HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

s_m_t

824 karma · joined September 20, 2015

submissionscomments
s_m_t··on DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI research environment
If you are going to do war you should do it well. An AI commander could be programmed to maneuver troops in a way to reduce civilian casualties, reduce damage on infrastructure, and even maximize the chances of the enemy surrendering rather than having them killed.

Of course, I doubt that an AI commander would replace a human making the actual decisions in the foreseeable future. It would just be another intelligence tool for military command. From this point of view you are essentially arguing for our military to be ignorant, I don't think that is a good bet.

s_m_t··on Booked: When Slaveholders Controlled the Government
Interesting. I've got a couple of points or questions to put forth if anyone cares to share.

Did the abolishment of slavery in the United States directly lead to any sort of economic depression? From one perspective they were eliminating what the article says was 16% of household wealth at the time, compared to 10 trillion dollars today, so you might expect a corresponding hit to the economy, but whatever productive capacity there was in the form of the slaves labor still existed, more or less, after they were freed. So to non-slave owners it might not effect them at all economically (maybe it might help them in some way, perhaps slavery drags down the market value of labor?).

This, I think, is different from the question of oil. When you abolish the use of oil the oil doesn't go on to produce on its own accord. Any economic gain you once had from oil would presumably vanish completely. And it wouldn't just be the oil owners that lose out, I'm pretty sure I have more wealth because of the economies use of oil even though I don't own any shares of oil companies.

s_m_t··on Twitter fired its VR manager because of something he posted to Facebook in 2013
No, she just helped destabilize the country until he was killed and sodomized. And then laughed about it, on television. Surely this was the administrations intention all along. Of course they didn't expect him to be sodomized but as long as he died one way or another I really doubt they cared. Of course, now Libya is still embroiled in civil war.

The point is that there are legitimate reasons to support Trump over Hillary that don't involve someone being a racist, sexist, bigot. The world definitely isn't perfect and we have two (major) candidates to choose from that make a lot of reasonable people on both 'sides' existentially concerned about the future of the republic.

I agree with your concerns about Trump. I just think Hillary is even scarier, especially because a lot of the type of people who would protest and politically mobilize against the actions I think she might take support her.

s_m_t··on Twitter fired its VR manager because of something he posted to Facebook in 2013
But being the secretary of state of the administration that assassinates US citizens without trial (including a 16 year old US citizen) and laughing on television about a world leader being killed and sodomized with knives by a mob on television is acceptable?

We are all complicit in this madness. You should fire everyone and then fire yourself.

s_m_t··on No Man’s Sky – Procedural Content
I don't really view balance in single player games any differently than I do a multiplayer game. A well balanced game has a wealth of options open that promotes dynamic gameplay. A poorly balanced game degenerates into stagnant gameplay because one or two options are much more powerful than the rest.

A good example of a well balanced single player game is tetris. All the pieces are useful. It may be easier to complete a line with the straight piece, and in a tight pinch a less skilled player might hold out for it while placing down other pieces willy nilly, but if every piece was as easy to use as the straight piece then the game would have less variety and tension! At certain points in the game you may not want a straight piece because of the way you have laid down your previous pieces, the game is dynamic because the optimal strategy is changing all the time because of how you played the game, this adds even more strategy because you can also influence how the optimal strategy will change.

A good example of a poorly balanced single player game is... well in my opinion most single player games are poorly balanced. Either the game is so easy that it really doesn't require you to strategize at all or the game is easily cheesed by using one overpowered technique. This is especially evident in many RPG's, although they try to hide it with a huge skill tree (of which almost invariably a large number of skills are useless and a couple are ridiculously overpowered) or by having you learn a whole bunch of enemy weaknesses and resistances (IMO this is cheating, the challenge isn't dynamic as these stats are unchanging and typically only serve as an overwrought color matching exercise). Pokemon is a good example of this, although you have hundreds of pokemon to collect and train and it seems a variety of enemy types should force you to have a varied party yourself, the easiest way to beat the game is to overlevel your starting pokemon by giving them all the experience points and grab one or two other pokemon along the way to cover your weaknesses in the end stages of the game and load up with necessary non-combat moves.

s_m_t··on The Effect of State Marijuana Legalizations
New rule suggestion. You must argue at least one flaw in the study or article before pointing out the source may be biased.
s_m_t··on Apple facing record bill for Irish tax
You are assuming that the government is going to use those resources better than the company avoiding the taxes. Not everyone agrees with this. From this point of view everyone is acting rationally, they only might disagree about one specific assumption.
s_m_t··on Meme pages plan mass revolt against alleged Facebook bias
Do these pages make money by reposting content from other people and sites or do they just like getting likes?
s_m_t··on Netflix and Fill
and before that it was "Want to come up and see my etchings?"
s_m_t··on Three States and a Plan: The A.I. of F.E.A.R (2006) [pdf]
I'd like to read it as well, but out of disbelief.

Bethesda has been marketing 'radiant AI' bullshit for their past three games and never delivering. I really doubt they ever developed anything resembling high level autonomy.

I haven't followed the development of their games extremely closely but I read a good amount of game development news/marketing and I never saw anything convincing, only non technical talk. The most I ever really remember them talking about it was in an E3 demo for Elder Scrolls: Oblivion way back when where they lied by misleading the audience to think that an obviously scripted quest had something to do with their radiant AI system.

s_m_t··on Ask HN: Which parts of C++ do I need to learn in order to use Qt?
I'm going to recommend this as well. Whenever I need to quickly graph some data I use http://www.pyqtgraph.org/. Really easy to set up and 'pyqtgraph.examples.run()' gives you a nice diverse set of examples with the corresponding code to edit to your liking.
s_m_t··on Solving the Dating Problem with the SENPAI Protocol [pdf]
This already exists, it is called flirting.

Given two socially well adjusted participants it allows either party to back down without hurting the other parties feelings and allows everyone to save face. The person escalating the flirtation doesn't feel bad because they aren't outright denied and the respondee isn't put in the awkward situation of having to deny someone.

It also has the added benefit of allowing each person to get to know each other better and figure out if they actually have real 'chemistry' to begin with. Furthermore, attraction isn't binary, you might initially start chatting with someone with the intention of escalating the flirting process but figure out, hey, I just want to be friends with this person! With the SENPAI protocol you might just end up in an ill fated relationship with your would be friend

s_m_t··on Google Cuts Its Giant Electricity Bill with DeepMind-Powered AI
Please! Imagine all the time, gas, and sanity wasted at red lights when there is absolutely no cross traffic!
s_m_t··on Google Cuts Its Giant Electricity Bill with DeepMind-Powered AI
I'm imagining DeepMind allocating a small percentage of the energy money saved to keep a certain rack suspiciously cool.
s_m_t··on Unilever Buys Dollar Shave Club for $1B
I don't think that would work out for them. Letting everyone know that someone was willing to pay Dollar Shave Club and then yanking it from the market would lead to a flood of imitators and new competitors.
s_m_t··on AI fighter pilot wins in combat simulation
This conspiracy theory has the same fatal flaw that many others have: If arms companies are conspiring to cause war to secure business then there should be an even greater conspiracy undoing their work because many more businesses are hindered by war.

In this same way you can figure out that conspiracies about free energy and coal/gas industry suppression of alternative energies is bullshit. Almost everyone else in the world would love to have cheaper energy so they would not allow the oil or gas companies to suppress alternative energy.

Well that's my logic anyways.

s_m_t··on All the best advice we could find on how to get a job
Don't worry there are plenty of people willing to break the law and the government doesn't have the resources to prosecute crimes like these!
s_m_t··on Derek Yu’s “Spelunky”
I disagree about the teleporter. I think it is one of the best applications of rng in any videogame.

From the wiki:

"Pressing the action button while carrying one will teleport you in the direction you are facing. You will appear a random number of tiles away in the direction you are holding, either 4-8 tiles horizontally or upwards, or 5-9 tiles downwards. Note that you have to jump in order to teleport downwards; otherwise you will just drop the teleporter.

If the destination tile is a solid block, the teleporter tries to find an empty space up to 3 tiles above the selected location - If there is no viable space, the teleporter will warp you into a solid block and you will be killed."

You can indeed use the teleporter 100% safely (as long as your judgement of distance is correct, this of course makes it even more fun) or you can use it as a hail mary in desperate times. Of course, depending on the amount of 4 tile high walls in front of you it might not be much of a risk, this is what makes Spelunky so fun to me, making risk minimizing decision in a split second, I think the teleporter perfectly captures this.

s_m_t··on Peter Thiel Has Been Funding Hulk Hogan's Lawsuits Against Gawker
What exactly is the broader precedent here? That media outlets shouldn't collaborate with sexual predators for profit?

If Gawker is allowed to do this then why shouldn't they be allowed to pay for a similar tape? Hell, if it's fair game they should be able to pay in advance. They could even have sexual predators on retainer :)

s_m_t··on Nigerians Dominate Scrabble Tournaments Using Five-Letter Word Strategy
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_world

>The concept of the Western part of the earth has its roots in Greco-Roman civilization in Europe, and the advent of Christianity.[2][3][4][5][6] In the modern era, Western culture has been heavily influenced by the traditions of the Renaissance, Protestant Reformation, Age of Enlightenment—and shaped by the expansive colonialism of the 15th-20th centuries. Before the Cold War era, the traditional Western viewpoint identified Western Civilization with the Western Christian (Catholic-Protestant) countries and culture.

>Christianity remains the dominant religion in the Western world, where 70% are Christians.[38]

s_m_t··on Top developers can have a life outside coding
You could always go to bed early instead and wake up early in the morning.
s_m_t··on The TSA is a waste of money that doesn't save lives and might actually cost them
Paying for some F-16s on standby at certain points around the country seems reasonable to me. I mean, the TSA costs us ~7 billion a year anyways.
s_m_t··on Teaching C
I love K&R, 21st century C, Understanding C pointers, Deep C secrets but I think they are a little complicated for beginners. I wouldn't bother opening them until you have written a couple of small programs in C or you have good experience in other languages.

When I first learned C in highschool I got a few books on C which all seemed to have the word 'Beginner' in the name. 'Absolute Beginners Guide to C' is one I remember in particular. I think having multiple books is pivotal because as a beginner if you encounter an explanation that doesn't make sense to you it is very hard to reason around it. You probably have very little prior knowledge, almost everything you know and learn up to the point where you get stuck will be contained in that single book, and if you don't know any other languages you can't make any connections to help yourself out. The reason the second, third, or fourth book is so important is that it will have a slightly different explanation that might make something click in your brain.

s_m_t··on Ketamine and Depression: A Breakthrough?
This may very well be true, however, some people may still need help in the form of drugs to get them to a point where they can actually begin to make those changes.
s_m_t··on Inside Palantir
Actually the palantiri were created by the elves as communication tools, even before the sun and moon were created, and used by the good guys for several thousand years before they fell in the hands of the bad guys about halfway through the third age.
s_m_t··on Smart Kids Should Skip High School
I did most of my learning outside of school, but I did have a few classes that I liked, all of my history teachers were very good, my chemistry and biology teachers were awesome. I appreciate those classes and I'm glad I took part in them but I don't think it made up for the rest.

Perhaps we had similar experiences but we contextualize them differently. Do you think the classes you mentioned were worth everything else? Do you not think you could have had similar experiences to those classes if you had done something other than high school?

s_m_t··on Smart Kids Should Skip High School
I agree. Despite going to one of the best public high schools in the country I don't remember learning much of anything. Looking back on it it was more like a very pleasant teenage internment camp. Parts of it were fun, the drugs and alcohol being a highlight. Going to school high or getting high at school was pretty fun. Sometimes competing with other students on the tests without studying or doing any of the homework was fun. But I imagine I could have had a lot more fun and learned a lot more elsewhere.
s_m_t··on Online Dating and the Death of the 'Mixed-Attractiveness' Couple
Holy shit if those guys are unattractive I am FUCKED
s_m_t··on Facebook is ruining Instagram
That is a difficult problem to solve. How do you differentiate between genuine (even if self-interested) self expression and 'advertisement'?

If I think I make really muffins and I want everyone to know is that advertisement and is it a bad thing? Of course, I love my muffins so much that I want everyone to have them so I'm going to have to start charging, because the best way to get as many people to try them is to do it full time. And of course at some point I'm going to have to hire other people and teach them to make the muffins for me because one man can only make so many muffins. I'll probably have to incorporate and buy a muffin factory. And I'm much better with muffins than I am with words so actually the proclamations of my muffin's superiority are going to be designed by a professional.

I actually don't have a way with words so I'm not sure how to wrap this up but it's a piece of my perspective either way.

s_m_t··on Tools for thought: graphical algebra and Fourier analysis
That makes more sense
← PreviousPage 8 of 9Next →