562 karma · joined January 18, 2016
For the love of God. Texas didn't have an outbreak when they shutdown! Nor did Oregon, or California. That is the difference. All of Europe shut down _after the virus had already grown exponentially_ in most places. We shut down Oregon when there were fewer than 100 cases. After three months of being shut down in Oregon the curve had nowhere to go but up!
What in the hell did people expect? We shut down before there is spread, wait three months and then reopen. How is that a plan? Did anyone really expect that places where shutdowns were early and strong would somehow come out unscathed?
It has been true since day 1. You either need to shut down HARD until there is a vaccine (not possible, not sustainable, more deaths caused by this) or you deal with the surge of cases and do your best to protect the elderly/vulnerable.
What you don't do is panic, shut down too early, burn through all your money and political capital, reopen and then be all "golly gee there are cases now!". If we had waited until there was growth in cases, we could shutdown and actually flatten the curve enough to handle the shock to the system.
It is so. damn. frustrating. that this isn't more obvious to people. What materially changed between today and March 1?
Lockdowns where a bad idea from there start as there is no way to continue them until there is a vaccine.
I am very curious to see if NY and the other early hot spots avoid a resurgence like Europe has. That is what I am most interested now. If they do, perhaps the folks who are talking about cross-reactive immunity are on to something.
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-italy-...
What a time to be alive!
Also, NY is about as dense as the US gets, and has way more shared, multi-generational housing than the rest of the US. Also NYC has way more transit usage than any other area in the USA, which was one important vector.
Everyone keeps pretending like the lockdown is the only variable. It isn't!
I am not crying about China. It is the truth. The only way to prevent uncontrolled spread would have been to stop it before it became uncontrolled. The fact that the first cases were in Cali. in December shows how impossible that really is for a non-island nation (caveat only because NZ)
The main point I was making is that it isn't possible! By the time China had enough data to detect a novel virus, it was too late. It would have always been too late. China isn't to blame. This could just have easily of jumped species in Canada or the US. The point is that we can't be gods no matter how much we tell ourselves we are just that.
Hoisted by our own petard.
The goal should be to minimize spread among the most vulnerable.
Maybe the ability to control people coming in and out is more of a commonality than their responses? That is considering their responses looked _nothing alike_. NZ and Japan are basically as opposite as you can get in regards to a response.
I am probably wrong about the law used. IANAL.
How many people died from other, preventable things, while we learned that masks work? Something we knew then, by the way. Just ask any country that dealt with SARS Ver. 1.0
We can minimize it somewhat, but lots of people are going to die. If we locked down completely, lots of people would die of a litany of other things that would have normally been prevented in an open society. Fucked either way.
See my point?
I will say that being susceptible is not evenly distributed across a population. This is why prisons, meat packing and old people homes are more likely to have outbreaks. The corollary to that is that R0 is not consistent in a population. The R0 for people who live in old folks home is far higher than a bachelor who works from home.
So when the person said that they ran out of easy people to infect, that is absolutely true.
Now that it is raining in the Atacama, we have no political will to do anything.
Edit: I was sassy before I saw your edit :D. High-five on agreeing in principle!
I lied! NY and NJ are not in New England. The USA is annoying.
It was never going to work and people were screaming that at the top of their lungs in March. We were called ghouls or accused of supporting genocide. I am not kidding.
Compare the states of New York and New Jersey to the country of Italy. That is a more fair comparison. Not USA -> Italy.
One more thing. Italy didn't beat it. As soon as free movement is restored to the EU, it will spread again. The only thing that would prevent that is the ballyhooed theory that there is latent immunity in 40-60% of the population. If that is the case, than yes Lombardy is in the clear.
But if that is the case, then we also ruined the economy over a disease that was only going to infect a quarter of the people feared, and kill even less. Changes the math, doesn't it?
Edit: Fixed my stupidity about regions of my own country.
In my state, Oregon, we locked down when there were only a handful of cases, and not much community spread. Most spread was either in long-term care or familial. But we locked down _hard_ and had pretty good compliance. I am talking, standing in the middle of I-5 at noon compliance. Sure you'd have to keep an eye out for trucks from time to time. But still.
We set up surge capacity. Hospitals in Portland set up triage tents and cleared out other beds for a surge...... that never came. A few weeks in, the tents were taken down, the staff was laid off. We sat in our cocoon waiting for something, not sure what. Eventually the pain of being closed started to tick away, and we started reopening...
But nothing materially _changed_ between then and now. We just stopped community spread of an infection nobody really had. We've had less than 6k infections in Oregon. Now we are opening up and guess what? Cases are increasing! We didn't flatten the curve we crushed the curve. So there was no controlled spread, it was just us all feeling proud of ourselves for three months while the poor suffered.
The sneaky lie was that, in a country as big as the US, a flatten the curve strategy was never going to work at a national level. We need community level response.
We locked down Oregon over what was happening in NYC. That is akin to Northern Ireland locking down because of Moscow. That isn't an exaggeration. If anything, it is an understatement.
All of the European countries that we are saying "why can't we be more like them?" all had orders of magnitude more cases than Oregon. So if Oregon quadruples in cases over the next month we are still better off than a lot of nations.
To flatten the curve, there needs to be a damn curve to flatten. Had we waited until there was known, uncontrolled community spread and _then_ shut down, we would have a lot more political will. Now if it gets to that point after three months of being shut down, I doubt anyone will give a shit what the Governor says. Goodwill has been burned through and then some.
COVID-19 Lockdowns are threatening the survival of US primary care
Yes, a subset of the people not going to the doctor would have not gone due to fear of this disease. However, in a lot of jurisdictions, primary care _closed_ to make room for a "surge" that never came (or is slowly coming). Now these offices have reopened, but to debt, missed rent, low visits etc. Closing them under the lockdown orders was the original sin.
The goal here, in my opinion, is to _never_ return to the sort of broad stroke lockdown where society stops completely. That is an entirely untenable solution, and any new evidence we have to mitigate the virus without that sort of action is welcome news. We should be cheering these researches on, not vilifying them. They are doing science. It is an imperfect art, it is a series of terrible mistakes that eventually lead to a revelatory moment.
Furthermore, if we know that shared living spaces, farm work communes, jails etc are the main source of serious infection, we can hyper-focus on those scenarios and allow the economy to somewhat recover.
We all need to get off our relative high horses, by the way. What is an opportunity to work from home for a lot of us, is a recipe for financial disaster and bankruptcy for many, many others.
If we stop ICE from using these tools, are you saying that sex trafficking victims are less worthy of help than detained immigrants? How do you draw that line?