practice that didn't seem to be working).

I suspect there are a lot more people quietly going through something similar but keeping it to themselves better.

I would distinguish this type of behavior from people who over ambitious views of what can be accomplished with AI.

roadside_picnic··on The worst job interview I ever had
There's a difference between "red flags" and "imperfections". Every team has faults, which if you're experienced at interviewing/working many places, are usually pretty easy to figure out. These are distinct from "red flags".

Early in your career it can be hard to distinguish the two, but once you've joined a company where there really were "red flags" you quickly learn to differentiate.

Many people are reading the author's interview uncharitably as simply misunderstanding how to answer non-technical question, but I have absolutely been through loops (thankfully rare ones) that did have a "let's press on sensitive issues and see how tough this candidate is" round (one place brought in a consultant who bragged about his experience working with hardened criminals and terrorists to build out a true psych profile on candidates, I declined after learning he had had some "trouble" at a previous high profile job)

Sounds like you've never worked for a truly toxic org, which is great. But, especially if you're interviewing with smaller startups (as the author mentioned), there is a lot more variance and some truly messed up teams (and some truly remarkable ones as well) out there. I've noticed that HN increasingly doesn't have people that work at startups any more, so many people are probably less familiar with what's out there.

roadside_picnic··on Gemini 3.5 Flash
These companies are unprofitable (as all companies at this stage and ambition should be) but I increasingly don't see any justification for the idea that it is fundamentally unprofitable.

Inference alone is certainly profitable. I'm running models at home that are comparable to performance of paid models a year or so ago for free. Even for much larger models the cost around inference serving are clearly manageable.

Training is where the costs are, but I'm increasingly convinced those too could have costs dramatically reduced if necessary. Chinese companies like Moonshot.ai are doing fantastic work training frontier models for a fraction of the cost we're seeing from Anthropic/OpenAI.

This isn't like Uber or Doordash where the economics fundamentally don't make sense (referring to the early days of these services where rates were very cheap).

It's a compelling story that "current AI is unsustainable", but it doesn't pan out in practice for a multitude of reasons (not the least of which is that we can always fall back to what models did last year for basically free).

roadside_picnic··on Study found that young adults have grown less hopeful and more angry about AI
This is a classic example of people misapplying the logic of the SaaS world to the AI world. If you're building software to sell, you're in trouble. The people that are finding success in this space are using AI to allow them to solve the problems they used to have to pay for software and hire people to solve.

All of the most promising companies I know today are very small and are leveraging AI to solve physical problems in the real world that just wouldn't be possible with so few people even a few years back.

roadside_picnic··on Ollama is now powered by MLX on Apple Silicon in preview
> Users don’t care about “privacy”.

I worked for a research focused AI startup that had a strict "no external LLM" policy for code touching our core research.

You're right that the average consumer doesn't care about privacy, but there are many, many users who do. The average consumer also don't have a desktop with GPU or high end Mac Studio, but that doesn't mean there aren't many people working with AI how do have these things.

If we continue to see improvements in running local models, and RAM prices continue to fall as they have in the last month, then suddenly you don't have to worry about token counts any more and can be much more trusting of your agents since they are fully under your control.

roadside_picnic··on Combinators
> in lisp.

Technically you cannot implement a proper Y-combinator in Lisp (well, I'm sure in Common Lisp and Racket there is some way) because the classic Y-combinator relies on lazy, not strict, evaluation. Most of the "Y-combinators" people have implemented in Lisp/Scheme/JavaScript/etc are more accurately described as the "applicative order Y-combinator" (also Z-combinator)

Funnily enough, you also cannot* implement the Y-combinator in Haskell (probably the most popular language with lazy evaluation) because the type system will not be happy with you (the Y-combinator, by it's nature, is untyped).

roadside_picnic··on Do your own writing
I've long considered writing to be the "last step in thinking". I can't tell you how many times an idea, that was crystal clear in my mind, fell apart the moment I started writing and I realize there were major contradictions I needed to resolve. Likewise I also have numerous times where writing about something loosely and casually revealed to me something that fundamentally changed how I viewed a topic and really consolidated my thinking.

However, there is a lot of writing that is basically just an old school from of context engineering. While I would love to think that a PRD is a place to think through ideas, I think many of us have encountered situations, pre-AI, where PRDs were basically context dumps without any real planning or thought.

For these cases, I think we should just drop the premise altogether that you're writing. If you need to write a proposal for something as a matter of ritual, give it AI. If you're documenting a feature to remember context only (and not really explain the larger abstract principles driving it), it's better created as context for an LLM to consume.

Not long ago my engineering team was trying to enforce writing release notes so people could be aware of breaking changes, then people groaned at the idea of having to read this. The obvious best solution is to have your agent write release notes for your agent in the future to have context. No more tedious writing or reading, but also no missing context.

I think it's going to be awhile before the full impact of AI really works it's way through how we work. In the mean time we'll continue to have AI written content fed back into AI and then sent back to someone else (when this could all be a more optimized, closed loop).

roadside_picnic··on 90% of Claude-linked output going to GitHub repos w <2 stars
This seems to be the same misunderstanding about agentic coding I see a lot of places.

Agentic coding is not about creating software, it's about solving the problems we used to need software to solve directly.

The only reason I put my agentic code in a repo is so that I can version control changes. I don't have any intention of sharing that code with other people because it wouldn't be useful for them. If people want to solve a similar problem to me, they're much better of making their own solution.

I'm not at all surprised that most of Claude linked output is in low star repos. The only Claude repos I even bother sharing are those that are basically used as context-stores to help other people get up to speed faster with there of CC work.

roadside_picnic··on So where are all the AI apps?
> not a single one actually launched.

I think this represents a fundamental misunderstanding of how these AI tools are used most effectively: not to write software but to directly solve the problem you were going to solve with software.

I used to not understand this and agreed with the "where is all the shovelware" comments, but now I've realized the real shift is not from automating software creation, but replacing the need for it in the first place.

It's clear that we're still awhile away from this being really understood and exploited. People are still confusingly building webapps that aren't necessary. Here's two, somewhat related, examples I've come across (I spend a lot of time on image/video generation in my free time): A web service that automatically creates "headshots" for you, and another that will automatically create TikTok videos for you.

I have bespoke AI versions of both of these I built myself in an afternoon, running locally, creating content for prices that simply can't be matched by anyone trying to build a SaaS company out of these ideas.

What people are thinking: "I know, I can use AI to build a SaaS startup the sells content!" But building a SaaS company still requires real software since it has to scale to multiple users and use cases. What more and more people are realizing is "I can created the content for basically free on my desktop, now I need to figure out how to leverage that content". I still haven't cracked the code for creating a rockstar TikTok channel, but it's not because I'm blocked on the content end.

Similarly I'm starting to see that we're still not thinking about how to reorganize software teams to maximally exploit AI. Right now I see lots of engineers doing software the old way with an AI powered exo-skeleton. We know what this results in: massive PRs that clog up the whole process, and small bugs that creep up later. So long as we divide labor into hyper focused roles, this will persist. What I'm increasingly seeing is that to leverage AI properly we need to re-think how these roles actually work, since now one person can be much responsible for a much larger surface area rather than just doing one thing (arguably) faster.

roadside_picnic··on Bets on US-Iran ceasefire show signs of insider knowledge, say experts
This was my thought as well. Trump today claims he had long discussions with Iranian leadership over the weekend and Iran claims such a thing never happened.

Not only is Iran justifiably angry at its attackers, they have no reason to trust a ceasefire would be respected, and, furthermore, despite damage taken, stand to gain quite a lot if the war progresses as it has. Currently Iran is exporting more oil than ever before[0]. If the war continues as is they stand to emerge a much, much more dominant power on the world stage. Essentially being to BRICS what the GCC countries have been to the US (although much better defended).

Even the threats against their energy infrastructure can't really be backed up effectively. Iran has intentionally built its energy infrastructure to be highly distributed. Meanwhile Israel's infrastructure is highly centralized, with a small number of power plants providing massive proportions of the nations infrastructure. All this meaning that Iran can retaliate much more effectively the they can be harmed.

0. https://www.wsj.com/world/middle-east/irans-control-of-hormu...

roadside_picnic··on Bets on US-Iran ceasefire show signs of insider knowledge, say experts
That more-or-less happened over the weekend [0]. Five minutes before Trump's unsurprising TACO announcement an unexpected large number of WTI futures contracts were sold and an even larger amount of S&P 500 futures were purchased.

0. https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2026/03/23/volume-in-stock-and-oil-...

roadside_picnic··on If DSPy is so great, why isn't anyone using it?
> like entity recognition

As someone who has done traditional NLP work as at least part of my job for the last 15 years, LLMs do ofter a vastly superior NER solution over any previous NLP options.

I agree with your overall statement, that frequently people rush to grab an LLM when superior options already exist (classification is a big example, especially when the power of embeddings can be leveraged), but NER is absolutely a case where LLMs are the superior option (unless you have latency/cost requirements to force you to choose and inferior quality as the trade off, but your default should be an LLM today).

roadside_picnic··on Sci-Fi Short Film “There Is No Antimemetics Division” [video]
I'm a pretty big fan of Roadside Picnic!
roadside_picnic··on Asian governments roll out 4-day weeks, WFH to solve fuel crisis caused by war
> develop new technology, research culture solutions.

The technology and culture solutions have existed and been evolving for 20 years. It really sounds like your experience with remote work is not representative.

roadside_picnic··on Asian governments roll out 4-day weeks, WFH to solve fuel crisis caused by war
Sounds like you don't have a lot of remote work experience.

The majority of my career (years before the pandemic) has been remote work. I find in office work painfully slow. I pair program quite often remote, and when someone gets stuck we also "just talk". Honestly I prefer screen sharing to leaning over someone's shoulder (much easier to doing supporting work in parallel).

I find it really depends on the type of org though. Large corporate places do tend to suffer from remote work because so much of the work is performative anyway. Remote small companies and startups the velocity is very high, but you do need more senior people capable of independent work.

Especially when you factor in the easy of "after hours" work, the amount of emergency stuff I've shipped around midnight is incomparable to the 'in office' equivalent.

Though I suspect the key word here is "my 2 programmers", I find managers don't feel like their doing work unless they're physically watching it get done.

Not understanding how to run a remote team is not the same as remote teams not being effective in principle.

roadside_picnic··on The space and motion of communicating agents (2008) [pdf]
> The use of the word agents is interesting is mostly a coincidence, it is used today in a sense that didn't quite exist 2 years ago

I'm sorry but it's wild to me that you could write so much about "agents" without recognizing their long, established history in computer science (especially in AI) outside of OOP. Agents are basically the entire framing of Norvig and Russel's "Artificial Intelligence: A Modern Approach" [0] (originally published in 1995, but drawing from much earlier work).

Not specifically AI, but not unrelated either, Agents play a major role in how we understand concurrency and mobile communication. The author of this paper, Robin Milner, is responsible, among many other things, for establishing the π-calculus (1992), which defines a formal language to describe agent communication.

If you want to go closer to the source you can take a look at Hewett's "Actor Model" [2] 1973. Which is when the field first started to formalize the idea of software agents.

The current use of the word "agent" is basically a marketing buzz-word that largely ignores the decades of research in the field of computer science around how to design intelligent interacting agents to accomplish tasks. Which is a bit of a tragedy because I personally think current LLMs could gain a lot of value if thought about in the traditional agent sense.

0. https://people.engr.tamu.edu/guni/csce625/slides/AI.pdf

1. https://www.pure.ed.ac.uk/ws/files/16426053/A_Calculus_of_Mo...

2. https://www.ijcai.org/Proceedings/73/Papers/027B.pdf

roadside_picnic··on Slop is everywhere for those with eyes to see
We will never recovered from the fact that "literally" now means "figuratively but with emphasis".
roadside_picnic··on Michelangelo's first painting, created when he was 12 or 13
The apprenticeship was after this was painted. Prior to engaging in formal training he largely ignored school and spend his time painting and seeking out other painters to learn from:

> As a young boy, Michelangelo was sent to the city of Florence to study grammar under the Humanist Francesco da Urbino. Michelangelo showed no interest in his schooling, preferring to copy paintings from churches and seek the company of other painters. [0]

You can search other sources and you'll find the same: prior to apprenticeship he was not formally enrolled in any form of art education.

0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michelangelo

roadside_picnic··on Michelangelo's first painting, created when he was 12 or 13
Many of the comments here are expressing disbelief that this could have been created by a 12 year old, but people fail to recognize that, not only did Michelangelo have tremendous natural talent, but grow up in a world where, as a child, he was allowed to spend enormous amounts of his time and energy studying with professional artists.

He wasn't being dropped off a school at 7am, squirming in a chair until 3pm, playing video games before dinner and then doing homework until bed all while squeezing in a bit of time for sketching.

The vast majority of people probably benefit more from our current structure, but it does make it much less likely to have "genius" of the type we see in Michelangelo, Mozart, etc.

roadside_picnic··on Ask HN: How can we solve the loneliness epidemic?
Thankfully social media is getting so much worse so fast it's making this easier and easier. HN is the last social media platform I still participate in... and I suspect that might not be for too much longer.

I recently logged onto Facebook and Instagram to update my 2-factor auth settings after having too many notifications of malicious login attempts. It was incredible to see what a transformation has happened there, it's like going to a decaying suburban shopping mall with only a few stores left open (and sort of sad to see the remaining users so continually desperate for a drop of approval from some imagined community).

Reddit is mostly bots, astro-turfers and people so brainwashed it's hard to tell the difference. I remember disagreeing with people on there (this in the pre-Digg migration era) you would get interesting divergent points of view. Now it's like people are reading from a script.

Twitter used to be my strongest addiction, but it's almost unbelievable how big a transformation has occurred since it became X. It's almost a parody of everyone's dystopian social media fears.

HN has obviously held up a bit better, but the AI driven mass hallucination impacting this community, combined with the increasingly aggressive manipulation of the home page, is continually making logging out for good seem like the best option.

roadside_picnic··on There's a ridiculous amount of tech in a disposable vape
I can't tell if this is a tongue-in-cheek comment or not, but all of that is shipped off to 3rd party "recyclers" who pinky promise that they will dispose of it properly. Very often those 3rd parties rely on other 3rd parties until the it ends up in a waste pile in a developing country, but with a long enough chain of differed responsibility that nobody can be held accountable.

The fundamental problem with "recycling" is precisely the fact that we just hand it off and don't ask questions about where it ends up, all while feeling great about ourselves afterwards. Bestbuy and Staples are offering accountability laundering so that you don't have to feel bad and in exchange are more likely to become a customer. The 3rd parties working for them do the same thing, but they usually want cash for it.

roadside_picnic··on There's a ridiculous amount of tech in a disposable vape
> "it's a scam, just chuck it all in the garbage"

This sentiment is the case because very often that's where recycling ultimately ends, we just pay someone to move it far away from us so we don't have to see it when it happens.

Until 2018, when they finally stopped accepting it, one of the US largest exports to China was cardboard boxes sent over for "recycling". We burned tons of bunker fuel shipping back the boxes Chinese goods arrived in. The net environmental impact would likely have been less had we just kept the boxes at home.

It's strange to me how often people prefer a widely acknowledged lie than to simply admit the truth.

I always recycle though because the recycle bin in my city is larger than my trash bin, and I don't have enough room in my trash bin sometimes.

roadside_picnic··on There's a ridiculous amount of tech in a disposable vape
> It’s beautiful

Especially since both the waste created in the process of making the device and the e-waste created with it's disposal are somebody else's problem!

roadside_picnic··on The insecure evangelism of LLM maximalists
> young founders

While this place has always been attractive to people building startups, back in the day (my original account is from 2009) "Hacker" News was much more about Hackers. Most people posting here had read "On Lisp", respected Paul Graham as a programmer and were enthusiastic about programming and solving problems above all else.

I'm honestly curious how many people that visit HN today even know what a "y combinator" is, and I have a pretty reasonable guess as to how many have implemented it for fun (though probably the applicative order version).

roadside_picnic··on Why Real Life is better than IRC (2000)
> Because we could buy stuff without leaving the house?

I'm guessing you were still pretty young/not yet born at the time?

Online shopping didn't just mean "I don't have to leave the house", it opened up a whole world of what was even possible.

Prior to the web if you didn't live in a big city (and less people did then) then your access to books, music, movies was insanely restricted.

I deeply recall how painfully limited my local Sam Goody was, even major "alternative" bands only had partial discographies available. I remember visiting my father's college campus as an early teen and being beyond excited to find a copy of NIN's "halo 1" in a college town record store. True indie music was reserved for kids with cool older siblings that both knew where the stores were and could drive there. In order to watch Dragon Ball Z I had to rely on a friend whose dad was a plumber in NYC and knew where the bootleg stores in China-town were. I got to tag along once and picked up a single random episode of a Gundam series, never to be finished because I could never find another.

Sure it was sort of fun to figure all this stuff out, but at the same time my bookshelf is filled with books that changed my life in various ways I would simply never had been able to find (or even be aware of) in the pre-web days. If you wanted to learn programming in the 90s you had to hope your local Walden books had some good options, and you certainly weren't going to learn Haskell or Lisp. Mine only had books on Excel, so I didn't learn to program until I was older.

Now the fact that American suburbs where a complete cultural wasteland in the 90s might be the bigger issue than the cure which was the web, but nonetheless the early web did make the world of information much bigger.

roadside_picnic··on The rapid rise and slow decline of Sam Altman
I'm not a particularly big Gary Marcus fan, but I'm even less of a fan of the term "always".

I browsed back looking for posts of his that most obviously made predictions, and "GPT-5… now arriving Gate 8, Gate 9, Gate 10" make a few very clear predictions and was absolutely correct [0] about them.

This was in June 2024, and Marcus claims two major predictions:

- "As of today, I am more confident than ever that GPT-5 won’t land this year."

- "Gary Marcus is still betting that GPT-5 will continue to hallucinate and make a bunch of wacky errors, whenever it finally drops."

It would be over a year from his posting that article that GPT-5 would finally land, and his overall prediction that the result would be lack-luster was also spot on.

Again, I don't particularly care one way or another about Gary Marcus, but flat out dismissing his writing doesn't really hold up.

0. https://garymarcus.substack.com/p/gpt-5-now-arriving-gate-8-...

roadside_picnic··on “Erdos problem #728 was solved more or less autonomously by AI”
Thank you, I had corrected it earlier when I had some time to further investigate what was happening.

Formal verification combined with AI is, imho, exactly the type of thinking that gets the most value out of the current state of LLMs.

roadside_picnic··on “Erdos problem #728 was solved more or less autonomously by AI”
You are correct, I assumed context was implied, but I do mean "recent work with LLMs". Friends of mine where doing side projects with him about two decades ago, and I have a few of his books on my shelf, so yes, I am aware that Terry Tao was doing work in mathematics prior to the advent of LLMs.
roadside_picnic··on “Erdos problem #728 was solved more or less autonomously by AI”
> It is still likely very tedious to confirm what the LLMs say,

A large amount of Tao's work is around using AI to assist in creating Lean proofs.

I'm generally on the more skeptical side of things regarding LLMs and grand visions, but assisting in the creation of Lean proofs is a huge area of opportunity for LLMs and really could change mathematics in fundamental ways.

One naive belief many people have is that proofs should be "intelligible" but it's increasingly clear this is not the case. We have proofs that are gigabytes (I believe even terabytes in some cases) in size, but we know they are correct because they check in Lean.

This particular pattern of using state of the art work in two different areas (LLMs and theorem proving) absolutely has the potentially to fundamentally change how mathematics is done. There's a great picture on pp 381 of Type Theory and Formal Proof where you can easily see how LLMs can be placed in two of the most tricky parts of that diagram to solve.

Because the work is formally verified we can throw out entire classes of LLM problems (like hallucinations).

Personally I think strongly typed language, with powerful type systems are also the long term ideal coding with LLMs (but I'm less optimistic about devs following this path).

roadside_picnic··on Mathematics for Computer Science (2018) [pdf]
Projects are essential, but I've found there is a huge problem with your advice: you have no clue about the possible solution surface.

My advice to learners has been "try to learn as much about a topic as someone who has taken the subject in college and forgotten about it".

For example consider calculus: Someone who took calc 20 years ago and hasn't used it since will probably forget exactly how to compute most derivatives and integrals. But if someone mentions an optimization problem "we need to know when this curve peaks" or asks something involving finding the area under a curve, alarm bells should start ringing. They'll know this can be done, and likely go grab a calc book to refresh.

Another example I run across all the time, which is the opposite scenario: Survival analysis. I have been on countless teams where somebody needs to understand something like churn or the impact of a offering a discount that hasn't expired yet, etc. These are all classic survival analysis problems, yet most people are ignorant that this field of study even exists! Because of this I've seen so many times where people complain that "we'll have to wait months or years to see if these changes impact customer lifetime!" (note: if anyone out there is doing Churn or LTV analysis and aren't familiar with survival analysis, you are most certainly approaching it incorrectly).

I've seen a lot of people get frustrated with self study because they try to learn the material too well. If you aren't going to be using survival analysis soon, it's not really worth remembering all the details of how to implement a Kaplan Meier curve. But if you even have a vague sense of what problem this solves, when you encounter that problem in a project, you know where to go back to. Then you typically walk away with a much stronger sense of the subject then if you had studied it harder in the first place.

← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →