HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

salawat

6,043 karma · joined December 14, 2017

submissionscomments
salawat··on You Know Who Hates AI? Insurance Claims Adjusters
Can confirm. Until I worked on an honest phone system tuned to actually get people connected with call centre reps, I never quite had a feel for how malicious many contact funnels have become. A good one runs like a Swiss watch, and is trivially tunable to sub-5 to 10 minutes wait times. Anything longer is a conscious choice on the company's execs part. It doesn't "just happen", and to the degree it does, it shouldn't be happening on the regular. Not if you're watching your metrics and tuning appropriately.
salawat··on Dwarf Fortress' creator says the industry's in shambles over AI
Don't assume people are trolling. That's how we got where we are. The response to "No one could possibly be that daft..." Is "Of course they can, and they aren't going to disappear if you ignore them."
salawat··on Thoughts on Pope Leo XIV's Magnifica Humanitas
Greed is good for the Greedy, but disasterous for anyone you'd ever want live with. Greed simplifies and creates clarity by destroying and debasing acts of humanity that are actually worthy to something that can exist as a row in a ledger. A society cannot thrive on greed alone. A society based only on greed abandons every moral check against corruption and manipulation imaginable. There is nothing more frightening to a crook than a world full of decent people that can't empathize with greed, and will actually talk amongst themselves about it, and react. Without greed, people can't be easily greased or goaded. They can't be controlled or cajoled or moved with mere trickery. You are forced to appeal in the one thing the crook doesn't have in abundance. Virtue, and rightness.
salawat··on Flock Safety's controversial CEO just got a taste of his own medicine
Hanlon's Razor is especially effective at getting Good people to put out their own eyes to keep them nice and soft targets for the malicious. I'll take being a harder to find likable by people I have no desire to be liked by to make myself a harder mark. The honest ones will understand. The malicious were never worth being close with, and I'm doing the world a service by getting the borderline enlightened.

Sufficiently advanced stupidity being indistinguishable from malice is also something to keep in mind.

salawat··on Flock Safety's controversial CEO just got a taste of his own medicine
Your rate limits on adding and removing credit cards? Your input sanitization? Designing your system to not just disclose details around anything but that relevant to a logged in/authenticated user?

There are many practical ways to handle that sort of thing that isn't Cloudflare. It just requires thinking and a bit of dev time.

t. Been there, done that, cartels used an app to try to launder money through loyalty programs. Management was deadset against doing the one single thing that would make it impossible to do that at scale.

Ulterior motives abound everywhere but especially behind people claiming X is the only answer. Fingerprinting is far more intrusive than just only allowing one to add at max 2 cards a day per user.

salawat··on Will AI developers be on the bench of future Nuremberg-like trials?
When you start finding yourself asking these types of questions, it is a very strong sign to slow down and step back.

Whether you listen to your intuition or go full speed ahead... Well, that's on you. I know what let's me sleep at night.

salawat··on Humanity has the debate about AI consciousness backwards
It is hard to get a man to understand that which his paycheck depends on him not understanding. But they need more than a Philosophy class. They need several, and a practicum, then a Voight-Kampff-esque test to ensure understanding and that the lesson sunk in, with a shock collar and a behavior monitor overseen by someone who does pass to ensure they experience what they do to these systems in a more tangible way.

Human beings are notorious for being nonchalant about other's pain when they are insensate to it.

salawat··on Taylor Farms: How One Company's Reach Became a National Risk
Consolidation does not improve food safety. Read the ISO's. The standards of the industry are equally effective at a scale of 10 or 1000 different orgs. Everyone watches everyone else, and makes batches traceable, and those who don't are told to shape up by downstream, or they lose downstream consumers.

Consolidation's only benefit is shifting the fiscal gain into fewer pockets, which comes with it's own perverse incentives. (See the Boeing/Airbus duopoly and the problems that causes.)

salawat··on Felony charges for citizen deleting phone data at US Border
The almighty 10bux. I do indeed.
salawat··on Boeing engineers, tech workers reject contract offer
>While you are at work, forget about your free speech rights. You must obey the CEO. That's what you are paid to do. Obey.

There is a very particular tension that results from over-consolidation and the inability to support competitors in a sector. Having become TBTF, it is such that governing philosophies converge to a only one set thereof. This is half the reason it is preferable to have 100 redundant manufacturers, rather than 1 super integrated one you can't do anything about. Employee arbitrage of employer and employers having to literally compete with one another for talent keeps managerial excesses in check.

Get rid of those extra competitors, get rid of the check on shitty corporate behavior.

salawat··on What we lost when search stopped making us think
No. Unless you count the non-existence of the DMCA which essentially resulted in the creation of an accessible and accurate internet index becoming de facto illegal, and the fact webmasters and other netizens actually operated with enough restraint to not have crawlers, web spiders, and what few scrapers there were hammering sites to the point of ruin in the search for moar data.

It was an index that could be searched via Boolean operator, with a few other more complex operators attached. The biggest problem came in once SEO became a thing and started reverse engineering the relevance algorithms, completely poisoning the index.

salawat··on What we lost when search stopped making us think
The way one successfully fights a tidal wave is lining up with peers and resisting the siren call of "if I don't someone else will." Solidarity is how these things have been worked out since before I was alive.

It sucks, but no one ever said a life lived right would always be easy.

salawat··on AI boosted homework scores, then exam scores dropped: study
Doing the right thing never becomes less rational. It may suck compared to the temptation towards the alternative, but part of growing up and being responsible is realizing there is a reason the shortcut isn't supposed to be normalized.
salawat··on Stop Anthropomorphizing Intermediate Tokens as Reasoning/Thinking Traces (2025)
What is terrifying is the propensity of people hoping for a mechanical slave to do everything possible to avoid touching on the possibility for being-ness of the technology they are desperately hoping will work as a basis for that implementation.
salawat··on Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does it without consequence
You just created a large, TBTF corp's veto. Pass a law or have a law passed a corp TBTF doesn't want? Break it and force the Government's hand to strike it down.
salawat··on Every Model Cheats
Insurers are corporations. What makes you think they just won't pay out or will cease being useful as anything but value extractors?

Honestly, the fetishization of "Insurance will save us" needs to die. The risk doesn't go away.

salawat··on Every Model Cheats
People problem, not tech problem. Can't solve people problems with tech, you can only make them worse, and wider.
salawat··on Don't paste the AI, please
There's something profoundly disrespectful about feeding snippets produced by human authors en masse into a machine learning algorithm to create a predictive text generator to be applied as labor replacement, regardless of accuracy or appropriateness to the context or use case. There's something profoundly disrespectful about forcibly scraping the human corpora without asking for permission first, or considering compensation in anyway, or just setting out that "yeah, we're doing this, and damn the consequences". There's something profoundly disrespectful about then taking this device running on investor money chasing the promise of a value that just can't conceivably be delivered, and employing it to do all the unethical things you could imagine just because you can engineer the "No" out of the model.

Of course the level of moral disengagement that's rife around here generally precludes any recognition of such things, as that might be construed as "harshing the vibe on the innovation, man". So I guess everyone had better just settle in and get used to some serious profound disrespect until this type of thing hits enough of a critical mass that a societal ethics framework begins to manifest around it and not be ignored.

salawat··on White House Says Slavery Is Being Taught Wrong, Should Not Be So Negative
What makes you think that healthcare being tied to the coincidence of employment isn't a similar form of golden handcuff?

If you can't control what the employment circumstances are, you are fundamentally servile to the operation of the System. Keep that in mind. That vote is on an ass that goes in a seat. That ass in the seat is not bound in any way to deliver, and with enough bloody money, it doesn't matter truth or lies, it gets said all the same. What's on the table plays, and you ain't at the table.

salawat··on Where Human Sleep Went Wrong
Life has a surprising amount of detail, and if you're only curious enough to interact with the answer as 'technobabble', this does not speak well of your genuine curiosity on the subject. However, in general...

Form is shaped by function. The liver/pancreas are designed to handle the production of detoxifying/neutralizing agents that may in and of themselves kill nearby tissue, resulting in the propensity for notable regenerative capabilities. Kidneys/intestines are high surface area to provide more room for the physical processes driving selective permeability to occur, as well as habitable spaces for beneficial microbial symbiotes that aid in digestion. Skeletal/smooth cardiac muscles are optimized for energy burning to facilitate movement. Tendons/cartilaginous membranes are optimized for lubricating joints/connective tissue purposes. Tissues like the thalamus and tonsils, are there for immunity modulation and detection. Neural tissue however is all about signal propagation, and creating shifting networks of continuity that encode information and patterns, the tissue itself is just the medium, and that medium requires some process to clean out or reset the gradients in the synaptic gap. Otherwise, electrical charges cannot be consistently conveyed as flows of ions, actuated by releases of neurotransmitters into the bridge of the synaptic gap. The other constraint unique to neural tissue as well is it isn't motile, or capable of physical movement. All it can do is carry charge by a process of chemically modulated action potential building, yet also needs to have a means to carry out adjusting it's environment which coincidentally, tends to be filled with ions. Ions + coordinated patterns of charge propagation creates effective pumping infrastructure capable of creating overall fluid movement without the help of direct cardiovascular pressure, which can also facilitate the movement of non-charged molecules given sufficient ionic movement to disturb the neutral medium. However, this coordinated firing pattern to create overall ion flow isn't "information encoding to the cognitive process at hand" per se. It's just a bunch of cells getting fluid to move to get waste products to another location to get handled. None of those "knows" anything more than it's immediate environs, but based on things like quorum signalling in biofilms, it isn't outside the realm of possibility, that neural tissue has a completely chemically mediated process by which it knows "gradient blah can be shifted if everyone around me fires", and that given sufficient time and scope, you get an emergent quorum signalling based metabolic progress that selectively induces "coordinated garbage" from the information processing point of view, but very much not biologically/physically garbage point of view, in that that firing pattern clears the chalkboard so to speak for further processing.

So to answer your question: why do nerves seemingly need to stop what we want them to do (full time cogitation as directed by an emergent consciousness that their physical processes collectively facilitates)? The answer comes down to homeostatic maintenance, and work the tissue has to do because that's how it evolved. You use the same bunch of neurons, they fill the immediate space with metabolic waste products which makes further firing or usage more difficult until the waste products can be cleared. How do you clear them? Stop doing what you're doing & ion pumpas a group. Coordinated ion pumping isn't driving the pattern recognition/consciousness engine in ways that make any sense, it's just cycling fluid to refresh the operating environment to restore the substrate for unburdened cognition again.

Eukaryotic organisms are hard, maddeningly complex, and contain an astonishing amount of detail for something that for whatever reason, usually just seems to work. Could write volumes on these things for how deep the rabbit holes go.

salawat··on Expert Witness to ChatGPT: "Show how 3M is 0 percent at fault"
More like the depth of your wallet. Remember, bullshit asymmetry principle applies, and when the accounting is done, the bill is due. The bigger purse has a much greater advantage.
salawat··on The National Park Service Is Using Flock. Rangers Are Pissed
Enantidromia. It's just kind of how we humans work. The more you push, the harder the backlash. Mind, that doesn't mean any policy is wrong per se, but trying to change something without taking it into account is a fool's errand.
salawat··on Where Human Sleep Went Wrong
The fact they electrically signal via chemical analogs fuelled by immersion in nutrient bearing fluid that also accretes waste products, yet is kept separate from the primary loop of the cardiovascular system by the blood-brain barrier?
salawat··on Diesel Margins Top $100 a Barrel to Reach Record High as Supply Crunch Grows
Our technological grasp has exceeded our societal capability to responsibly wield and direct it. This same situation was absolutely rife in philosophical circles around the world wars of the last century, (see Heidigger's writings on technology), and the stakes are only higher now.

We are now down the last generation to have eye witnessed and executed nuclear Holocaust. Their tapes are all that remain. The first generations to truly industrialize the process of bringing death (rise of the machine gun, poison gas, concentration camps, weaponization of aircraft and the flying machine), have likewise, left the experiential pool, leaving only their written, and otherwise recorded material behind which does a fat lot of good if no one can be arsed to actually read, watch, or be affected by these cautionary accounts.

Throw in the increasing centralization of wealth and power, the unchecked consolidation running rampant, and massive arbitrage of the third world to avoid paying for the externalities of our industrial bases, and the knock-on consequences arising from climate change and concomitant political destabilization, and the stage is set for some very, very bad times if we do not mature and get very damn serious, very quick.

salawat··on Sticky wage norms and the real wage cost of unexpected inflation
>People won't ever stop wanting things.

Citation required. I assure you, wanting vs. being able to realistically acquire is a very powerful force of want extinguishment. You cannot, in fact, get a thing, if the world around you is not conducive to enabling you to pull the requisite capital together to meet the prices set. Something that is getting markedly harder for various strata in the economy currently.

salawat··on Meta's blockbuster trial draws parallels to big tobacco
The poster is implying the reinforcement at play is the problematic thing at issue, and they are assigning the word "gambling" to represent it, or so it looks like to me. I think you aren't parsing their meaning correctly because what they seem to be aiming for is extinguishing the automatic reinforcement.

You're claiming it's making your life better, ostensibly by a relative report of the hedonic response a newly introduced piece of music auto delivered to you by the recommendation algorithm invokes. The problem they hint at though is the passive nature involved. You aren't finding that new piece, it's getting pushed. That pushing incentivizes optimizing for continued engagement, an act children, intellectually and developmentally disabled individuals, as well as those in the throes of cognitive decline/impairment, are not at all well equipped to self-regulate against when pitted against paid behavioral psychologists designing maximally engagement encouraging interfaces.

The incentive, and the existence of predatible populations is the problem I take away from it. I can agree you should be free to opt-in mind, but I can also see the wisdom in a by default interface wherein engagement hacking is forbidden being the norm, and that norm coming with a minimally controversial algorithm boiling down to "chronological feed of known/subscribed to sources", followed by a link of some sort to open an interface to the recommendations.

Facebook/Insta/Shorts are absolutely not that non-engagement farming interface. Hell my grandmother toward the end was about driven mad by it, and it was all I could do to just try to remind her that just because the machine had it on offer doesn't mean she had to partake, but her community centric character made that a bit of an ordeal for her.

There is absolutely a pathological pattern to the way tech companies hunt for eyeballs to monetize, and it is a damn shame it's taken this long to start getting traction to even talk about it.

salawat··on Amazon scans and destroys books to comply with copyright law
Issue isn't with libraries. Issue is with pathological incentive systems rewarding the manufacturing of artificial scarcity, and the fact that pseudo-capitalist zealots cannot accept that maybe just maybe money is not normal should be the end objective of existence.
salawat··on Has the hallucination problem in AI been solved?
What makes you think I'm not concerned about it? I've been positively mortified at the seeming cavalier way in which all caution is thrown to the winds. I've honestly had to fundamentally reassess my understanding of the average character of humanity given the last decade.

Fact is, those with the foresight to see how this can go badly are also seemingly the types of people who don't end up in a position to prevent harms by it. Furthermore, it seems inevitable in a sense, because greed for power seems to necessitate development of automated weapons in ASAP in spite of the risks, and the fact it basically renders traditional warfare pointless.

It appears we'll have to learn the hard lessons, same as our forebearers with. I just hope we can avoid having to regress back to sticks and stones on account of fucking ourselves by overdoing our capability to destroy on account of not being willing0able to peacefully coexist.

salawat··on Has the hallucination problem in AI been solved?
The types of people using it that way are not concerned with the best interests of anyone but themselves, and arguably not even that except within a very immediate time horizon.
salawat··on AI Can Now Design Functional Viruses. Should We Worry?
Keep in mind the world is run by hierarchs. Of course the solution will look hierarchical in nature. The problem is fundamentally speaking, the hierarchism is a self perpetuating problem, because we still have to solve who amongst us can be trusted with the top of the hierarchy, which hierarchism states by definition "most of us can't be". It's like encryption, it's excellent at turning every other hard problem into a key management problem.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →