HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rorymarinich

407 karma · joined April 28, 2009

If you're looking for exciting, brilliant graphic design at college-student prices, shoot me an email. I'll have a sexy-schmexy web site up soon if you'd rather wait for that.

i.am@me.com

http://twitter.com/rorymarinich

submissionscomments
rorymarinich··on A tale of evolution. How Facebook and I grew apart.
Every friend I have left (51 at current count) has expressed doubts re: Facebook use, and has contemplated switching to something. Every one came to the conclusion that the disadvantages to switching far outweigh the advantages of switching; more, there's no real competitor to switch.

You need to limit your Facebook friends. Having too many FB friends mimics the feeling of being overly fakely social: You get much more closeness if you stick to the people you really care about. Stop treating it like a monolithic connection. Friend and unfriend people whimsically. Stick to people you really care about interacting with.

Facebook is about the social. If you're not using it as a strictly conversational tool, then it doesn't work well. (Other than sending messages, but whatever.) It's not for documenting links, or documenting conversation. It's about today rather than last week or last month.

And no other tool handles that as well. Tumblr doesn't handle conversations well, Twitter doesn't handle multimedia well. Buzz is hideous and bad and it gives me skin-crawlies; plus I don't have a Google account. If there was a similarly social service, I'd consider moving over, but there's not.

rorymarinich··on Grooveshark's new Javascript/HTML interface
Yay, customer surveys! I like those!

I actually have an Rdio account, because I have a curious bias towards web sites with sexier names/subconsciously believe I am judged by the names of web sites I use. When I joined I had the impression that Rdio would only let me listen to unlimited songs if I paid you money. Now I see that's not the case, so I'll give your service a go.

First thing I don't like is that you don't give me a big search bar. I'm not paying you money. I don't want to log in. I even resent Grooveshark's making me log in to share songs, that's how lazy I am. (I do have a Grooveshark account, which I rarely use.) So the fact that your front page looks more like a product than like an easy service, that scares me away.

I think the two most common-looking site designs are: search bars and product pages. Product pages are universally ugly and I run away from them actively. Search bars I will type in something and see if the engine meets my whims. So Grooveshark's front page sells more.

Rdio fails the Cardiacs test: http://www.rdio.com/#/search/cardiacs/ returns nothing, whereas Grooveshark gives me almost their full catalogue. Cardiacs is my general test of band obscurity: If you have them you're bound to have most of what I want, and if you don't then I trust you less. (You both fail my Victoria Pipe Police Band test, which is pretty sad, because I request my fervent demand for pipe music be sated. >:( )

When I go to a band's page, I get something that looks like informational bullshit. Which is nice — I use Last.fm for my band-related nonsense — but when I want a music player I want small entries that show me as much music as possible. If I search a band I want three albums on my screen simultaneously. Grooveshark gives me a LOT of music, and fast.

But here's the clincher:

When I go to play music, you ask me to sign in or register. BAM! I'm looking for a new site. I don't like giving out my email address. I don't like picking new secure passwords. I will only do it if I think you're worth the effort.

Right now I use three sites to listen to music. I use Grooveshark, or I use Bandcamp, or I use TheSixtyOne. Occasionally I use Pandora but that's WAY rare. Grooveshark's for general music hunting; Bandcamp is for searching for and buying music, and listening to musicians I know use it (like Sufjan Stevens); TheSixtyOne is when I want to explore random music. Each one is designed specifically to mimic my usage pattern. They look the way I want them to look.

Rdio looks like a college design project. (I'm not saying it looks bad. I go to a design college.) While it's pretty, it's not very functional — you have a lot of design choices that go against the way I'm trying to use the site. Kind of like when search engines make gangly content-crammed designs that stop me from actually finding what I'm searching for. I'm going to stick to the stripped-down tool that does what I want when I want it.

If you want to compete with Grooveshark, go slimmer, more efficient, and sexier. Make it easier for me to find the music I want than Grooveshark, easier to share, easier to — anything. If you don't, I have no reason to even contemplate switching. The good news is that I'm not loyal to Grooveshark beyond my affection for its design; because I don't have an account or use more features, I'm not entrenched. If you do something convincing I'd consider moving over.

Feel free to discuss this more with me, either here or in email. I love discussing design philosophy.

rorymarinich··on The daily tomato: How to maintain focus and kick ass on multiple projects
Thanks, Ryan!
rorymarinich··on The daily tomato: How to maintain focus and kick ass on multiple projects
Can somebody passionate explain what Pomodoro is? When I Google it all I get are sauce recipes; I'd love if an enthusiast for the system could explain to me what makes it so effective and nice.
rorymarinich··on So what is a designer?
Yep!
rorymarinich··on Ask HN: Review my "coming soon" page
I'm still confused myself; the Internet hasn't been restricted to university usage since the way-early 90s, right? What specific service are you providing? Without that I can't be more clear.

(If it's something you'd rather keep secret, I understand, but can't exactly help much. Or if you want to talk privately, send an email and I'll try to get back to you quickly.)

rorymarinich··on Ask HN: Review my "coming soon" page
The font you use for your tag line is too silly — it doesn't make me feel particularly learned or wise or any of the things I associate with scholarliness. Ditto that wishy-washy blue color.

The "email-subscribe" widget is ugly and gray. The border is too thick on the "email" and the slightly rounded "subscribe" box feels like a parody of web 2.0.

"to get updates on our progress" should not be on a separate line from "subscribe" but in general it should not be there at all. Think of a more concise way to say what you want to say.

The "h" and the "r" in your logo font make me want to punch a baby even though said baby has done nothing wrong. I don't know what font that is but it makes me feel kind of like the bondage rape scene in Blue Velvet makes me feel.

"We're taking it back" should not be on a separate line from "The internet was built...", nor should it be in bold.

So inasmuch as "coming soon" pages go, you managed to incorporate all the things you're supposed to have while simultaneously making them all very unpleasant. But why is this posted here? Why does it matter? Is this an attempt to make us subscribe and build up your prelaunch audience? Or are you a designer trying to master the art of coming soon pages? Otherwise I don't know why you'd care enough to ask for a critique.

(Also: WAS the Internet built for universities? What does that even mean? Do you mean the old old Internet that started as a university project? Or do you mean 2005-era Facebook? I am so confused. Please explain.)

rorymarinich··on So what is a designer?
"The right place to find a designer," goes the adage, "is wherever the designer happens to be." Frustratingly, there is no official hub where every designer goes, so you have to look in a lot of places. Elance has some talented people, but it doesn't have all the people you should be looking for.

When you're looking for a designer, the rule is you try to find somebody who makes things you like looking at first. That's the most important part. Looking through their portfolio, then, you're trying to see the extent of their prowess. Do they rely on the same design tricks with every single layout they make (gradients, pretty buttons, slidy things), or are they making sure each web site does what it's supposed to do? Have they got any subtlety of understanding what a web site's needs are, or are they designing a bunch of things that look the same no matter what they're meant to be?

Then you talk to them. See if they "get" what you're talking about. Don't plan your questions in advance — conversations work better than interviews. Do they intuit your needs? If you have to clarify something that at first isn't clear, do they catch on to where you're going? You want somebody who's going to make the web site you want to make.

As for price: Offer what you can afford, and see if they'll take it. With designers, you never know. My team has taken $200 contracts because the work was simple enough and we liked the team offering. We've done freelance work because we liked the cause or liked the challenge and had an opening in our schedule.

The best way to find designers is to stick to people who've made work you like, or people you know, or people who've said interesting things, and contact them directly. Sort of like how directors stick to their favorite actors and cinematographers or, if they don't have any, they ask their friends to help out. Keep it personal. Personal does better work for you.

(If you're not speaking hypothetically, by the way, feel free to write me — we're open again for business starting Thursday. [/selfpromotion])

rorymarinich··on So what is a designer?
Fair enough. :-)

I also know they're not writing pieces like this - which I see as a problem. I do think awareness to the shifting role of the designer is necessary at this point.

But I still don't agree with this. If anything, I think we need more designers to step up and say "The idea of a 'designer' is dead. Stop pretending like it's possible to be a professional in this day and age; we're all amateurs of differing degrees. There's more to learn than you'll ever be able to learn, so all that matters is that you learn the things you care about learning. Stop wasting time defining things, separating them into canons and non-canons, pretending like success necessarily defines designers or adds an extra meaning to their work."

I'm primarily studying advertising right now — though it's certainly not my only or even primary interest — and one thing that attracts me to the study is that the top advertisers on the planet have been saying this for a decade. Agencies like Wieden+Kennedy and the Barbarian Group turn out some work that's so beyond the kin of what we recognize as advertising that it forces you to acknowledge that the old definitions have been thrown out the window, regardless of whether some people insist they're still there.

Design hasn't gotten there yet: It's a more conservative field than advertising. (I mean, so is everything. That's the whole idea of being in advertising.) Even the people I just named tend to be more conservative with their designs than the half-generation following them is going to be. Of all the ones I named I think only Inman and the Twitter team are really doing something new, and even they aren't off-the-walls crazy. Not that there's anything bad with that.

But certainly one of the reasons I'm not primarily a designer is that it's one of the few artistic fields whose education focuses on old tried-and-true standards rather than on the crazy things that happened last week or yesterday or earlier today. A whole lot of design feels appallingly stagnant.

(I'd love to talk this with you more in-depth, by the way — would you mind if I shot you an email?)

rorymarinich··on WikiLeaks Will Unveil Major Bank Scandal in Early 2011
> prosaic

You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.

Apparently detailed reports of the US spying on its allies, or reports that the US deliberately concealed the civilian death count in Iraq to make the war look better, is prosaic? Because I find shit like that very interesting.

rorymarinich··on So what is a designer?
I like — and by "like" I mean "am vaguely unhappy" — that this post and most posts like it are written by a person or people whose idea of web design is slapping a light color on another light color, adding padding, and then @font-facing in something that looks vaguely elegant. Is this design, meeting priorities in the simplest and most boring way imaginable? Is design simply matching proper lineheight to a fontsize, declaring it readable, and calling it a day? Is design making a vaguely pretty blog without also applying serious thought to what the contents of that blog will be?

When was the last time you saw Jon Hicks or Elliot Jay Stocks or Jeff Zeldman or Shaun Inman write vapid entries like this about the definition of designer? When do the designers at Twitter or Tumblr write entries about how they define the word "design"? They don't, because they know that talking about words and positions and statuses like they mean something is silly. Words are what we make of them. They're especially dolled up by people who don't have any toys to play with but words.

Designers can be anything and do anything. Same thing with "advertisers" and "artists" and "engineers" and "rockstars" and whatever other terms people decide to throw about themselves. Designers can write. Engineers can build web sites.

EDIT: I see that the guy who wrote this post is on HN responding. Fred, I hope you can forgive my irritability and frustration — I really don't mean this as a jab at you. But I'm bothered that you try and define design in the basest terms — "a designer does X, Y, and Z" — and refuse to discuss the goals that design can achieve. You're talking about design like the whole point is to make a company a quick buck. I know a fuck of a lot of designers who'd really hate their jobs if that was all they were doing.

rorymarinich··on Congressman wants WikiLeaks listed as terrorist group
Well, we've known certain parts of the right have wanted to classify the NTY as terrorists for years now.
rorymarinich··on The unbearable lameness of web 2.0
Click-through rate might be slightly more accurate than simply pushing everything, but it's not an ultimate solution because it too makes assumptions about your usage. The one assumes you want everything equally; the other assumes that your desires can be perfectly correlated to your clickthroughs. But that's not true for anybody; what's worse, the reason why it's false is different for everybody. (What if the people who interact with me are more active than the people I actively seek out, and Facebook misinterprets my responses as active interest? What if I'm simply innocently stalking a girl obsessively but actually find her updates bland and individually unworthwhile? One must think of the stalkers, especially if one is hoping to make money on the Internet.)

The real issue is that cases like those of anthuswilliams above you are unique and difficult to replicate. That's one of the noted problems with music recommendation services like Pandora too: What matters isn't what users tend towards but why, and why is a question that can't be effectively computed. It's more freeform.

I think the real solution would be a site that actively helps a user be responsible for himself. Something that doesn't simply indicate what features are available, but why users might want to use them to sort out their friends. Contrary to what the OP says in his blog post, that is possible today, but it requires responsibility on both the parts of the reader (who must sort his inputs neatly) and the publisher (who must figure out where to publish what). And web sites presently don't feel it's worth their time to help you with that task.

rorymarinich··on The unbearable lameness of web 2.0
Yes, and even this is a more complicated problem than simply stating it would make it seem.

Imagine a solution that was open and allowed anybody to utilize its social graph. In theory this would allow other sites to build off the original and feed it back, maintaining equilibrium between every service. But in practice, this only holds until somebody decides to make a proprietary graph, because then users have nothing to gain by using any service other than the proprietary top level with the extra functionality.

And why would we do something like that other than greed? Well, perhaps we want to implement some unique system that's not streamlined or practical, but which we need for a particular plan we have. So we create a system that contains that extra, proprietary data, which is proprietary because making it open would simply make every other service messy. Or perhaps it's that what we want to do would take too long to implement in an open solution, and we'd rather be advanced than be consistent. But the more we build on, the harder and harder it is to move back to that original openness.

Similar to an environment like Flash, for instance, which lets developers implement functionality that's vastly beyond HTML (or, was vastly beyond, and still to some degree is), but which then ruins engines that rely on HTML's open format to work. Either you develop to be open, and sacrifice potential features, or you use something proprietary and lose that connection, and further place yourself in the hands of a third-party developer.

There isn't a single optimal solution, unless you consider using multiple platforms an optimal solution. (Which I do. I don't feel frustrated at using four sites to monitor my various friends/feeds/updates. I just be careful to delineate all four so that each item appears in the right place, and so that my own updates get pushed to the right places.

rorymarinich··on Tumblr Falls Into a Really Big Pile of Money
My bet? Probably most of them. But that's only because almost every service is abandoned by most of its initial users. I set up a site once where literally the instant you made an account you were adding content; you typed your name, hit enter, and then filled out a profile field. Still this led to a great deal of blank profiles.

Probably if their goal is to make a load of money they should start figuring things out. I don't know if that's their priority, though; they seem to enjoy being Internet superstars. Hopefully they'll hit on a wonderful profit plan, but really, no hurry. Plenty of companies have spent excessively long times getting profitable but they've pulled through anyway.

rorymarinich··on Tumblr Falls Into a Really Big Pile of Money
What's funny is that I simultaneously agree with you and think you're missing the point.

Tumblr has done an awful job of monetizing. I'm pretty sure the team doesn't give much of a shit about monetizing, because they seem pretty damn happy with their site as-is and every monetization attempt of theirs has been something ephemeral and community-focused. The only one that's been long-lasting is their Theme Garden, which is poorly-designed and, I suspect, not very successful, mainly because Tumblr's primary audience is looking for a free, well-designed way to express themselves, and sees no reason to pay $49 for a pretty theme.

But at the same time, Tumblr is immensely valuable, because it's becoming the go-to community for bored youth. Name a single community more geared at your average (non-techy) youngster. The only one I can think of is LiveJournal, and LiveJournal is not sexy. Tumblr is sexy. It is surprisingly intelligent considering how sexy it is, but it is not a web site used by people carefully calculating features and userbases; it is a web site used by people who like web sites to look and act sexy. (Sometimes I feel frustrated at Tumblr because of this; it's not really worth it. Nothing wrong with people who'd rather be sexy than smart.)

Posterous has more features than Muscle Milk has nutrients, and Garry Tan (the only Posterous staffer I've talked to) is a superbly bright and kind person who spends way more time answering inane emails than a successful person ought to, so I like Posterous, but it is not a sexy site. "Sexy" isn't something you usually put on bullet point lists, but it's super-duper important, and it's very difficult to design for. Actually, I think there's a case study in design right here: The more features you place somewhere, the harder it is to make it sexy. Tumblr is very good at adding features and maintaining their inner sexy. Not just in how they look but in how they feel - I've never felt a site that makes posting new content feel as rewarding as Tumblr does. (Second place: Facebook, distantly; they used to be better at this.)

It's valuable because a significant portion of youth worldwide are addicted to it. If I'm launching a new product (whether it's "internet service" or "TV show" or "me trying to be clever in a blog") I'm going to pick Tumblr over Posterous, because what I want isn't a set of features that make my job easy, what I want is easy connections to an enormous market that might latch on to me and make me popular/viral/book deal/whatever.

(By the way, the theme marketplace is pretty poor, but the theme garden is one of the highest-quality purveyor of themes you can get for any blog engine. I wish Wordpress or ExpressionEngine or Drupal had themes that consistently sexy. But I'm admittedly biased: something like 40,000 people use my old Tumblr themes.)

rorymarinich··on Why People Don't Like Nerds or Programmers (In School)
Not at all! My ideas are entirely open for discourse. I don't think for an instant that what I wrote was immaculate and untouchable.

The reason I'm pissed off about this whole thing is that it's a bad essay. It's not worthy of pulling up and discussing. And this is a crowd that's never going to agree with the things I've said, and yet because it's Hacker News I find the need to argue anyway, knowing it's going nowhere, and so it's a huge time sink over a piece that doesn't deserve this attention.

The people politely responded? I wouldn't have gotten involved at all if that was the case. The reason I got an account was because I was being called things like a "sad, angry little man," and maybe I'm thin-skinned but stuff like that really pisses me off.

I know this is a defensive thing to say, but my Twitter post was half in jest. If I was pissed off at Hacker News, I wouldn't be here. Does that make me as bad as the people I was blaming? Probably. This isn't a personality quirk that I'm entirely at peace with; it's certainly still a part of me. I don't think I'm perfect and I'd never pretend to me. The fact that I write so much about these things is because they're parts of me I still don't like. I think I've been saying that from the start.

So if you want to fly off-the-handle at me for getting annoyed because a community I really like had a huge uproad over a piece of mine I really didn't care for, feel free. I probably deserve it; I act immature at times; I say things without thinking. You're older than I am and more well-known than I am and so by all means you're probably in the right. I'd just hope you would find better things to do with your time than squabble over a 3 AM ramble by a college freshman.

Now I noprocrast this account away, because I'm finished.

rorymarinich··on Why People Don't Like Nerds or Programmers (In School)
It's not worth it to get into a pissfest. I don't care enough. One comment:

If you don't like being generic, then why the hell were you nothing but a bag of gross generalizations in your stupid little essay?

It's not an essay. It's a blog post. I write fast and I write long and I publish everything that I write because I adhere to the belief that perhaps something I write will help somebody with something. I treat my blog like a blog. It's not a professional platform. The stuff I do in my life I keep entirely separate from all the things I write. If I ever got to the point where my sole source of fame was a web site with my name on it, I'd consider myself to have done a piss-poor job with my life. Same if the only thing I had going for my name was an ill-conceived rant clustered around by people who prefer rage to straight thinking.

As it is, I've gotten responses from people to this that've thanked me for writing it. That means that for 20 minutes' work it was time well-spent. My frustration doesn't come from disagreement. It comes from the fact that my post, which is about as good as 20 minutes' worth of quick typing can get you, got put on Hacker News, which is a place where intelligent people discuss meaningful things, when this is a piece that deals in overgeneralities.

When I wrote this piece, my thought wasn't "How can I capture the high school experience?" It was "What is it about this type of programmer that really annoys me?" I hit on my conclusion, which I still stand by, and wrote all the thoughts I've got on the subject matter, typed it quickly, and put it online. I thought it would get a handful of responses. Nothing big, because it's not big or at all important. I wrote two or three things yesterday that I think are better than this particular piece.

But you just ignored the post I just made to focus on my original post, which I've already apologized for. It's obvious that of the two people I said you might be, you're the latter. You're ranting at a mindset that I don't actually have just so that you can be Fucking Awesome Zed now that your blog's been toned down. If you really want to get pissed off at me for things I don't believe, you have every right. But I'm through with this. I expected better from you.

rorymarinich··on Why People Don't Like Nerds or Programmers (In School)
See, even now, my talking about this comes off as confrontational, to no effect. I still think it was better for the original conversation to leave it out.

Nah, that's a completely sensible point. I don't think it's hard to make programming seem cool, though: there are some very awesome things that've been made. WeFeelFine comes to mind. Talk about how something beautiful like that was made and it'll at least make people realize more that programmers can be artists, too. (Not the best example, but it's what first comes to mind.)

Have I ignored something else that annoys you?

Nope.

Sure. The way it's written, it seems like you are referring to all nerds, but I will assume that this is not the case.

Yeah. I could revise this, but I don't think it would be worth it. It wasn't a major piece of writing, in any event.

rorymarinich··on Why People Don't Like Nerds or Programmers (In School)
Perhaps it's that I think the vast majority of programmers are doing meaningless work, and so their use of the term has diluted what the word means for me. But then, I'd pick the term "designer" which some people think is just as meaningless.
rorymarinich··on Why People Don't Like Nerds or Programmers (In School)
We could have a whole lengthy discussion about this, but I still disagree. I think that success is easy enough that somebody who's willing to try and try again will succeed sooner rather than later.
rorymarinich··on Why People Don't Like Nerds or Programmers (In School)
I was actually going to mention Drupal, because it's what I've spent a good five years playing around with. I love it.

There's something about the questioner being unwilling to help themselves. Not a lack of understanding about a topic, but a lack of understanding about understanding in general. A kind of feeling that some people think things are literally magic, not just a chain of connections that anyone learn about and manipulate.

That's not the vibe I get from a lot of the more arrogant types. If somebody asks "How do I make a custom forum" and somebody says "Well, you're going to need to know a lot of things, so if you don't know X Y and Z it's going to take you a lot of learning", that makes a lot of sense, agreed. But the attitude that comes off of a lot of programmers is "Yeah, you can't, don't bother," and I feel that hurts a lot of curious-but-ignorant people.

rorymarinich··on Why People Don't Like Nerds or Programmers (In School)
If he didn't care, he wouldn't have gone out of his way to make a blog theme that screamed "Obnoxious asshole" and then gone on to rant about things that got him called an obnoxious asshole. I'm not saying that those two things make him an obnoxious asshole, but then, Zed never once assumed the attitude of "I can't believe people are calling me an obnoxious asshole." I'm certain he didn't care that they were, and so in his mind it's totally okay.

If he complained about people not calling him sensitive with that logo of his, then I'd call him out for being a hypocrite. That's what I'm doing with nerds: I think that nerds go out of their way to be disliked and then complain that nobody likes them.

rorymarinich··on Why People Don't Like Nerds or Programmers (In School)
Bullshit. Gravity is a provable part of science. The social sciences are harder to deal with. Meanwhile, you want proof? I'll offer myself and every single person I know who's willing to be social as proof. I'm friends with guys with weird hair and glasses who use Digg and they were an accepted part of high school because they didn't go out of their way to be exclusive and closed-off. When I decided to stop being a dick to people just to preempt their disliking me, I found out that I was rarely disliked. (In fact, I went to a further extreme, because I'm quick to call people out for saying stupid things and I like colorful insults, and yet people didn't mind so much as I continued to get along with them.)

Show me the person who makes an active attempt to stop being hated - not by being "cool" but by starting to act friendly towards people - and fails after a few weeks' effort and I'll consider your experiment a potential refutation.

Would the multitudes of people coming to refute his points confirm his point that there is a conspiracy to hide the truth?

I said "Nerds are in denial" and a lot of people jumped on board to deny it. I'm not saying that proves it either way, because I don't presume to judge people by their comments online, but it's not exactly evidence of my wrongdoing.

rorymarinich··on Why People Don't Like Nerds or Programmers (In School)
I'd think the anxiety are outnumbered by the things that Facebook makes simpler. (I just add my relatives, and hope they don't mind that I occasionally use foul language. They usually don't.)
rorymarinich··on Why People Don't Like Nerds or Programmers (In School)
Look man, you said you had a solution to the problem. What I said is hardly a leap. You have a funny definition of "drastic proportions".

I use hyperbole. I ought to have said "proposed" solution. Either way, your response was snide and still hasn't addressed what I said in that point. I think that what I proposed would help the two sides understand each other in a way they don't know, and in my experience the more people get to know each other the better they get along. The disconnect at the moment is that nerds think other people are wasting their time, and other people think nerds only do what they do because they haven't got anything else going for them. When you make people like stuff, they form bonds.

You're descending into ad hominem territory here. Please don't.

I need to apologize to the people I've argued with in this thread, because I've been much angrier and snappier in these responses than is appropriate for Hacker News. This morning I woke up to find a bunch of emails from people telling me my blog was broken in IE and I found this on the top of Hacker News. I've been writing a post for a little while now that I was going to submit here; I only submit things here if they're quality things. This is part of my daily writings, where I spill out a bunch of things on my mind without thinking about them, admitting all the while that I'm not putting careful thought into my writings. So to find that sort of thing here and discussed by people calling me a sad angry little man really just isn't a good way for me to start the day, and it's not how I want to approach my work. So I'm mad because I'm finding myself seriously debating something I wasn't exactly serious about in the first place, but I've got a sense of propriety about my writings and so I refuse to let people dis what I've said without defending myself. You've stood out to me as one of the people who's most deliberately ignoring the things that I'm saying, though this response was a lot better. Again: apologies.

Causes for these things are shared - blame is given to one side or the other for their own actions.

Okay. By that standard I'm blaming the nerds for deliberately setting up a situation wherein they're persecuted, when they could easily avoid the entire situation by not being so deliberately hostile. Does that work?

rorymarinich··on Why People Don't Like Nerds or Programmers (In School)
I clarified what I said in my response to Zed's post. I should have thought before making that previous response.
rorymarinich··on Why People Don't Like Nerds or Programmers (In School)
No! Of course it's not okay to hurt somebody. If I made it sound like that I fucked up big-time.

What I said was that it's the attitude above that leads to physical violence. When somebody starts wanting to punch somebody in the face, it comes from that particular level of dickery.

I am not at all a violent person. I don't fight people, I don't hit people. I don't have a personality that leads to fights. The closest I get to violence is posting angry things online. And I'm certain that writing all these responses at 7 in the morning might have dimmed my writing a bit, but I never once implied violence.

What I said, again, was this:

If we were having this argument in real life and I was a more naturally violent person, I'd probably hit you, and then in your eyes I'd become the bully and you wouldn't be guilty of anything.

That's not me threatening. In fact, the one "threat" I made was the one where I lock out my Hacker News account because debates like this are a waste where nobody learns a damn thing. The point I was making was that chairface's comment was aggravating and glossing over points in a way that was smarmy and obnoxious. (His response to the parent post clarified a lot, so props to him.) That's an attitude that's not just on Hacker News. A friend of mine had it when he'd constantly pester a violent kid just to provoke a reaction. He'd get clocked in the eye and tell us all what a savage that other kid was. The point of my stupid poorly written blog post was that this is a common attitude amongst nerds when they handle things socially. They'll do things that they know will alienate them because they think the alienation is forthcoming anyway. In doing that they give themselves some "control" over their hopeless state.

I mean, I'm certain I'm talking to somebody who knows what I'm talking about. I've seen a lot of people dismiss your blog posts because of the "ZED'S SO FUCKING AWESOME" logo or because of your many elongated, poorly written rants. I'm too lazy to search back, but I've gotten into a lot of Zed debates on this site where you get slammed because your old web site was just begging for people to call you immature. You obviously knew that would happen and you went on doing it anyway, so you fit into the category of people I'm talking about here.

You're quoting me saying a lot of shit I didn't say, Zed. Cut that out; if you're going to get pissed off at me get pissed off at me for what I believe.

I never said violence was defensible. I have friends who have been molested and harassed and hurt. I think it's one of the most terrible things there is. And this entire argument is such a loose tangent from the argument I originally made that it was stupid of me to respond in the first place. I'm aware of that. There's a difference between an abused woman and an abused nerd. Nerd abuse is largely petty in nature. I know maybe two kids in my nerd group who got into fights, ever, and neither of those was a case of random abuse: both sides wanted to pummel the other side. So when the argument sifted away from petty and towards serious, my response should have been: that's not the same thing. Abuse and rape stem from an entirely other side of human existence than things like teasing and name-calling.

Child abuse is not name-calling. If you're suggesting that calling somebody a name is child abuse, you're off your fucking rocker. If a nerd is getting hit and hurt for what he's saying and doing, there's something pathological behind that happening; when a nerd is ostracized because he acts like a jackass, he's responsible for its happening.

The point I was trying to make, half-asleep, earlier today was that people who are getting seriously abused should take action to stop the abuse. If you're getting beat up or raped then you should take action to stop it from happening, because otherwise you're letting a guilty person get away with a crime. The only blame on the other person is letting the criminal get away. They aren't responsible for the horrible things being done to them.

But now I'm just repeating myself, and to be honest I can't tell if you just flew off at me because you think I said a terrible thing or if, like your critics claim, flipping out just gets you off. If it's the former, then I've clarified myself, and I'm sorry for sounding like I meant something I absolutely do not. If it's the latter, we've got nothing left to talk about.

rorymarinich··on Why People Don't Like Nerds or Programmers (In School)
One of the most-disliked kids at my school was the football captain, a Republican football player who wouldn't stop talking about politics or sports. I was in a class with him and with a completely insane dweeby kid who tried to add a word of Japanese into every sentence he spoke, and that second kid was completely ignored. We all made fun of the captain, because despite being football captain, he was just an absolute boring jerk. Similar targets in classes included pretty much all the sorts of people you just named. Even in really pretentious groups, like groups of actors, the one who nitpicked clothing was the one nobody else liked.
rorymarinich··on Why People Don't Like Nerds or Programmers (In School)
I think that the porn thing was pretty tasteless on the part of the presenter. But a part of being civil is avoiding confrontations that you don't have to be in. I used to feel really uncomfortable attending religious services because I was an atheist, for instance, but I've come to the conclusion that while it's awful to lie about what you believe, it's pretty icky to force your beliefs on other people. So while I think that the presenter and DHH are being kind of obnoxious, I accept that DHH's good traits stem from that obnoxious attitude, and I can like his product without necessarily liking that attitude.

It also depends on what you mean by "insulting." Frankly, if a cute girl asks me to program, then I will almost certainly tease her as I help out. I think the porn thing was an attempt at tease that ended up being a bit too insulting. There's definitely a line, but usually if you cross that line people will understand so long as you do.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →