HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rothbardrand

811 karma · joined June 3, 2017

I've been shadow banned. Apparently HNs "moderators" has detected my opinions are not sufficiently marxist. I know how this goes. I was once shadow banned here for relating how I had met Grace Hopper. Another time for merely linking to a PDF of a scientific paper in response to someone elses scientific claim. In both cases, no other posts for days before the ban.

850 points of karma proves I'm a good contributor here.... but one moderator disagrees with me and they take arbitrary action, without cause, without warning and without justification.

Don't ever pretend like you believe in the rule of law, you're criminals under your own rules!

Thinking is not tolerated here, clearly. I've done nothing wrong here, except make arguments. Haven't even gotten in a tiff with anyone. Clearly a moderator disagrees with some opinion of mine and we can't tolerate that, can we?

It was nice being on HN for awhile... but of course, the anti-intellectual snowflakes who run this site cannot abide actual critical thinking.

A shame, this could be a good site if discussions were allowed, instead it is a filter bubble of only one ideological viewpoint. You guys reject thinking and the concept of diversity while justifying your sexism, racism and general bigotry with the #diversity hash tag.

I am glad, though, to see that you guys have become such a laughing stock... I worried the rest of the country might not be smart enough to see thru it. You wonder why Trump? That's why. Your fault.

The thing is, you know you're hypocrites, but instead of learning or thinking you just make your wall 10 feet higher.

dang, you're a liar, and an anti-intellectual piece of shit.

And I know that you know it. KYS

submissionscomments
rothbardrand··on Segwit2x Bitcoin Fork Suspended
Bitcoin core has a consensus mechanism and it is a very good one. What gets into the code is only that which has near unanimous agreement. which means proposals are discussed and altered and improved until everyone is happy.

Believe it or not this is working well, and bitcoin is moving forward at a very rapid pace (especially given the difficulty of doing blockchain systems right)... people just don't realized it because few people read the release notes.

Those who think bitcoin needs a consensus mechanism to determine its direction usually think that it doesn't have one and that some cabal is in control.

That's not the case.

Remember, Segwit and LN were from outside the community, the LN developers are mostly not part of core, and in fact one of the authors of the paper is an ethereum guy.

They both got support in core quickly because they are good ideas.

Both were announced in the fall of 2015 and cores support was in the code by May of 2016!

rothbardrand··on Segwit2x Bitcoin Fork Suspended
We know who satoshi is. We can't prove it, of course and we respect him enough to leave him be in peace, given what he has done (and the fact that the current team is stronger than him.) He doesn't like the attention he gets even now when only some of us have worked it out.

Please feel free not to believe me-- you shouldn't, I could be shilling for Craig Wright (ironically the one person who has proven that he isn't Satoshi) ....

At this point Satoshi is a principle and a philosophy and bitcoin needs to survive without him.

The person who used that alias would be offended at the idea that the direction of bitcoin should be determined by him.

rothbardrand··on Quantopian hedge fund has lost about 3% since beginning of trading in June
Every investment I've ever bought has gone down within 6 months of the time I bought it. Unless you perfectly time a bottom that's what's gonna happen. The question is where it is in 6 years, not 6 months.

Plus, for a hedge fund there are a lot of initial costs and entering a position is where expenses happen generally.

rothbardrand··on Paradise Papers: New leak from offshore finance firm
You invoked morality. The moral calculus is pretty clear to me: I’ll take the gay loving advancer of technology over governments stealing money to use it to blow up people any day.

Apple has the moral high ground, and that ground is higher the less taxes they pay.

Remember military spending is far more than roads.

rothbardrand··on SEC warns famous crypto-currency backers
I think the trick is that you "get" that %7 as an account credit, but since you're never going to be able to withdraw the money...

these days all a ponzi needs to do is have enough shill accounts claiming that they were able to withdraw successfully, and drowning out those who complain.

rothbardrand··on Blockchains Considered Harmful: Is Brute-Force Processing Replacing Good Design?
Please define "insane"? Those who oppose PoW and think it uses "too much" energy never give a reason. Seems to be based in basic "we should all be poor hunter gatherers" marxism to me.

Mining is profitable, bitcoin is valuable enough to make it so, and it is valuable because it is doing jobs that people want to pay for it.

By definition, economically, it is not insane in the least.

rothbardrand··on Blockchains Considered Harmful: Is Brute-Force Processing Replacing Good Design?
less than perfect decentralization is still more decentralization than a monopoly. in this case the competition is a monopoly (eg fiat)
rothbardrand··on Blockchains Considered Harmful: Is Brute-Force Processing Replacing Good Design?
Worth noting that the vast majority of bitcoin is mined from hydroelectric power.

Ironically for the ether pumpers on this thread, the primary crypto currency that is powered by burning coal and oil is ethereum.

rothbardrand··on Blockchains Considered Harmful: Is Brute-Force Processing Replacing Good Design?
Ethereum is going to PoS as a mechanism to reduce liquidity and increase the coins price. Nothing more. The entire history of ethereum is full of a lot of... less than ideal decisions like this.
rothbardrand··on Blockchains Considered Harmful: Is Brute-Force Processing Replacing Good Design?
IF it were insanely expensive, nobody would mine. That you don't value the results, doesn't change the economic value of the activity you don't like.
rothbardrand··on Blockchains Considered Harmful: Is Brute-Force Processing Replacing Good Design?
The max block size for bitcoin went from 1mb to 4mb in August of 2017. The ONLY reason it took so long is that the courtesy signaling that core put in for miners was used as a veto as part of this anti-bitcoin effort to try and increase centralization. Please at least familiarize yourself with the oppositions arguments before stating conclusions like this.
rothbardrand··on Blockchains Considered Harmful: Is Brute-Force Processing Replacing Good Design?
You don't give any support for your initial thesis, nor does the post you're responding to.

Make a technical or economic argument.

Meanwhile: http://www.truthcoin.info/blog/pow-cheapest/

rothbardrand··on Blockchains Considered Harmful: Is Brute-Force Processing Replacing Good Design?
There's nothing cheaper than proof of work: http://www.truthcoin.info/blog/pow-cheapest/

The real reason Eth and others are going with proof of stake is that it locks up coins and thus dries up liquidity... this is a way to pump the coin price.

It doesn't provide the same level of security as Proof of Work, and the idea that Proof of work is somehow bad because it uses electricity is nonsense.

That's like saying we need to stop digging gold up out of the ground because its expensive, and we should just trade paper receipts for virtual gold.

The above post is not an actual technical argument (notice its logic is circular) and is just the type of typical FUD pumping of Ethereum you get from ethereum people.

rothbardrand··on The U.S. Isn’t Prepared for the Next Recession
This comment identifies parties responsible for actions, but these actions are taken by democrats and republicans alike, no president in my life time has failed to engage in these practices. This is not a political response.

Recessions are not "just how economies work". Recessions and depressions are the product of the monetary shenanigans of the central bank, as laid out well in the Austrians Business Cycle Theory. The short overview is, easy money means government gets to spend and the money creation process includes showering those at the top - wall street banks and government connected entities-- with new money that they are expected to "invest" in the economy. The problem is this is malinvestment and distorts the markets.

You can only do it so long and you invariably create bubbles.

A recent example of this I have lived thru is the dotcom boom...when it went bust, interest rates were put below the cost of money, and banks were mandated to make bad loans (prudent underwriting of loans was considered "racist" by democrats in the late 1990s so CRA was changed, later analysis showed it wasn't correlated with race after all.) Then under Bush the spigots were really opened and suddenly you have very cheap money to buy houses with.

Buying a house with cheap federal reserve money was a form of the carry trade--- where you buy an asset worth X and then pay it back with increasingly lowered value dollars.

This resulted in the housing bubble and of course the housing crisis.... which was "fixed" with massive amounts of even more easy money. This money is now going into wall street again, this time into equities, and hedge funds and venture capital.

It will eventually bust again.

IF you don't have an easy money policy then interest rates follow the supply demand dynamics of a market, and it will self regulate. Even if you don't think it will perfectly regulate itself (and that's true) it will tend to, rather than get way out of whack.

What we have now is an economy that is has gotten so out of whack and never been able to properly recover itself by unwinding the last two bubbles.

rothbardrand··on When did the golden age of The Simpsons end?
Rick and Morty has already lost its appeal to me, because the person who recommended it, and so many of the fans are assholes who think that Rick is a person to emulate and justifies their assholishness.
rothbardrand··on Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech companies is over
Silicon Valley is not dominant now. It is merely perceived as dominant by a cult of silicon valley, which exists primarily in the heads of people who live in SV.
rothbardrand··on Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech companies is over
He's right, but "Silicon Valley" only exists in the minds of silicon valley maximalists who live in a bit of a filter bubble.
rothbardrand··on Peter Thiel: Silicon Valley’s monopoly on big growth tech companies is over
IF your goal is to work for google, facebook, Amazon or Microsoft, then yes, Google is a great place to be.

But if your goal is to work for next decades google, Apple, etc, then no, Google is not the place to be.

Start working on Bitcoin. Start working on Ethereum. Get to the cutting edge.

Everything you do at google right now is about 10 years out of date (and I'm including machine learning and all their "cutting edge" AI stuff) and targeted at supporting their existing established business.

Take this from someone who has been on the cutting edge for 30+ years-- the challenge for most people is that the cutting edge changes, and you have to be paying attention to follow it... by the time you learn mobile development, surprise, there's bitcoin! (as an example.)

rothbardrand··on Bitcoin Pioneer Says New Coin to Work on Multiple Blockchains
Things to consider: 1. Create lots of accounts, allocate money to yourself. 2. How do you hold people accountable in a distributed trustless manner? 3. Once you have centralized identity or accountability, then there is really no use to doing a blockchain. So solving 1 & 2 is the hard part of your idea. 4. Freicoin had demurge built in, you had to spend it or it would go down in value. This is anti-capitalist-- literally, they were marxists trying out their idea-- the consequence of this is that it undermines people's ability to save and invest for the future. If your coin goes down in value over a lifetime (Which you can accomplish easily by simply having increasing inflation over time-- very much like the USD) then it becomes difficult to save for retirement or that time of your life when your medical expenses go up.
rothbardrand··on Bitcoin Pioneer Says New Coin to Work on Multiple Blockchains
By "pre-signed" transactions you mean ones still in the mempool? Actually not a problem, with the change to the ten opcode those would succeed on the correct chain.

Bitcoin has forked, by the way, August was a soft fork, and it has had a couple hard forks in the past.

What's new is that 2X is an attack fork. (Maybe "assault fork"?)

Sorry if my response seems pedantic, I am agreeing with you.

rothbardrand··on Bitcoin Pioneer Says New Coin to Work on Multiple Blockchains
Bitcoin has layers. One of the layers people don't understand is the layer called "core". The creators of bitcoin were cypherpunks and so they had a decade before bitcoin existed where people worked out how such a system would work. Those cypherpunks became core. While people think of bitcoin as the software, or the network or the white paper, what it really is, is a collection of engineers (you have to trust the engineers to trust the software and network and ultimately money) that is very diverse, and a genuine meritocracy. Since bitcoin attracted a lot of libertarians and wanna-be-I-think-I-am-libertarians its relatively easy to say "core is the new evil overlords! a monopoly!" when the reality is that core is a large number of people who don't agree on a lot of stuff and have developed a process of reaching consensus. So, unfortunately, some uneducated non-engineer felon like Roger Ver can spread a lot of claims about core and those get believed despite core people explaining patiently in engineering terms why the claims are false (eg: big blocks are not free scaling, segwit is more efficient, etc.)

Non-engineers simply cannot understand the technology arguments and so they are manipulatable via social engineering, which in this case is literally legions of paid shills (http://birds.bitcoin.com is the attackers site where shills get paid.)

That's the layer that's under attack now- because the powers that be want to control bitcoin and they can't beat the software, they can't beat the hash power, but they think they can maybe beat the people. (And in Ver's case, he shills BCH to keep its price up while unloading it to get more BTC.)

Actually that twitter account is one that I've seen many times before, and I would not consider him someone who understand how bitcoin works. He seems to be an engineer who has taken a superficial look and then fallen sway to propaganda.

This is the thing about bitcoin, there are layers. Here's some of the layers: 1. "Bitcoin is internet money" 2. A block chain is a chain of database entries 3. I understand what Proof of work is 4. I understand how economic incentives work in bitcoin 5. I understand why PoW will always be better than PoS 6. I understand why ethereum can never work (ultimately) 7. Now I really understand the economic incentives 8. Now I understand bitcoin

Of course this is more than a little tongue in cheek.

The white paper can be found here: https://bitcoin.org/en/bitcoin-paper

But a lot of the standards are found here (in various levels of adoption)... this bit is really relevant for wallets: https://github.com/bitcoin/bips#readme

Read the white paper at least once before holding any bitcoin. And then re-read it at least 5 times one the course of 2 years. It has layers and you will come to understand them over time.

Reading Mastering Bitcoin I understand is really useful too. (I got thrown into the deep end of btcd so I didn't have that luxury)

rothbardrand··on Bitcoin Pioneer Says New Coin to Work on Multiple Blockchains
He may have answers to those issues, and I understand he may want to keep them under his hat until they are thought out.

But know this-- if you want a chance at success, peer review is going to be needed when you are ready. And a lot of testing.

rothbardrand··on Bitcoin Pioneer Says New Coin to Work on Multiple Blockchains
It's easily proven-- go there and look at all the /r/btc brigading going on. The subreddit is full of trolls. And of course whenever one gets abusive and is banned they cry censorship.

Now look at my comment you are replying to-- -3 -- an attempt to downvote it into oblivion with no actual responses (other than yours) to the points I made.

There is censorship going on, but the ones crying the loudest are the worst offenders.

rothbardrand··on Bitcoin Pioneer Says New Coin to Work on Multiple Blockchains
disruption that is unnecessary and only going to happen because this "fork" is literally malware.

Look at BCH for an example of a responsible fork. They did the right things and still people lost money, but they did at least do their best.

BCH is an ideological fork for bigger blocks and no segwit. I think they are wrong, but they did it in a relatively responsible manner.

2X is straight up malware.

rothbardrand··on Bitcoin Pioneer Says New Coin to Work on Multiple Blockchains
Also, it's very notable that none of the people supporting the 2x scam understand bitcoin, either that or they tell lies about how it works to support the scam.

If you take the time to read the white paper and listen to the people who are explaining how things work you won't fall for the propaganda that has you posting this kind of nonsense.

But I do credit you for admitting that BTC1 is months behind.

rothbardrand··on Bitcoin Pioneer Says New Coin to Work on Multiple Blockchains
You know when you start by calling your opponents positions "propaganda" that it kinda impeaches your argument before you've even begun.

Bitcoin has already gone from 1-4mb max blocks this August, going to 8mb is unproven.... and it does reduce security because it increases centralization. The great firewall of china is a real thing, and I've seen first hand that 1mb blocks have trouble crossing it. Absolute number of full nodes is not a relevant measure in this issue... miner centralization is.

Untested is true... the 700 nodes that were spun up in the past could of days are not running a test network, and thus it is untested, and also 700 insta-clone AWS instances that are there just as part of the attack do not constitute testing.

The fact that BTC1 is months behind is in fact a problem, its one developer has clearly been working on his alt, and there's no indication that the code will be maintained going forward-- especially since it is months behind already.

I think it's hilarious to rephrase "Wanting to steal the bitcoin of SPV wallet users" as a "feature" of "not having to upgrade." BCH put in replay protection and did a good job of trying to be a good citizen and still people lost money.

You guys are flagrantly pushing malware that hides its nature and ARE going to cause people to lose funds... hell, you guys have been talking about straight up attacks on bitcoin as part of your attempt to launch your scam coin.

It's not hostile to disconnect incompatible nodes that are going to cause a hard fork-- you guys keep redefining terms and putting spin on your actions in a way that tells me that you know you're supporting a scam.

Nodes that do not follow the consensus rules will be disconnected anyway, this is the way bitcoin works, disconnecting immediately simple saves the network a lot of effort to discover the incompatibility... but hiding it is great if your goal-- as has been stated by you guys on multiple occasions-- to attack bitcoin.

rothbardrand··on Bitcoin Pioneer Says New Coin to Work on Multiple Blockchains
This doesn't really make sense. The thing that gives cryptocurrencies value is that they are scarce. The thing that gives them security is proof of work, allowing a distributed consensus algorithm that is hard to game.

Cryptocurrency isn't a source of magic money in the sense that you could tap it for a "basic income" type scheme-- where the recipients are not doing anything to earn it.

In cryptocurrency every actor in the system has a job that they do, namely, miners mine and that's how they get paid.

I'm not saying its impossible, it just seems like it doesn't make sense at first look.

rothbardrand··on Bitcoin Pioneer Says New Coin to Work on Multiple Blockchains
There's no evidence of that, more than %90 of miners are running core, and there are more businesses opposed to 2x than endorsing it: http://nob2x.org

Meanwhile "signers" of the New York "Agreement"[1] are dropping like flies, most recent Coinbase that says they will support the core chain.

Hell the biggest "proponents" of 2X aren't willing to risk their own bitcoin in a swap (eg: Ver who has backed out of such promises in the past too with BCH)

2X is nothing but a scam to get suckers to sell BTC for B2X while people like Ver sell B2X to get more BTC!

Its funny how the bitcoin haters talk about censorship-- reality is /r/bitcoin is not censored, but the entire 2x movement was done behind closed doors, with no peer review, with a heavily censored slack channel and mailing list-- that is if you can get on it in the first place... while bitcoin does all this in public.

2X hasn't had commits or serious work in months last I checked and I really feel sad for the people who bought the propaganda these scammers are selling.

[1] It's not an agreement when only one side agreed with itself.

rothbardrand··on Bitcoin Pioneer Says New Coin to Work on Multiple Blockchains
Economic incentives matter. Bitcoin has them right for making itself "digital gold"... but ethereum discovered the "be your own virtual altcoin at almost no cost and raise a bunch of money" application.
rothbardrand··on Bitcoin Pioneer Says New Coin to Work on Multiple Blockchains
I think lack of replay protection and making the nodes pretend to be core nodes makes the intentions clear.

If you're honest you don't need to deceive like that.

← PreviousPage 2 of 11Next →