669 karma · joined August 20, 2014
Oh don't mind me, just pulling excuses out of my ass. I love posts like these and I especially love their graphs. Less so for the (little) content they contain. More so for people's reactions to the content. Its confirmation bias bait all the way down!
I don't mean to be so negative and critical. I'm just tired of people trying to explain the state of the world from a single graph!
Income inequality could be increasing for different reasons at different times. It might not be increasing at all (depending on how you define income)!
---
Let's stop drooling over graphs and have an actual conversation about the "problem". Who am I richer than and why? Who is richer than me and why? Maybe if we answer these questions we can solve income inequality (assuming we still want to solve it all).
I don't forgive Trump or Acosta for the way they behave. If you're caught in a loop, it is your responsibility to break out. So I criticize Acosta for this indiscretion and I criticize Trump for past and future indiscretions.
This is his only argument in the piece:
> [Restaurants] were in fact opening; employment in food services and drinking establishments has soared.
But does that data support his conclusion? Could Seattle's population growth explain the gains in restaurant employment? Why a chart starting from 1990 for a law passed in 2018? Has enough time elapsed to understand the impact of the law? Was the downturn in restaurant employment in 2018 related to the minimum wage law?
Though I love it, let's skip the Socratic dialogue. The $15/hr minimum wage does not go into effect until January 1st 2019! Let's wait and see how customer's react to higher prices before declaring victory.
This library is considered "pre-release" until I've written docs and added better test coverage.
If Ohio's steel industry grows by 500% who reaps the benefits? Me? The guy writing code in Portland, Oregon?
No... its pretty clear that a specific subset of people receive the benefits. The people who own the steel mill. The people who receive employment from the steel mill. The governments which tax the steel mill. But not me.
Economic growth isn't uniform. Its an uneven field that benefits some and not others. That's why people move and change jobs. That's why societies abandon old interests and embrace new interests.
I don't know why anyone should feel entitled to economic growth if they didn't participate in it in any way.
> 0 peers.
> Refreshes YouTube.
> 500.
> Realize the internet is a distraction from what is really fulfilling and meaningful in life.
> YouTube's back up.
> Watch "Micheal Jackson's 'Bad' but Every Time he says 'bad' the Music Speeds Up".
He was rejected from our universal healthcare system because of the astronomical costs of keeping a 96 year old man (with a life ending disease) alive.
Those costs exist under every system regardless of whether or not the customer sees those costs.
This is not a defense of our "private" healthcare system. This is a defense of our public healthcare system. They made the rational decision to focus their resources on younger people with better chances of recovery. Dr. Lederman made the rational choice to sell his Nobel prize to extend his life. At least that option was available to him! The same can't be said for people like Charlie Gard.
That was understood in my post. Long periods of paid leave inhibits earnings growth and leaves you vulnerable to replacement regardless of gender.
This is what was meant by "Fixing the pay gap between never-married women and mothers will solve the gender pay gap as a corollary."
> Women are being treated differently here because when a man and woman decide to have a child, the woman is guaranteed to have to take leave.
Yes there is a guaranteed recovery period. And, yes, depending on how long you are absent this leave will effect earnings. But...
> men don't get the same treatment despite being fathers
Men who take long paternity leave suffer the same income stagnation as women.
"Still, most men can’t afford to take more than a few days off after the birth of a new child. Especially because parental leave can depress long-term earnings [...] regardless of gender."[1]
Compelling paternity leave does not increase the earnings of mothers. It decreases the earnings of fathers. Which may very well shrink the gender wage gap but it makes families poorer and less able to provide for themselves and their children.
To be trite, you're cutting off your nose to spite your face.
> I view this more as spreading the burden
This, I believe, is our fundamental disagreement. You think a burden is being spread more thinly whereas I think you've created additional burdens. In my opinion, and I believe the data backs me up, this strategy reduces fathers and does nothing to help mothers (economically).
1. https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/12/the-ris...
For two reasons. One simple and one complex.
The first and simple reason is that you're applying rules categorically. If I live in a multi-generational household I don't need to stay home and care for the children to the same degree as a more "typical" family. Compelling me to stay home reduces my earnings with no added benefit to my wife or family. In fact you've hindered my family's ability to progress economically. You've hurt a specific woman to help the average woman. As I've illustrated above, the average woman does not exist. Mandatory leave helps a statistical category but not women.
The second more complex reason has more to do with economics.
We already know that women who have never married earn more than men of the same category (the gap is not large or worth considering).
> As far back as 1971, single women in their thirties who had worked continuously since high school earned slightly more than men of the same description. As far back as 1969, academic women who had never married earned more than academic men who had never married.[1]
From this we can gleam two things. 1: Women are not being "treated differently based on the circumstances of their birth" (at least in a way that disadvantages them in terms of salary). 2: Mothers are being treated differently based on their behaviors.
I hope the first statement is self-explanatory but the second might need additional context.
How does an employer know if a women will give birth in the next five years? The obvious answer is "they don't". So if that's the case how do businesses know to pay mothers less than never-married women? Because they're not paying mothers less. They're paying never-married women more. People with more continuous years of service are more able to capitalize on opportunities in the workplace and are never in a position to be rendered redundant by a replacement.
If you compel men to take paternal leave, you open them up to all the detriments that mothers face. You take a family who's member has already taken an earnings hit and doubled down.
The gender wage gap (as it exists in the United States in 2018) is not a concern. Efforts to fix the gap will result in lower wages for fathers not higher wages for women (the terms "fathers" and "women" were chosen with significant care).
tl;dr: Fixing the pay gap between never-married women and mothers will solve the gender pay gap as a corollary.
1. https://www.nationalreview.com/2016/08/pay-gap-studies-dispr...
I didn't push a human being out from between my legs. Because of that I'm capable of working. I would like to be useful to my family. Working is one way I can do that.
If I work while my wife is on leave and the gender pay gap is worsened. I don't care. If my wife stays home to recover from her ordeal and the gender wage gap is worsened. She doesn't care.
The gender wage gap is so abstract and cynical at this point. It is beyond meaning. People aren't allow to live their lives the way they see fit because of some stupid number.
Shocking I know but there is no such thing as the "average woman". If her wage is different from the "average man" it has no bearing on the earnings of a specific woman with specific goals and habits.
I know you did not explicitly argue against this idea but I do think you inferred that his position was correct and decried others for "conspiratorial" thinking.
It's good to remember that we are all vulnerable to this sort of half-baked thinking. Even though most people think they're the only rational person in the room.
---
> The problem of racial and ethnic disproportionality in imprisonment appears to be less about criminal justice practitioner racism but rather societal inequities that foster higher rates of serious, especially violent, crime among blacks and to a lesser extent, Hispanics. These inequities include racial segregation and isolation and the resulting concentration of disadvantage in black and Hispanic communities. Such structural disadvantage, in turn, has long been linked to higher rates of violent crime.[1]
Taxes may be excessive but lower if the services received for the taxes are inferior or undesirable. Or if the tax is raised in regressive or arbitrary ways.
Germany may have a large, effective bureaucracy while Spain may have a smaller, corrupt bureaucracy. This I believe is demonstrated by the "Corruption Perception Index".
Welfare states really have nothing to do with how regimented society is.