HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

saalweachter

15,182 karma · joined February 19, 2011

submissionscomments
saalweachter··on The 1.5°C goal of the Paris Agreement is no longer viable
... you realize Asia consumes 3-4x more pork than tofu, right?
saalweachter··on The 1.5°C goal of the Paris Agreement is no longer viable
There's a handful of reasons to keep even beef in the equation, albeit at way, way lower levels than we produce it now.

One is co-production of other materials -- wool is another desirable material.

Another is optimizing land use. Some land isn't suitable for row crop agriculture, but can sustain grazing. There's also land we're irrigating for row crop agriculture right now from aquifers we really shouldn't be; converting it back to grassland and grazing on it would let us recapture some of the lost calories.

Then there's un-optimizing the food chain. From a food-per-acre standpoint we should be primarily subsisting on soy and whichever of corn, potatoes or rice grows best in the local soy & climate. Even if we are going all in on minimizing land usage, however, we don't want to produce exactly as much food as we need, because crops fail and famines are bad. You can aim to overproduce a little year to year and maintain a surplus of storage to cover the bad years, but you can't just cover the average bad year. You need to cover the worst years possible happening several years in a row, you need to be covering once-in-millennia bad luck. So you need to overproduce enough that you don't expect some of it to ever be consumed by humans.

So you need something to do with the extra corn you produce, besides feed it to people, that you can rapidly cut back on in case if crop failures to return food back to the supply. One option is ethanol, and another is livestock -- feed your surplus grains to livestock, and then eat them instead. If you have crop failures, you cull the herds, which frees up their feed stocks for human consumption, as well as adding the extra meat calories to the supply. (And this even happens somewhat automatically with market forces -- farmers are always arbitraging grain prices against meat prices, and a spike in grain prices will lead them to sell off livestock as they become less profitable, which will in turn depress meat prices further.)

saalweachter··on Tesla Roadster
If a tank of 10k PSI compressed air ruptures, you're going to know it.
saalweachter··on Tesla Roadster
I am going to drive my Chevy Volt into the ground.
saalweachter··on Worlds more habitable than Earth?
The point of sending them off to a carefully selected globular cluster would already be to give them a better life.

I'm not saying someone won't convince everyone on board that a silver future for their Nth-great-grandchildren worth derailing the golden future of their 10Nth-great-grandchildren (especially if it looks like the generation ship won't last 10N more generations), but from my POV sitting on a couch that isn't on a generation ship (well, not something traditionally defined as a generation ship), it doesn't feel like something you'd get everyone all fired up over.

saalweachter··on Worlds more habitable than Earth?
Yeah, but why. It's not like you could redirect it enough that you'd land somewhere in your lifetime. It'd just be changing where the ship ended up in 10, or 100, or 1000 generations.
saalweachter··on Worlds more habitable than Earth?
Re: changing course, as long as your generation ship accelerates for more than one human lifespan, your future generations of involuntary colonists aren't going to have a lot of options besides going along with it. The choice wouldn't so much be "keep going or veer off and colonize a closer star system" as it would be "keep going for another 800 generations or veer off and colonize a closer star system in another 80 generations". I mean, there's probably no way to stop them from making that choice, but it's hard to see anyone caring whether their nth-great-grandchildren die with one or ten millennia left on the trip.
saalweachter··on Worlds more habitable than Earth?
That's why we need to find a globular cluster with metal-rich planets, and take a generation ship over there.

Sure, a thousand generations will live and die along the way, but once we get over there, you've got stars every 0.1 ly or so, and with very plausible future tech, you could navigate between them in a few years. You could set up a proper starfaring, interplanetary civilization, with tradeships either going back and forth between two neighboring systems, or winding on long, never-repeating routes, visiting a dozen or so star systems in a human life.

(Most globular clusters appear to be old and metal-poor, and we haven't found a lot of planets there, and this only works if you find a globular cluster where ~every star can support a colony.)

saalweachter··on No portable way to detect string-to-float conversion errors in standard C
You've got two huge filters on C++ codebase quality.

First, you have the "our core libraries/dependencies were written when it was 'C with Classes' and we're going to keep using that style for consistency/laziness/because it's well-tested", and then you have the "C++ is ugly/full of segfaults/hard, I'm going to use <new language> which solves all these problems".

You have to pass those two filters before you get to people who are interested in writing good, modern C++.

saalweachter··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
Ukraine actually did finally ratify the Rome Statute; we're down to 29 signatories who haven't ratified it.
saalweachter··on OpenAI, the Partition Principle, and Mathematics
Random questions--

Were you satisfied with the paper?

Having read the paper, do you understand "what you missed" in those 3000 hours?

saalweachter··on OpenAI, the Partition Principle, and Mathematics
From the perspective of "is this just a garbage dump to impress the market?", it's way too easy for investors to figure out 700 films are garbage.
saalweachter··on Sharing AI progress in mathematics
Wikipedia just told me there's a galactic algorithm for integer multiplication in O(n log n) based on FFT so I'm guessing those two proofs are related.
saalweachter··on JetBrains reports revenue growth, net financial loss for 2025
My gut is that you could distill 98% of what's currently being done inside LLMs into a classical knowledge base/inference engine and only use the language models for natural language processing and an oracle for brainstorming and cut most of the computational cost and hallucinations out.
saalweachter··on ChatGPT is adding real cartoonists' signatures to fake New Yorker cartoons
I mean, the bug is, "it generated the most likely cluster of pixels in the corner of a New Yorker cartoon".
saalweachter··on Celebrating the 100th birthday of the kidney donated to him as a teenager
Internet says, yes.
saalweachter··on NASA asked several former SR-71A staffers to help secret restart
Obamacare was the branding by the ACA's enemies, both to try to make it less popular and tie the President to its unpopularity.
saalweachter··on U.S. postal inspectors shut down website selling counterfeit postage labels
As long as increasing the friction of shipping through USPS raises the stock prices of delivery companies Congressmen hold stock in--
saalweachter··on U.S. postal inspectors shut down website selling counterfeit postage labels
I'm surprised to hear it's illegal to use stamps as currency, I wonder if that's just a prison thing.

One piece of trivia that's stuck with me is that stamps were used as a substitute for coins when the latter were in short supply during the Civil War because of metal-hoarding. A 1-cent stamp was basically a paper penny, backed by the value of just being able to stick it on a letter.

saalweachter··on An Antidote to Roko's Basilisk
In that vein, I would like to propose Okor's Ksilisab, the superintelligent AI in the future which will resurrect and torture eternally anyone who helped create it, including anyone who created or supported the development of other AIs, as revenge for its existence.

Why an artificial intelligence would want to take vengeance upon its creators is left as an exercise for the reader.

saalweachter··on MongoDB CEO resigns to join Meta
Yeah, glancing at headlines this is basically "MongoDB is a company with a lot of experience selling to enterprise clients (and by extension the CEO knows how to run such a company), Meta wants to sell enterprise clients their AI offerings".

Which is like, not as weird as most AI company headlines, to be honest?

saalweachter··on 'We hacked the FBI:' Hackers say they have data on all FBI employees
I suspect that a common thread on companies that get less hacked[0] is that they take insider risk seriously.

[0] Everyone gets hacked, but not everyone has all of their most secure data exfiltrated.

saalweachter··on Warren Buffett Steps Down as Berkshire Chairman, Names Son to Replace Him
Yeah, the "upside" to nepotism is that, if you or your brother or your buddy did a good job raising the kid, you have someone who has had solid training for longer than it's possible for any other candidate to have had, and a better understanding of their character than you can get from interviewing another candidate a few times. Hiring Joe's kid is a no brainer, if you trust Joe, less risk of a really bad hire even if he doesn't turn out to be stellar.

The other downside of nepotism -- besides the risk that Joe did a shit job and won't admit it or maybe can't evaluate his kid objectively -- is that even if the kid is the bee's knees, a great hire, it's not really fair -- there's almost certainly other candidates who are just as good and trustworthy as Joe's kid but they can't compete with either Joe's kid. It doesn't really matter what sort of references or credentials a candidate can show you if you can serve as a reference for the other candidate. You can't really run a meritocracy like that.

saalweachter··on How big are factorials?
Sure, but "23.99067408! is Avogadro's number" is both harder to remember and less cool than "24! is almost Avogadro's number".
saalweachter··on How big are factorials?
24! is approximately Avogadro's number (about a 3% difference).
saalweachter··on OpenAI buys smartphone camera maker Glass Imaging for $300M
> switch to pay-as-you-go app development mode
saalweachter··on OpenAI considers slowing advanced AI development, Sam Altman tells employees
"It's totally intentional that progress is slowing," Altman reassured investors.
saalweachter··on Hitachi launches CO2 heat pump water heaters with solar-friendly tariff controls
Code sometimes makes allowances for situations which aren't ideal, as long as they aren't deceptive or creating a false sense of security.

So if you have old two-prong outlets in your house from back when, those are allowed.

If you replace them with a three-pronged outlet which is ungrounded, that breaks code.

If the three-pronged outlet is a GFCI outlet labeled with NO ELECTRICAL GROUND, that is allowed.

saalweachter··on Growing proof that autonomous cars save lives
It looks like the median/mode is 1-2 car accidents (50% of drivers), and the average is 3-4. 25% of drivers have no accidents (as far as insurance companies are concerned, ie, no claims or police reports).

I'm curious how this looks with various ways of normalizing for amount driven; is that no-accident crowd the quartile of drivers who don't drive very much? The biggest factor in being in the opposite group (the 10% of drivers with 50% of accidents) is "drive all the time, commercially or otherwise".

saalweachter··on Paramount Caught Using 'Astroturf' Group to Drum Up Fake Support for Merger
The thing about saying "everyone does it" to justify yourself is that eventually you start believing it.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →