HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rplst8

1,392 karma · joined September 5, 2011

submissionscomments
rplst8··on Robocalls Flooding Your Cellphone? Here’s How to Stop Them
How do they go about spoofing the source numbers? That seems like a huge security risk overall for the phone system.
rplst8··on Robocalls Flooding Your Cellphone? Here’s How to Stop Them
This is a great point - and was the primary idea behind charging for sending email by the message to combat spam. Someone years ago proposed that if we just charged 5 cents per message sent, most people would pay less than $5 a month while spammers would have to pay millions of dollars of the course of a year, making the business unprofitable.
rplst8··on What I believe II
First, I think you meant "Now substitute... 'innate linguistic capability' with 'innate technical interest'" right? Because it's the "interest in things" vs. "interest in people" argument that Damore uses, or did I miss the point entirely?

If I didn't, I simply have the following to offer: there are many, many fields that are dominated by either women or men. No one really knows why. Simply saying "sexism" and calling it a day doesn't give enough credence to the problem. It doesn't identify the root cause. And unless you merely want to treat symptoms, ignoring the root cause will cause the problem to fester.

rplst8··on [dead]
First, it depends on the age of the physician. At some point in the late 90s or early 00s most (if not all) of the medical boards require that doctors continue to take continuing education credits to keep up on changes in medicine. In addition they have to re-certify every 10 years. That was not the case in the past, and older doctors are grandfathered. But if you doctor is younger than 40, they will likely need to re-certify and keep up to date.

Second, the prevailing wisdom on low fat diets are still up in the air. AFAIK, the American Academy of Physicians and the American Heart Association have not changed their positions on low fat diets.

rplst8··on [dead]
If this is the case, then no one should lend any more credence to the term "full stack developer" than to the phrase "I like to work on all sorts of software" - because it's meaningless.

What I do know is that there are many dishonest types that will say they are "full stack" when they really aren't. Then there are others that will not lie on a resume and say they are, when they in fact aren't.

The reality is that any dev can learn to do both - but hiring managers want it all, now, for free, and with a smile.

All that said - the more disciplines and domains you use day to day, the worse off you are going to be IMO. Sure it's good be a polyglot, but specializing helps to hone and sharpen skills.

rplst8··on More than 60 women consider suing Google, claiming sexism and a pay gap
> the playing field is by no means level, and neither of us chose to be born into our respective families.

Agreed. However our parents did choose to have us, raise us, and give us the best fighting chance. Ignoring that ignores their hard work and skills to properly rear children. If in this new system we just give everyone a job and a good salary "because" then what incentivizes anyone to properly rear their children or give them anything other than the minimum the State mandates.

I'd argue that the drive to provide a better life for one's offspring is the fundamental building block of empathy. By society ignoring that capital that someone's parents built up in their children, you risk a change in behavior where parents say, "your life will be great because you will have a job and salary no matter what." Then, the very idea of love and empathy for one's offspring breaks down, and thereby in society as a whole.

rplst8··on More than 60 women consider suing Google, claiming sexism and a pay gap
I'm not sure what you are arguing in favor of exactly.

Say we do make actual individual merit the only factor in hiring and pay. Would those "unlucky" enough to have been born a starving child in Africa ever have a chance at getting a high paying IT job? Likely not, as they won't have the education or skills needed to do the work.

I'd argue your use of "luck" in all these cases is wrong. It's more like fortune, and that hiring and pay is tied to both individual merit, and the merit of your ancestors. And when I say ancestors, this is usually as little as 2 or 3 generations. A vast majority of those in the US are descendants of a wave of poor immigrants in the mid and late 19th century. Going back 4 or 5 generations on all sides of my family tree, no wealth of any significance was transferred down, other than work ethic and usually trying to give offspring the best chance they can. It was not by any means perfect, but I was the first in my family to go to college, earn a degree, and be "successful". Note: I'm defining successful as "more assets than debt". I'm not wealthy by any sense of the word but I have a stable income and I'm able to save for retirement and own a home (via mortgage).

If we take that merit out of the equation - what societal pressure or incentive is there to improve upon oneself, and make a better life for one's children?

rplst8··on More than 60 women consider suing Google, claiming sexism and a pay gap
Why should same responsibilities = same salary?

What if Joe and I and have the same responsibilities. Just to build working code. However, I can produce 100 working/tested lines of code a day and Joe can produce 150 lines of the same.

Joe isn't entitled to a higher salary because he's more talented?

rplst8··on Volkswagen executive pleads guilty in diesel emissions case
P.S. it's a tortious offence at best.
rplst8··on Volkswagen executive pleads guilty in diesel emissions case
There is such a thing as cruel and unusual punishment. Getting 100 years for that "crime" of essentially violating a regulation is preposterous.
rplst8··on Saluting Walt Mossberg’s career
I didn't downvote him - as far as I know you can't downvote replies to your own comments.

P.S. The other smart phone manufacturers are just as guilty, but Apple makes the most profit from externalizing their costs. The other phone manufacturers basically lose money on the operation AFAIK.

rplst8··on Saluting Walt Mossberg’s career
I 100% agree with you. When Mossberg left the WSJ this thread was on HN... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6414723

The tech press was then, and is now, a total joke compared to other forms of serious journalism.

I wrote this about Mossberg's colleague Kara Swisher a few years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8036679

I think my comments still stand.

The tech press is terrible at covering:

  - Energy Use/Efficiency of tech (not just laptops I'm talking datacenters, etc.)
  - Governance of the Internet
  - Privacy (until recently - sort of [and it still gets buried])
  - Software copyright issues
  - Market/monetary prospects for new tech 
    (I think the article sort of talks about the fear of 
     "crushing innovation")
  - Energy tech itself (new forms of power generation, batteries)
  - Tech in our lives (and I'm not talking about the fear card)
     - autonomous vehicles, medical devices, etc.
And Mossberg was and is part of the problem. It's pageantry for the common man rather than serious journalism.

Things have improved slightly since I wrote that 3 or 4 years ago but there is still waaaaaaay too much noise about Apple's latest widgets. Instead we should be hearing much more about the socioeconomic, political, and societal impacts that technology has and the fact that Apple's entire business model is centered around filling our landfills with their devices that become unusable with their latest version of iOS.

rplst8··on Improving air conditioner efficiency could reduce worldwide temps
CO2 per capita is not the only measure of absurdity.
rplst8··on Improving air conditioner efficiency could reduce worldwide temps
That's cheap for drilling from what I've been quoted. Most systems I looked at when I had a house before were in the $30k range installed.

I have three friends/co-workers that had the systems installed. None were particularly impressed with the average cost savings. They said bills went down, but not dramatically. One person had the whole system redone at the suggestion of another HVAC contractor (saying the first cut many corners) the re-done system wasn't much better.

While they may "pretty much never die" this is basically the "cheap on average, but expensive for the unlucky person" argument. This quickly turns into a prisoner's dilemma. No one buys because of potential repair costs, therefore everyone suffers (from higher bills, and eventually global warming).

Wells are not always an option depending on what your land is sitting on. If you are over a big granite deposit, good luck.

rplst8··on Improving air conditioner efficiency could reduce worldwide temps
I've said elsewhere in the thread, but insulation does little to help in the summer months. Fiberglass insulation mostly protects from convective cooling/heating (i.e. airflow). Heat in the summer is mostly through conduction and even more-so radiative (near infrared). Windows treatments could definitely help there, but unless you want everyone's windows to be mirrors, it likely won't help that much.
rplst8··on Improving air conditioner efficiency could reduce worldwide temps
Which requires another Carnot cycle.
rplst8··on Improving air conditioner efficiency could reduce worldwide temps
To be fair, if you die from a heat wave - you probably weren't going to last that much longer anyway.
rplst8··on Improving air conditioner efficiency could reduce worldwide temps
Having large groups living in mega city heat islands is also an absurd configuration but pretty much the entire world is guilty of that one.
rplst8··on Improving air conditioner efficiency could reduce worldwide temps
Good insulation is pretty standard here in the US for everything built in the last two decades or so.

That said, fiberglass insulation mostly only helps against convection cooling/heating. I.e. through the movement of air. Summertime heat is mostly conductive and radiative i.e. near infrared. Insulation doesn't do much to stop that.

Shade trees however help this big time. A large tree placed in the right spot to shade a house in the afternoon can replace as many as seven window air conditioner units.

rplst8··on Improving air conditioner efficiency could reduce worldwide temps
Yes. I was talking strictly about the air source style heat pumps and/or reverse Carnot cycle A/C units.

Everyone knows GS heat pumps are more efficient.

rplst8··on Improving air conditioner efficiency could reduce worldwide temps
Yes.
rplst8··on Improving air conditioner efficiency could reduce worldwide temps
Bingo!

WFH = less traffic, less industrial building construction, less heating/cooling of empty spaces (offices at night, homes during day), less indoor lighting usage (homes are usually very well lit from outside light while most cubical jungles are lit by fluorescent lighting).

Wanna save the environment? WFH!

rplst8··on Improving air conditioner efficiency could reduce worldwide temps
While it's not the best thing to do, it doesn't matter much as the efficiency of the systems go way way up when the outside temp is near the same as the inside temp.
rplst8··on Improving air conditioner efficiency could reduce worldwide temps
The challenge for these is the cost. First, you either have to drill wells that are ~500 feet deep or lay coils of tubing under your yard (if you have one) below the frost line. Doing either is expensive, though the wells are much more so. The downside of the cheaper option (the coils under yard) is that earth shifts, and the coils will too. I've had two separate friends install these (usually 4-6 separate coils) only to have the earth move and rip open a coil or kink it. Usually you have a valve for each one to shut it off so the unit can sill operate on the remaining working coils, however with each lost coil the efficiency goes down.

Also, the ground-source heat-pumps aren't cheap. They are in the $7-10k range - just for the unit - and not many people know how to repair them as they are a bit of a specialty item in the HVAC industry.

rplst8··on Improving air conditioner efficiency could reduce worldwide temps
There are standardized efficiency measurements that all A/C manufacturers must conduct and publish in the US. You'll see terms like COP, EER, and SEER. Those allow you to compare pretty easily.

Currently the minimum is a SEER of 13, but I've seen units as high as 22 advertised.

rplst8··on Improving air conditioner efficiency could reduce worldwide temps
Well, the efficiency of a heat pump/refrigerator is limited by Carnot's theorem. Essentially it boils down to the difference of the outside temperature compared to inside temperature. With an indoor temp of ~72F and outdoor ~90F the maximum efficiency is a COP of about 30. Current AC units are in the 2 to 4 range. So a 30% increase doesn't seem impossible that low on the efficiency scale. There was a recent similar jump in efficiency when the US raised the minimum SEER standards for new systems from 10 to 13.
rplst8··on Loudness (2007)
The effect you want - roughly the same volume through a whole track, can easily be achieved with tasteful use of compression. Some genres hardly need any to start with.

There are a number of albums that were mastered quite well that have a good dynamic range, yet still sound good in my car, on headphones, or at home on the big stereo.

The heavily compressed stuff just sounds bad all around.

Here's another good article that covers this: https://riprowan.com/over-the-limit/

rplst8··on A Slow-Motion Trainwreck Facing the Meal-Kit Industry
I disagree entirely. I cannot get the ingredients for most of Plated meals for what they charge. I end up with lots of spoiled food, unless I make huge batches and eat the same thing all week.
rplst8··on Iron Nitride Permanent Magnets – An Alternative to Rare Earth Magnets (2014)
It looks like the theoretical max for rare earth is not that straight forward. See the BH(max) column here:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rare-earth_magnet#Magnetic_pro...

rplst8··on Hyundai Whistle-Blower, in Rarity for South Korea, Prompts Recall
Manufacturers often use a term MTBF or "mean time between failure". I'm not sure if the 2000 hours spec is an MTBF or not, but essentially that is an average life with some standard deviation.

Personally, I think a pretty big swath of engines make it well past 100,000 miles now - there are usually other issues with cars at about the 10 to 15 year mark with most makes and models that have to do with rust.

Designing engines that last significantly longer on average (say 250,000 miles) would require either a beefier design, which will add weight and reduce efficiency, or exotic materials that will significantly increase the cost.

Automobiles are pretty amazing for what they are. I agree with many others that they have gotten ridiculously complex, but this is mostly because of the emissions requirements - and that said I do enjoy the fact that smog is not much of an issue (at least in the US) these days.

← PreviousPage 8 of 19Next →