> We'll analyse your photo, describe it in words, and generate a new image from scratch.
I've tried the same technique to get around "copyright policy" refusals, but never get anything close to what I want.
315 karma · joined October 24, 2012
https://x.com/samrolken
> We'll analyse your photo, describe it in words, and generate a new image from scratch.
I've tried the same technique to get around "copyright policy" refusals, but never get anything close to what I want.
Do we know that it wouldn’t have varied in its answer by just as much, if you had tried in a new session at the same time?
Location: NYC and the Balkans (RN Macedonia)
Remote: Yes
Willing to relocate: No
Technologies: Ruby, Rails, JavaScript, AWS, building and launching web applications in general
Résumé/CV: upon request
Email: sam.hn@samrolken.org
I for 20 years I have worked building web software for startups. Most recently was at Slice where I was technical cofounder through VP of engineering for eight years. Since then I've been splitting my time between New York and Macedonia where I have a team of full stack web developers. Experience is with e-commerce, marketplace platforms, consumer facing web software, APIs, cloud infrastructure, and more. Available for hire in a technical cofounder / tech lead role or to take over maintaining and developing existing web software. Also available on contract basis to launch web apps. Location: NYC and the Balkans (RN Macedonia)
Remote: Yes
Willing to relocate: No
Technologies: Ruby, Rails, JavaScript, AWS, building and launching web applications in general
Résumé/CV: upon request
Email: sam.hn@samrolken.org
I for 20 years I have worked building web software for startups. Most recently was at Slice where I was technical cofounder through VP of engineering for eight years. Since then I've been splitting my time between New York and Macedonia where I have a team of full stack web developers. Experience is with e-commerce, marketplace platforms, consumer facing web software, APIs, cloud infrastructure, and more. Available for hire in a technical cofounder / tech lead role or to take over maintaining and developing existing web software. Also available on contract basis to launch web apps.If you mean K&R C as a shorthand for “plain old C” then there’s a lot of it going on everywhere. Embedded and industry especially.
Some countries have more than one language. Some languages have more than one country. And the political implications of all of this all mixed in.
Either you're dealing with someone honest, or not. Seems simple, right?
But, there is a third option. Sometimes someone will earnestly and honestly make a commitment, but then later on they will not see themselves as being obligated to follow through, or they will rationalize some reason they don't need to meet their commitments they've previously made.
I would probably also take a more broad version of that bet, if we agreed upon a good definition of "abuse".
10 years is tricky though, because this topic has a political angle about it.
I look at this stuff as a political move by Apple as much as anything else. There's a lot of political pressure around encryption, and the "think of the children" angle is very compelling for a lot of people. This CSAM voucher system is cleverly designed to handle that concern without compromising privacy or security for anyone who isn't uploading multiple previously-known CSAM images to their iCloud Photo Library.
How this political situation will unfold over the next 10 years is hard to say. I hope for the best. But it's important for threats to privacy and security to be challenged.
I have wished for more legitimate and valid criticism of this system. Almost every criticism that I've seen is based on plain misunderstandings of how the system works, which isn't helpful.
The image is not fed directly into the hashing function, like taking an MD5 hash of a file or something.
Rather, the image is first evaluated by a neural net that looks at specific visual details, and has been trained to match even if the image has been cropped or anything like that. The results of the neural net evaluation are what is then input for the hashing function.
This is explained in detail in Apple’s documentation they released with the announcement.
Apple screwed up big time in the functionality and messaging around it and some people found their original files deleted when they weren’t expecting it. Big problem.
But it was hardly some plot to scan users’ hard drives for copyrighted content and delete it. On the contrary, iTunes Match would happily launder a whole library full of pirated low-quality MP3s into legal, high quality, DRM-free AAC files.