562 karma · joined January 18, 2016
I do not deny the severity of COVID-19. For those over the age of 65 it is far more dangerous than the flu. For those under, it is about as dangerous with the exception of those under 30 where it is far less dangerous.
The problem with the world today is that nuance no longer exists. There is a place between doing nothing and draconian lockdowns. But nobody seems to advocate for that middle ground at all.
You have absolutely no clue about my political stance, so don't pretend to know this is motivated by my politics. The problem is that you see this through a lens of politics. You believe that the only reason someone may disagree with you is political.
Please provide data that refutes any of the points I made. I will be happy to check them out and change my mind, if warranted.
We have had 399,857 deaths over the average expectation, and 328k over the upper bound. Are you saying that every single one of those excess deaths are from COVID infections? How many of those are from deaths of despair, lack of preventative healthcare due to closures, abuse, murders, aggravation of Alzheimer's etc.
The simple fact, that I would love to hear a reasonable refutation of, is that a majority of the people who have died from COVID would have died this year from another cause. However, those who have died from the impact of our response would NOT have died this year.
All in all, we reduced the number of life years due to our response. That is the problem.
Edit: Lets look at state data.
Florida has been widely criticized for their lax restrictions, while California has been widely celebrated for their lockdown. So which performed better?
Florida has 18,000 excess deaths and a population of 21.48 million.
California has had 37,000 excess deaths and a population of 39 millions.
So about the fucking same. Notice also that a lot of the excess deaths in California came throughout the Summer, where there wasn't as big a spike as there is now.
But lets take your numbers as they are. It wouldn't be 5% of all infections, or 5% of all severe infections. It would be 5% of all infections _above hospital capacity_. Health systems wouldn't disappear, they would just not take in more folks, or triage more aggressively. I know you address this in your comment, but it is important to note. Because it greatly changes the emotional appeal for your emotional argument to spell it out.
Don't bring long-covid in to this discussion, there is no real hard evidence that it even exists AND is an artifact of covid.
Do you even fucking realize how much our response to COVID has impacted food programs worldwide? How shutting down major economies has pushed our children back by _years_ of educational attainment?
People die from everything, for fucks sake. People die from TB, which inoculations against are way down this year. People die from lack of clean water, which financial assistance from developed nations has tanked this year.This is not even counting the delay in cancer treatment, heart treatment. Hospitals in my state were essentially shut down all Spring and Summer when we had incredibly low community spread. So the woman who is six months late for her mammogram, is her cancer less important than COVID?
When you say people die and it is a big deal, are you only concerned for well-off white people in developed nations? Because I do say you've turned a blind eye to all the death and famine around the world to suddenly be on your high horse when it comes to COVID.
Edit: I am sorry but I need to come back to this. Do you have any idea what these lockdowns are doing to mental health of teens and adults? Suicidal ideation is on the rise as is self-reported depression. So are you saying that those who kill themselves from despair and depression aren't as entitled to support to help _them_. We closed down a nation to support those at risk from COVID. What will we do to support those who are dying from other means, due to our response?
If you truly believe that that trade-off is worth it, then I completely understand now how authoritarian governments convince otherwise logical people to submit. Create an enemy, make everyone afraid of it, and then claim you are the only one who can protect them.
I am sure you are a smart, logical person. But your approval of what would be martial law for a .5% IFR is astounding.
Furthermore, many countries have laws that prohibit house arrest, which is essentially what you are suggesting here.
Finally, unless the entire world did the same, we would not be "covid-free". As soon as one person with covid entered the country post-lockdown, cases would grow. If Australia had actually beaten covid, then they could welcome people back. But they didn't beat it! That isolated themselves from the world and continue to do so. That isn't beating it at all.
You may be right that almost everything is open again, but there are also leaving thousands of their citizens stranded abroad. This is an absurd payoff for a virus that, at worst, kills .5% of people who contract it.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/australia-...
https://www.wsj.com/articles/hospitals-retreat-from-early-co...
This is how my state views the vaccine: "OHA considers the planningfor COVID-19 vaccine to be an opportunity to reimagine how the agency engages communities in co-creating the work of public health. This vaccine plan, as mentioned above, is a starting point for this journey."
Fuck this all. Get shots in the arms right fucking now
How does one define "inclusive and fair". Who decides what is inclusive? The Union? I don't want to apply the fallacy of inclusion, but if someone wears a crucifix and that makes an atheist feel excluded, who is right? I know "the Union will decide" but tyranny of the majority is a real thing. See the ban on burkas/hijabs in many "inclusive" countries.
Also, if you are appealing to the public, saying that the working conditions at Google, where you are paid near the top 1% of the all workers and have free food etc, "working conditions" might not be the right term.
We have the freedom to decline to work on projects that don’t align with our values
When do you declare your values? Is it always a moving target? To be a conscientious objector in the United States, there needs to be a demonstrable history of your objection. You can't get drafted and then suddenly find religion. How do you stop the inevitable abuse of this exclusion?
First, the author goes straight to the ventilator as a fear tactic. The fact remains, most infected do NOT get hospitalized, most hospitalized patients do NOT require ICU level care, many ICU patients do NOT require invasive ventilation. The author makes it seem like there are no steps between getting COVID-19 and being on an invasive ventilator. We now know[1] that this is not even suggested for most patients.
Secondly, they buried the lede a bit, "ICU beds usually run at about 70-80% capacity.". This is a point that is rarely mentioned, so I am glad this author did. But when you hear pearl-clutching news stories about the local hospital being at 80% capacity, remember that is _normal_. And hospitals can manage surges. It is like when the media focuses on case count rather than death rates or % positive rates. It creates a false sense of fear and panic.
Finally, and this is my biggest problem about this article. We all know COVID-19 is dangerous, deadly etc. The market of emotional COVID hit pieces is saturated. It needs to be accepted that each person assess risk differently. And assessing the risk of COVID and deciding to still go to the gym doesn't mean the person hates science or is a dumb person. It means that they are accepting the risk.
You could (convincingly) argue that in a society, we can't assess risk at the personal level as our very existence risks others. This is a deeply philosophical question, and it lands somewhere between the runaway train thought experiment and the butterfly effect. Somewhere between a direct action resulting in death vs. a serious of consequences in which the end result is the death of someone but you were the prime mover. At which point does the "blame" reduce to 0? I am interested in this debate.
Anyway, stop with the emotional pleas. People know. They simply accept it.
[1] https://www.statnews.com/2020/04/21/coronavirus-analysis-rec...
Whereas in the past I made more reckless proclamations about lockdowns and responses, I am trying to retrain my instincts for bluster and provide only what I have strong evidence or data to support.
Not for nothing, but new cases seem to have peaked in Iowa and are now trending downwards, so that is good news!
A quick search seems to indicate that the authorities in Iowa are keeping exact data private. Whether to hide reality or avoid causing a panic, I can strongly say I am against keeping that data private.
And to be consistent, perhaps Des Moines should be locked down but Ottumwa not. But without the data I've not the slightest clue.
I didn't pretend that demographics is important. Demographics _is_ important. I didn't mean to say it was the _only_ factor. My main point was to demonstrate that nobody has convincingly rejected the null hypothesis in any of these response models. My point was that I can posit a reasonable theory that there is correlation between age demographics and COVID deaths/known cases. You (rightly) pointed out a country that has terrible demographics for my theory did fine. The key here is that _both can be true_. Everyone seems to be looking for a panacea when, thus far, one simply does not exist. The lockdown approach has contradictions as well, so if you profusely reject my demographic argument, you can't strongly hold on to lockdowns. We are talking about a disease, that while a relatively "normal" coronavirus, is still novel. And we are comparing responses across nations with wildly different cultures, densities, demographics, health care systems, travel levels, living situations and access to testing. My point is that maybe it was _just_ lockdowns that helped Vietnam. And may it wasn't just the lack of lockdowns that hurt the United States. We need to consider all explanations. And for the record, I do consider lockdowns a valuable tool at times!
Regarding the good will argument. Again you pointed at one location with one culture to imply that it would be widely supported elsewhere. While culturally Australia is probably closer to the United States than any other nation, there are still very key differences. The Australia lookdowns are really interesting for that reason though, that it is culturally similar to the United States. But, and I may be wrong, the lockdowns were limited to Victoria, and were not applied blanketly across their nation. This is not in contradiction to my beliefs. I have posted in the past about the idea that my state locked down _too soon_ before there was community spread. Essentially, we locked down when things were bad in New York. A lot of the opposition to lockdowns in the United States is the blanket approach in which they are applied. Counties with zero of few cases are locked down with the same vigor as metropolitan areas where cases are exploding. People rightly wonder why they can't go to work when the outbreak is across the state. I have always thought very targeted lockdowns would be a reasonable approach.
Furthermore, your points regarding Italy and France supporting lockdowns is rather interesting as well. First, both are far more collectivist than the United States in general. This isn't good or bad, it is a different culture that approaches problems in a different way. It just so happens that viewing the whole as or more important than the individual lends itself to restrictions in the benefit of the whole. The United States traditionally indexes on the individual above the whole (argument being that each individual adds to the whole, so the effect is the same). I am not here to argue individualism vs. collectivism but I will say that the issue is more complex than "Americans don't believe in science" (this may be a straw man, I don't think you've made that argument, but I tangented myself). The other point is that as lockdowns eased, cases rose. So what does that tell us? Two things...
First, it tells us that lockdowns do suppress spread (no shit). You keep people from interacting, and diseases spread through interaction are reduced. Abstinence is also the best way to prevent HIV. It is a truism that lockdowns reduce spread. And I would never argue against that (my argument is that it isn't _just_ lockdowns). But more importantly, it tells us that lockdowns must be maintained in order to continue to reduce spread. The "anti-lockdown" argument is that the time period required to actually _prevent_ deaths (not delay) is too long. It is effectively until 60%+ of the community have received a vaccine (this is ignoring heterogeneity in mixing and travel). A two-week lockdown is absolutely pointless unless at the end of those two weeks everyone is vaccinated. A two-week lockdown just delays the spread.
Now you may be saying, "Mr. salmon30salmon, the goal is not to prevent infection but to reduce strain on hospitals" and I would respond, great! I agree! It is important, even critical, to ensure hospitals are not strained. So why is _that_ not a metric we are chasing? I get the delay, 7-12 days from being infected to being hospitalized, so by the time hospitals are full you are rightly fucked as the next 7-12 days worth of people come in. But as shitty as our models have been, they are somewhat accurate in that timeframe. I support a lockdown for localities where the local hospital is nearing capacity. That makes sense.
Which brings me to the third (maybe final? this is stream of consciousness so we will see) argument. By which metrics are you saying Iowa is worse off than any European country. Let us look at the data, the source of truth in times of madness. All of my data will be from either worldometer or the Bing Covid dashboard.
Iowa:
- There are currently 84,772 active cases (or 27,345 per M)
- Deaths per 1M population: 666
- Tests per 1M population: 359,387
- Cases per 1M population (identified): 62,970
- Positive Test Rate: 17%
- Population of Iowa: 3.1 Million
- Total Case Projection (using a 10x median from Nature[1]: 620,970 * 3.1 = 1.925 Million cases
- Death Projection for ACTIVE identified cases (84,772) (lets take the best best IFR of .6%) = 508
- IFR based on projections: (666 * 3.1) + 508 / 1.925 Million = .13%
- IFR based solely on identified cases: 1%
France:
- There are currently 1,891,592 active cases (or 29,101 per 1M)
- Deaths per 1M population: 792
- Tests per 1M population: 296,031
- Cases per 1M population (identified): 31,935
- Positive Test Rate: 10%
- Population of France: 65.3 Million
- Total Case Projection (using a 10x median from Nature[1]: 31,935 * 65.3 = 19.24 Million cases
- Death Projection for active identified cases (lets take the best best IFR of .6%) = 11,349
- IFR based on projections: (792 * 65.3) + 11,349 / 19.24 Million = .32%
- IFR based solely on identified cases: 2.4%
This was all napkin math, so it may be wrong. But between those two, who is fairing better? I would rather live in Iowa, if my only decision point was COVID risk. Iowa has tested more people (35% of their population!). Thus, more cases have been identified. So based solely on cases, Iowa is doing worse. Now it wasn't fair to apply the 10x to both France and Iowa. Iowa has probably identified more than 10% of their cases due to heavier testing. But that doesn't make it any better for France. That would increase the IFR for Iowa most likely, but not three fold to .32%. Even the identified case IFR is worse for France with 2.4% vs 1%. Even with 5x unidentified Iowa beats France with an IFR of .27%
If I were a decision maker, I would emulate Iowa (limited lockdowns if any, masks encouraged, less dense cities). But this is against my thesis, that one size does not fit all. France is more dense in her cities, has more multi-generational living etc. What works (or didn't work) for France won't work for Iowa. That is why I argue against blanket lockdowns
<3 Salmon30Salmon
Actually let me list what I think, since you seem interested enough in my opinion to spelunk my comment history:
- COVID-19 is a dangerous infection. The degree of risk and severity is directly correlated to age.
- For those below ~30 years old, the infection is between as to much less dangerous than some strains of influenza.
- Between 30-60, the infection is appreciably more dangerous than the flu, but not severely so
- Over 60 the infection is far more dangerous than the flu, and extreme precautions are warranted
- The projections of disease modelers were incredibly off the mark early on, by orders of magnitude. The models are better today.
- The fatality rate was grossly overestimated. Early in the pandemic, we had numbers around 1-3% IFR (not CFR). This was also off by an order of magnitude. Real IFR will end up around .3-.5%. Deadly than the flu, but again with the burden on older people
- Most public health measures we are deploying were created for pandemic influenza. They do not necessarily apply in the same ways to pandemic coronaviruses.
- Masks clearly work to reduce the spread of infections. Not mandating masks is a terrible idea, and governments who have avoided it thus far will be judged harshly
- Influenza has around a 15-20% asymptomatic rate. Coronavirus has twice that. This causes huge problems for contact tracing though it is clearly not impossible
- We over-focused on surface spread and panicked people into disinfecting everything, while ignoring aerosol spread
- We over-focused on spread between strangers and in public, and downplayed the real risk, which is spread within families and those who live in close quarters
- This alone caused imbalanced risk assessments for people. Eating at a restaurant with proper distancing and ventilation IS safer than having an indoor neighborhood block party without masks.
- Lockdowns require an exit strategy that is something beyond "more lockdowns".
- Lockdowns are a great public health strategy if they are incredibly short lived and adhered to
- It was clear in March that the only way out of the pandemic was immunity, be it natural or vaccine enhanced. Lockdowns should have been thrown out the window at that time
- The goal posts were constantly moved from curve flattening to deaths to raw case counts
- Metrics for reopening should have been clear from the start and based entirely upon hospital capacity
- Ignoring the impacts of the lockdown is close-minded thinking that has and will continue to cost lives
- Essentially, we knew by April at the latest that eradication was no longer a possibility, and that we should have switched from eradication to mitigation
- Mitigation would include targeted restrictions based upon age risk
- Mitigation also requires acceptance that cases will increase and deaths will occur, but the goal is to reduce those, we can't aim for elimination. The cost is too great and the odds are too low
- Public health officials shot themselves in the foot several times throughout the pandemic
- While I understand why masks were downplayed originally, that was a terrible mistake. Saying "masks work, but we need them for our medical heroes" or some shit would have been better
- Maybe that would have made masks "cool" instead of a political signaling tool (again, I 100% support mask mandates)
- Outside spread was confused by the support of the civil rights protests in the Spring. We knew then and continue to know that outside spread is very unlikely and that the protests were safe. But at the same time we were shaming people at the beach. Both were safe, and to declare one safer than the other based upon the ontology of the events was a terrible mistake
- The media spread fear and panic before it was warranted. Constant updates on death counts outside of context was a dangerous game.
- Related, most locations locked down too early. Locking down prior to community spread is a waste of resources and good will.
- As said above, lockdowns needs to be applied carefully. Too soon and you blow all good will as time goes on. Too late and you may make it worse by forcing people indoors
- Locking down before community spread exists had the effect of costing states and people millions up millions of dollars with little helpful impact
- The pandemic became a political tool for the left and the right, both wielding it to the extremes. The left was virtually arguing that this was apocalyptic, the right was saying it was the flu. Both are clearly wrong, and the extremism caused public trust to tank as both arguments were easily falsifiable. Once this occurred, early in March, we lost any chance of actually combating the virus in a smart, sustainable way.
Again, anyone who was paying attention would have known that the lockdown strategy would need to extend until there is a vaccine. Nothing would materially change month to month as the lockdowns dragged on. The "just two more weeks" crowd caused a ton of fatigue in people who were earnestly wanting to help stop the pandemic. We needed leadership from the beginning explaining the tradeoffs. Explaining that lockdowns would need to continue intermittently until there was a vaccine. We needed honest leaders telling us clearly that lockdowns do not protect you forever, and once the lockdown ends you are as vulnerable as ever.
Both of those mistakes led to people, again, distrusting the public health officials. We were told we needed to lockdown to stop the spread, and we did so. And then people kept getting sick and dying. Because it was sold as a panacea to the pandemic, when that turned out to not be the case people thought, "fool me once shame on you..." and gave the good ol' middle finger to the public health officials. Again, I don't agree with this attitude but I understand it. It is frustrating to lose your job in the name of safety only to see everyone still die.
Celebrating Europe all summer long when it was so obvious to anyone who thought about it that another wave was coming was shortsighted. We spent all summer saying "if only we could be more like them!" in the United Stats, only to see them end up in the same situation as us in the Fall. Now people are saying, "so you advocated for strict Euro-style lockdowns, and they are in the same boat now.."
Today, lockdowns almost make sense. We have a clear exit strategy with a vaccine around the corner. Except, we already burned all resources and good will locking down too early.
I am not a crazy COVID denier. I am a realist who understands data and human nature.
New Zealand has really 2 truly international airports (Auckland and Christchurch). The United States has over 50. In 2017, the United States saw over ~70,000,000, tourists through her ports of entry, while New Zealand saw 3,700,000 . These statistics are for tourist entries, so they don't even include repatriating citizens who traveled internationally. To institute the same quarantine rules in the United States would be untenable. Furthermore, inbound travelers to the United States _are_ supposed to quarantine for 14 days, there is just no enforcement mechanism.
And regarding the per capita infections, the most important figure is tests/1M population. We both know that testing doesn't cause infections, and tests only tell you what already exists. However, it is equally as true that absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. So just as some nations may be reporting lower per capita infection rates, they also have a lower per capita test rate. You can't, with a straight face, say that India, which has performed 91,359 tests per 1m has fewer cases than the United States, which has performed 516,656 tests per 1M population. Put another way, 50% of Americans have been tested at one point in the past year, whereas only 9% of Indians have been tested.
Before just shitting on everything and having strongly held opinions strongly held, actually research the data and understand the tectonics underlying the world's response. It is not nearly as black and white as you and others seem to think it is.
Tourism data from Wikipedia* (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tourism_in_New_Zealand and (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tourism_in_the_United_States#2...)
Test data from https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/
* It seems that the "Total" row for New Zealand may only be the top 12 countries, but the difference is so large that it hardly matters.
That is to say, I believe the survey is targeted for indoor mask usage, as this is also the mandate in most states that mandate mask wearing (while indoors, or outdoors when 6 feet is not possible)
New Zealand is an island that, for all intents and purposes, closed their ports to human travel.
Early in COVID, everyone suddenly became statisticians and had opinions on exponential growth, and while most of their proclamations were ill-informed, the truth remains that one infection can spiral out of control quickly. With a disease that exhibits nearly 40% asymptomatic rates and is aerosolized, there is no eradication. It will be with us in waves until we are immune via natural immunity or vaccinations.
If New Zealand opened their ports today to the same levels as the United States' ports, they would quickly see a spike.
https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2020/10/06/pandemic...
Perhaps instead of acting like a fool on the internet you research the nonsense you spout. Spreading lies just makes the world more divisive.
Source: https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2020/10/06/pandemic...
I would be interested in seeing if there is data to say whether being put in the ICU actually _increased_ risk of death. Of course this would be hard to prove as only the most sick went to the ICU etc.
I think a majority of people stopped giving a shit in June[1]. The government's continued lockdown policies are 100% at fault for continued economic distress.
Secondly, that is exactly what triage is! People die, doctors are trained to decide of a group of people which are dying, who has the better chance of not dying.
We need to understand better why Vietnam is seeing such positive results but saying you know why for certain is disingenuous