HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rscoots

12 karma · joined March 6, 2021

submissionscomments
rscoots··on Google Drive bans distribution of “misleading content”
Who at Google do you trust to decide what information you and I are allowed to know? What is this person's qualifications?

How can they be held to account when they inevitably get it wrong?

Where will the highly-transparent write-ups detailing moderation decisions be published?

Seems like if Google actually gave a damn about the morality of censorship as some sort of 'neccessary evil' you'd be able to answer these questions easily^. Until then, it's a non-starter in my book.

rscoots··on Facebook's “see no evil” strategy
Who at Facebook do you trust to decide who is a "sober voice" that will be artificially promoted after the organically popular are censored?

What is this person's qualifications?

How can they be held to account when they inevitably get it wrong?

Where will the highly-transparent write-up detailing this decision making be published?

Before these Q's are answered I don't want FB touching their algorithms at all.

rscoots··on Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of reporters, news outlets
I couldn't find any clips.

My parent comment has been downvoted a bunch. Why?

rscoots··on EU unveils sweeping climate change plan
This part was always the most surprising to me. How are people expected to travel long distances individually in the future?

Wouldn't other carbon-reducing initiatives lessen the need for banning gas-powered calls altogether?

rscoots··on Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of reporters, news outlets
When did this happen?

Genuinely curious

rscoots··on Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of reporters, news outlets
> Being blocked from twitter is ... a non-event.

Good, then by extension leaving the person on Twitter is also a non-event. So it seems there is no need for censorship here!

rscoots··on Twitter sees jump in govt demands to remove content of reporters, news outlets
>Trump was a bigger threat to journalism while he was in office than any content moderation rules Twitter could ever enforce.

Besides idle threats to "open up the libel laws" and temporarily blocking random journos from white house events, I don't see how this could possibly be true.

Two things can be bad at once. In measurable terms I'd say opaque, coordinated social media bans are the greater and more permanent of the evils here. We can't deflect to Trump forever.

rscoots··on Man Wrongfully Arrested by Facial Recognition Tells Congress His Story
Everyone mentions 'training sets' in 2021 as if the experts in this field have not been well aware of this issue for decades.

Even balanced training sets produce disparate levels of accuracy between races. It would seem computers are just less capable of recognizing certain faces.

I've never heard it also affects women though.

rscoots··on Man Wrongfully Arrested by Facial Recognition Tells Congress His Story
Yea but I think almost by definition the software will find a person that looks very similar to the actual perp. So then subsequent humans are more likely to make the mistake.

I don't see how this is much different than artist's sketches or just using the video itself, other than cops might put more undue stock in the software, and the obvious potential for mass surveillance.

rscoots··on HK media erase their archives amid rising arrests
>offer US citizenship to Hong Kong era that want it.

Can someone fill me in on how this would causally improve the prospects for Hong Kong's freedom?

rscoots··on Facebook keeps recommending political groups
>The fact that you consider all activities queer folk do to be adjacent to politics is so frustrating.

First of all I want to make clear I do not think this and never said this. But yes, many would consider LGBT groups to be a "politically adjacent topic" (to quote myself), just as groups like gun enthusiasts or crime watch networks would be. If literacy became a political hot topic then yes, book clubs would be politically adjacent too.

No one here is arguing Facebook or anyone else should consider your particular LGBT group 'political' though because it clearly is not.

>The core of the issue is when you have political figureheads very carefully craft a narrative where all LGBT existence is political.

In fact the "core" of this entire post, topic, and thread is Facebook censorship, not political narratives around LGBT issues. I share your opinion that even modern liberal society is way behind on the issue you bring up, but that's all the more reason to distrust labeling by FB. So sorry for the confusion, but I'm glad we agree groups like yours should not be censored.

rscoots··on Facebook keeps recommending political groups
>Because the answer is no, LGBT youth groups aren't political

None of them can ever be political? Really?

Obviously groups realted to any politically-adjacent topic can run the gambit from entirely political to totally divorced from any politics or activism.

I thought you were implying the first poster was not aware of that fact is all.

Regardless, thinking Facebook (or anyone) is in any sort of position to decide this is a total farce, at least to my eyes.

(Waited to post... Got my account rate limited cuz my fellow liberals downvoted me w/o comment. Seems like HN might not be a good place for reasonable discussion on controversial topics.)

rscoots··on US ranks last among 46 countries in trust in media
And the evidence given for that influence was number of channels. Same reason John Oliver gave in his segment.

I don't wanna go back-and-forth on this too much tho sorry.

rscoots··on US ranks last among 46 countries in trust in media
Then why talk about the number of channels they have when this is what you actually mean? Like I said, it just strikes me as dishonest in that specific way.
rscoots··on Facebook keeps recommending political groups
I think that was the poster's whole point though.

Name the people you trust at Facebook to make that same distinction you just made in your post.

Name the process you as a consumer can use to hold those at Facebook to account when they inevitably get it wrong.

Point me to the highly-transparent records of how and when Facebook employees made that decision.

Obviously none of the above exists and that is the core issue.

rscoots··on Canada: Hundreds of unmarked graves found at residential school
Ahh yes, generating a large righteous and hungry movement with no good ideas in place. What could possibly go wrong?

I'm sure there are initiatives and policy changes the govt is pursuing in this space. We'd do well to learn about them if we do truly care.

rscoots··on US ranks last among 46 countries in trust in media
But for the Senate the size discrepancy is at the state level not within state races. A senator from Connecticut has less constituents than Texas but still has to win a pure majority in Connecticut.

In any case I think you'll agree this is now a much narrower point about Sinclair than ppl like Oliver intended to make.

(Got my account rate limited cuz too many fellow liberals downvoted me w/o comment. Seems like HN might not be a good place for reasonable discussion on controversial topics.)

rscoots··on US ranks last among 46 countries in trust in media
That comparing 2 randomly selected companies does nothing to measure the total left/right viewership and engagement of news broadcasts.

Why downvote if you didn't understand my point?

rscoots··on US ranks last among 46 countries in trust in media
MSNBC is not a local network and is not the only liberal TV news broadcast in the country. Neither is Sinclair the only conservative.
rscoots··on US ranks last among 46 countries in trust in media
Why mention company size and not the far more relevant total viewership #s?
rscoots··on US ranks last among 46 countries in trust in media
I'm on the left but I always saw the argument of

>how many local news outlets are owned by the conservative Sinclair Broadcast Group.

...to itself be dishonest 'journalistic' spin, in this case perpetuated by John Oliver among others. "How many" local news outlets is irrelevant when you consider a vast majority of Sinclair's outlets are for tiny rural channels, meanwhile large urban and coastal channels will undoubtedly skew more liberal but be fewer in #.

When else has the metric of "how many channels" ever been used to determine reach and engagement?

Not sure of the numbers, just wanted to point this out.

rscoots··on Out-of-control Chinese rocket expected to fall to Earth in the coming days
Citing Wikipedia aside, the WHO exists in large part to get large, competing nations to cooperate on matters of public health. This often involves placating these nations.

You should take some time to read up on the many respected and qualified institutions who've done a much deeper dive on this "conspiracy theory" than the WHO ever intended to.

rscoots··on The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think
Good Q.

This comment and the subject of the article remind me of a very unrelated article I just read about obscenities.

"...[societal] concern [about obscenety] has been transferred from the sexual and scatological to the sociological"

The middle finger emoji doesn't raise an eyebrow today but would've been unthinkable in the not-so-distant past. Today we've got the best and the brightest invested in cracking the hard cases around skin tone instead.

rscoots··on Police Kill Too Many People–White and Black (2016)
Yup.

Vast majority of policing jobs youre right are pretty mundane and not esp dangerous. Policing in high crime areas can at times be a different ballgame though and more stressful/dangerous than the average would suggest.

rscoots··on Police Kill Too Many People–White and Black (2016)
>The UK is 0.5. I come from the UK, it has plenty of violent people in it.

Far, far more violent crime in the US. And there's essentially no guns in the UK.

Even still, rates have been falling in the US to my knowledge.

Edit: For perspective, I live in Chicago. There are usually 80-100+ shootings a weekend here. Since all US cops have guns that means cops just in 1 city could theoretically shoot 100 people a weekend and technically be justified. This really isn't the case in any other "rich" country as you put it.

Not that this doesn't mean there's not huge issues with policing and society, it just doesn't make sense to compare US to other countries.

rscoots··on Prank Windows XP simulator
Great stuff! But where are the Windows Vista references?
rscoots··on Facebook prevents sharing New York Post story on BLM co-founder's real estate
Yes, facebook is known for its strong stances regarding "privacy and personal information"

What's glaring is that there's not even a veneer of consistency in this decision. Will they now be going back and censoring all articles that could lead to someone's residence? All future articles?

Of course they won't. They're content to be self-evidently biased on this point. As a liberal this troubles me.

rscoots··on A Facebook content moderator’s resignation note
This podcast from last year answers all these questions. Although the answers are not encouraging...

Very eye-opening stuff: https://youtu.be/qv_hokG2oSo

rscoots··on YouTube suspends account for linking to a PhD research on WPA2 vulnerability
That post really does read like a parody haha.

Such a desire to shield mega-corporations from any moral culpability since they think it serves their personal sensibilities. Very naive.

rscoots··on RMS addresses the free software community
Then why invoke the "hundreds or thousands" point at all?

Seems irrelevant and sort of crass given the gravity of the other qualms you have.

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →