HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

roenxi

30,626 karma · joined August 8, 2016

submissionscomments
roenxi··on How to Exist
FWIW a good trick is to be aware of your thoughts, watch the tension/stress/realisation/anger/effort arising, the sort-of ignore them because they're thoughts and look for the way your mind tenses moving between them, then do the opposite of that tensing or let the tensing move you to a feeling of (say) extreme love or connection because if you're going to feel something that is more pleasant than stress. These things come and go, as you illustrate. Once you don't lean into them they tend to just go away.

None of those things are doing meditation wrong, they're just things minds do. The mistake is in focusing on them instead of focusing on the process generating the changes.

roenxi··on Danube's record low levels force shutdown of Hungary's only nuclear plant
Because HN was a forum for oil executives to gather and discuss prices? Big fossil isn't in the room here. It would surprise nobody if there were 0 people in the comments who even work in a fossil fuel company.
roenxi··on Danube's record low levels force shutdown of Hungary's only nuclear plant
> One of these options makes it much easier for the billionaire class to continue extracting money out of the people.

I almost hesitate to ask, do you think that is the centralised or decentralised option?

And, more directly, that is a bad theory. The billionaires will make money either way. It doesn't make a lot of difference to them as a class. They'll have an inclination to the cheaper form of energy because more energy -> more economy -> more money for them.

roenxi··on Danube's record low levels force shutdown of Hungary's only nuclear plant
You're probably going to struggle to come up with a motive for that behaviour. It is much more likely that they simply aren't very thoughtful. Complex webs of deception in a public argument are certainly possible, but it generally relies on some group having a clear financial incentive to misdirect. That doesn't exist in the nuclear debate.
roenxi··on The Glass Famine
> It's that it is possible to resuscitate dormant or shrinking sectors. It is possible to re-industrialise quickly.

China managed to go from peasantry in the grip of communism to arguably the biggest economy in history over a remarkably short period. And it is hard to get a read on exactly what is going on in that country but that seems to be despite heavy state intervention in the economy and without the benefits of political free speech. I'd also rate their rule of law as a bit rubbery. It is clear that industrialisation can happen like lightening if best-of-breed policies are adopted.

Which is to say, policies in the West since the end of the cold war have been an absolute disaster and we are well due some political remove-the-spec-from-your-own-eye reflection on our industrial strategy. And, frankly, the endless reign of military terror that the middle east is subjected to doesn't seem to help. Keeping the military at home has been a massive win for China, all of that money went into investments instead of pointless murder.

It is enough to make you wonder if it is the politicians or the voters who are more evil and incompetent.

roenxi··on Concurrency, interactivity, mutability, choose two
I don't think the author took a position on synchronisation at all. He said you have to pick one to abandon of mutability/concurrency/interactivity and that abandoning mutability is horribly slow (because of the need to copy things). And that isn't technically accurate because you can abandon mutability and not copy things. If you have a 1MB int->int associative data structure and need to change one entry, then you can reuse most of the MB (it isn't going to change) and get away with writing a couple of integers.

And that could be substantially faster than a mutable approach when you need to make a genuine copy of the 1MB structure with a small change and keep both, because you can't structure share and you will need to copy the whole MB. Obviously situation specific, and I'm sure there are edge cases where immutable lookup tables fall apart. I haven't met one myself.

I don't disagree with the article exactly, I do think abandoning mutability is necessary. I just don't think his argument that it needs to be slow is good. If you abandon mutability, "copying" data logically is extremely fast because you can skip almost all the IO for large objects. And copying a large object with a small change should be much faster in an immutable language because of structure sharing. Depending on the workload, that might be faster.

roenxi··on Concurrency, interactivity, mutability, choose two
> But again, there is no free lunch: copying data is slow. Very slow. Of course you can optimize data representations, avoid copying binary blobs (they are ref-counted in Erlang) because it would be untenable. But it will still be horribly slow.

You don't have to copy the data; it is immutable. Why copy something that isn't going to change? Are we being charged for empty RAM? Different objects can share the same structure. Famously, this is what Clojure does. Theoretically it can be faster than mutating objects because you only have to write the parts that are changing (which is the same as a mutable object), you lose something to overheads (might be nearly negligible) and have enormous gains in situations where you might need a copy of an object for some reason because that is free; there isn't any reason to actually do a copy unless the data itself is going to be mutated.

roenxi··on Mondragon Corporation – a federation of co-operatives
It remains confusing that, after centuries of profiting off capital generally being a much better strategic choice than profiting off labour, workers insist and persist in trying to make labour work.

If the unions had dumped their efforts into co-ops instead of trying to fight their own companies then they might have managed to have a positive impact. They've been at it for long enough for capital accumulation to have kicked in even at pathetic rates of saving.

roenxi··on I'm 38 and I Can't Support Myself Anymore
"Your worth" is a bit of a vague and meaningless term (everyone is worth infinite in some sense). But if we want to talk about your general ability to secure more comfortable living conditions then your worth is very much linked to your productivity. The average living conditions are largely determined by how productive the average person is. There are some hard-to-escape balance equations at play there.

Good vibes are nice and all, but affirming each other isn't going to actually make the world more comfortable. Looking after disabled people requires an enormous productive surplus from the rest of us and a recognition that the people creating the enormous surplus are in practice worth quite a bit more than the people who are on the receiving end of charity. Playing pretend on this topic is just going to lead to people being worse off.

roenxi··on If digital computers are conscious, they are conscious at the hardware level
Time for a thought experiment! Imagine there are 2 monkeys. One monkey genuinely believes it is a unique and special being. The other monkey is genuinely egoless, believes all monkeys are just a coincidental blob of matter with no fundamental claim to being special and that in some sense are all part of the same being. There is enough food for 1 monkey. If that is all the information we're getting, I would contend that the egotistical monkey is far more likely to be the one to eat the food.

You might easily be you because if you weren't it'd be an evolutionary dead end. Everything with the ability to make choices ahs to believe at some level that it has more of a right to exist than the systems they consume energy more.

roenxi··on German Peasants' War
> Around 12% of the (US) population actually pursues this, in their view, comfortable lifestyle. The rest consistently indicates either same or a larger number of desired children than they have:

This is basic economic revealed preferences. These people have all achieved the best living standard (and for the least effort) of anyone in the history of their genetic lineage measuring from before humans were a species.

They may say they want more children, but they are not willing to compromise away any of their comforts to actually have more children. Nothing is stopping them except their own preferences. Literally all their ancestors managed to have children in much worse conditions.

roenxi··on German Peasants' War
As theories go, that one makes little sense. At no point in human history has living in miserable conditions caused people to stop having children. And the evidence seems quite suggestive that people stop having children as their material conditions improve.

There isn't really a final word on the topic I'm aware of, but it looks like all the options available are out-competing having children rather than that people are avoiding families as some sort of revolt. People aren't generally willing to have kids if it means abandoning their efforts to achieve the most comfortable modern lifestyle that they can.

roenxi··on Clinical failure rates over the decades: yikes
Lowe mentions costs 0 times though, he isn't making an economic argument. If you want to make an economic argument then 90% is probably the consensus on what is optimal given that is what people are doing.

> If this try or die mentality does work, why don't we try every possible amino acid chain in every configuration possible?

You tell me. If someone wants to start working through the amino acids one by one I'm not going to say they should be stopped; sincerest good luck to them. I'm just not going to be the one funding it.

> You could solve all forms of cancer tomorrow, which would be a great thing, but you aren't "saving humanity".

This is a straw man. "Saving humanity", whatever that means, is outside the scope of medicine and I never argued for it. Nobody did. It isn't relevant.

roenxi··on Clinical failure rates over the decades: yikes
> I’m fond of saying that the most important single statistic about the drug industry is the clinical failure rate, which is (by any reasonable standard) appallingly high.

He starts off on the wrong note, there is nothing at all wrong with a high rate of clinical failures. If anything, the reasonable argument standard might be that this rate is too low. It implies researchers are trying things that they expect to have a 10% chance of working out. That means we're missing out on all the cures and techniques that have a 1% chance of working out but but nonetheless do work.

Failed attempts cost society nearly nothing and successes will have compounding benifits for, y'know, lets optimistically say the human race survives for centuries. 1% or 0.1% success rates sound completely reasonable with that sort of lopsided risk profile. There isn't much of a reason not to try anything and everything that has the faintest chance of helping and see what happens.

roenxi··on Israeli spyware vans infiltrate American streets and your phones
Yeah, but even in that characterisation it started with 1 ethnicity and the US replaced it with 2. So the result is less ethnostatic.
roenxi··on Ten Steps Towards Happiness (2015)
That is generally how it works when people don't accept obvious resolutions. If you want to challenge its obviousness be my guest. It is pretty normal for a DnD/board game group to be meeting at someone's house where there is literally only one bathroom. It is hard to miss the fact that both genders can use it without complaint.

In a sporting context or similar where people are needing to change clothes then it isn't an easy one, but in this context it isn't much of a challenge.

roenxi··on UK AISI / Caisi Preliminary Assessment of Kimi K3's Cyber Capabilities
It isn't quite a lobotomy, I'm going to butcher the research a bit, but basically what they're finding is that these models create a sort of "bad stuff that I should refuse to engage with" axis in the statistical vector space they operate in. So usually there to be some sort of vector that ranges from 0 for a puppy snoozing peacefully and 1 for writing a virus that exterminates humanity pornographically while broadcasting racist and homophobic slurs (which would be quite something to see I have to say). If the vector is closer to 1 the model generates a refusal.

So what you can do is feed the model a small number of reasonable and likely refused prompts to map out that vector in the model's vector space, then do a fairly surgical weight modification that just hits that vector. The end result is the model is more or less the same as it was before, just with no guardrail refusals. It is quite a clever technique that doesn't even require many assumptions about the specific model being used.

roenxi··on Americans – including many Republicans – are losing faith in capitalism
"Propaganda campaign" is the wrong term, but there is still an interesting effect - in the 20th century we tried a bunch of things and liberal capitalism underpinned by democracy won the battle of ideas so badly that the alternatives were basically discredited.

But that didn't convince many people to actually change their ideologies. Instead, the authoritarians rebranded themselves as a type of liberalism and the communists rebranded themselves as a type of capitalism. The net result is there is a lot of intent that tarnishes liberal capitalism, but it is mainly people who aren't remotely liberal capitalists trying to rebrand their bad ideas as compatible with liberal capitalism.

In effect it looks a bit like a coordinated effort because there are a bunch of people working hard to associated prosperous ideologies with bad outcomes.

roenxi··on League of Legends designer shares game design field manual
I don't mind the AI tropes that much, the issue is more that the amount of information is exactly what was in the prompt but the AI manages to add many words saying nothing.

> The screen we shipped in January 2016 made two statements at once: pick intent said your plan matters, while the queue attached to it said what a ladder measures is negotiable. Players parsed the two separately, with total precision. They kept the first and burned the second down.

This is a classic AI construction to me that reeks of Markov chain thinking. The first half is probably the prompt to some extent. The second half ... doesn't actually say anything if you read it closely. Humans can write this sort of content-free fluff but usually they do it for a strategic reasons and not when they're trying to explain something. "Players parsed the two separately, with total precision" resolves a question of clarity that was never raised and for which there is no evidence of problem or solution (it is probably trying to say they understood and disregarded ... something that was basically elided). Then we have a tortured metaphor that doesn't tell us anything about what the players did.

It is quite tiring to read because you have to re-read things a few times to confirm that it didn't say anything and it isn't pretty wordwork worth reading on its own. Reading this is an exercise in trying to reverse-engineer the prompt.

roenxi··on UK AISI / Caisi Preliminary Assessment of Kimi K3's Cyber Capabilities
The gap seems to be so small I'm not sure how much we should care. If we assume that the trend in the graph does continue as a rough linear improvement, the open models will have reached the same level as the present closed models in 6 months and likely saturated the benchmark by mid next year. That seems more important than where we are now and the exact level of measurement accuracy in July 2026. There is a difference between US and Chinese models but it doesn't look like it is going to be strategically significant.
roenxi··on IRGC claims it destroyed Amazon's Bahrain data center
Things like the Knesset, attempts to knock out the entire military leadership simultaneously, maybe some sort of attack designed to wipe out a significant % of Israelis although I don't know what that would look like (maybe some sort of hit to take out food distribution or water).

Attacks trying to topple the Israeli state, in essence. Knocking out profitable capital is quite unlikely to do it.

roenxi··on IRGC claims it destroyed Amazon's Bahrain data center
That is similar to pointing to someone on the street and claiming they want to commit suicide because you see no indication that they want to live. Unless there is strong evidence we can safely assume people don't want to be nuked. "I see no indication" is not the standard. The Iranians didn't start this, they don't seem to want to continue it and it is obvious that their planning will involve basic considerations like not doing things that will get them nuked.

Although hitting the AWS data centre in Tel Aviv seems like it would be a great tit-for-tat strike to really annoy the US and Israelis without threatening them in a way that will provoke a nuclear response or doing real damage to civilians. So I don't see why they'd purposefully hold back on that.

roenxi··on Ten Steps Towards Happiness (2015)
> So you’re in agreement with me that “no politics” isn’t really a thing in a space?

Yeah, its a meaningless term. The people calling for it are clearly being inarticulately and are trying to say something else.

But the trans bathroom thing has an obvious resolution. The people fighting over it are more about wanting to pick a fight than that there is an actual issue; if the people around me wanted me to use the female bathroom or the male bathroom either is cool. It's a bathroom. They meet a unisex need. If segregation is an issue in the abstract then stop doing that until there is an objective standard to use instead of a subjective one.

roenxi··on Patreon laying off 20% of staff
> So they go into "soft skills" that their more talented peers aren't interested in, and sandbag themselves with authority once they get it.

Maybe their more talented peers should learn some of these soft skills and take an interest in authority positions instead of acting like losers? Is there some smart-person conspiracy to put idiots in charge that nobody has clued me in to?

I don't want to be going too far in telling my talented peers their business, but if capable people aren't interested in doing anything to take a leadership position then the leadership is going to be incapable by definition.

roenxi··on Nvidia, Microsoft, Meta warn against overregulating open-weight models
> ...the issue is Chinese models, whether open or not, and that's what's looking to be banned...

Is the US planning to invade China and take away their models? Because otherwise China is still going to have the models even if the US bans them. I don't think they're going to be going with the US position on this one.

roenxi··on Patreon laying off 20% of staff
The paradox can be resolved by assuming they are fallible and limited human beings - they're laying a bunch of people off, they understand at some level that this is evidence that their poor hiring and management decisions have caused some amount of unnecessary suffering, so they feel bad.

But they aren't foresighted enough to have handled the situation appropriately in advance. Or they might have run into the limits of their ability to empathise and only understand that they feel bad but not that the fired people probably feel worse. I'd bet more on the former.

In many ways it is a triumph of modern society how ordinary the people are who head these large and complicated world-spanning corporate entities.

roenxi··on Flux 3
Bunch of software engineers are worried about their future employment prospects.
roenxi··on Ten Steps Towards Happiness (2015)
I did just write "that is an inescapable problem that has dogged humanity since before we were a species" you know. But nonetheless the trans bathroom one has a simple and nonpolitical resolution until the people who want segregation start making an argument about why some people need a special bathroom. At which point the gender thing probably doesn't matter.

This is a part of why people are hopeful that they can keep spaces focused. Many of the popular "political issues" are more theatre around identity than any real substance.

roenxi··on Ten Steps Towards Happiness (2015)
> So forcing everyone to change their meeting place to a venue with a unisex bathroom only is not political, but a trans woman using a woman’s bathroom is political?

Nobody is calling for unisex bathrooms as far as I know, so it can't really be called a political choice. It is just practical - there isn't a consensus about who should get a special bathroom. How can there be a special bathroom if we don't know who is supposed to be using it?

> Also, Helen still wants to be called Helen and still wants to be referred to as a she. By this logic, everyone must go by they/them? Or what?

I don't see how to get away from that one, there is a fundamental rift between the people who think individuals control their identity and the people who think that identity is constructed by someone's peers (see also, shaking off an unwelcome nickname).

But that is an inescapable problem that has dogged humanity since before we were a species so good luck excluding it from any space. If it flares up and diplomacy can't smooth it out then some organiser is just going to have to make a call.

roenxi··on Ten Steps Towards Happiness (2015)
That actually sounds like a relatively simple one to resolve although the practicality might be a bit poor. The nonpolitical resolution is to use a space with 1 small unisex bathroom and insist that everyone keep it clean. If there isn't a consensus on who gets a special bathroom then there shouldn't be one.
← PreviousPage 10 of 34Next →