HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rohan_shah

355 karma · joined March 16, 2019

meet.hn/city/in-Sangli
submissionscomments
rohan_shah··on I tried starting a manufacturing unit in India
No I hadn't heard of it. Will check it out now.
rohan_shah··on I tried starting a manufacturing unit in India
Except the fact that all land in India is a farmland.
rohan_shah··on I tried starting a manufacturing unit in India
Thanks for offering your help. Currently nothing much can be done by even myself.

Will let you know.

rohan_shah··on I tried starting a manufacturing unit in India
Land is a state subject.

And as far I can see the central government is really committed to making a difference on the ground as they have done in states administered by them.

There are special zones in India but lot lot less than China or the USA. And all the land in that land bank is sold out where I want to start the unit. (Sangli Niraj Kupwad MIDC)

rohan_shah··on I tried starting a manufacturing unit in India
You are right. I see that the central government is fully committed to EoDB.

Also they have done wonderful work in Gujarat by making this process completely online.

And land is a stage subject.

Therefore, this write-up is not targeted at the current central government but at the wrong doings of past 70 years and why India still lags.

rohan_shah··on I tried starting a manufacturing unit in India
Yes that's right. It's similar.

But the problem is that the whole of India is made up of hundreds and thousands of small towns. And there are hardly any land banks zoned as industrial land because almost all of India is fertile land.

rohan_shah··on I tried starting a manufacturing unit in India
Actually there are almost no pre defined industrial zones.

There are very few and most of them are bought out.

I can hire an lawyer or agent to this work, but the cost is very very high. I decided to do it myself to understand the depth of this mess.

rohan_shah··on I tried starting a manufacturing unit in India
Not paying bribe because of moral issues as well as the fact that I could buy 10 MacBook Pro's with that much money.

There are agents who provide the "NA service". They quoted me 10,00,000 (10 Lakh or 1 Million Rupees) excluding all the legal payments to government.

All land is Agricultural Land by default. Industrial land banks (created by MIDC are few and far and our land is near a MIDC industrial land bank which is out of stock, meaning completely bought out)

Yes there is road access.

No. the land is almost barren land. Far away from flooding. So no problem with natural disasters.

rohan_shah··on I tried starting a manufacturing unit in India
All land is Agricultural Land by default unless it comes under Municipal borders of a city or owned by MIDC (Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation).

So yes, the whole point of this NA document is to convert the agricultural land into non-agricultural land on paper.

rohan_shah··on I tried starting a manufacturing unit in India
If I paid the amounts they wanted ~ 10,00,000 (10 lakh or 1 million) Rupees each, it would be done in 7-8 months.
rohan_shah··on I tried starting a manufacturing unit in India
Author of the article here. Do ask me if you have any questions.
rohan_shah··on Show HN: Full Text Search on Podcasts
Is there any site that ranks podcasts by viewership/listenership numbers?
rohan_shah··on Focus has become more valuable than intelligence (2018)
I have also experienced that. If feels like there direction-less flow of thoughts about a lot of things and nothing to focus on.

I got help from Vivekananda's books. He mentions that the ability to concentrate is the only difference between humans and animals.

And the degree of focus determines success in human life.

But he warns that learning the ability to focus without learning how to completely get out of the mind-thought complex is like going inside a complex maze without the map.

His books are quite small and can be finished in a few hours. Worth reading.

rohan_shah··on Sand Theft
The bjp government along with police is trying to use Satellite surveillance to stop sand mining. But it's only partially working...
rohan_shah··on Calculus Explained with GIFs and Pics (2014)
You're right. But not for this statement.

At most, he could have written "The slope of a linear equation or "line" is constant. This is a known fact."

rohan_shah··on Calculus Explained with GIFs and Pics (2014)
"The curse of Knowledge"
rohan_shah··on From Underwear to Cars, India’s Economy Is Fraying
I agree that there have been problems. And yes, many people are impacted due to the slowdown.

But I am not sitting in an ivory tower. I am a middle class Indian living in tier 3 city who is trying to learn to code and make a living remotely...

rohan_shah··on From Underwear to Cars, India’s Economy Is Fraying
I just explained why the demand is falling...
rohan_shah··on From Underwear to Cars, India’s Economy Is Fraying
I did not vilify cash in any way in my argument. I just stated my (little, unscientific) hypothetical analysis of the existing underlying situation.

Ofcourse, getting rid of cash is very helpful to a "government" or "state" in collecting taxes, tracking as well as negative interest rates (even though I hope that is far away for India).

But cash also helps get rid of corruption and any government which itself exists on the basis of black money will never do anything against black money which is what a factual analysis of the previous government will tell you.

And the cash earners who earn too less to be taxed should be helped to get out of poverty which is only possible when they get a bank account and receive the money via direct benefit transfer which was meant for them instead of political goons.

So it is no myth that the money Indian government was spending for the poor, never reached the poor and one of the reasons was because it was cash. And if we do not vilify corruption, I don't think any positive future is possible.

*Not that the current government is white-washed and exists without black money, but the previous simply wasn't interested in solving the problem.

rohan_shah··on From Underwear to Cars, India’s Economy Is Fraying
So black money is equally prevalent in Pakistan also? Another sign of our strong bond, connection and brotherhood! xD
rohan_shah··on From Underwear to Cars, India’s Economy Is Fraying
When you buy a property, you have to register the property (on your name) with the local government body (generally the Municipal Corporation).

The fee paid here is calculated as a percentage of the price paid for the land/property. So everyone buys (on paper) at exactly the ready reckoner rates (the minimum prices) and then pay the minimum taxes (or registration fees). While in reality the prices are way higher than the ready reckoner prices (generally 5 to 10 times) and so the rest of the price is paid in cash (unaccounted black money).

If I may ask: Where in India so you like to spend your time in terms of urban/rural India? Have you found any life-threats just because you're a foreigner?

rohan_shah··on From Underwear to Cars, India’s Economy Is Fraying
Not that I am a big fan of SCMP, but this fact is well known that India provoked the war[1]. There was even an opportunity to call off the war but we (our government) denied it.

[1] https://www.scmp.com/week-asia/geopolitics/article/2102555/i...

rohan_shah··on From Underwear to Cars, India’s Economy Is Fraying
I've a theory but that is not backed by data.

Land prices in India are dropping rapidly. Here how (my hypothesis): People for generations have thought that land prices will always increase. It might have been true before Demonetization. But now it is almost impossible to do anything with cash (expect the purchase of land). So if anyone thinks of buying land for any residential, commercial or industrial purpose, they will not able to use their cash in building because there are subsidies available for those who take loans to finance such building. So people will use loans (accounted money) to build their buildings. You cannot also buy cars with cash (unaccounted cash).

Because of this, land purchases have either gone down or vanished (by unaccounted cash which was majority of the purchases).

So the prices are rapidly falling as people decide on selling and don't find a buyer at the perceived market rate. So they lower the prices and the vicious downward cycle continues.

Put simply: There was a land price bubble because of black money. Now the bubble is slowly bursting. IMO the bubble was so huge (as a % of the GDP), I think we're in serious trouble with the spillover effect of fallen property prices.

rohan_shah··on From Underwear to Cars, India’s Economy Is Fraying
Yes. Things that have never been done before on such large scale can be only be perfected with incremental changes after gathering data.
rohan_shah··on From Underwear to Cars, India’s Economy Is Fraying
"Prosperity" here means stable 2 meals a day...
rohan_shah··on From Underwear to Cars, India’s Economy Is Fraying
We fought with China, not the other way around.
rohan_shah··on From Underwear to Cars, India’s Economy Is Fraying
Exactly. The science and art of economics is also a technique with only probability based outcomes. If the underlying assumptions change, then things will slowdown / grow in unexpected ways.
rohan_shah··on Lectures in Quantitative Economics with Python [pdf]
Goes very well with your username.
rohan_shah··on Lectures in Quantitative Economics with Python [pdf]
Even though finance and economics overlap, I think that comment was referring to the social and psychological side of economics.
rohan_shah··on France and Germany Agree to Block Facebook's Libra
Exactly. If a substantial amount of people stop trusting the "promissory state money", then the inflation will be uncontrollable (or not controllable by the state) and the state won't be able to give anything in return of their promissory notes.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →