HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

russnewcomer

1,034 karma · joined January 26, 2011

"Full Stack Developer", also was once a Mobile App Developer, IT Generalist. Midwest USA now, other time in non-American counties. Software for agriculture, manufacturing, worked in education for a while.

username same at the google mail service

submissionscomments
russnewcomer··on The Voyeur's Motel
This is a pretty disturbing article, and I feel like Talese should have reported Foos to the local authorities. Foos is clearly a serial sexual offender, and should have been reported or at the very least put into treatment. Talese admits that Foos is an unreliable narrator and is pretty clearly a voyeur for sexual purposes, mentally shielding himself by saying, "oh, I'm just a researcher."

Journalism is one thing. This is enabling a predator, just as much as Foos' two wives.

russnewcomer··on Why are Americans so angry?
You are correct, and what I should have said was something closer to

"You're depending on the answers from 1018 people to be statistically relevant, and they may not be because by the end of the survery people just hurriedly say whatever to get the survey over with, and I'd bet that 50% of the answers should probably be discounted, so you're depending on what may not be a statistically relevant survery, since America is a big, big country, to drive your thinking on that country."

russnewcomer··on Why are Americans so angry?
Well, I am personally skeptical that those well-established models and prior theories are a) being followed and b) as effective as thought. More a) than b).

But my greater skepticism comes from basing policy or expectations of a country on simplifications. Again, I wonder if they asked the same number of people if the same questions and subbed out disappointed for angry if they would get a significantly different response?

russnewcomer··on Why are Americans so angry?
Maybe I'm just too skeptical of these types of stories coming from generic polling, but I will say that I don't have a high degree of confidence in polling done by random phone calls (the CNN/ORC poll listed says that on page 14 [1]). My wife frequently answers the political poll questions when people call, in part because she feels sorry for the poller. Answering those calls can take 15-30 minutes. So you're depending on the results of people who have 15-30 minutes to answer 35 questions about the government. I feel like there's a selection bias at work there already, and you're assuming that people will give thoughtful answers to the questions, that the order of questions doesn't affect responses, etc, etc, etc. You're depending on 1018 people who actually may not be statistically relevant, since America is a big, big country, to drive your thinking on that country.

Plus, would the responses to the surveys be different if the word 'disappointed' was used instead of angry? And would the perception of the responses be different?

Secondarily, and this is far more anecdotal, but I am friends with a fairly wide swath of people via social media, from conservatives to libertarians to liberals to progressives. The key takeaway that I have from watching all of their posting and all of their interactions is that people are angry at others. And people have always been easily angered by others, it's just that the modern American landscape allows for a) easier access to others and b) easier access to well-written, rational condemnation of others than can be easily shared. But reading through my feed,

Maybe Americans aren't actually angry, but since it's easier to construct understandable stories using language like anger, Americans feel like they should be angry?

[1]http://edition.cnn.com/2015/12/29/politics/cnn-orc-poll-full...

russnewcomer··on Al Jazeera America to Shut Down in April
This is unfortunate but expected. Al Jazeera has a severely unfair reputation in America, and most people probably had no idea of the difference between AJ(Qatar) and AJ(America). Hopefully they will continue to have coverage in America, and this doesn't actually mean their total exit of America-based reporting.
russnewcomer··on Bill Ford Isn't Scared of Apple
Mr. Levy - do you see a parallel between Bill Ford and someone like Lou Gertsner? I wonder if Ford could have the same trajectory as IBM here?
russnewcomer··on When Are You Really an Adult?
I don't have any utopian view of life in Russia or anywhere. And I was not intending to make a statement about modern Russia or really Russian culture, more about my observations from reading classic Russian literature. I think modern Russia has, like America, a confluence of old and new philosophies that contend with each other, and produce different results different places in culture.

But in my thinking on this subject, at least, there is a difference between dependency and responsibility that I think maybe doesn't come across the best.

russnewcomer··on When Are You Really an Adult?
I've frequently thought this over the past few years, and I feel like the conclusion I have is different than others in this thread.

I don't becoming an adult is really about you, exactly. It's not about your independence, or your actions.

It's about when other people become dependent on you.

I think this is the way that it has long been thought of in cultures outside of the post-Enlightenment West. This was my strong opinion after reading Dostoyevsky, Tolstoy, (Russia isn't western like the rest of Europe) and Aquinas, Augustine, and Aristotle. I think that this is in part what the Apostle Paul is saying in 1 Corinithians 13:11 ( http://www.esvbible.org/1+Corinthians+13%3A11/ ), where you'll note that he doesn't say the equivalent of stopping to be like a child meant I had become a man, but rather I became a man, so I stopped being like a child.

I think about soldiers I have met and know. They change when they get to NCO status. I think of the boys I have met from North Omaha, which is arguably one of the worst places in America for young African American males, and that there is a difference between the ones who are the oldest in their families and the ones who are the youngest, even if they are the same age. And I think of my friends, and how we've changed when we've had kids, or when someone started a business and got ( real, not just one of his buddies-while-still-in-high-school ) employees.

Adulthood isn't about you, it's about your relationship to others.

russnewcomer··on Most violence in the world is motivated by moral sentiments
You make a compelling argument based on your presuppositions.

If one doesn't hold a Christian theology based around total depravity, then yes, sin does seem like an arbitrary construct. In fact, even among Christians who hold to essentially similar theological views, there is disagreement about what actions are disobedient to God's instructions, and that's not an easy task to sort through.

As for if I would be willing to substitute any definition of God, no, I wouldn't. But my argument still holds up due to my personal presupposition that the Christian Scriptures are the inspired Word of God, and other religions that deny part or all of them are not correct.

Again, this is heading way off topic for the article, so if you are interested in continuing, feel free to email.

russnewcomer··on Most violence in the world is motivated by moral sentiments
It seems, based on your comment, that you have experienced Christian practice not meeting Christian teaching, which saddens me.

Sin, in Christian theology based around total depravity, is not 'essentially not being Christian enough', but is rather a failure to obey God. As I said before, this is an area where different religious backgrounds or experiences make discussing this issue difficult.

I certainly don't mean to say that Christians are less violent, but that they should be.

This feels like a discussion quickly falling away from the article and off-topic for the thread, so if you'd like to continue it, feel free to email me, my username at gmail.

russnewcomer··on Most violence in the world is motivated by moral sentiments
I'm not sure that I expressed myself the best above based on your response, but partly that's because of the difficulty in discussing topics like this across religious traditions.

I would disagree that violence is caused by the judgement, 'you are right, I am wrong'. I think that violence is ultimately caused by sin, vis a vis Augustinian total depravity. But the justification for violence, often among Christians, is self-righteousness (or put another way, pride).

But again, this is a difficult issue to discuss between religions because the basic assumptions are different and terminology has slightly different meanings.

russnewcomer··on Most violence in the world is motivated by moral sentiments
I'd guess that the opposing hypothesis would be that violence is economically /politically/religiously motivated. Maybe thought of as extrinsic versus intrinsic motivation?
russnewcomer··on Most violence in the world is motivated by moral sentiments
A pastor of mine once talked about this in context of Martin Luther and Zwingli ( in context of the Kappel Wars ), and talked about how violence is often the moral outgrowth of those who have grown so assured of their righteousness (in a Christian context) that they felt they could not sin by committing violence. He pointed to Matthew 5:21-26 and 5:38-47 (The Sermon on the Mount) to bolster his argument against violence by Christians, and I feel that it is generally a correct one. (Further strengthened by Romans 12:9-21) Thus, the case laid out in this article is one that I agree with, generally. It's a case long laid out by a succession of Christian Theologians, albeit using different language.
russnewcomer··on C.S. Lewis' Greatest Fiction: Convincing Kids That They'd Like Turkish Delight
It's almost assuredly a splitting of hairs, but having read a decent amount of Lewis, and knowing a bit about the times and places he lived in, I think Lewis would admit to having a conscious bias against Islam, but not a conscious one against Muslims. (A bias against the belief system, not against the people that practice it)

His use of Turkish Delight is, I have heard, thought of as a personal thing, that Lewis as a young boy would have been mightily tempted by Turkish Delight.

Knowing also the yelling that goes back and forth between Christians and Muslims about bits and bobs in the other's corpus of literature and culture, I'd imagine that it is as much planned anti-Muslim bias as unintentional.

russnewcomer··on Show HN: Lasergist.com – Your custom design in pure, laser-cut Stainless Steel
USA, yep. Glad to see that you've got all of the obvious wrinkles thought through and planned for. Here's hoping you have to buy a new laser soon!
russnewcomer··on Show HN: Lasergist.com – Your custom design in pure, laser-cut Stainless Steel
Since you're European, I just wanted to tweak you on Mazak v Trumpf. :)

Again, not telling you how to run your business, but I think you may face a large number of unhappy customers because of poor understanding of how laser cutting actually works. I hope someone is manually reviewing parts before you make them, because it would be bad overall if a LaserGist customer's one-off bad part path caused issues on your other parts, presumably for more regular, high volume clients.

Really, good luck! I just may order something in the near future. Ships by Christmas?

russnewcomer··on Show HN: Lasergist.com – Your custom design in pure, laser-cut Stainless Steel
This is a great idea and I wish you guys success, I really do.

I just hope your margins are high enough, or you're doing this on the side your company's main business, because your prices seem extremely low to me. (Also, Mazak over Trumpf?)

I worked for a while (albeit approximately ten years ago now, but still) for a custom fab shop that did a lot of custom business with lasers (for industry, not consumer, generally), and I have a fair idea of the cost of lasers, the stainless you're using, and probable cost of development for the software toolchain you put together for this. And I hope you're using something like SigmaNEST or ProNest and not just chunking down rectangles for your parts, because that would help your costs considerably. It sounds like, from your description, that you are, and that you're using cutouts from other parts to do it, which will hopefully help your costs.

And I would be worried about high-rework costs or low customer satisfaction due to heat issues from people who don't understand laser, or hole locations, etc, etc, etc?

But you probably have already thought of all this, and don't need a random internet commenter to bring it all up. I had wanted to do something like this when I worked at the custom fab shop, but I didn't have the time to develop the toolchain necessary to do it all in 2005-7, so I guess I'm a little jealous.

Good luck!

russnewcomer··on Show HN: LawPatch – JQuery for Law Using Git
I like this idea in general, as a non-lawyer who tries to read things I'm signing, but I wonder if foot-noting or other in-document attribution system is a better answer? I can see struggles where a contract written with LawPatch is consulted in 10-15 years, and there are dead links or other similar technical problems. I don't see where LawPatch addresses that, unless I'm missing something?
russnewcomer··on Oh, Go Ahead, Overthink FizzBuzz (2008)
Yeah, we only gave that candidate the document because we were had just come up with it, we figured he would completely ace it. When he came back with really bad answers for all of the questions (including, "I've never heard of Powershell and I'm not sure how I would use it to do this" in 2012 with claiming the last 10 years as a Windows admin), my boss called me into his office and we just stared at the answers in shock.

Awesome. I was a bigger Total Annihilation fan/community member than I was for Homeworld, but still, it tickles me when I see names I recognize from gaming being 'real people' somewhere on the internet years later.

russnewcomer··on Nintendo Controller Teardown
It's pretty impressive to look at and consider the differences in the complexity of the circuit boards in successive generations.

It would be very interesting if someone had a chart of BOM costs for the various controllers and systems, to see if the budget for controllers has changed since the NES/Famicon days.

Also of course, if Nintendo really wanted to make a killing, putting the original NES in a controller and selling that with an HDMI port on the end would be sweet. I'd pay $50 for a low-hassle, no-legal-ambiguities way to play NES games with my kid.

russnewcomer··on A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists
Maybe it's not a bits and bytes technical problem, but it's technical according to the definition of the adjective, "of or relating to a particular subject, art, or craft, or its techniques." If the Paris police had the information, but were unable to properly analyze it, that's completely a technical problem.
russnewcomer··on Oh, Go Ahead, Overthink FizzBuzz (2008)
In general, I would agree with you. In that particular case (which I remember because the person with 20+ years of experience was recommended by a client), that person claimed they had written their own CRM system.

(Way, way off topic, but are you the ceejayoz who used to be a Homeworld webmaster? I spent a month or so of my life on Homeworld in late 2000, fun times.)

russnewcomer··on A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists
Metadata analysis and pattern recognition of publicly available data is one.

Better data organization tools are another (a family member is studying forensic science and has done internships with large-ish police departments that still largely use printed and hand-written documents to manage cases)

But that's my point. I haven't done much thinking on this either, so I can't see around the corners of time to see what it could be. But just more yelling back and forth about encryption isn't accomplishing much.

Maybe it's not a bits and bytes technical problem, but it's technical according to the definition of the adjective, "of or relating to a particular subject, art, or craft, or its techniques." If the Paris police had the information, but were unable to properly analyze it, that's completely a technical problem.

russnewcomer··on Oh, Go Ahead, Overthink FizzBuzz (2008)
I worked for a while for an IT services company. For our entry level tech support position, I put together a quick interview document that we emailed applicants, asking them 4 questions. They had to help someone fix their printer via email, fix their email client, write a powershell script to copy files from one directory to another, and solve FizzBuzz.

We honestly didn't care if they blatantly plagiarized the answers (especially on the last two), because the point was the right answer as much to see if they knew enough vocabulary to know how to Google the question.

Out of 30 responses, including recent college graduates with good GPAs, people claiming 20+ years of IT experience, owning their own IT consulting firm, etc, not one of them got all four right. Some even said, "I don't know how to solve this" on FizzBuzz.

The person who actually got them all correct? My wife, an ESL teacher who I gave the questions as a control, and told her to not spend more than 15 minutes on them.

Anyone who overthinks FizzBuzz is an automatic hire in my book. (yes, I know about http://www.joelonsoftware.com/items/2005/01/27.html )

russnewcomer··on A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists
I am not saying that it is 'only' or that they are entirely guided by that motive. But if you look at that as one of their primary guidances, and assume a lack of technical knowledge in many areas by the lead principals, their actions make sense. Maybe their are ways to help them achieve their goals that have not been conventionally explored?
russnewcomer··on A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists
Clearly I didn't get my point across.

If the Paris police had all the information they needed to go after such people, but didn't, that's the technical problem that really needs solved, not an encryption backdoor.

russnewcomer··on A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists
Encryption backdoors are a lightning-rod topic on HN, but instead of repeating all the common-talking points, I'd suggest the following:

Think through something like this, outside of your expertise, that you think the powers-that-be should just do. Maybe it's something with your local municipality's approach to road resurfacing, maybe it's the quarterback on your favorite football team, maybe it's your local zoning board.

Chances are better than even that there is a decent technical reason why they don't do what they do. Looking at things that way will save you a lot of headache in your life, and set you on the path to getting on someone's side to affect change, rather than just being another shrill voice yelling against them.

So politicians and intelligence services calling for encryption want, institutionally, to keep people safe. How can tech companies do that without breaking or backdooring encryption? That's the real problem to solve, and the first person to figure out how to do that will be way ahead.

russnewcomer··on Homeschooled with MIT courses at 5, accepted to MIT at 15
I don't have as much time as I used to, having a job, marriage, and child now, so I don't currently read 10+ books a week (I'm more at 2 or 3 a month now).

But when I was a kid,

- I usually read a book or two a week as part of school,

- We typically were done with 'school' by lunchtime, and so I had a lot more free time than other kids.

- I stayed up late reading quite a bit

- We lived 15 minutes outside of town so I read in the car a lot (driving or in parking lots during my siblings' activities)

- I read a lot of not-intellectually-demanding stuff like Star Wars, Star Trek, or similar novels mixed in with more serious history.

- I used to read at about 600-1200 wpm (depending on the test), which is on the higher side. It's a skill on top of natural speed, I'm now out of practice, and I top out around 500.

I skim a lot on fiction, I admit. I also read chunks of words instead of individual words when I am really going, which diminishes comprehension, and so I don't do that when I am reading theology or philosophy or something I want to deeply learn.

russnewcomer··on Homeschooled with MIT courses at 5, accepted to MIT at 15
Oh, I'm not really that smart, so really, not much respect is due. :)

I agree that going to college early isn't a good idea for the peer socialization aspects. The intellectual ones, I think it's fine. But every kid is different.

russnewcomer··on Homeschooled with MIT courses at 5, accepted to MIT at 15
Hm. I feel that I've written poorly, because I don't understand why you're making your argument from my writing. I feel like you're just restating my argument without the personal experience.

My point in writing was entirely to say that I've been through a similar journey, as have others in my family, and (while I didn't mention this originally), I have friends who have done the same thing. Thus, I have observed this situation from several different perspectives.

Based on what little evidence I have from this article, Ahaan Rungta's family is taking the course of action that has the best probability of a positive outcome. However, as my own story and that of my family illustrates, some kids will do fine and others won't, coming out of essentially the same circumstances.

Will Ahaan Rungta be fine? Depends on what you mean by fine. I mean that he's likely to graduate from school no more messed up than any other college student, and that his family seems to have positioned themselves to do that the best.

← PreviousPage 5 of 8Next →