HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sDlEzAtyoNAz

-16 karma · joined July 17, 2018

submissionscomments
sDlEzAtyoNAz··on How Indian Americans Came to Run Half of All U.S. Motels
The dogma of Catholicism did not destroy the clan structure in Europe, though it was certainly used by those who did. It was the humans running the church, who had particular political objectives relevant to the time and place which are not necessarily anything like the political objectives of the people involved with the church these days.

No one here is making the argument that Catholicism cannot exist alongside close extended families, so your objection to the argument that is being made falls completely flat.

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Russian hackers targeted U.S. conservative think-tanks, says Microsoft
>Even if everyone did it (they don't; most countries have nowhere near the necessary capabilities), it does not follow that all can or do do it to the same extent.

My comment does not assume that everyone does it or that everyone does it to the same extent.

>And this is not a situation in which all sides doing it makes any less likely to continue. It is more akin everyone polluting because everyone else does.

You've lost me completely. What did I say to suggest that everyone doing it makes it less likely to continue?

>Not all polluters are equal, but they should all be condemned and if possible stopped.

It's a bit easier to pin blame for pollution on someone than it is to pin blame for meddling in another country's politics, which is almost necessarily clandestine. That's why it's reasonable to expect that countries will be able to make and keep agreements to limit pollution, even if they don't have a great relationship, but not particularly reasonable to expect that they will be able to make and keep agreements to not interfere in each others' internal affairs.

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Russian hackers targeted U.S. conservative think-tanks, says Microsoft
You're just re-iterating what I replied to, without addressing what I said.

Sometimes, not playing the game is suicide.

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Russian hackers targeted U.S. conservative think-tanks, says Microsoft
There are still people there with power/influence. Hacking the election won't do you much good, but manipulating those people certainly might.
sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Russian hackers targeted U.S. conservative think-tanks, says Microsoft
>"Everyone does it" is a piss poor excuse for pretty much anything.

It's really not. If doing "it" gives you some advantage, and not doing "it" means you're going to get outcompeted by someone else who is doing "it", then it's in your interest to do "it", which is a perfectly fine reason for doing things. If you can manage to get everyone not to do "it", or make doing "it" disadvantageous, then by all means. But that is not always a viable option.

It's probably not a viable option in this case. You can try to make it less advantageous by attempting to punish other countries that engage in it, while downplaying it when you do it, but it's still going to be worth it for countries to try.

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Katie's New Face
>Can you see how the guns aren't working?

I can see that they're not an automatic cure-all for violence. There are parts of the US with extremely high gun ownership rates, and virtually no crime. And there are parts of the US with high gun ownership rates and high levels of crime. The fact is that there are many people in this world with violent tendencies. There always have been. Their violent tendencies are not a consequence of guns being around.

However, guns are a very effective tool for defending one's self and one's family against such people.

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Katie's New Face
I'm talking about the ~6 million estimated violent crimes that occur each year. Many, many of those are deadly threats. Any that involve a weapon are automatically deadly threats. Any involving multiple attackers are deadly threats. Any that involve a significant advantage in physical force of the attacker over the target are deadly threats. In general, any that involve the attacker being in a position to cause death or grave bodily harm are considered deadly threats, and can be legally met with lethal force if that is necessary to stop the threat.

I'm not sure what world you are living in. There are millions of people who are victims of violent crime each year in the US. It happens. A lot.

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Katie's New Face
>i don't have gun in my place and feel perfectly safe about violent criminals

Perhaps you are. I don't know where you live.

>violent crimes are very rare here in Europe where i live, especially during burglary

I hope it stays that way. That's not how it is in many parts of the USA. And no, it's not that way because we have guns. It's because we have more people who are inclined toward violence. I'll leave you to guess why that might be.

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Katie's New Face
Crime victimization surveys. The 'actual statistics' you refer to are reported crimes, i.e. crimes which were reported to the police and which the police took the time to record. They vastly underrepresent the actual number of crimes. That's why people who are interested in getting a more accurate estimate of the actual number of crimes do crime victimization surveys. This is all pretty well known and obvious. That you aren't aware of it is telling.

Unless these guys are liars too? Who knows, maybe 'ebbv knows better than them? https://www.bjs.gov/index.cfm?ty=pbdetail&iid=6166

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Katie's New Face
>What do you need a weapon of killing for?

Are you denying that there are situations in which a gun will incapacitate a deadly threat but pepper spray will not?

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Katie's New Face
That's hugely dependent on who you are and where you live and so on, but there are estimated to be around 6 million violent crimes per year, or about 55 people per violent crime. Of course many people are victimized more than once, so you can't easily extrapolate to how likely a random person is to be victimized. Either way, over a lifespan, that is a significant risk.

>And it doesn't seem logical to me that a criminal who wants to (i.e. rob you) is really going to actually shoot and kill you to do it.

What you're missing is that I don't want someone to rob me. I don't want my family to ever be at the mercy of a violent thug. They ultimately depend upon me for their safety, and I am going to do what I can to guarantee it.

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Katie's New Face
>Against what?

In the US, that would be against the individuals who collectively commit millions of violent crimes per year (surveys indicate this number easily exceeds 5 million per year).

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Katie's New Face
>Ad hominem attack required because factual statements do not support any of your arguments.

No other statement is required to address yours because it's a naked assertion.

>Well, if your statement is factually correct, then the statistics show that a huge chunk of gun owners are incompetent.

What does that have to do with the safety of my family?

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Katie's New Face
>Does that really happen enough to worry about?

Yes, of course it does. There are literally millions of violent crimes in the US in any given year.

>Should I spend my money on a newer, safer car or a gun?

I leave that to you to decide. I don't know you. Bringing a gun into your home might make you less safe if you are an irresponsible person or if you have psychological issues. If you are a responsible person with no psychological issues, but you live in an area that has virtually no violent crime, then it might just be a waste of money.

>I can't imagine that there are that many scenarios where a gun saves the day from violence

There are estimated to be over 100,000 defensive uses of guns in the US each year. The widespread ownership of guns has had a clear influence on the behavior of violent criminals. Particularly, in the US, criminals avoid breaking into homes when they are occupied, because they know many occupants will be armed.

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Katie's New Face
>You don't wish to go here as the statistics are against you.

What a hilariously arrogant statement.

>Gun owners are far more likely to have their gun fired in an accident or in a suicide than as genuine defense against a criminal.

Whether your gun is more likely to be used against you or in an accident is almost entirely in your power to control. Whether someone else decides to attempt to make a victim out of you is much less so. Wealthier people may be able to take precautions like avoiding areas frequented by certain groups of people and strategically choosing where to live but that is out of reach for many.

>As the victim, you are far more likely to survive an encounter if a gun isn't involved.

You're also vastly less able to prevent yourself and your loved ones from becoming victims in such an encounter if you aren't armed. That's why criminals in the US have a much greater tendency to avoid occupied homes than do criminals in other parts of the world. I would much rather take my family's safety into my own hands than leave it to the benevolence of violent thugs.

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Katie's New Face
You also have a substantially reduced ability to defend your families against violent criminals that live in your country, so there's kind of a trade off there.

And no, violent criminals don't need guns to hurt you. People have been hurting each other a lot longer than gunpowder has been around.

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Would You Let the I.R.S. Prepare Your Taxes? (2015)
I'm not sure what it would mean for a speed to be "safe in general". What is the general case? Whether a particular speed is safe or not is situation dependent, and the situation absolutely includes the quality of the drivers and vehicles involved.
sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Would You Let the I.R.S. Prepare Your Taxes? (2015)
If you look at the low level of fatalities on the autobahn, I don't see how you can argue those speeds are unsafe.
sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Would You Let the I.R.S. Prepare Your Taxes? (2015)
Are you suggesting those "excessive" velocities are not actually safe?
sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Health Insurers Are Vacuuming Up Details About Customers
If I do indeed have no idea what I'm talking about, you have done nothing to change that.
sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Health Insurers Are Vacuuming Up Details About Customers
>By that measure, then, the extent to which sick people are covered simply comes down to how much "charity" healthy people are willing to volunteer.

That is reality. If you can't afford something yourself, then you're going to have to have other people pay for it for you, or else you won't get it.

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Health Insurers Are Vacuuming Up Details About Customers
What do you think I said that I will feel differently about when I'm older and sicker? You made a bunch of claims about the nature of the health insurance market, and I pointed out that your claims were bogus. What feelings are involved there?
sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Health Insurers Are Vacuuming Up Details About Customers
>So, a free market is ineffective at allocating resources in healthcare.

It doesn't suspend reality, that's for sure. If you don't have the resources to pay for your own healthcare, and don't have the resources to pay someone else to pay for your healthcare, then you are going to have to get someone else to volunteer their resources for it, or you're going to go without.

>Unless we redefine healthcare to mean "care for people who are not sick," which does not really make it healthcare at all, does it?

Plenty of sick people, or people who become sick, are perfectly capable of having their healthcare needs met through the market. There are many, many people who have enough money to buy health insurance, even if they have some chronic conditions and therefore would need to pay someone a lot more than a healthy person would to cover their health care expenses.

If your standard for effectiveness in allocation of resources in healthcare is that no one's ability to get health insurance is affected by their current health status, then yes, the market is going to be ineffective by your measure.

If your standard includes, for example, having financial incentives for people to limit their own use of health care services, like how we have financial incentives for people to limit their use of basically every other resource out there (e.g. houses, cars, land, anything else that costs money), to ensure that resources are left available for other people to use, and you don't want to deal with heavy-handed government approaches to that problem, then by that standard, a health insurance market is very effective.

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Health Insurers Are Vacuuming Up Details About Customers
>Demonstrably so. Just look at pre-Obamacare "high risk pools" for concrete examples.

I'm obviously not talking about individuals who are so expensive to profitably insure that they can't afford the premiums. I've already stated that the market isn't going to work for them. It's not the size of the pool that's causing problems here; the contents of the pool are the problem.

>They just pick the healthy ones, if allowed.

They also pick the less healthy ones that are able to afford to pay the higher premiums it takes to make it worth it for the insurance company to cover them, assuming the insurance company is allowed to charge such premiums. There is plenty of money to be made there. Where there isn't any money to be made is in people who know they have high expenses and can't afford to pay them.

>You are using some very weird definitions of "charity".

Are you taking issue with my characterization of government welfare as charity? Why should it be excluded from such a broad category?

>Obamacare's subsidized premiums aren't shouldered by the insurance companies, they're provided by the government.

That's not what I'm talking about. I'm talking about people who have pre-existing conditions, who are definitely going to cost the insurance company more than they're going to be paying in, regardless of subsidies, who the health insurance company can't charge more money to and can't deny coverage to.

>Insurance paying out more than premiums taken in for a particular subscriber isn't "charity", it's how insurance works.

Actually that hinges on whether it's known before the agreement is made that the particular subscriber is going to have more paid out on his behalf than he is going to pay in. If it is known, then that's not insurance. It's charity.

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Health Insurers Are Vacuuming Up Details About Customers
>So you raise prices for them, and they get kicked out, too.

They only get kicked out if no one will offer them prices that they can afford and that they want to pay for. Why do you expect that would happen?

>Until they do get sick, at which point they get kicked off the insurance plan.

It seems like that would be solved by treating health insurance like term life insurance as the person you're replying to suggested.

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Health Insurers Are Vacuuming Up Details About Customers
>You're okay with a society where people die on the street because they didn't have enough wealth?

I didn't take a position on whether or not I'm okay with a society where people die in the street if they don't have enough wealth.

All I said was that people who can't afford to buy health insurance need charity, whether that charity is public or private. The market is not going to help them. Attempting to fit that round peg into a square hole is going to cause a lot of issues that are very obvious to predict, in addition to all of the issues that are less easy to predict.

>How much money you have isn't a determinant of the moral worth of your life

Neither is anything else. The 'moral worth of your life' is fundamentally an opinion, not a fact.

>So why do consider it as a relevant detail in the allocation of healthcare?

Because that's how we allocate most goods and services, and it does a fairly good job at it.

>Why should the obese, smoking trust-fund kid get the heart bypass but the obese smoking poor guy not?

That's a pretty complicated question that comes down to an individual's own priorities and that individual's assessment of the potential effects of various alternative policies on the attainment of various goals.

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Health Insurers Are Vacuuming Up Details About Customers
>Everyone is at potential risk for needing something like a transplant eventually.

Not everyone is at equal risk, and many choices people make can have an impact on that risk. That's the point of this thread.

>Making the pool large enough allows reasonable premiums, just as I can pay a couple hundred bucks a year to replace my entire house if it burns down.

What is 'large enough'? The populations of many entire European countries are dwarfed by the number of subscribers to several health insurance companies in the US. Of course we don't know how large health insurance companies would get in a market without heavy government interference, but do you have some reason to believe the size of pools in a market with less interference would result in unreasonable premiums?

>The rest of the developed world defines the risk pool as "everyone", and the end result is healthcare costs half of ours (including the tax component) and similar outcomes.

And our health care system requires subscribers to insurance companies to pay those insurance companies to A) provide charity to people who wouldn't be able to afford to buy insurance in real market and B) pay for routine care (i.e. care where there is no risk to insure against - you know you're going to need it). And of course the health insurance company is going to collect its cut of the money that the government has forced subscribers to funnel through those companies. Is it really any surprise that system gets expensive?

>You need government, not a charity.

You need charity, whether it's administered by a public organization or a private organization or funded by private individuals or taxpayers.

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Health Insurers Are Vacuuming Up Details About Customers
Also shockingly, if you already know you need a heart transplant, you're well beyond the point where any market-based risk pool is going to offer to pay for your transplant in exchange for a premium that's below the cost of your transplant.

You need charity, not a market.

sDlEzAtyoNAz··on Health Insurers Are Vacuuming Up Details About Customers
If they can't afford to pay anyone enough to insure them, they should ask for charity, because that's what they need.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2