HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

salmon30salmon

562 karma · joined January 18, 2016

submissionscomments
salmon30salmon··on Reddit reports 18% reduction in hate content after banning nearly 7k subreddits
More accurately would be to say Reddit reports 18% of hate content moved to a different platform. This would be akin to saying "salmon30salmon saw a reduction in hate content when he stopped attending hate group meetings".

While I appreciate any attempt to reduce hate, it isn't really something to cheer in this case. The goal is to reduce hate, and pushing people further into the fringes doesn't do that. Now instead of being part of a community that has hate, but also positive information, the hate groups are going to be forced into a more focused hate forum. It is a means to further push people to the fringes which could further radicalize folks.

Essentially, Reddit etc. doesn't make people hate more, the internet just exposes the hate that already existed. It is part of a larger cultural problem. People don't generally become hateful after seeing 12 memes, they are raised in an environment that breeds hate. Banning the subreddits _feels_ good, but it is not a solution to the core problem.

salmon30salmon··on US economy suffers worst quarter since WWII as GDP shrinks 32.9%
COVID parties were mostly fabricated. Don't spread FUD. Unless we locked down until there is a vaccine cases would return.
salmon30salmon··on US economy suffers worst quarter since WWII as GDP shrinks 32.9%
I am sorry, but I think you overcorrected. The problem was that we locked down at all. Nearly the same mitigation could have happened with masks, distance and isolation. Yes, testing was a shitshow.

But look at Spain, Australia etc. If you lock down, eventually the virus comes back. Here are literally the only options:

1. Lockdown fully and completely until there is a vaccine that's distributed

2. Lockdown hard until cases in (Region) are zero and then reopen without any outside entry to (Region)

3. Take public health measures like masking, isolation of sick, protection of weak and accept cases and deaths

4. Ignore it, accept lots of death and cases

This virus will continue to spread until there is immunity, either through natural means or vaccine. Lockdowns don't stop the virus unless migration is also stopped. Period. All it takes is one person to fall through the cracks and your 6 months of lockdown are thrown out the window.

There are structural problems that need to be addressed, the fact that hospitals are profit driven and operate near 100% capacity at all times. The fact that our public health departments are political by their leadership. The fact that there is zero trust of anyone anywhere.

But you fix all of those and you still have a virus that will spread until immunizations levels are met.

Finally, the Gulf States are having their _first wave_! They flattened the curve during the NYC outbreak. But people moved, virus spread.

Lockdowns are a terrible, blunt, unsustainable, damaging, dangerous and ineffective in the long run.

salmon30salmon··on Coronavirus protein treatment trial 'a breakthrough'
To be fair, Remdesivir is an under-patent medicine designed by an American company, it isn't all that outlandish that the USA would procure as much as possible. The "among other things" is doing a _lot_ of heavy lifting in your statement. I do not see any evidence that the USA bought anything that would limit the ability for other countries to develop a vaccine. Only to use Remdesivir as a treatment. Which, I can see both sides of that really.

I also don't have a problem with the USA targeting 300 mil doses through OWS. They simply mean they will buy that many, not that other countries can't buy more etc. As I said, the leading vaccine right now is from a British university and a Swedish/British company funded by the USA (in part). I think it is totally fair for the USA to make a large investment and "pre-order" 300 million doses. If they were ordering 600 million doses and demanding that the patent be transferred to a US company, that would be shady.

But yeah, OWS is certainly part of Trump's re-election campaign. I despise Trump, and I hope OWS is successful well before November. If it gets him re-elected so be it. People are dying.

salmon30salmon··on Coronavirus protein treatment trial 'a breakthrough'
That is Operation Warp Speed[1] and it is a very large investment by the US Government to find a vaccine. You should be thankful that the United States has the money to invest in this global research, instead of spreading FUD that the USA is blocking others from getting treatment. In fact, the Oxford trial that was announced today was heavily funded by this program, with the NHS being some of the first to be vaccinated if the treatment is approved. How dare the USA help the NHS, amirite?

Seriously, would you rather the USA didn't make this investment? What is your optimal outcome here?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Warp_Speed

salmon30salmon··on Notable – A Markdown-based note-taking app
It most likely isn't a clone. While Bear predates Notable, the timeline does not seem like Notable was a deliberate clone at all.
salmon30salmon··on Another 1.3M Americans File for Unemployment
My mistake, I thought you were referring to the 600/week extra unemployment benefit.
salmon30salmon··on Another 1.3M Americans File for Unemployment
Do you live in the same state? That is probably the difference :)
salmon30salmon··on Another 1.3M Americans File for Unemployment
Trump messed up a ton in this crises, and has a lot to answer for. This is not one of them.

Unemployment is almost all within the remit of the individual states. The government approved additional payments to each state, but the state government is responsible for dispersing and managing the unemployment system.

salmon30salmon··on NYC Has Its First Day in Months with No Covid-19 Deaths
I understand the hesitation, and I think even those that are excited by this theory are stoic towards history. However, one thing to note is that this is _not_ the Flu. The influenza virus often mutates far more, far quicker than coronaviruses do. There is certainly reason to be cautious, but there is also reason to be optimistic.
salmon30salmon··on NYC Has Its First Day in Months with No Covid-19 Deaths
This seems to be evidence of the theory that herd immunity is lower than expected due to cross-reactive T-cells lowering the susceptible pool. If I recall correctly, the last serology study of NYC showed ~25% infection rate, which is right where those postulating this theory expect the virus to burn out at.

While this isn't the only ingredient, and physical distancing and awareness play a role, it is good to see more and more locations exhibit the same burn-out pattern. I do not think that there is a single location thus far that does _not_ show this pattern (including Sweden!). The biggest potential outlier is Iran. However, Iran has some similarities to the United States in that a majority of the population lives within dispersed population centers. As such, we should look at each _region_ (as opposed to the country as a whole), when considering the theory above. Much as we must do with the United States. Miami is on it's first wave, as is Houston etc.

What I am really looking for is any evidence of a true second wave, and thus far there hasn't been any. And NYC would be ripe for one. Due to its density, even with the best of intentions, there will be close contact and opportunity to spread the virus.

Long story short, this is very, very, very good news.

EDIT: I want to add, that the refusal many people to see the United States as as collection of different outbreaks as opposed to a single, massive outbreak is very frustrating. We can't have an honest conversation regarding the best response to this virus when everyone is trying to score nation-state points over the fact that the US still has cases. Yes, the first region is _not_ seeing a resurgence. The outbreaks in the South are _new_. They sprang up in the past few weeks. This is fundamentally different than what we saw in the EU, as each country had their outbreaks at around the same time. If you want to compare, compare NY state to others. We can't make progress if continue to be either smug/defensive. This isn't a game.

Additional Reading:

Swedish T-Cell study: https://news.ki.se/immunity-to-covid-19-is-probably-higher-t...

NYC Serology: https://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/preliminary-antibodies-...

Study from Levitt et. al.: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.06.26.20140814v...

Study in Cell on T-Cells: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S009286742...

salmon30salmon··on Covid-19 in schoolchildren – A comparison between Finland and Sweden [pdf]
Because UBI is fundamentally different than most deficit spending. It actively injects cash into circulation as opposed to kick-starting economic activity which leads to increased spending/circulation.

UBI has not ever been tested at a large scale, and we have no reason to believe it will work. The last thing we need in this fragile economy is inflation. And UBI without increasing revenue will cause inflation, no way around that.

salmon30salmon··on Covid-19 in schoolchildren – A comparison between Finland and Sweden [pdf]
The update the CDC made is interesting. AS the footnote in the estimate table states, the IFR is taken from the pre-print _A systematic review and meta-analysis of published research data on COVID-19 infection-fatality rates_ by Meyerowitz-Katz, G., & Merone, L. et. al. The conclusion of their paper states:

> Based on a systematic review and meta-analysis of published evidence on COVID-19 until May, 2020, the IFR of the disease across populations is 0.68% (0.53-0.82%). However, due to very high heterogeneity in the meta-analysis, it is difficult to know if this represents the ‘true’ point estimate..._

There have been several reports that the IFR has lowered since late May, so it will be interesting to see if they rerun their metanalysis with June/July data. Their paper also makes the point that this could be an underestimate due to reporting issues (under-reported deaths). But likewise it could be an overestimate due to under-reporting infections (with so many asymptomatic cases). I am a little concerned over the lack of mention of that fact in the paper, which to me is as important as the under-reported deaths.

I understand your concern regarding long-term impacts. While we can't dismiss those concerns, it would be the only coronavirus in the history of known coronaviruses to do anything like that. So with our knowledge of this virus and the family of viruses, we can say that is "unlikely".

Tissue damage from a lung infection is _not_ rare. The flu does this (https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/07/090717150302.h.... Any pneumonia can cause scarring of the lung tissue, viral or otherwise.

If you are referring to the clotting and inflammation, again this is not altogether rare for a serious infection. Inflammation is common and not normally dangerous. The clotting is interesting, but also not unheard of. Also some interesting evidence that this may be a secondary infection (perhaps caused by venting? https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6836438/) https://principia-scientific.org/cv-19-autopsies-show-blood-...

There are going to be a lot of deaths. I can't argue out of that reality. It is really unfortunate. We will all known somebody who dies from this, or at least are within a free degrees. The debate, in my opinion, isn't on preventing all deaths, it won't happen. It is how do we minimize death while preventing long term societal and economic damage. And how do we protect the most vulnerable without causing those damages elsewhere.

I know it sounds weird, but the age stratification of the IFR is a HUGE gift of this virus. It is more age stratified than the flu or other common pandemic sources. We are very lucky. Next time we may not be, so I hope we can learn from this on how to prepare for what we feared this was.

salmon30salmon··on Covid-19 in schoolchildren – A comparison between Finland and Sweden [pdf]
I think that like most things in the states, this is super dependent on where you are. I know in my area, teachers were _not_ working every day, despite still doing online learning. They were supposed to check in with the kids every few days. In fact, most went on unemployment (at the request of the district) to be able to make the lower work scheme work without impacting district budgets.
salmon30salmon··on Covid-19 in schoolchildren – A comparison between Finland and Sweden [pdf]
It isn't counter factual. We flattened the curve! Why did we not have outbreaks in Florida three months ago? Because we had flattened the curve! The naughty truth that the brigade of curve flatteners failed to mention early on is that as soon as mitigation strategies are let up, the cases would skyrocket. This is exactly what is happening. Flatten the curve is, was and will continue to be a pipe dream. The virus will win. It will infect _n_ people until it reaches _x_ saturation and burn out. Or we get a vaccine and distribute it to artificially help it reach _x_ faster. That is the only way out of this. What did you expect when a population with little prior exposure locked down for three months and then unlocked? They would be protected by their good intentions?

You are making an assumption that this would ravage the labor force. Not to be glib, but unless your country has a labor force primarily comprised of 75+ year old workers, no labor force is getting ravaged by this disease. Yes, people will get sick. Some will die. Some will die from loneliness. In the time it took me to write this, hundreds of children died of preventable disease the world over. Some died of starvation. Some of lack of access to clean water. A woman was just murdered and another killed her lover, probably, somewhere. We can't ever have zero risk and to advertise otherwise is irresponsible at best.

Also please note, the poor and minority people that you are claiming to protect through blunt force lockdowns are actually the ones still working. Still butchering your meat, picking your fruits, delivering your Amazon order and washing your apartment complex. And the poor who aren't lucky enough to still be in work and in debt, falling further behind and face the least amount of economic security in 100 years. Let people decide what is best for them, you have no moral authority to claim righteousness in your cause and disparage mine.

Please, don't accuse me being counter-factual unless you want to counter my facts. Yes, I left Germany out. Germany is interesting. There are some theories around about that, but I am not well versed enough on them to comment, so I didn't include it. Well caught. I apologize for not blindly speculating and instead passing it over.

Finally, we were already told that mitigation saved two million lives: https://www.cato.org/blog/did-mitigation-save-two-million-li... so the corollary is that had we not mitigated, two million would be dead. And the Imperial College model really did estimate that much. Though they didn't give such a precise timeline: https://www.cato.org/blog/how-one-model-simulated-22-million...

And lets not forget the folks at the UW: A different, data-driven model from researchers at the University of Washington predicts “about 1 million cases in the U.S. by the end of the epidemic, around the first week in June, with new cases peaking in mid-April,” said UW applied mathematician Ka-Kit Tung, who led the work. “By the first week of June, we project that the number of new cases will be close to zero if current social distancing policies are maintained.” That model predicted two weeks ago that the number of new daily cases would peak around now, as seems to be the case. (https://www.statnews.com/2020/04/17/influential-covid-19-mod...). Again in that model, nobody ever talked about what comes next. I will tell you. More cases. Or immunity. One of those two.

salmon30salmon··on Covid-19 in schoolchildren – A comparison between Finland and Sweden [pdf]
The parent said "print the money" which very much is MMT. Bonds/other debts are a different discussion and we very much are deficit spending right now to combat this.
salmon30salmon··on Covid-19 in schoolchildren – A comparison between Finland and Sweden [pdf]
We don't know the long term consequences of completely shutting down a majority of society for an unknown period of time, including depriving children of an education. So let's not compare unknowns. This whole thing is an unknown and we need to accept some risk in each direction or be motionless.
salmon30salmon··on Covid-19 in schoolchildren – A comparison between Finland and Sweden [pdf]
> New Zealand, Taiwan, Vietnam, South Korea, and Germany have done it without herd immunity or a vaccine with a variety of strategies. We should follow their examples and stop using various forms of “American Exceptionalism” as an excuse to not learn from them.

Two of those are islands, one might as well be and the other two are Vietnam and Germany. Vietnam is very interesting. There is a strong chance of Vietnam being a prime area to study the cross-reactive T-cells due to the previous experience with SARS. Furthermore, besides dickhead in chief, I don't believe most people made any sort of exceptionalism claim. The USA is a massive nation experiencing several outbreaks at once. The EU just happened to all have their outbreaks around the same time. We can't compare _just_ the results of each nation and rank the response. We need to look at demographics, density, cultural aspects, interconnectedness etc.

>Print the money. It’s short term and there’s already massive demand and supply shocks that will only get worse if the pandemic isn’t curved.

No. This has never been, and never will be, a sound economic strategy in anything but the most extreme of examples. Also, the pandemic _is_ flattened. Remember we were supposed to have millions dead by now had we done nothing. We did flatten it (too much, probably) and now it is curving up, but still not at the rate that was first feared. But this gets in to a different debate. I have made this point elsewhere in my comment history if you are interested in my opinion.

> believe Canada and some countries in Europe are doing this through an employer-based grants, where the government subsidizes wages to keep them on the payroll. Whether this is ultimately desirable is up for debate, but the companies are going to be screwed with in terms of productivity (and everything else) if this ravages the US labor force. How to do it equitably? Just let the parents/caregivers decide for themselves.

Most relationships are not like that. This would almost universally fall upon women to put their careers on hold. This has been researched and reported widely. We did a similar thing with PPP and it saved many jobs. It was a terrible implementation and corrupt as fuck. But it did save many jobs. But again, someone has to pay the piper and don't keep swooning over the nonsense that is Modern Monetary Theory.

salmon30salmon··on Covid-19 in schoolchildren – A comparison between Finland and Sweden [pdf]
"Most" is doing a lot of heavy lifting in that sentence. And lets also be real, there is a self-reporting bias there, where I doubt very many people (myself included) would admit to _wanting_ to not work and still get paid, even if that is the motivation.
salmon30salmon··on Covid-19 in schoolchildren – A comparison between Finland and Sweden [pdf]
It could be argued that the multi-generational home is one of the cultural ingredients for such a bad outbreak in Italy. That is a lot more common in that country than in some other parts of Europe.

It is also somewhat common in immigrant groups in western Europe and the US (though somewhat out of economic necessity rather than cultural norms) and those groups are also the hardest hit in the US (apart for retirement homes).

Causality is hard to prove, but it is something worth looking at.

salmon30salmon··on Covid-19 in schoolchildren – A comparison between Finland and Sweden [pdf]
I appreciate your perspective and I am sorry that that is the situation in your state. I admit I can only speak for my state, and as such should limit my opinions to that context.

Thank you!

salmon30salmon··on Covid-19 in schoolchildren – A comparison between Finland and Sweden [pdf]
It is only a fallacy if incorrectly applied :D

In some cases, it is better to continue course with known variables.

Also, I wouldn't say it is non-existent. As I said in another response, I currently see a lot of evidence for the cross-reactive t-cell immune response causing the virus to burn out after around 25% infection rate.

salmon30salmon··on Covid-19 in schoolchildren – A comparison between Finland and Sweden [pdf]
Three questions:

1. What makes you think we _can_ get this under control without herd immunity or a vaccine? I am of the belief that there is a certain level of latent immunity via t-cells in a large portion of the population and thus effective herd immunity is around 25-30% infected. But for arguments sake, lets say it is around 70 based solely on Rt.

2. Who would pay for the UBI? My state is already running low on money. We are already having to cut programs. Raising taxes doesn't count, that would take a year to pass, a year to implement and collect and probably a few years in court litigating. So how do we pay for it?

3. How do you equitably select a parent to stay home? And how to do reimburse their employer for lost productivity? Do you guarantee their job upon the end of the pandemic?

salmon30salmon··on Covid-19 in schoolchildren – A comparison between Finland and Sweden [pdf]
Well the issue may well lie in my first statement. I am not disagreeing in principle with you. But we a day late and a dollar short to actually make large scale societal change in the time needed to respond to _this_ pandemic. The children need an education, parents need to work. That is the fact of the times.

Should this be an ongoing conversation to prepare for the _next_ pandemic? Certainty. But we lost the benefit of time on this one.

salmon30salmon··on Covid-19 in schoolchildren – A comparison between Finland and Sweden [pdf]
We don't know this. We would need full contact tracing and much faster testing to know this. Plus, we now know antibodies may _not_ be the biggest contributor to the immune response. It seems T-Cells are in some cases able to fight the disease without ever mounting an antibody response Thus no antibodies.

But the ol' maxim applies here: absence of evidence is not evidence of absence

salmon30salmon··on Covid-19 in schoolchildren – A comparison between Finland and Sweden [pdf]
Here is a big problem. The children need to go somewhere. Parents need to work, bills need to be paid and tax incomes need to continue to flow. So what to do with the kids?

Right now, the options are either send them to school, where there are (in the US) government employees making sure they are safe. The workers are well represented by a strong union, have good healthcare and reasonable wages. The other option is to send them to private day care, where private citizens with no oversight, very low pay and no worker protections are being asked to shoulder the risk. It seems like we have no problem hoisting even more responsibility upon the poor and least represented in society.

Teaches are essential workers, much like firefighters, DMV workers or court clerks. We expect a girl making minimum wage at Kroger to accept that she is an essential worker. Why do we not expect the same from school staff?

Disclosure: I have siblings and other close relatives that work for and in school in the US. I am not externalizing the risk.

salmon30salmon··on Covid-19 in schoolchildren – A comparison between Finland and Sweden [pdf]
It could be argued that the response to the Spanish Flu, Polio, HK Flu, H1N1, Zika, Swine etc. It appears by most measures this is an order of magnitude less lethal than Spanish Flu. THIS one, however, is political.
salmon30salmon··on U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native American reservation
Rome also had decades of civil war where a majority of the ruling class was either a) killed in said wars or b) killed after the wars in proscriptions by the victor. The only people left in the Senate were either weak-willed or allied to the "winner". The proscriptions by Marc Antony basically wiped out whatever resistance was left after the death of Julius Caesar. Couple this with the fact that the populace by-and-large just wanted peace, you can see why Octavian was able to rise.

In relation to the parent point, Octavian also went through great lengths to _appear_ to be acting at the will of the Senate. He was "first citizen" and all rights and protections granted to him here "granted" by the Senate. Whether this was under duress or just abdication for the sake of peace is debated.

There are some parallels between the current situation and the fall of the Republic, but there are for more differences. We are more at the Gracchi stage than the Caesar stage at this point. So there is hope!

salmon30salmon··on U.S. Coronavirus Cases Are Rising Sharply, but Deaths Are Still Down
I am probably the archetype of the straw man you invented in your comment regarding people saying the virus is not dangerous. Let me make a few things clear to you and the others who see this as a binary proposition.

This virus is _very_ dangerous to specific groups of people. We know this not only through observation but also through a more complete understanding on its spread, mechanism of action and cross-reactivity. We also know, with a good deal of certainty, that there are also groups who are at a very, very low level of risk from this virus.

What the people you so easily disparage are arguing is not that the virus is not dangerous, but that we are not responding to the actual threat, but rather the perceived threat based on data that is now 5 months old. And that by making this mistake, we are increasing danger to not only those at risk to the virus but also those who are at low risk through our obtuse response.

There are facts which can't be denied. The IFR is NOT anywhere near as high as we once feared. This is good news! We have two treatments that seem to help. This is good news! We understand that a majority of those infected will exhibit minor or no symptoms. This is good news! But we are still _acting_ as if this has a 2% IFR and no treatment.

We have less certainty, but are still researching the following. There is evidence that cross-reactivity in T-Cells with other coronaviruses is helping reduce the impact on a large portion of the population. We see evidence that _something_ has changed in the virus in the past 6 months. Genome sequencing hasn't revealed if this is true or not, but the research is ongoing. We see that outdoor spread is very unlikely. We believe nosocomial spread is a primary means. We see that super-spreaders may account for more of the spread than asymptomatic incidental contact. We have contradicting evidence of lockdown efficacy. And most importantly, we have not seen a TRUE 2nd wave. What is going on in the USA is not a 2nd wave at the community level, no community that had a large first wave is currently seeing a second wave.

Finally, there is debate around whether the herd immunity level is far lower than once thought. Michael Levitt and others are postulating that around 20-25% of the population needs to be infected to see a sharp decline in infections. This has played out in a lot of continental Europe, NYC and the UK.

So it isn't as simple as your snide sarcasm would have us believe. This is why actual debate is needed, not dismissive arrogance as displayed by your comments.

salmon30salmon··on The tricky math of Covid-19 herd immunity
How would a quarantine be over by now? We don't have a vaccine nor any reliable treatment. Unless we closed our borders completely like NZ, we would have an outbreak immediately upon reopening. Just like we are seeing now.
← PreviousPage 4 of 8Next →