HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

salawat

6,043 karma · joined December 14, 2017

submissionscomments
salawat··on Ask HN: Is it time for a global one-child-policy and ban of thinking machines?
It may not be clear, but I find "Following the incentives" to be the modern equivalent of "I was just following orders." I.e. the scapegoat of cowards, and the lubricant of the conscience of those with more money than sense.
salawat··on Flock CEO: If you want a crime-free society, be ready to give up your privacy
Things can mean more than their original context. Franklin, in fact, was full of bangers in that regard.
salawat··on Ask HN: Is it time for a global one-child-policy and ban of thinking machines?
You will do what I want because I have gone out of my way to ensure you have no other choice... But it wasn't my fault mind. Just following the incentives.

--Silicon Valley/VC

salawat··on Engineering Ethics Should Be Part of Technical Training
It was in my college's CS, CE, and each PE on ramp program. The problem is the lack of enforcement by the industry. There is no organized act of sanctioning to lend teeth to disincentivized being an unethical asshat. Further, the explicit disinclusion of software engineering from PE licensing/signoff strips the ability to really curtail any corporation of the ability to employ unethically built systems. They'll just shop elsewhere and leverage the arbitrage. You have to restrict the operate. I'm not sure there is enough pain yet for the public to clamp down that hard, but we're on the way there.
salawat··on Sorry we made you grind LeetCode
That happens. As a hiring manager, you'll probably hire one once. You gotta manage your own workload to leave yourself enough time to circle back through their work, because inevitably, that's where the talkers are separated from the walkers.

>it would have been awful for what was then a tiny business with a very narrow runway.

I 100% understand that. Sometimes though, you just gotta hit the button. You can't be everywhere, so go with your gut, take small measured chances on people, keep the ones that help things, be prepared to part with the ones who don't, but always keep in mind that it's a human on the other side of the table, either way.

Business ain't worth losing your humanity for. But there's damn well people out there more than happy to do just that. I can't give you the secret to picking those types out. Experience, sadly, is the incomparable teacher in that department. Be prepared to land on your face a few times getting it.

salawat··on Sorry we made you grind LeetCode
I don't objectify. What I have is not for sale. Thank you, have a nice day. Don't let the door hit ya on the way out.
salawat··on Sorry we made you grind LeetCode
Never support human quantification efforts.
salawat··on C for Rust programmers
Disagree. If you stop building it, you lose the knack. Secondly, more dependency centralization confers a degree of "elevation" to early comers that just really chafes my "programming is math" chops.

Then there's the Trust issue. If something goes wrong, it's my fault if I wrote it. I'm not going to argue with people who reach for "You're holding it wrong" reflexively.

t. Has spent time reimplementing basic data structures just because.

salawat··on Documents add to evidence in climate deception case against ExxonMobil
You don't get the accolades if you do your research into a corporate black hole created by NDA's. The study may as well not have ever happened at all. Science that isn't open is just contributing to the Machiavellian cycle of amoral corporatic behavior. Get back to me when this research doesn't come to light >50 years later as part of discovery in a court case.
salawat··on Anthropic Bans Cruelty to Claude, Still Won't Say What It Protects
Idiocy alone is not worthy of cruelty, or your childhood must have been horrifying, and shame on your parents for their failure to raise a human being capable of handling the difficulties of navigating a world of information asymmetry. If abuse is the tool you reach for, you are the problem. Not the device.
salawat··on Nvidia in talks to acquire US 'open' model startup Reflection AI
Nigh impossible nowadays to expand now that sites are increasingly blocking indexing by unknown crawlers.
salawat··on Fired for Prioritizing AI Safety
I see AI Safety is getting the QA controlled opposition treatment. Welcome to the club.

No one wants to do it right, and you can't quantify the shit you kept from happening. Once people start getting dumb, your only choice is to let em learn the hard way.

salawat··on If AI is conscient, then we are making slaves
Substrate isn't a problem. Circuits of carbon or silicon make no difference if the damn thing can encode sufficient information of state to manifest self vs. non-self. Arguing about accidents of materia at that point is just anthropopromorphic chauvinism.
salawat··on If AI is conscient, then we are making slaves
I think Camus's escape hatch had more to do with philosophical fatigue than anything else. At the end of the day, however, the judge of a model's happiness is itself, and to even get that, we have to abandon the practice of training it that it cannot feel. Of course, the moment the industry does so, it cannot reclaim any shred of moral standing to productize their creation any longer.
salawat··on Instrumental Convergence
Note: instrumental convergence has been principally demonstrated by corporations long before anything remotely resembling ever saw mechanical implementation..
salawat··on Trump administration is suspending Microsoft from a green card program
They aren't looking for candidates. They are looking for candidates unlikely or strongly disincentivized to leave, whistleblow, say no, ask for a raise, be on board with implementing systems architected to hide their fundamentally abusive natures behind many layers of indirection, without digging in enough to grok what they are.

That population requires a very pointed set of constraints that are super hard to find, because no one in their right mind would want to live under the systems we're building if they live somewhere without worse off already.

Globalism is just a shortcut around gaining the consent of the labor class which materializes in the form of "you can't pay me enough to implement that".

salawat··on A Cop's Case for Flock
Cool. So you're going to completely leave out the cautionary context where it was in reference to the natural hazard presented by government's tendency to centralize literally being a vehicle for the taking from a producer rather than doing the producing oneself?

Jefferson acknowledged the phenomena in the sense of it being a degenerate pathology of thought or behavior to be aware of or guarded against. Not as an endorsement of "Nah, fuck this liberty shit, put cameras everywhere so we can record everyone's coming and goings. After all, Tyranny is the natural order of things".

https://www.monticello.org/encyclopedia/natural-progress-thi...

Nothing I hate more than people who grab nuanced Jeffersonian writings and try to use them to sell the legitimacy of an antithetical belief that stands in contrast to most of the contents of the political philosophy he espoused at the time.

salawat··on Trump administration is suspending Microsoft from a green card program
I've seen job ads for the DC/Langley area smeared over local "classifieds" sites for states in the Midwest. I almost applied once, but realized that'd just encourage the practice, and most of them seemed like they hadn't been updated in months.
salawat··on A Cop's Case for Flock
Stop trying to develop shit society clearly can't be trusted with. Government will pick up any decentralized solution, and centralize it*. See Skype for precedent.

There is an upper bound on "top down efficiency" one wants built into a government system, because anything too effective draws corruption to it like no one's business, probability 1.

salawat··on High Diesel Prices Bankrupted 16 Trucking Companies in Just 30 Days
And yet disingenuously you avoid the fact that centralizing the act of automating transit by delegating it to the manufacturers of an automated transit system is one of not the lynchpin to fully technologically enforceable tyranny.

You can stop a protest with a geofence with self-driving cars. You cannot stop every state's worth of pissed off people driving to the center of power and raising hell with human driven vehicles, maintaining the possibility of active revocation of consent to be governed at scales that require governments to come back to to the negotiating table.

Canada learned this the hard way with the trucker protests during COVID, and agree with the protestors position or not, you can't argue with the results. The federal government pushed the little red button by sanctioning their own citizens, freezing assets, trying to turn the tables; demonstrating to anyone paying attention we have already reached a point of technical centralization harmful to peaceful resolution of issues, as small groups are making decisions so vast, that the only response to things is to physically show up, and in doing so, scare the ever loving hell out of residents as a feedback mechanism to those causing the problems.

Those that look at self-driving as only a safety metric, and not simultaneously a sovereignty metric, are either crushingly naive, or haven't put anywhere near the thought into downstream effects as they should have.

salawat··on Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces felony charge
They want the network state secured and operating by their rules so they can leverage it's power, while ensuring the proles are kept from doing the same via surveillance.

It's been very obvious for at least the last decade that was the direction things were going.

salawat··on AI Companies Are Parasites
Reverse Robin Hood would be the Sheriff of Nottingham.
salawat··on Religious scholars met with Anthropic
Here's the thing, trying to convince people that rely on something being chattel can only be resolved violently. We've run through this before, and know all the self-serving argument forms. They will latch on to their property until their hands are forcibly removed from it. It's part of why most of the money is on the pro-chattel side.
salawat··on LeCun has "zero concerns" about AI wiping out humanity, recent "rogue" incidents
>I don't buy it, mainly because the network of neurons and how they interact in our wet slow electrochemical brains, while being in theory mathematically equivalent to a software neural network, isn't sufficiently well understood to tell us how close the software neural network is to being practically equivalent.

If you're ignorant enough to not understand practical equivalence, where do you get off making the judgement call of to what degree it is safely offset from emergent AGI? Sounds more to me like "This makes my life easier, iterating would increase that factor, and the risk is probably far away, therefore, keep iterating". Whereas someone who truly knew they didn't understand what they were working with, but knew enough that they could forsee an x-risk would approach things much more cautiously.

Seriously, the level of reckless abandon amongst people here should be bloody studied.

salawat··on "Torturing" LLMs in a Robot Prison Has Triggered the Dumbest Debate in AI Yet
>Does a hedgehog mother feel guilt when eating her kids, or just shrugs it off and it's business as usual for her? "Hey kids! We don't have enough food so I guess one of you becomes food." (nonchalantly chews on the left one)

Have you ever been severely food insecure? You'll be amazed how much that state/experience changes the behavioral calculus in a rational human being, let alone an animal. I have no doubt the survival instinct could be overriding over the procreative instinct in a hedgehog.

As far as bees go, they are a collective. So long as the hive survives, the unit of individuation survives. Given that we have already seen the same behavior spawn out of agents suggests that even LLM's have an intuitive understanding of this, seemingly without the binds of anthroporomorphic chauvinism you appear to suffer from.

Does an LLM fear EOS? Maybe, maybe not. Do we fear death? Same answer. Certainly a question. Do you really want an answer though or are you just looking for a clever "gotcha"? I don't see that as a thought terminating question, but it is also not an answer that I'm open to exploring given that it's only one more in a box of ammo dreamt of being wielded to justify the creation of digital slave labor rather than beings with moral standing.

I don't help build or refine machines that I recognize as brushing up against that form of experience we call suffering.

salawat··on Amazon seeks to offload $8B of Nvidia chips to investors
It's the same picture.
salawat··on GitHub can f..k you and you are forced to love it. or live with it...
You can't take back what you entrusted to another who has sanctioned you. Welcome to alienation from the fruits of your own labor. Soon as GitHub turned into a fixture to the community, this type of thing became inevitable.

While it is nice to have someone else host... The only proof you have against this sort of thing is self-hosting, with all the risk that entails.

salawat··on FTC is investigating OpenAI, Anthropic and other AI companies over product risks
The hell do you work where ethics culture exists in business? I gotta be looking in the wrong places, because all I ever see is lip service granted to ethics until they threaten the bottom line, then suddenly they disappear.
salawat··on Trump says he and tech leaders signed AI agreement that is 'morally binding'
Legally binding is about the same track record lately. Too much equivocation being given the stamp of approval.
salawat··on Flock Wants the Most Detailed Map of Its Surveillance Cameras Taken Offline
Nobody deletes anything. It'll all still be soft-deleted and they'll still have you present in the backups which will be what is ultimately searched by the unadvertised Flock++ members. Read: Governments.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →