HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

romaniv

2,750 karma · joined February 2, 2011

submissionscomments
romaniv··on Novelist warns against utilitarian trends in higher education
Exposed to a wide range of topics for the low price of $23,410 per year ($46,272 in private colleges). No thanks. I'd rather go to the nearest bookstore, library or use the Internet for what's intended.

http://www.collegedata.com/cs/content/content_payarticle_tmp...

romaniv··on Novelist warns against utilitarian trends in higher education
> Now, universities by and large do not attempt to "prepare people for citizenship and democracy." Instead, they educate them to be members of a "docile, most skilled, working class."

You need to go to liberal arts college to be prepared for citizenship and democracy? Really? If by the time you get to college you're not interested in "humanities", you're very unlikely to get interested after being forced to listen to some mediocre lectures. And make no mistake, that's exactly what the wast majority of students will get.

romaniv··on Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article
Whether the statements are true or not is what the journalists should care about

This is a very naive view of journalism. It is trivial to do horrible, biased reporting while printing statements that are factually true or not falsifiable. In fact, that is how most of the biased articles are constructed these days. In the age of the Internet you can't get away with outright lies. The tool of trade are mission, misrepresentation, manufactured context, selective citation, cherrypiked expert opinions and so on.

romaniv··on What it's like to write for content farms, from Brooklyn to the Philippines
Your comment highlights the shift in perception of search engines between around a decade ago and now. In the past "search" was something people did, while search engine was a tool that helped them. Right now "search" is something Google does. Human, on the other hand, are seen more like a passive recipients of information.

My point is, Google's algorithms do not need to tell the difference between good and bad articles. They need to give users tools for effectively filtering out the garbage they don't want to see. As far as I can tell, Google does not even try to provide that. Instead, they have a mysterious algorithm that's supposed to feed you the "right" results if if it knows who you are.

romaniv··on Off the Grid, but Still Online
Great comment. I would like to add that there is a world of difference between drudgery of tactile work and drudgery in office work.

Tactile work is more engaging and less stressful. It does not require constant multitasking or context switching. You concentrate. You also build up a certain skill at it, which allows you to feel good about what you're doing. (I.e. you go from just making nails to making good mails quickly.)

In many ways I find low-level manual tasks to feel more like "creative" office work.

romaniv··on Two HN Announcements
No need to mix then. Display it separately. On the bottom or on the left. Something has to be done with new submissions.
romaniv··on C# and F# approaches to illegal states
AFAIK, code contracts in .NET still have all the issues they had several years ago. The absolute worst one being that you need to install something for them to actually work. This means different computers will have different code behavior.
romaniv··on Axel Springer Acquires Business Insider
Yes, but there are a lot of people who are fed up with the kinds of online media you described. While clickbait works, it's not the only thing that does. It's just the cheapest.
romaniv··on Launching NginScript
I'm willing to bet it won't bring them any new business. And in the long run, it will encourage their existing users to dump nginx and use Node.
romaniv··on Launching NginScript
> So many better choices out there.

For now. I get the feeling that soon enough a lot of them will start dying out. Trying to "sell" some language other than JS in a mostly-JS shop is already an impossible battle. Popularity is used as a counter-argument for everything.

romaniv··on “This story is being previewed exclusively on Apple News until Tuesday”
You have to admit that after establishing its dominance Google started to dictate its own rules for web design, rather than adapting to the pages people already had. Google's algorithm that places incoming links above anything else for relevance is singlehandedly responsible for forum spambots, fake websites, and the dynamic where new websites have no chance to compete with something established, unless they run some kind of marketing campaign to "seed" the links.
romaniv··on Encryption might be the reason why we haven't heard from aliens
>An encrypted signal can't be "too random"

It should if encryption is good. After all, security proofs for encryption define "secure" as "indistinguishable from random".

romaniv··on Encryption might be the reason why we haven't heard from aliens
> Is there currently human technology that does anything similar to this?

Any sort of steganography tries to achieve something similar. I wouldn't be surprised if something similar would be used in military radio communications.

romaniv··on Hello, declarative world
Database and file updates can be treated as a part of page's output.
romaniv··on Hello, declarative world
For the most part, it is possible to remodel applications to handle stateful things outside of the main program.

Consider a website. An entire website can be modeled as a function that takes headers, URL and request body as parameters and returns headers and body as the response.

You can use the same principle to model almost anything. You take real inputs as inputs and output instructions for imperative side-effect to a minimalist agent of some sort.

romaniv··on Happy Birthday Monkey Island
The Secret of the Monkey Island is mostly a comedy game. And it's funny. There is satire, absurdism, meta-jokes. Something for everyone. But it also made very good use of interactivity for humor - something characteristic for adventure games and something Lucas Arts was very good at.

Broken Age is far more bland in comparison. And while I'm not a fan of brain-wrecking puzzles, it could do with a bit more challenge.

When it comes to point-and-click adventures these days I would recommend titles from Wadjet Eye Games. They're more serious overall, but still have that characteristic "adventure game" humor.

romaniv··on Scientists Replicated 100 Psychology Studies,Fewer Than 50% Got the Same Results
This is why we need effective media watchdogs that record past performance in a consumable fashion. I don't know (m?)any websites that do it well, though.
romaniv··on Scientists Replicated 100 Psychology Studies,Fewer Than 50% Got the Same Results
>An ideological response would discount the arguments, discredit the sources, and proceed merrily along.

But that's exactly what happens in the media where most of the people get their information about these studies.

romaniv··on Scientists Replicated 100 Psychology Studies,Fewer Than 50% Got the Same Results
Maybe the editorial staff assumes the responsibility for all the correctness issues? That would actually makes sense, since they have the final say in what gets published and should do some additional verification. Just a theory. I don't read The Economist very often and never offline.
romaniv··on Scientists Replicated 100 Psychology Studies,Fewer Than 50% Got the Same Results
>Is there a way to escape the echo chambers?

So far I haven't found a reliable way out. Social media and personal blogs definitely aren't it. In fact, they're feeding the badness.

Interestingly, I feel that paper editions of newspapers and magazines have less broken articles than their websites.

For me, the scary thing isn't that there are biases. It's that pretty much all major media outlets occasionally participate in Culture Wars™. That is, they take an extreme position on some polarizing issue -- whichever appeals to most of their core audience -- and then use every method available to reinforce their "side" and either ignore or try to discredit the "opposition".

But even that isn't the worst of it. The core problem is that both "sides" of such issues are often objectively wrong. Is it even sensible to try extract The Truth™ from two equally full buckets of bullshit?

I feel like this has become much worse recently. Maybe it's just me changing. Then again, there were no Twitter outrage campaigns before Twitter. There were normal outrage campaigns, but they were mostly wars by proxy fought mostly in the media. People observed them and maybe agreed. Right now, almost everyone is an active participant. Which generates news in its own right and skews coverage even more.

romaniv··on How books help us to be better human beings
> In the late 20th century, however, there was a sustained assault from within the profession of literary studies on the very idea of common humanity

I'm surprised someone at New Statesman admits this. Very often I feel that the very purpose of modern literary studies is to establish "credentials" that allow the holder to shut down discussion of books by using jargon and appeal to authority. In those disciplines, there is very little effort applied to improve the actual understanding of literature. Constructs, constructs, constructs. In the end, you end up spending most of your time dealing with linguistic constructs of the field itself and very little time thinking about the ideas of whatever author you study.

Noam Chomsky commented on this when speaking about post-structuralism. He noted that it's mostly an attempt to present "scientific" front for something that is inherently not a scientific field.

Of course, the response from the field was that he just doesn't understand what they're doing. Just like everyone else outside of the field.

romaniv··on Moving forward with work on the D language and foundation
Somehow I find this more inspiring than most commercial success stories. Deciding to work on ideas instead of working for a large or small company. I sincerely wish the best to the D Foundation.

(I'm an occasional lurker on D mailing list and proud owner of the D book. That mailing list, BTW, taught me a great deal of things about a whole bunch of programming languages.)

romaniv··on The Gracie jiu-jitsu story
> I don't know of any other martial art where

I don't know any other martial art where so many practitioners claim that their MA is, literally, the best.

From Gracie Academy website, which is the first one coming up in Google: "[...]Gracie or Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu is the most effective martial art on the planet[...]".

A little bit of modesty and camaraderie would go a long way here. A lot of martial arts have formative/spiritual components that help people out in life. Pretty much any real TMA which has proper training, beyond aggression and handing out belts.

romaniv··on Towards Neural Network-based Reasoning
So, with 10K samples it can parse semi-arbitrary data presented in a natural language, semi-arbitrary questions in a natural language and give natural-language answers? Am I missing something? This sound so much more powerful than anything else I've read about that I'm suspicious.
romaniv··on How “oldschool” graphics worked [video]
Canvas does exactly what I'm talking about, but for my purposes I would prefer something that works outside of a browser.
romaniv··on A Course on Automata Theory
I was lucky to have an excellent professor for a similar course in college (it was called Computation Theory). It completely changed the way I think about programming. Specifically, it changed how I think about program state and software bugs. Also, knowing about finite state machines really helps with requirement analysis.

So, highly recommended.

romaniv··on How “oldschool” graphics worked [video]
I wish modern computers had some reasonably efficient APIs for doing pixel-level screen buffer stuff in a straightforward way. Without using pixel shaders on polygons and other hacks.
romaniv··on Working Toward Bret Victor's “Learnable Programming”
I don't think it's about bootstrapping to dev. I think it's about allowing people to solve certain problems using programming, but in a different way from what we're used to. It's about visualizing explorative programming. That's the way I understand it.
romaniv··on Facial Recognition Software Moves from Overseas Wars to Local Police
> Facial recognition software, which American military and intelligence agencies used for years in Iraq and Afghanistan

Mighty good it did them there...

It's disturbing that no matter how much technology police gets, they always seem to want more. I mean, look at the encryption backdoor debate. We're being monitored in all ways imaginable, and apparently it's still not enough.

romaniv··on Facial Recognition Software Moves from Overseas Wars to Local Police
So, let's say you do that. Then what?
← PreviousPage 15 of 30Next →