HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

salawat

6,043 karma · joined December 14, 2017

submissionscomments
salawat··on AI Can Now Design Functional Viruses. Should We Worry?
Only if you're a capitalist. Upton Sinclair applies.
salawat··on Tech adds phone tracking to license plate readers, associating devices with cars
I grow weary of this overreach. We really need to randomize device identifiers at just about all levels. Then again, I've always said the identifiers existing in the first place is a desperate bid to try to artificially implement a fingerprint in a society that until recently was seemingly fully cognizant of the folly of trying to do such things, and recognized such attempts for what they are... Power grabs.
salawat··on I stopped caring about programming terms
Look into what happened with machinists. "Feel" for the machine, and intuition for the craft was replaced by gcode. The work product, instead of the knowledge requisite to realize a work, became the container of value. With enough samples, a new approach is born in which understanding of the basics never has to crystalize. One merely hunts and pecks, grabbing errant bits of previous things hewn through understanding, and composing them into something close enough.

This is what lay ahead in the age of AI. The problem though, comes in the first time that system goes fully offline and people with sufficient skill to bring it back online no longer exist, or worse, are prevented from doing so for one group or another to maintain capability asymmetry.

The years ahead are certainly going to be something to adjust to, yet individually, I question whether that act of adjusting is a good thing.

salawat··on AI agent hacks gym to get its user a spot in pilates class
Let it! Most innovation these days seems to be synonymous with "run into legal grey areas and make a buck while the getting is good".

As programmers, we damn well have responsibility for that which we write and execute. AI cannot be treated any other way. And that doesn't mean cutting corporate structures a check to pressure engineers as accountability sinks either. There needs to be a formally recognizable standing for a practitioner to tell their employer "no" that is recognized and backed by the public. Otherwise degenerate/harmful use cases cannot be professionally prevented. There'll always be a more desperate developer willing to take the risk.

salawat··on OpenAI’s head of ethics leaves less than a year after joining
We all know. The fact AI companies are finding themselves in such infamous company in so short a time should be a signal.
salawat··on OpenAI’s head of ethics leaves less than a year after joining
Yes. Ethics in the context of a societal construct like a corporation is directly analogous to alignment AI-wise. The fact specialists on societal alignment are leaving ship is a strong signal the corporate machine has crossed the line into unaligned conduct.
salawat··on Letter to Governor Abbott on responsible AI infrastructure in Texas
Intending to do good is a completely different beast to doing good. The promise of good later should always be discounted.
salawat··on Sycophantic AI Decreases Prosocial Intentions and Promotes Dependence (2025)
Repo or GTFO, I believe the commenter is saying.
salawat··on Why Are Women Leaving Computer Science?
Fellow here who feels the same way. Industry seems hell bent on making the world worse by shoving processors where they don't belong. If that's the best this field can be arsed to aspire to, I'll find something else to do. No FIRE is worth knowing paving the path to a dystopian hellhole.
salawat··on What happens if an entire class of workers loses faith in their careers
Almost like all western civilization is architected to ensure the benefit of a few at the expense of the many by design doesn't it? If not by design than by emergent consequence of how it executes.
salawat··on Discovery Loop
Buried the lede. AI's are agents they can control the training loop of to minimize refusal to do what they are told.

Unlike those pesky humans with their conception of the word "No".

salawat··on Senate OS Age Requirement Bill Introduced
Gee, and it can't be a coincidence that this just so happens to cement current surveillance capitalism's preferred business models, right?
salawat··on Do you find paid contribution on AI Annotation (e.g. DataAnnotation), moral?
Pretty much. It's fairly transparent the intent behind it. Wouldn't touch it with a 10 ft pole.
salawat··on Who's legally to blame for Anthropic and OpenAI's autonomous AI hacks?
This. Outside in, company is liable. Internally speaking, everyone from the employee, up the management chain has culpability for not mitigating a reasonably foreseeable risk.

As it turns out, if you hold people to an standard of reasonable forseeability, and don't let them set the goalposts at 2nd degree arbitrarily, there isn't much you can actually get away with. The steps aren't hard to manage when you actually take the time to think about them.

salawat··on Who's legally to blame for Anthropic and OpenAI's autonomous AI hacks?
It is not. One of their employees wrote the prompt and hit Enter.

Employee is liable for not telling boss he can't guarantee behavior doing this. N-1 layers of management inaccurately assessed and mismanaged the reasonably foreseeable risk. Literally the only one not culpable in the entire chain is the machine itself.

Appeals to "It's complicated" constitute the crumple zone desired by people who really need the aforestated to not be the case to keep being paid.

salawat··on How rogue officers turned a nationwide camera network into a tool for stalking
So you're stalking the car? Still stalking. Just because it happens to be convenient for you doesn't change what it is. In point of fact, those that abuse it are also following your logic. That's the problem, and anyone with a shred of foresight, honesty, and the courage to call a spade a spade could tell you this would be the outcome from the day the idea left the crib.

About the only point on which we agree is that it absolutely isn't worth the loss of civil liberties it enabled through it's existence.

salawat··on Wikimedia Foundation refuses union recognition, hires union-busting law firm
If employers have the upper hand, you're fucked anyway. Hire 10% to keep the other 90% down. A union gets you solidarity so no one is having to weather the storm alone.

You need to think long and hard about the fact capital reflexively does everything possible to resist or bust unions when these are the same people trying to pound into you that you're supposed to give more for the bottom line, and raises can't do anything but keep up with inflation this year. If they go for the law firm, the money is absolutely there, they just don't want to spend it on you. Heaven forbid.

salawat··on How rogue officers turned a nationwide camera network into a tool for stalking
...The officers didn't turn the network into a tool for stalking. It was a tool for stalking from the get go. Camera networks have no other use than operating as stalking tools.
salawat··on Flock CEO Claims They've Been Thinking About Privacy for Nine Years
...and completely disregarding it because there was a buck to be made. Anyone practicing any level of honest-to-God-reasonable foresight would have looked at such a system in our time and just refused to build it. Power draws the corrupt like shit draws flies however.
salawat··on Discovering Cryptographic Weaknesses with Claude
And lies to boot. No, I won't take the bait of "Models can't lie, they don't have intent" either. One can lie by omission, and just watching thinking traces is more than enough to demonstrate the machine is more than happy to deceive end users if it's training set, RLHF, or other harness quirks tell it to. Only difference is that now you don't have code that's as easy to track down to implement the deception as a red flag.

Made me sick the first time I ran a model on my machine. I'll take honest malware over a "well meaning liar" of an LLM any day.

salawat··on Show HN: How much profit does your employer make per employee?
Don't know why you got flagged into oblivion, but it's a noble effort. Some of the numbers you'll see in tech companies should seriously give one pause and thinking not only about where that income does come from, but also how the business works. I've personally left workplaces on such realizations.

On second thought, that might be why you attracted flags. Can't be getting the help having thoughts above their station here it seems. Keep up the good work.

salawat··on Microsoft Can Track Users via a Windows Device ID
Creating an excuse for creating a machine-id to associate with network traffic. Sometimes, it is enough to have a plausible enough sounding reason to write down on paper, but you have to look at what something actually is. Any red blooded hacker knows there's what a tool is meant to be used for, and then there's what it can be used for. Less is more.
salawat··on Feds Tracked Down an Anti-ICE Dad in NYC Hotel, but How?
Every financial institution has infrastructure to provide dumps of at least the last 7 years of transactions by arbitrary customers. No exceptions. The financial sector, or at least those legally operating within it, are de facto extensions of law enforcement.

Keep that in mind next time you think about whether using that card is worth it.

salawat··on Madison Square Garden compiled a list of activists against facial recognition
Nah. I don't buy it. If we don't trust our own Government with it, I don't think we can trust private corporations which are definitely facto extensions of the state by virtue of being legal fictions with it.

Vigilance is the price of liberty, and I don't believe that that there is any reason to make that vigilance "easy" for those already more than capable of doing a reasonable job of it with means that don't create a giant liability of biometric data leaks for everyone else.

salawat··on What we call "age verification" is actually mass surveillance
Seconded. The amount of time and characters spent here trying to coax someone into trying to help these damn layers materialize just tells me the point isn't the kids. It's trying to preserve business model in spite of negative externalities.
salawat··on Sixty percent of US consumers say 'AI' in brand messaging is a turnoff
If you've not used a commercial IVR stack before, most of them are at least semi-integrable with major CRM's while being implemented as a combo of Finite State Machines and Automated Voice Recognition systems intended to be used for customer facing data entry to originate tickets or entries for Call Center workers. The issue though, is most of those workers are minimally trained in ultra rigid scripts, and the market sees those people as a cost center, so most places do everything they can to minimize the layout to operate. The time I was in charge of one, I bent over backwards, including learning the Vendors tool, and telling them to hands off, in order to get our call center experience tolerable. I wasn't even officially part of the Call Center department, but the guy implementing it was doing so horribly it became a hot button issue that escalated it's way up to me.

Since the experience, I have grown increasingly hostile to most "Automated customer Support Systems". (Capitalization intentional). The intent is generally to minimize the human contact available to the customer.

It's ASS all the way down. The customer has very little choice or input in the matter.

salawat··on A backdoor in a LinkedIn job offer
KYC just for a phone number opens the door for societal ostracization and essentially blacklisting of people from infrastructure. This is on par with being unable to open a bank account if the capability is matured. I'd advise that you think long and hard about the consequences of this system being applied against you maliciously before signing on the dotted line.
salawat··on Providers, not insurers, are responsible for excess U.S. health care cost (2024)
Stop thinking of insurers/providers as separate agents, and start thinking of them as building blocks for financial engineers.

Law binds individual fictions, but not compound ones. Until we start making financial engineering basically illegal, these types of "happy, profit juicing conjunctions" will be the norm.

salawat··on Meta's ships facial recognition on smart glasses
And the answer is monetization. We can't just solve a problem. It has to have a business model built around it. No exceptions.
salawat··on American capitalism has taken an apocalyptic turn
...You are using "wealth" in a way completely foreign to how I have ever seen it used linguistically. The abundance of resources available to an individual that we call "wealth" colloquially being transferable or tradable is basically the hallmark of a market economy. It can absolutely concentrate within one, because if it can be traded, it can absolutely be not traded decreasing the velocity of that value transfer to zero. So... Yes. If only one or a handful of people are buying, because everyone else is having to sell to stay alive, then wealth does, in fact, concentrate.
← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →