HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

russnewcomer

1,034 karma · joined January 26, 2011

"Full Stack Developer", also was once a Mobile App Developer, IT Generalist. Midwest USA now, other time in non-American counties. Software for agriculture, manufacturing, worked in education for a while.

username same at the google mail service

submissionscomments
russnewcomer··on Homeschooled with MIT courses at 5, accepted to MIT at 15
> Are you sure?

Well, of course, all of us deal with pride and so part of my motivation to type up the story is that I'm proud of what I've accomplished, yeah.

> Being a smart fellow, you must know that your experience is not evidence that this young man was not "pushed" too much and that he will "be fine."

Of course my experience is not evidence of someone else's experience. However, I have experience being homeschooled, and entering college early, so I think I have a degree of ability to relate to Ahaan Rungta's situation that others in this thread do not. I think my contribution to the thread is to provide a counter-point to those who were decrying his parents for pushing him too hard, or depriving him of a childhood, which can only be provided by personal experience.

Additionally, I think my story demonstrates the variability of how children, within the same family, respond to environmental and parental stimuli. My sisters were fine starting school early, I wasn't so much, and if I would have lived at home during my first year of college, instead of in a dorm four hours away, it would have been different.

russnewcomer··on Homeschooled with MIT courses at 5, accepted to MIT at 15
I applaud this family, and am glad for Ahaan's sake that he isn't just shipping himself off to college, but is going to still have his support structure.

I was homeschooled, along with my two sisters, my entire educational career until college. We all started taking college classes early, my older sister correspondence at 14, my twin and I correspondence at 15. All of us took classes at local colleges before starting 'real college'. All of us scored high on our ACTs, all of us got scholarships to college.

My parents didn't really push us, we were just smart. We had childhoods, I was a starter on the basketball team, and played college soccer for a year. I also read 10+ books a week, played way, way too much Civilization and Total Annihilation, and did plenty of volunteer work, especially at our local public access station.

For my sisters, going to and living at 'real college' worked out well, they both succeeded in their own ways (my older sister graduated with two masters a few days after she turned 21, my twin sister received a lot of recognition from professionals in her field before graduating, was salutatorian, etc), whereas I didn't do so well being away from home and the support structure. I'm lazy, and I thought could just not do assignments I didn't want to and do well enough on other assignments to make up for it. Long story short, my GPA dropped enough to lose my scholarship, and I decided that the private college experience wasn't worth borrowing tens of thousands of dollars for.

So I moved home, finished my bachelors from the state university in town. Snagged an internship and then got a job offer from that company, essentially during my junior year for a full time job, contingent on finishing school.

My point in typing up this story is not to say that I am or was awesome. My point is that I am pretty sure that Ahaan Rungta is a pretty smart kid, his parents probably pushed him less than you think, and that as long as he and his family figure out how to navigate the maturity journey, he'll be fine.

russnewcomer··on The Hard Math of the Cinderella Story
A good minor league for football would be pretty expensive, just considering travel. If you're traveling with 40 guys (the realistic minimum that you could take to field a team), that gets expensive pretty fast. A true minor league could probably work if the NFL teams agreed to subsidize it, and they put it in a single major metro area. Like, the NFL has a 4 team minor league in Dallas, and did a lot of community marketing, played on high school fields, etc. You could build a single gym/practice facility, and the teams could rotate around in it. The problems are that you start to get into affiliation issues (what major teams are affiliated with what minor teams, and what does a major team do when it wants to send down a CB, but there are no teams that play man press with open slots for a CB?) and the fact that football is much, much more a team game than baseball or basketball, and most players need a couple weeks in the system to really make an impact, whereas a baseball player can get traded from one team to another with minimal adjustment, and a skilled basketball player won't need much more time.

The other issue is that there already is a sort of minor league, it's called the practice squad. And if you have minor leagues, the practice squad guys are in a weird limbo, because they are not getting game reps like they would in a minor league, yet they are the guys just good enough to almost be NFL players who would benefit the least from game reps, because of the work they are putting in with the full team. There are actually many minor football leagues, most playing indoor football, and those guys almost never make it to the NFL.

For the NFL, the real solution isn't a minor league, it's doubling the practice squad. That could cost each team about... (using numbers from the article) $1.5 million, and that's probably the best solution if the powers-that-be really feel there is a talent gap.

russnewcomer··on Why are little kids in Japan so independent?
Reading this article, I can forsee comments about how American kids are being messed up since they can't go and do things freely, pointing to this story about Japan as an example.

While I myself would wish to live in a community where this kind of behavior is OK or encouraged (I'd like for my son to be able to walk to the grocery store a quarter mile away at age 6 or 7 without fear of societal repercussions), I also reject some of the narrative that this article seems to be putting forth (and I predict the comments here will also put forth) that if we let our kids be independent, they'll turn out better. They might, they might not. They'll definitely have a different set of problems, just like every generation before them.

russnewcomer··on How one bank’s failure triggered the Panic of 1857
As I read this it strikes me how much even the height of capitalism is a participatory, integrated, community-based culture. And how much the actions of a few can arbitrarily affect so many.

Interesting lesson for the startup scene of today, (which I am not a part of, so I don't really know) is what would happen if a large fund (Say, a18z) suddenly looked for exits for ALL of their portfolio companies. Would Silicon Valley see a similar crash to the Panic of 1857?

russnewcomer··on Free Lossless Image Format
I don't see any comparison here on the impact of decompressing? Is this going to hit a processor harder than JPG/PNG/BPG/et al will, and thus be a hit to people on mobile devices?
russnewcomer··on The sky's gone dark
Not to be flippant, but I don't think that would scale well enough.

"Space is big. Really big. You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it's a long way down the road to the chemist, but that's just peanuts to space." Douglas Adams, The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy

russnewcomer··on The sky's gone dark
I'm not read enough to understand exactly how the Kessler Syndrome scenario cstross proposes would interact with GPS, but significantly naval spending by the Superpowers is the big powers is the major effect I can easily see. When you have to protect undersea communication lines for military command and control (assuming the Kessler Syndrome would be a convenient way for hostile nations to launch attacks against other nation's orbital assets), meaning drone warfare becomes untenable outside a direct LOS engagement if undersea lines are not secured.

I also think there would be a major issue with weather satellites and prediction, causing a significant investment to be made in weather radar and alternative weather prediction and monitoring strategies.

russnewcomer··on The ethics of donating breast milk
Yeah. It's really kind of torturous to try to plan meals (no cheese, and the amount of packaged food we can eat goes waaaaay down), or figure out what she could possibly eat when we go out (especially if we are somewhere longer than planned and need to eat before getting home, that's terrible.).

There are informal milk swaps, but part of the deal is that the way the biology works, it's better for the baby to have their own mother's milk ( if you're giving another mother's milk, it's statistically not much different than formula [to anyone reading, I know this is a controversial statement simplifying a complex issue]).

russnewcomer··on The ethics of donating breast milk
Not googling wrongly at all. Just missing that the proteins that the mother ingests make their way into the breast milk. Therefore, when my wife ate dairy/soy then pumped and bagged the milk, it is no longer usable for our son since it has the proteins from her consumption in it.
russnewcomer··on The ethics of donating breast milk
First time father with a seven month old here. I observe there is frequently more attachment to an idea (don't formula feed!) than there is the ideal (baby should be as healthy as possible).

But I also observe that part of that is driven (at least, in America, where you seem to also be located) by the conceptual societal framework that has led kids to understand you should only be with people who don't criticize you, and my wife and I heard from several people while she was pregnant that we 'need to find our tribe,' where we try to exclusively spend our social time in a sub-group of people that share our philosophies on child-rearing and related fields. I reject this line of thinking as needlessly polarizing, and I think that if you only are with your tribe, you're going to be messing up your kid the same way everyone else in that tribe messes up their kids (and I also observe that every generation of Americans since the 'Greatest Generation' complains about how their parents raised them, I don't expect my children's generation to be any different)

russnewcomer··on The ethics of donating breast milk
I have a seven month old, and my wife has shared bagged milk that she pumped before we figured out that he can't eat it because he seems to be MSPI.

The hardest part about infant nutrition is that passing on knowledge about it isn't a part of modern American culture, and so when we had our son, we felt we had to do a lot of reading and research to figure out what was the best thing to do.

And it's tragic, although understandable from a certain perspective, that a significantly lower portion of [statistically speaking] lower-income African American women do not plan to breastfeed. Tragic solely in the cost savings that it could be for them that could help them slowly make their way out of poverty. (Yes, yes, structural societal issues aside, I mean for them individually).

It also appears pretty true that almost anything involving infants, birth, and the fuzziness of medical ethics provokes strong reactions from those involved. Hopefully, the focus will remain on doing the best thing, and less on doing the thing that people yell the most about.

russnewcomer··on The sky's gone dark: On Kessler Syndrome
I'm not read enough to understand exactly how the Kessler Syndrome scenario cstross proposes would interact with GPS, but significantly naval spending by the Superpowers is the big powers is the major effect I can easily see. When you have to protect undersea communication lines for military command and control (assuming the Kessler Syndrome would be a convenient way for hostile nations to launch attacks against other nation's orbital assets), meaning drone warfare becomes untenable outside a direct LOS engagement if undersea lines are not secured.

I also think there would be a major issue with weather satellites and prediction, causing a significant investment to be made in weather radar and alternative weather prediction and monitoring strategies.

russnewcomer··on Paris’ Day Sans Cars
Maybe it's because I grew up in farm country and then lived in a war-torn 'developing' national capital, but whenever I read these kinds of stories, I think, 'Yes, but do you actually want to live in a city without cars? How will your grocery stores get their shipments? Do you really want the necessary human or animal-powered commercial traffic such a city would require? And if there are ideas for alternatives, how do you get that working in existing cities? Almost every idea I've heard basically boils down turning the roadways into something more like the railways, and that just is silly.

Americans wanting cities without cars have a oddly pastoral, almost bucolic vision of their cities when the cars are removed, when the reality is something ( not entirely, but moreso ) like this : http://cdn.c.photoshelter.com/img-get/I0000XCAUBam7ZnI/s/850...

russnewcomer··on The Plot Twist: E-Book Sales Slip, and Print Is Far from Dead
As a Kindle fan, I'd say e-book sales slipping are easily attributable to the fact that there is so much free content out there for e-readers that people are reading the free stuff and not buying. I think a significant test would be comparing library check-outs to ebooks to print sales. (Figuring out a test that isn't skewed would be hard, but let's handwave that away). I wonder if you'd see that 'e-book reading' people who used to check out lots of books from the library have dropped off and are just reading free books from e-book stores?
russnewcomer··on Daniel Thompson, Whose Bagel Machine Altered the American Diet, Dies at 94
Maybe technologically, but there have been significant technological advances almost every 100 years that don't look as significant to us because we're way past them. The jump from sailing to steamships doesn't seem that big to us, but in terms of reliability, speed, etc, etc, etc, it was an incredible leap, similar to propellers to jets.

I don't know about culturally. If you plucked a European adult from 1500 and dropped them in the same city in 1600, chances are the Protestant Reformation would have done a pretty big shakeup of their cultural and societal expectations.

Food is weird. Not arguing that there is a difference between 'modern' bagels and 'traditional' bagels, just arguing that the traditional way is perhaps not as traditional as someone might think, and I would guess that 'hundreds' of years isn't in many cases (perhaps not specifically with bagels, I'm not a bagel expert, when I eat them I buy the bag of mini-bagels from Aldi).

russnewcomer··on Daniel Thompson, Whose Bagel Machine Altered the American Diet, Dies at 94
I personally don't think the pace of change is accelerating, I think the uniformity of acceptance of change is.

In regards to your second paragraph, I don't know if 'more authentic' really means what you think it does. I've had the idea for a while that traditions around food are a lot more fungible than is popularly thought. Something like the documentary The Search for General Tso [ http://www.thesearchforgeneraltso.com/ ] or Rachel Laudan's work [ http://www.utne.com/environment/fast-food-culinary-ethos.asp... or https://www.jacobinmag.com/2015/05/slow-food-artisanal-natur... ] better illustrates it than I could in a comment.

russnewcomer··on Daniel Thompson, Whose Bagel Machine Altered the American Diet, Dies at 94
As a mere 30-something, it's always amazing to me to read about these things that seemed ubiquitous when I was a child (store-bought bagels, folding ping-pong tables, even things like vacuums, electric stoves, and color TV) really are recent inventions. I had no idea that the Bagel didn't become what I think of the Bagel until this article. I regularly talk to my nearly nineties grandparents, and they regularly mention something that they are amazed by that I just take for granted (air conditioning, power steering, batteries, frozen meals, and more).

I hope I don't lose my sense of wonder for the world.

Here's to you, Mr. Thompson, a tinkerer from the age when one could revolutionize the world twice from one's garage.

russnewcomer··on The most obsolete infrastructure money could buy – my worst job ever
I think the most interesting lessons of this story have to do with the following expectations.

First, the expectation of support timelines. It seems in tech that support is promised for products far beyond when the vendor should reasonably be expected to support them. Companies make large investments in technology that ultimately aren't long-term enough.

Lesson: Any company doing a major project where there is significant cost (as a percentage of the overall cost) in hardware or software, and that selected hardware or software is not commodity level or has low market penetration in their industry should seriously reconsider the projections of TCO, as long-term support will get increasingly expensive over the life of the project (Contrived example, supporting Windows XP via virtualization vs OS/2 Warp)

A second expectation is the timeline of viability for technologies. Non-technical business people of the past generally seemed to have an expectation of viability that was around 15-20 years. More recently, stated expectations seem shorter, but are actually not.

Lesson: Businesses that make serious investments in technology need to consider length of that investment, and technical people should probably take those estimates and double or triple them, because that's probably how long hardware/software will be in use. Companies providing technology or support need to have realistic timeframes of support.

As a corollary to this lesson, I have spent some of my career thus far doing IT support-type roles for small organizations, and while I haven't encountered quite the same level of obsolescence as the author, I have seen people using NT 4 for critical server infrastructure in 2012, I've set up DOSBOX[1] in Windows 7 for clients to continue to use that version of Lotus 1-2-3 they paid for and have been using since 1987 , and I've tried to figure out, in 2011, why Netscape Navigator on, I think System 7, ( using dial-up! ) wouldn't properly render a webpage. People keep tech a long time, and people in the tech world need to expect that, and plan accordingly.

The final expectation is one that technology companies have, which is that tech should be replaced. While there are many use cases where tech gets old, breaks, has to be replaced, there are lots of cases where it can be functional for almost indefinite periods of time, and industries that will expect such.

Lesson: Tech companies in should not neglect the future, but should also strive to design objects of technology that can last a very, very long time. Companies that do so will find a niche and make money because there will always[2] be enough customers to support them.

[1]It was going to get some use on an iPad via LogMeIn and there was some reason I've forgotten why DOSBOX was a better choice than the command prompt

[2] Subject to prevailing economic winds, of course. You can still buy buggies and buggy whips, but it's not a growth business.

russnewcomer··on The Bail Trap
Agree, but I think if it's hard to set it over $100, more judges are going to put bail into a manageable range, or even not set it where many times.
russnewcomer··on The Bail Trap
Absolutely, I agree. But my point, which I believe underscores the article's, is the people setting the bail amount don't appear to have a true understanding in many cases of the defendant's means.
russnewcomer··on The Bail Trap
You're completely correct, and my meaning was to say 100% of the bail, not the bail bond. I originally transposed the meaning of bail and bond in typing my post, and didn't correctly edit it. Obviously the bail bond companies can set their own fees, this is more for the case of people being able to bail themselves out without the need for a bond.
russnewcomer··on The Bail Trap
In reading the article, part of the conclusion that I came to is not that cash bail is inherently broken and unfixable, but the sense of scale by the people setting bail is. To a lower-income person with minimal savings and unpredictable income (like most of the subjects of the article), an unplanned $500 expense like bail is potentially crushing, whereas to a higher-income person with decent savings and regular predictable income (like the judges), an unplanned $500 expense is annoying but not catastrophic.

Restructure the law so that bail cannot be easily set over $100 for non-violent misdemeanors, and that 100% of the bail is returned to the person posting it for amounts under $1000, and NYC (of which I am not a resident) will be well on it's way to solving the current problems of the bail system, and then have a whole new host of problems with the new system to solve in 50 years once all of its weaknesses are exploited.

[edit] corrected improper use of bailbond to bail

russnewcomer··on The story behind ITA's $700M sale to Google (2014)
Not exactly related to the interview, but I remember reading about you from some of Andy Gavin's series on Crash, and wondering what the transition from Naughty Dog to ITA was like? I just imagine that personally, I would struggle to transition from game programming where even with great engineering standards, lots of things are more 'get it done fast and close enough to right, and if something just won't work, kluge it together because we have to ship in a week and if there is a collision detection problem leading to a crash because a player jumped from this particular pixel at this particular speed, just put a crate right there so they never can jump from there' and you're doing a AAA title with less than 10 people in less than a year (or whatever the short time horizon was on Crash) to something like ITA where I would imagine there is a lot more rigor and having a tax rule incorrectly applied could be the cause of hundreds of thousands of dollars of loss for you or a client, not to mention it takes five years to build a product.

My question would be, are there any good resources you can point to that would help someone trying to understand what the truly important engineering practices a software developer needs to follow are?

russnewcomer··on Microsoft Expands Its Parental Leave, Bolsters Paid Time Off And 401k Matching
Really interesting to compare this with another (current) front page article, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10012312

As someone who is employed by a company of <10 and had to take 1 of 2 weeks vacation for the my kid's birth, I wish I had this kind of benefit, but then if I did, I'd have to deal with all of the negative parts of working for a big company. It's a trade-off, and here in the hinterlands where there isn't VC funding to be had for every app idea or billions behind the company already, we end up with what we can. I'm happier in my small company 8-5 with almost no extra time than I would be working for a big company 7-7 with regular demands for time put in outside of the office.

russnewcomer··on Konrad Zuse: Nearly the German Turing
In episode 60 [1] of the great (and sadly, ending soon) podcast Pragmatic, John Chidgey talks some about the history of programming and more specifically some about Turing, arguing that Turing is overrated. I largely agree, and since I send John feedback after every episode, I sent him a longish rant, reproduced as follows:

When talking about the history of programming, there's always a difficulty because of the difference between computing and programming. It's nearly undeniable, for example, that Vannevar Bush had a greater impact on computing than did John Von Neumann (I'll take the haters on with that). As We May Think is more important than Von Neumann's draft, because what Von Neumann was talking about had already been created and codified, whereas As We May Think was much more of a visionary work. Maybe put another way, I think Von Neumann was a brilliant synthesist, bringing together the ideas of many into the next step in the evolution of whatever he was working on at the time. Bush, on the other hand, was a management/strategic level thinker who saw the revolutionary step ahead of whatever he was working on. But, Bush was not a programmer in any way, and his impact on programming is limited. Similarly, I think that Turing is overly lionized for his programming contributions because of the Turing test and Eliza. He provided a lot of the theoretical underpinnings, but I would argue that C.A.R. Hoare's contributions have a greater reaching practical impact than did Turing's. I suspect that Turing and Von Neumann had political connections in the ACM and IEEE that led to their improved historical standing. But as always, historical/political credit is almost as much a function of who you know/where you are as what you've done. (I'm a huge fan of Shannon, Mauchly, Adm. Hopper, Hoare, and Dijkstra, over others like Turing and Von Neumann).

It's also very difficult, when just surveying computer history, to give proper credit to Zuse, Lebedev, Scherbius, Rejewski, etc, due to the lack of English Language resources on their accomplishments, and lingering bias against the governments some of them worked for. One could make a very compelling argument for Scherbius as having created _the_ most pivotal invention of the twentieth century, because Enigma drove the large investment into cryptanalysis, which led to the large investment in devices that eventually became the general purpose computing machines of today.

There's also a large, long discussion to be had about the impact of figures like Marvin Minsky, Bill Gosper, Richard Greenblatt, Dennis Ritchie, Ken Thompson, Richard Stallman, Linus Torvalds, Brendan Eich, Donald Knuth, Peter Norvig, or Alan Kay had on programming, and also on the impact figures like Jack Goldman, Doug Engelbart, Steve Wozniak, Thomas Watson, Robert Noyce, Gordon Moore, David Packard, Bill Hewlett, Steve Jobs, Nolan Bushnell, Larry Ellison, Bill Gates, Vint Cerf, or Jim Clark had on computing. Few of those guys cross over from programming to computing or vice versa, yet each have critical contributions to be discussed and looked at. I don't know of a lot of good books or resources, though, that really tackle this. Steven Levy's Hackers is the canonical example, but it is heavily biased toward the AI Lab crowds, Lisp hackers, and the early Unix pioneers, without touching on the big industry/engineer types more than tangentially or even scornfully, and almost completely ignored the military/NASA. I also really appreciated Peter Siebel's Coders at Work, which was more inclusive but not really a history, more of a set of conversations. I'm told Petzold's CODE is good, and of course deeper into history there's the Godel, Escher, Bach: the Eternal Golden Braid, which I have on my bookshelf and have to admit not getting to far into because I don't really like math. Either way, as I'm sure you know, there is a wide, wide history of programming and computing that could be explored more, and I find it a shame that no one has done so with the historical rigor that I would like. (Such a book would probably be $100+ because sales would be so small since few people would be interested, and it would discourage others from taking up future projects)

[1] http://techdistortion.com/podcasts/pragmatic/episode-60-or-w...

russnewcomer··on The Most Epic Safety Video Ever Made (YouTube)
Safety videos like these, while requiring semi-frequent refresh, definitely do seem like the way to go. Engaging, short, fresh, and help frequent travelers re-engage with the safety briefing.

I've personally long used a similar concept in long, instructional or non-interactive emails I've sent out (when I was the IT director of a school, for example, and I had to help the staff understand some new policy changes) of embedding little jokes or trivia in the email, with one at the very start and then scatter them throughout the message. People would notice the joke at the start, and then pay attention to the rest of the email instead of just scanning or ignoring it. It became a well-known practice to the staff, and so people would more easily read my long emails since they knew there was an entertainment payoff in them.

Really, the lesson is that if you have boring, repetitive, or technical (relative to the reader/viewer's probably ability) content, have good presentation.

russnewcomer··on Nobody Knows What an iPad Is Good for Anymore
I'm a developer, but my iPad is my primary computing device while at home. My laptop died about a year ago, and I decided to save money and just use the iPad that I got as a Christmas bonus. About the only thing I ever feel I lack is legacy support for older Windows games. With the occasional keyboard pairing for longer emails, I would say that the only thing it really lacks is the ability to archive photos from my camera. Maybe I'm in the minority here in that I specifically don't do any development or really intense computing tasks at home, but I think that my use case mirrors much of the non-technical world. I know of many people who use iPads as their primary computing devices.

I think it's more accurate to say that tech journalists don't know what an iPad is good for anymore.

russnewcomer··on Google Fiber is coming to Atlanta, Charlotte, Nashville and Raleigh-Durham
Competition isn't always the boon to free enterprise that we would like it to be. I live in Omaha, NE, where Cox and CenturyLink are the primary ISPs. CenturyLink has limited gigabit fiber in some neighborhoods (not mine, unfortunately), launched late last year.

Cox has raised internet rates about 7% twice in the last 14 months.

russnewcomer··on The Ronco Principle
I wonder if pg's view of top investors as 'good' or, maybe more accurately, consistently moral has changed since he has gotten to know more of them personally? Not a charge of corruption or cronyism, but sometimes one has different standards for friends than for people one doesn't know.
← PreviousPage 6 of 8Next →