669 karma · joined August 20, 2014
Yes. Though that method is more inefficient than the ones we already have.
The Constitution's purpose is the suppression of the majority. At every end it is designed to impede 'progress'.
Three houses of government, a bi-cameral legislature, voting rules which require large majorities of representatives, voting rules which require large majorities of states, differing term lengths, and "hard" limits on federal power (admittedly this section of the constitution has failed).
If we wanted the majority to get what they wanted we would just vote in referendums.
Consider a scenario where there are two retired teachers for every working teacher. To the working teacher they are underpaid. To the voters they are overpaid. The problem lies in the middle. If you stopped paying retired teachers you could triple the salaries of working teachers. Both parties would be satisfied with this arrangement.
Of course retired teachers would hate this and rightfully so. They were promised a pension and now you're denying it to them.
It calls into question the structure of compensation. Throw their money into a 401k rather than giving them 80-100% pay for the rest of their lives.
Consider the argument: "can an Uber driver save for retirement?" If we define Uber driver as: "works for uber exclusively for 40 hours per week". Our answer to the question might be yes or it might be no. Ultimately what matters is the number of people who fall into that category every day for the rest of their lives.
If we find no people fit that category or that the people who do fit that category don't fit it for very long then we can safely say the answer to the question is irrelevant.
After all, "can unpaid interns save for retirement?" is a meaningless question. It doesn't matter. Statistical categories don't retire. And people who work as unpaid interns do not remain so for very long.
A person who drivers for Uber may just need quick, supplemental cash. Cash that may be exclusively funneled into a person's retirement account.
If we compel Uber to provide a "living wage" or a retirement package, we may find that those who need quick cash go without it. And people who would have saved for retirement are now not able to.
A better question would be: "do you think an Uber driver who (a) lives alone (b) in a two bedroom apartment (c) in the heart of San Francisco and (d) works 20 hours per week will be able to save $5500/year?" The answer is no. But there is a lot more to the problem than just "Uber driver".
Save a minimum of $5500/year or 10% of your annual salary. Whichever is greater (up to your cap).
Citation needed[0].
0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_research_...
That's basically how I exist now (excluding the "Walmart" prefix).
I sit, I eat, I play video games, I'm somewhat dressed. What do you imagine people with a "nice looking house with their nice looking family" do on the weekends? The middle class doesn't have some secret club we all attend.
You're so worried about "losing" something that you're forgoing the creation of something new and better.
But if I can attempt an answer. I believe it is libertarian in the sense that it does not require a large bureaucracy with onerous rules and regulations controlling the funds distribution and use.
The money is available to everyone for any use. The government may just serve as a pass-through entity.
> If everyone is entitled to a basic income as a matter of right, that means others must be coerced into handing over the fruits of their labor.
...is not an approrpiate response. Just because the government is funded through income at present doesn't mean its the only way to fund government. You could fund the government (and UBI) with a land-value-tax, for example.
If you remember your accounting courses: assets are equal to the sum of all liabilities and equity. Meaning mortgage debt and home equity combine to form your total home assets. A person may have $1m in assets and $900k in liabilities. Or a person could have $200k in assets but $50k in liabilities. Which person is more "wealthy".
I suppose its a matter of opinion because, after all, we haven't defined a goal. Is a low debt to equity ratio desirable? Depends on what you're trying to accomplish. Is high cash flow desirable? As an end state, yes that's desirable but what if that end state requires a large amount of debt to achieve?
My point being we should not rely on government agencies as our source of truth.
Additionally, the misuse (or overuse) of "snake oil" is becoming cliche. This hangover cure may work or it may not. But it certainly isn't snake oil because it has a limited scope of operation. And, until proven otherwise, was created as an honest attempt to alleviate hangover symptoms. Rather than being a callous money grab at the expense of people's health.
Hah! I didn't say you couldn't have an opinion on it. Only that you can't know the world that "could have been".
> Also what does net present value have to do with any of this?
Squander is a word which means to waste. If a government project has a net economic (or public health) benefit then by definition the money was not squandered.
There are only two stereotypical places I can think of it being "squandered". The first is the military which, who knows, could be NPV if you consider what the world could be like without it. Ultimately its unknowable. The second is the money not taxed. Which is a particularly frustrating mindset that I encounter on the internet.
In either case, we're not "squandering" money anywhere. You may disagree with the allocation of some resources but that doesn't mean its been squandered.
> America is mighty but that doesn't translate into the life quality of its citizens at all.
Countries can vary in development and quality of life but your original statement is demonstrably false.
> The economy of alleged US nemesis Russia is less than 9% as large as the US economy and hasn’t grown consistently in years.
Argument from incredulity.
> The genome of the Octopus shows a staggering level of complexity with 33,000 protein-coding genes more than is present in Homo sapiens.
Red herring.
> this “great leap forward” in complexity was due to “cryopreserved squid and/or octopus eggs” crashing into the ocean on comets millions of years ago
No evidence provided to support this claim. In addition, Cephalopoda is a very well documented clade. Meaning we have fossilized evidence the octopuses originated and developed on this planet.
> crashing into the ocean on comets millions of years ago.
Probabilistic fallacy. Interstellar objects in our solar system are rare (only one ever documented). Comets seeded with eggs have never been documented and should be considered exceedingly rare. The number of comets that ever make contact with Earth is very, very low.
On a more serious note, being young makes it appears as though the congress-person is taking advantage of an "impressionable" employee. Being good looking makes it look like the relationship only exists because of the congress-person's rank.