HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

romwell

9,193 karma · joined March 21, 2010

Mathematics / Computational Geometry / 3D printing

https://romankogan.net/math

submissionscomments
romwell··on Ask HN: Why is Pave legal?
>Anyone else remember when HackerNews had an adventurous libertarian ethos before the school marms infested the place with irrelevant and low vibrational commentary?

Boy will you not like the "high vibrational" commentary people would have for that adventurous™ libertarianism©* of yours.

The "medium vibrational" ones merely wish its pursuers behind bars, the more energetic ones are discussing optimal guillotine blade shape profiles.

* * * * * * *

Question to you.

Would a startup that maintains a public database of names, addresses, and approximate locations of people with net worth over $1B be libertariously adventurous enough by your standards?

You know, like Page, but crowdsourced, and with wage workers as the users (not as product). Purely opt-in. Give it a higher-energy vibe name, like, say, 'rage (as in "average" - for the average people).

Anyone who sees Elon Musk could anonymously report his location to 'rage, giving wage workers an option to avoid providing services to him - just like Pave gives employers an option to avoid getting services from undesirable workers.

Are you a pastry seller who'd rather call in sick the day Peter Thiel or his buddy JD Vance are in town again? Get 'rage, and avoid the awkward interaction.

Anyone who gets a wind of someone fitting the wealth profile will have an option to anonymously contribute this data to 'rage's Wealth Accumulator Registry (Rage WAR™).

They may be breaking their NDA's while doing so, but that won't be 'rage's problem, of course. 'rage will not be in the business of policing individual actions and limiting users' personal freedoms.

The user identity will be e2e encrypted, guaranteeing anonymity. It will be impossible to prove that someone has a 'rage account against their will, or find out they have one.

The app, however, will also allow users to confirm that they have a 'rage account if they choose to do so. This way, wage workers who are concerned about their peers could ask them to privately confirm their account status and contribution karma to avoid sharing a workplace with a scab.

Registration will require entering your own personal wealth data into 'rage WAR™.

While tax returns can be faked, someone uploading a copy of their W-2 paystub will practically ensure that one does not fit the target wealth profile for the B-status.

Those could be faked too, of course - and one could see large employers not wanting to collaborate with 'rage for whatever reasons.

That's exactly where startups like Pave come into play to verify the correctness of the data.

'rage and Pave would not only complement each other in the financial data ecosystem, they would form a natural symbiosis, giving wage workers incentives to ask their employers to use Pave. As for Pave, 'rage would merely be one of its clients, consuming W-2 data just like everyone else.

I hope you will find this proposal sufficiently adventurous and relevant; and I would love to hear your thoughts on this matter.

romwell··on Oxygene: A modern language built on the foundation of Object Pascal
It's the Delphi pitfall :(

Still the best IDE I've ever used, but that was because in 1990s Ukraine everything was pirated. Wouldn't be able to use it any other way.

romwell··on [dead]
That settles it.

A company spokes person would never misinform the public.

romwell··on Five Most Productive Years: What Happened and What's Next
>The subject here and now is Wolfram and the irritation of many comes not from the work that Wolfram has achieved on his own but the utter lack of acknowledgement | recogonition of work done by others .. a substantial amount of work by others.

He wrote many essays on history of mathematics and science that IMO not just give credit where credit is due, but help immortalize these achievements.

We would be also be better off if the people who do interesting things that he wrote about bragged about them - so we'd get more exposure to the interesting things.

Ignoring bragging is easy. Finding out what Ramanujan's thought process was when he was coming up with his brilliant mathematics, in the absence of his own detailed notes, is pretty damn hard.

[1] https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/category/historical-pers...

romwell··on Five Most Productive Years: What Happened and What's Next
Say what you want of Stephen Wolfram, but he's an interesting person doing interesting things - and managing to finish a lot of them.

A bite-sized idea I liked from the long article: "the very act of exposition was a critical part of organizing and developing my ideas".

I've arrived to the same conclusion for myself (and this article, hopefully, will be the last straw for me to start writing in an organized manner).

My only moderately-successful writing so far has been my ADHD wiki[0], which, in the spirit of Stephen Wolfram, I will shamelessly promote here and now (I've gotten some marvelous feedback from HN in the past, and I believe it to be a useful resource to many).

FWIW Stephen not merely boasting about productivity; a fair bit of the article is dedicated to talking about techniques and tools that he believes help him with that.

While his article on Computational Essays[1] is mostly a Mathematica ad, Mathematica is a great system (which have influenced things like Jupyter notebooks a lot), and the idea of literal programming and interactive data/code/writing is a solid one.

We have yet to have a solid collection of resources like that even for teaching mathematics (where it's natural to play with code to experiment with ideas).

Another bit I liked: and yes, one seems to be able to see the essence of machine learning in systems vastly simpler than neural nets. Sure, we all know about that cellular automata are the Woflram's thing, so it's not surprising to see them pop up in his article about minimal learning computational models[2], but I feel an article like that has been way overdue.

We've been playing with neural nets long enough without having a solid idea what's really going on, and it's limiting to use them as legos of sorts. Why these blocks in particular? What else is out there?

The ChatGPT explainer that he mentioned[1] is still my go-to article for learning about it; I think I'll add another one of his to the list.

Finally, the bit one why history is important - and finding out his archive of writing on history of math and science[4] is great. I believe that history is the most underappreciate science itself, and learning science without its history leaves you without either context or deep understanding of it.

(Personally, I add etymology to history: I find resources like "Earliest Known Uses of Some Mathmatical Terms"[5] invaluable).

And, of course, it's great to see that he's diving into linking mathematics, computation, physics, biology. Great discoveries often lie on the interfaces of various fields.

As Vladimir Arnold wrote in his famous essay[6], divorcing mathematics from physics has been a phenomenal crime. I'm guilty of it too. I recently made a post on reddit[7] with a GIF showing the osculating circles and the evolute of an ellipse. It's pretty, but what is really hiding behind it is the shape of the gear tooth which nearly all gears have.

I learned (and taught!) the mathematics behind it without having any understanding how gears are designed and why they work. And people who make gears make them without understanding the math behind the equations. This came up at work (I'm working on implicit CAD modeling), and from a discussion a better understanding (...and a better product) emerged. There is no reason for narrow specialization that creates barriers in fields that aren't just related, but are necessary for each other - so I believe that the mere fact of Wolfram doing this work is important.

Maybe he'll find out something groundbreaking in those directions. Maybe not. But I can guarantee that he and people around him will stumble into fascinating things along the way that they wouldn't encounter otherwise.

Lord Kelvin thought that what makes atoms different is how they're tied into different knots. That turned out to not describe the reality of atoms at all - but gave rise to knot theory[8], which has since gained a fundamental ground in mathematics, particularly - topology (you can construct any 4-manifold by removing a tubular neighborhood of a knot in 3-sphere and gluing it back with some twists - see Dehn Surgery[9]). So, while Kelvin did not find what he was looking for there, the direction his effort has jump-started may, in fact, fundamentally describe our reality - as we have yet to learn what kind of manifold structure our universe has. And knot

Anyway. All in all, good, thought-provoking article (this comment, which contains some thought at least, is a testament to that); I'd recommend looking beyond the title and looking into the things Wolfram mentions. There's a ton of interesting tangents there.

[0] https://romankogan.net/adhd

[1] https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/2017/11/what-is-a-comput...

[2] https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/2024/08/whats-really-goi...

[3] https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/2023/02/what-is-chatgpt-...

[4] https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/category/historical-pers...

[5] https://mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk/Miller/mathword/m/

[6] https://www.math.fsu.edu/~wxm/Arnold.htm

[7] https://old.reddit.com/r/math/comments/1f1yblk/evolute_of_an...

[8] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_knot_theory

[9] https://ncatlab.org/nlab/show/Dehn+surgery

romwell··on A dishwasher can make or break a restaurant (2017)
...while being simultaneously vilified for "taking our jobs" and being "dangerous" (whereas they are being very deliberately used to generate profits).

You are making a solid case to issue permanent residence permits to all undocumented workers (since our economy would, at this point, collapse without them), and - most importantly - punish employers with prison time for hiring people unauthorized to work going forward.

That's it, illegal immigration problem solved.

Employers like that are having their cake and eating it, too. The undocumented workers are the ones who get punished for their employer's crimes. Sorry, I'm not going to cite sources, as I've yet to hear about anyone going behind bars for hiring illegal immigrants.

EDIT: never mind, here's a source[1]. It wasn't hard to find.

>For example, the latest available data show that during the last twelve months (April 2018 - March 2019) only 11 individuals (and no companies) were prosecuted in just 7 cases. There were no prosecutions during either of the last two months.

Corporate employers aren't even being prosecuted. This tells you everything about the hypocrisy of the entire system (and anti-immigration rhetoric in particular, whether legal or illegal).

EDIT 2: "sporadically" hiring illegal workers isn't even a crime punished by prison [2]. Yay.

[1] https://trac.syr.edu/immigration/reports/559/

[2] https://www.justice.gov/archives/jm/criminal-resource-manual...

romwell··on A dishwasher can make or break a restaurant (2017)
>If the job is unskilled (i.e. you can train the next person to do it in less than one hour) and you have several people standing in line to take it if the person doing it, quits; then the current wage is clearly enough.

Enough for whom and for what?

For a society with slavery, absolutely. Also for a GULAG.

If that's the environment you want to live in, North Korea is the best country! Everyone is getting wages that are enough.

>It is just like the price of the meal. If it costs more than people are willing to pay, then it is too expensive; regardless of what you personally think it should cost

Yes, meals that people can't afford are too expensive regardless of what you personally think it should cost.

And wages that don't support living are too low regardless of what you personally think is enough.

romwell··on A dishwasher can make or break a restaurant (2017)
The parent comment said nothing about the job, they commented on a full-time wage.

Their point stands.

romwell··on When A.I.'s Output Is a Threat to A.I. Itself
Tomorrow's LLM-based doctor:

You've got a fever, and the only prescription is MORE COWBELL

Can't wait to see what fixed points will emerge in this dynamical enshittification system.

romwell··on When A.I.'s Output Is a Threat to A.I. Itself
That's because the traditional model didn't have a loop connecting the garbage output back to input.
romwell··on Microsoft donates the Mono Project to the Wine team
This is Hackernews.

What are those Desktop apps you speak of?

Clearly, everything is a command-line backend pipeline in container with a web UI.

And everything that isn't can be easily deprecated. /s

romwell··on Microsoft donates the Mono Project to the Wine team
It seems like the link we got (https://www.mono-project.com) might be the URL for the announcement - that's to say, this is the last update on that website, and will stay there indefinitely.
romwell··on The "Reimagine" feature on Google's new Pixel 9 lineup is incredible
>Except that requires time, money, and forethought.

You missed the point that actual IRL bugs are very easily obtainable for free and without much forethought.

romwell··on How a flawed idea is teaching kids to be poor readers (2019)
Thank you so much for reading that paper and writing this comment.

There definitely are resources that I can recommend. Can't do this at the moment (work awaits!), but will come back to this in the evening.

One book that did a lot for me was What Is Mathematics?[1] by Courant and Robbins. Godel, Escher, Bach[2], while not strictly a math book (and not a book I actually finished reading), was another. These would be my go-to recommendations without thinking much.

There are also many more playful mathematics books that might be an even better fit for what you want, but I'd need to go through my bookshelf to pick some.

> It wasn't until after collage that I stumbled across some gifs showing how/why various formulas in geometry are what they are, and I was really upset that those types of things weren't shown in school.

I know, right? Me too.

BTW, if you have ever stumbled into this one:

https://www.reddit.com/r/math/comments/g15ei/tan_demystified...

...I made it for that exact reason. I need to come back to this stuff.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/What_Is_Mathematics%3F

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%B6del,_Escher,_Bach

romwell··on How a flawed idea is teaching kids to be poor readers (2019)
Indeed it is, sadly. But I'm very glad you got to read this paper, and get thoughts from it! The more people see things this way, the closer we are to changing the education system for the better.
romwell··on The "Reimagine" feature on Google's new Pixel 9 lineup is incredible
Sure, but the author talks about it as if the same thing wasn't already possible with Photoshop and some effort decades ago (anyone remembers Worth1000?).

Of course, having the machine do it in seconds is a huge achievement.

But it doesn't bring us into the Brave New World the author is describing where Yelp has to be "afraid" of fake images of food with bugs.

Faking photos was a thing since photography was invented. As was faking text - aka lying.

Yet here we are, talking and stuff.

romwell··on How a flawed idea is teaching kids to be poor readers (2019)
I'm sorry, but as a mathematician and educator, the comparison to Common Core is unwarranted.

When you say it sounded like something to you, you communicate that you didn't understand what it actually meant and deduced the meaning through pattern-matching - which is exactly the problem here.

Common Core aims to rectify the problems introduced during the "New Math" era (and before it, too), which, like the "three cueing", took sense out of the art of reasoning and imagination we call mathematics.

To understand what I am talking about, I beg you (no exaggeration) to read Mathematician's Lament by Paul Lockhart[1].

It will give you an immediate understanding of how we teach mathematics wrong - like the article we are discussing exposes how we teach reading wrong.

[1] https://worrydream.com/refs/Lockhart_2002_-_A_Mathematician'...

romwell··on I'm tired of fixing customers' AI generated code
>unless you referenced both of them in later code

Generative AI: hold my bear

romwell··on US hospital told family their daughter had checked out when in fact she'd died
>When I was a teenageer a school counselor incorrectly perceived me to be in a crisis and had me sent to 72 hour hold

How could they do that without notifying your parents and telling them exactly where you've been sent to, and what they should do?!

How could they've done that without giving the hospital your parents' contact info? How could the hospital accept you without requesting it, given that you were sent from school, where you have limited rights because they have the responsibility for your well-being?

How could have they discharged without allowing you to contact your family yourself?

This should be grounds for a civil lawsuit, if not criminal prosecution. I am not a lawyer, but I really hope that anyone reading this would contact one if they end in a situation like that.

>They're just trying to get the bodies through as quickly as possible.

I don't think taking 30 seconds over those 20 hours to contact your family would've slowed them down any.

This is not about efficiency. They should not be allowed to operate.

romwell··on US hospital told family their daughter had checked out when in fact she'd died
I am so sorry for what happened to your brother and your family.

The hospital is directly responsible for your cousin's death.

The fact that they assured the mother that they'll keep him, specifically told her to come the next day, and then forcibly discharged him at 2am without either calling his mother or even providing mother's contact to him should be grounds for criminal prosecution.

This is beyond negligence. They lied to the mother and knowingly forced him out when they were responsible for his well-being.

It would've cost them $0.00 to dial his mom's number. The fact that he asked for his mom's phone and they refused means they did it on purpose. This sounds very much like and indication of malicious intent to me.

I hope your family sues the bejeesus out of the hospital, and that someone will get a felony charge over this.

This hospital mot merely betrayed the trust of your family. It is literally a public health hazard. It should not continue existing.

romwell··on The first mass-produced DRAM of the Soviet Union
>Are any pictures available? I would like to know how @ could look like a dog

"a with a long tail curling upwards, like that of a Laika dog[1]"

[1] https://www.wisdompanel.com/en-us/dog-breeds/east-siberian-l...

romwell··on Why Are We Still Making Unshaded Playgrounds?
Seattle is an exceptional city in the US in that respect, and the only one aside from NYC where I'd feel comfortable living without a car.

If not for the climate, I'd move there already.

romwell··on Why Are We Still Making Unshaded Playgrounds?
>Why Are We Still Making Unshaded Playgrounds?

Because the US is developed as an urbanite-hostile wasteland, devoid of third places[1], where people are kept out of the streets by design, and are goaded into existing only in the following locations:

1. Home

2. Work

3. Car

4. Somewhere you will be spending money - particularly, if it involves connecting with other people

Parks exist, but I can't recall the last time I met anyone at a park. The interactions are usually limited to "Hello" and commenting on the weather as you pass someone on a trail.

There are exceptions, of course. And there are shaded playgrounds too. But there's a reason most people meet their spouses online these days. The Internet has become our third place because our actual places keep us isolated.

NYC is on of the few exceptional American cities, but it, too, is not immune to the blight (so excellently described by N.K. Jemisin in her ode to The City[3] that only New Yorkers will fully appreciate).

The playgrounds follow the overall trend.

[1] https://esl.uchicago.edu/2023/11/01/third-places-what-are-th...

[2] https://www.theknot.com/content/online-dating-most-popular-w...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_City_We_Became

romwell··on Late Again
>All meetings should start at a time ending in 5 on the minutes side. Eg. 10:35 is a valid start time.

This is an excellent example of an ADHD accommodation that costs nothing to implement, and is absolutely welcomed by neurotypical people too.

Same goes for having meeting-free days, and a culture that teaches people to be mindful of interruptions[1].

Unsurprisingly, it's something companies like Meta have (software engineering tends to attract ADHD folks because Hyperfocus[2] is a trait of something ironically called attention deficit, and coding marathons are a great example of that in action).

Programmers talk about Flow all the time, but that's what Hyperfocus can easily mistaken for[3]. If you find it difficult to get started[4], but once you get going, you forget the world exists and find it difficult to switch out of whatever you're doing[5], and stopping feels painful.. yeah, that's hyperfocus.

Which, along with being late all the time[6], is an ADHD trait. ADHD is surely the worst-named affliction.[7]

Found out the hard way at the age of 34. Sharing my experience so that y'all don't have to keep on living your life on hard mode, and driving your Lamborghini brain on unplowed fields when it was built for a different purpose.

If you find yourself relating to the article we're discussing (Late Again), you'll likely find the links below interesting.

[1] https://romankogan.net/adhd#Hyperfocus

[2] https://romankogan.net/adhd/#Interruptions

[3] https://www.additudemag.com/flow-state-vs-hyperfocus-adhd/

[4] romankogan.net/adhd#Getting%20Started

[5] https://romankogan.net/adhd/#ADHD%20Switches

[6] https://romankogan.net/adhd/#Being%20Late

[7] https://romankogan.net/adhd/#Awfully%20Described%20Human%20D...

romwell··on Late Again
>Perspective from someone who identifies as a tidsoptimist, Swedish for “time optimist”

I also wondered all those things, and loved the word tidsoptimist.

Then I got diagnosed with ADHD as an adult at age 34, and it all clicked.

"Tidsoptimism" is an ADHD trait:

https://romankogan.net/adhd/#Being%20Late

A part of it is what's literally called Time Blindness:

https://romankogan.net/adhd/#Time%20Perception

https://romankogan.net/adhd/#Time%20Blindness

The article we're discussing (as well the one you linked, and the one written by Tim Urban on the same issue[1], and the words you wrote) is a universal ADHD experience.

Figuring out that this is how my brain works helped immensely. Turns out, there is no need to make up new terms (tidsoptimist, "chronically late person", etc). The words have already been invented. And many people have already worked out solutions, mitigation strategies (...and meds[2]).

I hope that my links above will help some people learn something about themselves, and for others - to understand their friends and colleagues better.

And for hell's sake, let's take the moral charge out of lateness itself. I'm not saying that it should be acceptable: to the extent that someone being late affects other people, there may (and should be!) consequences.

But being late has a stigma even when it doesn't affect anyone else.

And it makes it more difficult to have a conversation like this: "I have time blindness. Let's talk about what you'll do if I don't make it on time, and what the consequences will be. I don't want to make you wait." - which both helps avoid lateness and often allows for a solution other than "everyone will be angrily waiting for the late person".

[1] https://waitbutwhy.com/2015/07/why-im-always-late.html

[2] https://romankogan.net/adhd#Medication

romwell··on Lenticular Clock
>Won't this show the wrong glyph if you're looking at it from the wrong angle?

Time is relative (to your height).

romwell··on TiddlyWiki5 – A self-contained JavaScript wiki for the browser
I'm an ardent user of Tiddly Wiki as a knowledge database.

I know there's Obsidian and Logseq, but they feel like too much overhead to me.

TiddlyWiki does all of that, and it's a self-contained single HTML file. You can run it on Node.js, but you don't have to.

Oh, and also it's a journal and a blog.

I built my ADHD wiki[1] with it, and I don't think I'd have had the energy to do it with any other tool.

[1] https://romankogan.net/adhd

romwell··on Google removed Organic Maps from the Play Store
Google Maps limits how much you can download.

You can't download the map for the the entire world, or even an entire country.

romwell··on Google removed Organic Maps from the Play Store
Haven't tried EveryDoor yet. Thank you!
romwell··on Google removed Organic Maps from the Play Store
About three hundred megabytes for a country like Romania.

About a gigabyte for the US, several gigs for the whole world.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →